|
On February 16 2011 07:03 GMarshal wrote:Show nested quote +On February 16 2011 06:59 Coagulation wrote:On February 16 2011 06:48 kitaman27 wrote:On February 16 2011 06:35 Coagulation wrote:
GGQ has been 100% Useless this game. scum or no scum hes best be gone. In a game with 15 remaining and 6 modkills you would be willing to lynch a non scum? what makes you think hes non scum? The fact that he is being so blatantly scummy, what would scum gain from playing this way? If he were scum then why isn't he defending himself? If we hadn't had 5 modkills I'd be fine with just lynching him, but I realize now that if we don't hit mafia today then 2 more townies are going to be brutally murdered tonight, we aren't in a good spot right now and I dont think we can afford a mislynch. GGQ please post at least your name so we can use that to discuss weather or not to lynch. (according to the op there are no roles that win by being lynched, so you can't want to die)
NO U
|
If i was a vigilante, we would be winning D:
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
On February 16 2011 07:06 GGQ wrote:Show nested quote +On February 16 2011 07:03 GMarshal wrote:On February 16 2011 06:59 Coagulation wrote:On February 16 2011 06:48 kitaman27 wrote:On February 16 2011 06:35 Coagulation wrote:
GGQ has been 100% Useless this game. scum or no scum hes best be gone. In a game with 15 remaining and 6 modkills you would be willing to lynch a non scum? what makes you think hes non scum? The fact that he is being so blatantly scummy, what would scum gain from playing this way? If he were scum then why isn't he defending himself? If we hadn't had 5 modkills I'd be fine with just lynching him, but I realize now that if we don't hit mafia today then 2 more townies are going to be brutally murdered tonight, we aren't in a good spot right now and I dont think we can afford a mislynch. GGQ please post at least your name so we can use that to discuss weather or not to lynch. (according to the op there are no roles that win by being lynched, so you can't want to die) NO U
I'll post my name if you post yours!
|
On February 16 2011 07:09 kitaman27 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 16 2011 07:06 GGQ wrote:On February 16 2011 07:03 GMarshal wrote:On February 16 2011 06:59 Coagulation wrote:On February 16 2011 06:48 kitaman27 wrote:On February 16 2011 06:35 Coagulation wrote:
GGQ has been 100% Useless this game. scum or no scum hes best be gone. In a game with 15 remaining and 6 modkills you would be willing to lynch a non scum? what makes you think hes non scum? The fact that he is being so blatantly scummy, what would scum gain from playing this way? If he were scum then why isn't he defending himself? If we hadn't had 5 modkills I'd be fine with just lynching him, but I realize now that if we don't hit mafia today then 2 more townies are going to be brutally murdered tonight, we aren't in a good spot right now and I dont think we can afford a mislynch. GGQ please post at least your name so we can use that to discuss weather or not to lynch. (according to the op there are no roles that win by being lynched, so you can't want to die) NO U I'll post my name if you post yours!
Haha, I like your sig
|
Maybe he gets to choose whether to side with town or mafia or win alone.
Either way, looking at his posts, I'll put aside my Insanious vote for now even though he still hasn't posted anything.
Vote: GGQ
|
Okay, I can vote for GGQ.
Unvote, Vote: GGQ
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
Really, no one opposes this? Also, shouldn't there be more discussion on the extra night hit and/or the lack of day hit so far?
On February 14 2011 17:04 ilovejonn wrote:
I hope it wasn't a pro-town vig role who targetted kitaman27, what the heck.
You seem pretty sure about my alignment. My actions to that point weren't exactly all that helpful.
On February 14 2011 17:44 gryffindor wrote:
Can someone tell me what the fuck just happened? I have to do some reading.
Repeatedly requests behind the scene pm's, but you claim to be unable to keep up with the thread? Predominately absent when it comes to opposing the status quo.
These kind of posts seem to say "whoa, it couldn't possibly me who used a day shot!"
|
Oh guys I have an idea, how about whoever gets the least votes gets lynched for today!
|
ok im ignoring anything ggq says at this point.
|
United States22154 Posts
Yep, GGQ has some insane role and based on that I think it is a waste to lynch him, lets look at other targets shall we? if we dont find anything better we can still lynch GGQ, but at this point it feels like a waste of a lynch which we badly need to use to reduce mafia kp at this point.
|
Nope, look at the old Coag from insane mafia.
Coag was mafia who was being voted because his disruptive and unhelpful posts. Near the end of the day, Coag acted shit weird. Turned out he really is mafia.
|
Wait guys I am a detective and I checked lunar and he is a serial killer.
Oh wait PEVERMIND
|
|
|
On February 16 2011 09:27 GMarshal wrote:
Yep, GGQ has some insane role and based on that I think it is a waste to lynch him, lets look at other targets shall we? if we dont find anything better we can still lynch GGQ, but at this point it feels like a waste of a lynch which we badly need to use to reduce mafia kp at this point.
![[image loading]](http://blog.muchmusic.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/fry.gif)
|
Ok, got home.
My thoughts on the day post:
Based on writing style and how people were killed, I believe we haven't hit any mafia. This is due to the fact that mafia KP still seems to be 2. If it's 2, then either both grunts are still alive, or they are both dead and it is the Godfather writin' up all the hits. But this doesn't make much sense. The kills seem to be written by different people, one joking, and the other more serious sounding. Granted, this could be the GF purposefully trying to write differently, but I think it's safer to assume we haven't hit any reds.
As for the other deaths. These both happened in the same way, with someone on a computer who saw something, and then convulsed an' died. So either they can be attributed to the same source, or someone is trying to mimic the day hit from yesterday. I'm still not sure if this can be attributed to a person or mechanic yet. There is no real indication that someone is causing the deaths beyond that people are getting emails, so that causes me to believe that we shouldn't rule out that these deaths are related to something else. I honestly thought it might be a way to conceal WOG, but after seeing Darmousseh die, that can't be right. I guess we'll see if they continue. =/
As for GGQ, did it seem like he was acting insane before he was up on the block for being lynched? This looks like it was in direct response to people putting pressure on him, so it might be part of his red text, or it's some kind of "insanity defense". Still, he has looked scummy, and he doesn't seem to be contributing much to town. If he's a mislynch, it's bad because of not lowering mafia KP, but we're also not losing a strong scumhunter/poster. My vote is going to stay on him unless someone else incredibly scummy comes up before the day is done.
|
Vancouver14381 Posts
On February 16 2011 08:29 kitaman27 wrote:
Really, no one opposes this? Also, shouldn't there be more discussion on the extra night hit and/or the lack of day hit so far?
The last day hit happened near the end of the cycle, so we'll probably have to wait a few more hours to see what turns up. I think that if pever posts it up as soon as he gets the PM, then it could reveal something like the location/time zone of the killer.
My hypotheses about the extra night kill - did we somehow get lucky and got both grunts? So, assuming the lovers were town/mafia, we took care of one grunt on the first day. So then mafia had 1 kill and a 3rd party had another. Then one of the following - the Misder lynch, the kitaman daykill, or the 5 modkills - killed the second grunt. I don't think the modkills could include a mafia grunt since that happened at the same time as the 3 night kills, but I'm just bringing up the possibilities. Now we have the GF having 2 kills for himself and the 3rd party is still around.
On February 16 2011 00:37 deconduo wrote:
@JBright
Just fyi, you are not allowed to reveal anything from the red text in your PM. If that is the case for that comment at the I would advise you to edit it out and beg forgiveness from pever.
Yes, I left out everything that could be associated with the red text.
|
Vancouver14381 Posts
EBYOP: well, don't I look stupid. I didn't consider the different writing styles.
There hasn't been too much activity outside of the really active players, so I don't have a good read on the others. Guess I'll jump on the bandwagon too.
Vote: GGQ
|
On February 16 2011 07:03 GMarshal wrote:Show nested quote +On February 16 2011 06:59 Coagulation wrote:On February 16 2011 06:48 kitaman27 wrote:On February 16 2011 06:35 Coagulation wrote:
GGQ has been 100% Useless this game. scum or no scum hes best be gone. In a game with 15 remaining and 6 modkills you would be willing to lynch a non scum? what makes you think hes non scum? The fact that he is being so blatantly scummy, what would scum gain from playing this way? If he were scum then why isn't he defending himself? If we hadn't had 5 modkills I'd be fine with just lynching him, but I realize now that if we don't hit mafia today then 2 more townies are going to be brutally murdered tonight, we aren't in a good spot right now and I dont think we can afford a mislynch. GGQ please post at least your name so we can use that to discuss weather or not to lynch. (according to the op there are no roles that win by being lynched, so you can't want to die)
On February 16 2011 09:27 GMarshal wrote:
Yep, GGQ has some insane role and based on that I think it is a waste to lynch him, lets look at other targets shall we? if we dont find anything better we can still lynch GGQ, but at this point it feels like a waste of a lynch which we badly need to use to reduce mafia kp at this point.
GMarshal you know something we don't about GGQ?
Vote GMarshal
|
I whip my hair back and forth!
|
United States22154 Posts
ok at this point I guess GGQ is just going to persist in being useless, we may as well hang him
in reply to Insanious , I don't but when town all jumps on a single lynch and there is next to no protest along with the person being lynched happily spouting nonsense there's something wrong, at least in my opinion. I had some hope that maybe GGQ would be a little bit more helpful, but I guess not.
Also LD, I hadn't considered that as a viable defense method, mostly because it seems so strange.
Note that I still don't believe GGQ is scum, but since he seems to be hanging himself, I won't stop him.
The fact that we have pretty much decided a lynch does not mean that we should stop scumhunting however, we need to get cracking on that since as far as we know its 13 to 3 probably with a third party out there who may or may not be interested in helping town.
I really do not have time to do an analysis of anyone right now, however I will try to get one done during the night cycle today, but please for the love of god people don't get complacent because we have a set lynch for today.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
