|
On August 23 2011 01:04 Curu wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 01:00 Palmar wrote:On August 23 2011 00:59 Curu wrote:On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
....why are you blue fishing the Medic? Foolishness is in no danger of being lynched at the moment, there are a million scummier people in this Town. Are you being intentionally thick? I see no reason to disbelieve Foolisness's claim, especially with the RBer add-on. If no one gets RBed the rest of the game, he comes under suspicion and Foolishness makes sense as a N1 hit. I see no reason for the Medic to out himself to "confirm" a guy who shouldn't need to be confirmed at this point anyways.
Hence "I don't know when and how".
The medic should absolutely claim if Foolishness was up for a lynch. Also, if the medic suspected he might be getting shot for some reason, leaving the information with us is good.
If I get RB'd tomorrow does that confirm Foolishness? Hell no... I don't even know what you're saying here. But yes, he's not about to be lynched today, thus it's stupid to claim until at first near daybreak tomorrow, maybe even wait another cycle or two.
People keep talking about Vain: I think shooting him tonight would be an excellent idea. He hasn't contributed squat to this game and doesn't deserve to live.
|
I can agree with that. Medic claiming now or at the end of this night is absurdly stupid when Foolishness it not in danger of being lynched.
|
On August 23 2011 01:09 Curu wrote:
I can agree with that. Medic claiming now or at the end of this night is absurdly stupid when Foolishness it not in danger of being lynched.
So what do you think about lynching Mig?
|
On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
As for Navillus. I'd like you to figure out the answer by yourself. Go back and read the difference in tone how BrownBear was pushing his ideas and how Navillus was pushing his. Everything about Navillus screams enthusiastic townie at me. Filter out each's posts and look at the very, very notable difference in attitude.
I actually think Navillus is one of the less likely players in the game to be mafia at the moment.
I want to hear more from Mig. It really bothers me that Jackal is trying to somehow link my alignment to his flip, something he knows very well is ridiculously stupid to do as town, because townies have been wrong before, however it makes perfect sense as scum.
Care to explain this link Jackal?
You want Mig dead. What's hard about that?
|
On August 23 2011 01:10 Jackal58 wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
As for Navillus. I'd like you to figure out the answer by yourself. Go back and read the difference in tone how BrownBear was pushing his ideas and how Navillus was pushing his. Everything about Navillus screams enthusiastic townie at me. Filter out each's posts and look at the very, very notable difference in attitude.
I actually think Navillus is one of the less likely players in the game to be mafia at the moment.
I want to hear more from Mig. It really bothers me that Jackal is trying to somehow link my alignment to his flip, something he knows very well is ridiculously stupid to do as town, because townies have been wrong before, however it makes perfect sense as scum.
Care to explain this link Jackal?
You want Mig dead. What's hard about that?
Yes I think Mig is scum.
let's entertain the thought that he flips town, does that make me scum?
|
hahahahaha, always to the point jackal
|
|
|
bleh, ignore me.
Jackal only stated that if Mig flipped scum he'd see me as more green, not the other way around. So I'm just being an idiot.
|
On August 23 2011 01:10 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 01:09 Curu wrote:
I can agree with that. Medic claiming now or at the end of this night is absurdly stupid when Foolishness it not in danger of being lynched. So what do you think about lynching Mig?
As I said, one of Mig or Chaoser is probably scum because I don't think either is bad enough to park their vote on an OMGUS and not discuss anything else. I'm not ready to lynch him just based on lack of day 1 posting, he was completely invisible in WaW2 and AA (though to be fair AA was a PM game) on the first day of both games. I still need to read through but Personality has me kind of pissed off so I can't muster up the energy atm.
My scumtell for Mig has always been if he doesn't catch a scum by day 2, he's probably scum.
|
Upon rereading palmar's posts, I lean toward town. Palmar was never a proponent of the Sevryn lynch and he made several good (IMO) posts on how it matters not what a person thinks another's alignment is, but the WAY in which they propose their arguments. In this sense, I agree; the manner in which someone responds or posts is actually more important in order to determine their alignment than what they are literally saying.
|
On August 23 2011 01:11 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 01:10 Jackal58 wrote:On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
As for Navillus. I'd like you to figure out the answer by yourself. Go back and read the difference in tone how BrownBear was pushing his ideas and how Navillus was pushing his. Everything about Navillus screams enthusiastic townie at me. Filter out each's posts and look at the very, very notable difference in attitude.
I actually think Navillus is one of the less likely players in the game to be mafia at the moment.
I want to hear more from Mig. It really bothers me that Jackal is trying to somehow link my alignment to his flip, something he knows very well is ridiculously stupid to do as town, because townies have been wrong before, however it makes perfect sense as scum.
Care to explain this link Jackal?
You want Mig dead. What's hard about that? Yes I think Mig is scum. let's entertain the thought that he flips town, does that make me scum?
If he were to flip town my opinion of you wouldn't change. That opinion is currently you being a person of intense interest. Same as Foolishness.
|
yah, I said, I misread your post.
|
Ya sorry. Several posts went by between quoting you and posting.
|
RayzorFlash just made a nice ninja vote on Hiro.
|
On August 23 2011 00:58 RayzorFlash wrote:Another person i'd like to call out is hiro protagonist... All your posts so far in the game have been either little one-line questions to get peoples opinions without showing your own at all, or they've been defending Palmar... Also, the fact that you actually acknowledged quicksilver as a threat is pretty damning: Show nested quote +On August 19 2011 13:54 hiro protagonist wrote:
QuickSilver7 gets my vote for best opening post. Show nested quote +On August 20 2011 17:05 hiro protagonist wrote:
Also, Im gonna say it again: QuickSilver7's posts are fucking awesome. I dont care if he thinks Im scummy. It also seemed to me that you were trying really hard to look like you were contributing when people started switching from Sev to me, without actually contributing anything the rest of the game except for one-line questions. We don't know what your opinion is on anything, and everytime someone asks you a question, you just pop right back with another question instead of actually answering it. As of right now, I'm putting my vote on you until you contribute something useful, like a reason to not vote you... ##vote Hiro Protagonist
On August 23 2011 02:25 Jackal58 wrote:
RayzorFlash just made a nice ninja vote on Hiro.
Wait what??? :S
|
On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
As for Navillus. I'd like you to figure out the answer by yourself. Go back and read the difference in tone how BrownBear was pushing his ideas and how Navillus was pushing his. Everything about Navillus screams enthusiastic townie at me. Filter out each's posts and look at the very, very notable difference in attitude.
I actually think Navillus is one of the less likely players in the game to be mafia at the moment.
I want to hear more from Mig. It really bothers me that Jackal is trying to somehow link my alignment to his flip, something he knows very well is ridiculously stupid to do as town, because townies have been wrong before, however it makes perfect sense as scum.
Care to explain this link Jackal?
Just a couple of points. First, how do YOU feel like a scum Foolishness would have claimed, if not by claiming in such a way that leaves town to assume everything about it?
On the second bolded bit, why do you say that you want him to figure it out himself, but then go on to say EXACTLY how you want him to view Navillus? And further, you're using their 'difference in attitude' as evidence of BB's guilt. Why this isn't ludicrous to anyone else is beyond me? People are different, EVERYONE plays differently. Just because they're different doesn't make one of them town and one of them scum.
What you're implying about Jackals statement would make sense as scum, but I'm not seeing what you're seeing in Jackal's post. It's possible that you're town and are wrong about Mig, but the way you've been pushing his lynch deserves a look whether you like it or not if Mig flips town.
|
why don't we lynch RayzorFlash? He's probably gotten coached and his death would give us a lot of information to work with...
|
On August 23 2011 01:08 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 01:04 Curu wrote:On August 23 2011 01:00 Palmar wrote:On August 23 2011 00:59 Curu wrote:On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
....why are you blue fishing the Medic? Foolishness is in no danger of being lynched at the moment, there are a million scummier people in this Town. Are you being intentionally thick? I see no reason to disbelieve Foolisness's claim, especially with the RBer add-on. If no one gets RBed the rest of the game, he comes under suspicion and Foolishness makes sense as a N1 hit. I see no reason for the Medic to out himself to "confirm" a guy who shouldn't need to be confirmed at this point anyways. Hence "I don't know when and how". The medic should absolutely claim if Foolishness was up for a lynch. Also, if the medic suspected he might be getting shot for some reason, leaving the information with us is good. If I get RB'd tomorrow does that confirm Foolishness? Hell no... I don't even know what you're saying here. But yes, he's not about to be lynched today, thus it's stupid to claim until at first near daybreak tomorrow, maybe even wait another cycle or two. People keep talking about Vain: I think shooting him tonight would be an excellent idea. He hasn't contributed squat to this game and doesn't deserve to live.
If you wanna direct vigi's at least come up with more targets. I wouldn't be surprised if there actually was a scum medic.
On August 23 2011 02:44 supersoft wrote:
why don't we lynch RayzorFlash? He's probably gotten coached and his death would give us a lot of information to work with...
Can you write out what information we get then? In my opinion that only creates more wifom
|
Oh and btw. you think MY reason is bad but you miss gems like this
On August 21 2011 09:02 Lucidity wrote:
Ok from the voting thread it looks like Sevryn is the closest to being lynhced. We can't no lynch.
##Vote Sevryn.
Hurray for deadlines at 4am.
I'll catch up tomorrow and shit. Sorry.
|
On August 23 2011 02:58 Vain wrote:Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 01:08 Palmar wrote:On August 23 2011 01:04 Curu wrote:On August 23 2011 01:00 Palmar wrote:On August 23 2011 00:59 Curu wrote:On August 23 2011 00:56 Palmar wrote:
Foolishness made some correct observations on day 1. In addition he claimed a shot in a way I don't think Scumishness would've done. However, the medic who saved him should absolutely claim at some point, I've not concluded how and when is the best point to claim. I think claiming before this night would be stupid. Perhaps just as this night ends in case he gets shot? I don't know.
....why are you blue fishing the Medic? Foolishness is in no danger of being lynched at the moment, there are a million scummier people in this Town. Are you being intentionally thick? I see no reason to disbelieve Foolisness's claim, especially with the RBer add-on. If no one gets RBed the rest of the game, he comes under suspicion and Foolishness makes sense as a N1 hit. I see no reason for the Medic to out himself to "confirm" a guy who shouldn't need to be confirmed at this point anyways. Hence "I don't know when and how". The medic should absolutely claim if Foolishness was up for a lynch. Also, if the medic suspected he might be getting shot for some reason, leaving the information with us is good. If I get RB'd tomorrow does that confirm Foolishness? Hell no... I don't even know what you're saying here. But yes, he's not about to be lynched today, thus it's stupid to claim until at first near daybreak tomorrow, maybe even wait another cycle or two. People keep talking about Vain: I think shooting him tonight would be an excellent idea. He hasn't contributed squat to this game and doesn't deserve to live. If you wanna direct vigi's at least come up with more targets. I wouldn't be surprised if there actually was a scum medic. Show nested quote +On August 23 2011 02:44 supersoft wrote:
why don't we lynch RayzorFlash? He's probably gotten coached and his death would give us a lot of information to work with... Can you write out what information we get then? In my opinion that only creates more wifom
So you're saying if you get shot someone will be there to save you anyway?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
