TL Mafia XLIV - Page 95

On August 28 2011 12:52 chaoser wrote:


There is also a possibility that nard isn't mafia and is just nosy neighbor or possibly blue.

If the person foolishness was looking at was killed by the godfather and nard also visited then foolishness would only see nard.

This is why I said I trust foolishness' call as much as I trust my own.

On August 28 2011 12:48 wherebugsgo wrote:


He probably watched someone who died on the previous night. He gets a report of everyone who visited that person.

If nard visited a person who died, he's almost certainly mafia. This is, of course, has to be what Foolish was saying, because he was a watcher and he was 100% sure nard is mafia.

Now, the thing about vain is that there is a TINY possibility he's not mafia. But we'll wait for his claim before anything is said.

On August 28 2011 14:59 Varpulis wrote:
Guys, he's a claimed dt who's sure of his sanity. He's claimed his targets, how he knows his sanity, everything. Chaoser's fucked if he's mafia fake claiming, and I can't imagine why mafia would claim dt with no pressure on them.

##vote Vain

Also, Bumatlarge is scum. Without a shadow if a doubt, he's scum. Because we already have 2 good targets today, both very likely mafia (one called scum by a dead watcher, one called scum by a living dt) I'm not going to push for his lynch today, but I want to say it before I forget. I'll expand on these after I wake up, it's 2am where I am right now.

On August 28 2011 20:56 nard wrote:
Liquidite- Welcome to TL Mafia XLIV you are Lysander, the retired paladin, you used to be one of the toughest people around, exterminating cults, killing deamons, and generally fighting evil. That was a long time ago though, by now the arthritis has set in and your old wounds ache, not to mention the fact you are constrained to a wheelchair. Still, the true power of a paladin is in his iron will, and you still have that. Your unflinching resolve and your vote shall be your weapons against the cult.

so i guess i'm a nosy neighbor? of course anything i say now is kinda suspicious.please think it through though - a third townie lynch will hurt us so bad i don't think we can recover from it. do we have some other way of confirming me? maybe chaoser or better, somebody unclaimed as chaoser won't survive for long i guess.
anyway like i wrote yesterday, i will be actively monitoring the thread in the following hours and am ready to respond to your stuff.

On August 28 2011 21:55 chaos13 wrote:
nard is 100% mafia. Foolish would not have missed considering all the possibilities. He had to have watched someone who died, and nard was the ONLY person visiting them. There can be no mistake here. A 100% confirmed watcher has given us a 100% confirmed mafia

On August 28 2011 22:33 nard wrote:
does this mean there is a godfather in the game? how many options are possible?

1: im scum.
2: im a nosy neighbor and the setup includes a godfather
3: ??

On August 28 2011 23:00 supersoft wrote:


oh scum made their homework. Indeed if you randomly visited the poor guy who was killed by the godfather, there might be a chance that you're innocent.
But even if there was a GF, chances that you randomly visit the guy who gets killed by him are so low! Mafia also can't chose who visits whom.

mafia kills 3 people out of about 18. Depending which night foolish chose to check you.
one of them get's killed by the GF.
noisys randomly visit 1 guy out of 24 including scum?!
the chances that you're visiting someone who gets killed are like 1/8 and the chance that you visit the guy who gets killed by the GF are like 1/3*1/8=1/24

scum

On August 28 2011 23:13 supersoft wrote:
you think Foolishness also checked BB? he accused him pretty heavily. I believe he wouldn't do that without having him checked. I think he checked him night1 and nard night2... But why didn't he list BB as 100% scum if he checked him... hmm

On August 28 2011 23:34 Barundar wrote:
Seriusly. Foolishness flipped watcher. The way it works is you check someone you think will get hit, ie. someone you think is town, like as a medic. You don't get to choose a suspect to check, but if your target dies, and only one person visits, it's pretty much certain scum. Hence it's almost guaranteed that Foolishness didn't check BB. Why would he check his suspect? And if he had gotten a result where only BB visited someone who died, I'm sure he would have told us.

On August 28 2011 21:55 chaos13 wrote:


nard is 100% mafia. Foolish would not have missed considering all the possibilities. He had to have watched someone who died, and nard was the ONLY person visiting them. There can be no mistake here. A 100% confirmed watcher has given us a 100% confirmed mafia




I'll go with a confirmed blue before a likely blue. We can take out Vain tomorrow, or tonight if we still have a vigilante. nard is a priority because someone we know has a power role that can prove people as mafia has stated that nard is mafia.