EPTlol, even I got that joke :-D
Pick Their Power Mafia - Page 68
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
stefftastiq
Norway205 Posts
lol, even I got that joke :-D | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22631 Posts
Bumatlarge: Kill Varpulis | ||
|
redFF
United States3910 Posts
On June 02 2011 11:37 chaos13 wrote: I am going to repeat this, because there have been several who have claimed, including you and Kurumi. Granted, Kurumi's was a softclaim, but he confirmed it moments later. DO NOT CLAIM UNLESS IT IS NECESSARY. DO NOT CLAIM UNLESS IT IS NECESSARY. IT DOES NOT HELP US. IT HELPS MAFIA. DO NOT CLAIM UNLESS IT IS NECESSARY. I feel that required caps lock. On June 02 2011 06:43 chaos13 wrote:At the very least my death will be better than a different townies. One of you out there knows why. You'll still be killing a townie though. Softclaims then tells everyone not to claim... Contradictions | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + On June 02 2011 18:30 Palmar wrote: 3. Why Chaos13 is scum Here's the thing, I started thinking chaos13 was a cool bro, worthy of keeping around because he made sound calls like this: But let's look at some more stuff by him. I like people who call bullshit, but people who abuse lurkers and newbies to call bullshit on everything to gain town credit are useless. Just read through his damn post history... it's a disaster. First thing I noticed: Why do you care... the bro's got like 2 votes on him. Instead of complaining how about contributing your own analysis. All your posts up until this point aint got nothing in them except directions on how to play, not actually playing. So you want me to stop fostering discussion and trying to get people to actually contribute their thoughts to the game? When someone states that they're voting for a player without giving a reason, it's not a very pro-town move. I want to make sure that everyone explains their thoughts clearly in the thread so the rest of town can evaluate them and provide their own input. I don't see how this is scummy. More defenses. If you think he's town, you ignore me, and provide a better alternative. Don't just tell me I'm wrong and vaguely, and very damn carefully claim you're kinda suspicious-y. Stop being useless, man up and give me something to work with if you don't want me to lynch Varpulis I said earlier, I'm doing all my thinking in the thread, because it always leads me to more accurate conclusions. I'm still not sold either way on Varpulis. Deal with it. Good post bro. It was. I asked a player whose alignment I was unsure of a direct question in order to get him to contribute his thoughts on a player I was suspicious of. yay, you get logic. hi5 bro. Everyone knew this, stop posting fluff. You would be surprised how easy it is to overlook one of these scenarios. I write them down and post them because then if my ideas are stupid, people can tell me they're stupid and I move on. Sharing my thoughts and opinion is not scummy. nice contradiction bro. This is still less scummy than most things you've done in the thread. Opinions change. People told me my ideas on Amber were stupid, so I moved on. It took me some time to realize how he could be useful to us. At the time of the first post Amber was the point of discussion for a few pages, and nothing useful was happening. At the time of the second, we had organized a bit and my question was more helpful. Questions, useless one liners and pointing out the obvious is almost the entire thing chaos13 has done this game. Coag is not even in the game. You expect me to let that go by without questioning it?? Here's the best analysis in the game by jackal: Nice job calling out GM, at least he's not spamming the thread like you are. thing is, you haven't contributed for shit either. You're fluff-posting, that's damn sure, but nothing you say is of any real value to this game in particular. You must be right. It's not as if several players have already stated that they feel I am pro-town and have been actively trying to contribute. I have been doing my best to keep discussion on track and productive, I have shared my thoughts on players, if I felt a player was scummy, I posted an explanation of why. Nothing about that is fluff or spam. Stop asking questions and being useless. Seriously, I aint gonna go through more of his shit and quote it here. Do it yourselves. This guy hasn't contributed shit to the game, he's posting oneliners, fluff, advice on how to play, going after lurkers and stating obvious shit. Nah, I've contributed, my oneliners have been brief and far between, as well as far less frequent than some other players. Advice on how to play is good for some of the new players, lurkers are a good group to go after (and I think I've only been after Karshe and Tackster as it is, I've focused more on actives) and anything obvious is my own thoughts as I sort things out. I have a tendency to take a while to get to a good conclusion, and I need others input on my ideas or they end up being detrimental to what I actually want to happen. This guy is a scum trying to be pro town. Can we please just agree on it? I don't mind, shoot him or check him, but this bro aint no good guy. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
| ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On June 02 2011 18:18 sandroba wrote: Sorry but I have to dissagree with the kill sinani plan. First of all sinani is pretty much confirmed town right now so mafia will have to kill him sooner or later and then he can bring back BC. Second I want bum to kill prplhz or if he dissagrees make sure to fucking hit scum otherwise he's lynched next day. We have no way to be sure how many kp mafia has so bum HAS to anounce who he's hitting before the end of the night so we can confirm it. Bum, your win condition is to be the last man standing?? That's a fucking impossible win condition pretty much since you are outed as soon as batman is killed and you cannot kill batman. How the fuck do you win? I'm not fucking buying it in the slightest. Fear of the unknown? Or fear of bringing BC back into the game? Either way it's nice to know that the scum team is confirming Sinani isn't one of them. Shoot Sinani Bum. Or you could shoot this piece of scum right here. Don't really care. Just call your shot right before Day post goes up. Don't pull a fucking repeat of the RPGs on us Bum. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
Pros: -When I flip, town has the thoughts of a confirmed town player Cons: -Potential for WIFOM arguments as to why I died -Could alter mafia targets for the worse If nobody says anything within the next hour, I will post them. If enough people tell me not to, I will not post them. I really don't want all these to go to waste, and I think there is a good chance that I will be killed tonight. | ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
Why are You suggesting to kill prplhz? Maybe he's unkillable? Oh,that would make sense to vote on his death,prplhz does not die,bum is lynched.. So easy. Sorry guys for switching vote on Viscera,Sandroba was scummier. My Mafia list: Sandroba,he's 100% Prlphz,he's 100% Palmar Meapak_Ziphh Town reads are as obvious as BC's green blood,You know who they are. | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
And I also agree with jackals post. You guys should all read it again. | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
| ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
On June 02 2011 23:23 tnkted wrote: Also #vote VisceraEyes. He seems scummy (ha!). You freaking Necrophiliac,why bring crazy bodies again into our game. | ||
|
prplhz
Denmark8045 Posts
I think someone said that you roleclaimed at some point, but I don't remember that and I'm not going through that cesspool that is your posts again to find it. So did you roleclaim, and if you did, could you repeat what you said or link me to it? I am very confused about you. | ||
|
Jackal58
United States4264 Posts
On June 02 2011 23:23 tnkted wrote: Also #vote VisceraEyes. He seems scummy (ha!). It's night time Twinkles. Although that may be the appropriate time to vote for a Zombie. | ||
|
Kurumi
Poland6130 Posts
On June 02 2011 23:27 prplhz wrote: @Kurumi I think someone said that you roleclaimed at some point, but I don't remember that and I'm not going through that cesspool that is your posts again to find it. So did you roleclaim, and if you did, could you repeat what you said or link me to it? I am very confused about you. No scum,do it Yourself. | ||
|
tnkted
United States1359 Posts
On June 02 2011 23:28 Jackal58 wrote: It's night time Twinkles. Although that may be the appropriate time to vote for a Zombie. oh ha! i forgot about that. I didn't want to forget. #unvote | ||
|
bumatlarge
United States4567 Posts
| ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22631 Posts
We think sinani is town, so now bum shoots him without having to give any information about his alignment, I'm not buying this shit. Tell a bitch to shoot Varpulis. | ||
|
chaos13
Canada885 Posts
+ Show Spoiler [Player Notes] + *These are my personal thoughts so far. If you don't agree with them, deal with it. I'm not always right.* Kurumi -Usual erratic posting style, tough to analyze. Has actually been contributing in a meaningful way. Most likely town Karshe -Overwhelmed by size of game. Appears when called for lurking. Has since disappeared. Uncertain Mr. Wiggles -Uncertain deskscaress -Doesn't feel his role will be particularly useful. Strong personality. Could be either scum or town GMarshal -Defended Mataza when there was no real pressure on him. Contributing without contributing. When I point out his scumminess and vote him, he comes in with an excuse for being inactive over the next few weeks. Suspicious. Palmar -Disagrees with role claim, supports analysis. Strange fistpound thing with several players. Advocates shooting useless townies for information. Claims I am scum because I am giving off "maf vibes", but doesn't bother to provide any real evidence or analysis. Got around to posting actual analysis. It was rather weak, and mostly blamed me for posting fluff and spamming. Suggests a vigi shot on Mataza and Varpulis, as well as a DT check on Jackal58, three other players on my suspect list. This doesn't make sense if they are all scum. Possible third party. He doesn't quite fit town or scum. Suspicious. Fistpound List Returned offer by Palmar GMarshal Node tnkted Kurumi sandroba Offered it to Palmar without being asked VisceraEyes Mataza Ignored invitation from Palmar Amber[Light] redFF Meapak_Zipph Eternalmisfit DropBear Eternalmisfit -Inexperienced player. Attempting analysis, sometimes weak. Has good ideas when he's around, keeps discussion focused and on track. Most likely town. sandroba -Proposed claiming who we created roles for. Reacted strongly to pressure, but after initial scumminess has not done anything strange. Plan would probably not have been put forward by mafia, as it draws too much attention. Overall not giving me a scummy feel. Too few of his posts are suspicious Most likely town kitaman27 -Mildly aggressive. Contributing more than in XXXIX, where he was scum. Not as accusatory as in XXXIX. Most likely town. Kenpachi -Uncertain Tackster -Minimalist contributor. Reiterated what other players had already said. Lurked, made one large post. Claimed he had a migraine and is getting sick as excuses for not posting. Post was fluff at first glance, but on closer examination revealed some helpful comments and opinions. Upon re-reading his posts, he has actually added some good input. Role claimed Most likely town. Varpulis -Agrees with a variation of sandroba's idea. Has been targeted by many players who feel he is scummy. When multiple players are jumping on one it often leads to scum. Uncertain-possible scum tnkted -Strange style of play. Unique role allows (requires?) him to vote for players outside the game. Posting has improved in quality. Some question about it still. Uncertain hiro protagonist -New player, not being obvious. Uncertain redFF -Claims role will not be useful. Mason-type role. Lying scum or dumb townie. Not up to usual standards. Posting has drastically improved in quality. Good contributions. Most likely town. sinani206 -Called for hit on him, saying that something good for town would happen. Town Node -Good posts. Has defended me. Has been pro-town, but in a way that feels somewhat cautious to me. Very soft defense of GM when I asked for his thoughts. Defended me when Palmar called for a vigi hit without analysis. The way he is playing I am uncertain. His posting is pro-town, but it feels far too thought-out to be a townies. Will be keeping an eye on him. Uncertain. bumatlarge -Encouraging discussion and analysis. Claims SK type role as Joker. Either third party or scum. Mataza -Claims role will not be useful. Defended by GMarshal and Palmar after little pressure. Posting does not feel pro-town. Suspicious Mig -Lurker. Uncertain VisceraEyes -New player. Radical accusations and ideas. Scum team would control his posting more. Most likely town. Amber[LighT] -Ridiculous role restriction. Possibly fake. No way to analyze. Quoted several posts with symbols for his opinion of them. Is unsure of me, sees posts that could lead me to either scum or town, thinks Jackal is town, really thinks Sandroba is scum. Voted Sandroba. For such an inconvenient post restriction he is really trying to contribute. Most likely town. BloodyC0bbler -Very aggressive player. Stated by many to be pro-town. Experienced player. Possible scum Torte de Lini -New player. Lurker. Has a history of being extremely active that is not displayed. Possible option for new scum player Uncertain Cthsazsa -Uncertain Barundar -Lurker. Experienced player Uncertain Meapak_Ziphh -Aggressive player, encourages discussion. Genuine deliberation over me, came to the conclusion that I'm town. Has consistently been pro-town. Most likely town. DropBear -Uncertain prplhz -New player, seems inexperienced. Would have great difficulty pulling off scum. Most likely town stefftastiq -New player. Attempting analysis. Most likely town Rean -Few posts. Feels has been contributing when he has put little forward. I often do the same as town, I am more likely to pay attention to how much I am contributing as scum. Most likely town. Jackal58 -Usual aggressive play. Tunneling on me, but Jackal always tunnels. Posting feels scummy. Hasn't really contributed. Voted Sandroba without providing reasons. Suspicious + Show Spoiler [Alignment Lists] + TOWN -Meapak_Ziphh -prplhz -Rean -Amber[LighT] -Tackster -redFF -Sandroba -sinani206 -EternalMisfit -Kurumi SUSPICIOUS -GMarshal -Mataza -Jackal58 -Palmar -Varpulis *This list is not 100% correct, or mafia is making some crazy plays here. Mataza, Jackal, and Palmar can not be on a scum team together, there has been too much conflict/calling for vigi/DT's by Palmar. I would hazard a guess that 1-3 of these names are correctly identifying scum. THIRD PARTY UNCERTAIN -Karshe -Kurumi -Mr. Wiggles -deskscaress -Eternalmisfit -sandroba -kitaman27 -Kenpachi -tnkted -hiro protagonist -Node -bumatlarge -Mig -Torte de Lini -Cthsazsa -Barundar -DropBear -stefftastiq CLAIMED MASON CIRCLE -Jackal58 (claimed BC as well) -bumatlarge -Others ZODIAC LIST bumatlarge BloodyC0bbler GMarshal Meapak_Ziphh DropBear Node Jackal58 kitaman27 Rean Mr. Wiggles tnkted | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22631 Posts
But Bumatlarge needs to show loyalty by not shooting a confirmed townie, and rather someone he seems hesitant to shoot. you dig? | ||
|
redFF
United States3910 Posts
| ||
| ||
