EPT(Posting from airport, lol)
Godfather Mafia - Page 30
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
BrownBear
United States6894 Posts
(Posting from airport, lol) | ||
|
Chezinu
United States7432 Posts
On July 03 2010 02:16 Hesmyrr wrote: Knowing the criteria behind Chezinu (or in fact anyone's) lynch list would indeed be nice. Considering it's nature, I am more interested in the people he chose to leave behind: zeks, Thegilaboy, Bill Murray, DCLXVI, ElyAs, and BrowneY. BrowneY is no-brainer for moment, but I am wondering why you do not ElyAs lynch? Are you willing to propose 'an' alternative lynch candidate that town can choose to go behind? zek roleclaim - gains immunity from lynch and he probably isn't GF Bill Murray - because he would have recruited me if he was GF - if he is GF that was a great play by not recruiting me BrowneY- obv reasons Others - they will get modkilled so no point in killing them - these are people mafia feel comfortable killing because they know they aren't the GF. Town is also comfortable killing these people because it prevents lost of a town/blue since they would die anyways. So in a way it is a "no lynch". I didn't narrow the list further because I was trying to be objective. I didn't want to rule-out any potential GFs. | ||
|
rastaban
United States2294 Posts
On July 03 2010 03:45 Hesmyrr wrote: Also since it should be beneficial to pick a candidate for roleblock before day ends, let me actively try to start an discussion: given a choice, should we choose to roleblock someone suspected of Mafia (blocks NK) or Godfather (blocks recruitment)? Obviously Korynne's plan hinges on getting Mafia goon so we have some semblance of control over night death, but I rather like the idea of trying to roleblock Godfather too, since the # of successful recruitments he get off before dying is critical to the game's fate. Moreover by not shying away from RBing Godfather we can just choose to roleblock the scummiest player without worrying about details. We just need to remember in such case kill occurring in night does not necessarily mean the roleblocked player is town. As for roleblock candidate, I propose rastaban. I first noticed him only because of his frequent vote switch, but I don't think this is that bad chocie at all. He is fairly active in the game, but is one of those player who did not attract that much attention of the town, due to YI / Korynne / Bill Murray hogging all the town's spotlight. I would appreciate it if you guys also started talking about who to roleblock (since lynch candidate this point seem to be decided as either ElyAs or Abenson) and why. The problem with roleblocking the GF is that while it would be very productive, we have no way of knowing if it worked. Thats why the DT should consider getting a read on them even if the night kill isn't blocked. | ||
|
Hesmyrr
Canada5776 Posts
On July 03 2010 04:00 Chezinu wrote: zek roleclaim - gains immunity from lynch and he probably isn't GF Bill Murray - because he would have recruited me if he was GF - if he is GF that was a great play by not recruiting me BrowneY- obv reasons Others - they will get modkilled so no point in killing them - these are people mafia feel comfortable killing because they know they aren't the GF. Town is also comfortable killing these people because it prevents lost of a town/blue since they would die anyways. So in a way it is a "no lynch". I didn't narrow the list further because I was trying to be objective. I didn't want to rule-out any potential GFs. Alright. You could have titled the list better than "list of lynch candidates" :p Also Bill Murray exclusion makes for a pretty shoddy objectiveness, doesn't it? I don't know much about players here so not sure what relationship you have with BM. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
i am just in line with my town meta i probably would have recruited L, but that would have been dumb, as he's inactive as shit | ||
|
YellowInk
United States578 Posts
| ||
|
DCLXVI
United States729 Posts
On July 03 2010 04:00 Chezinu wrote: zek roleclaim - gains immunity from lynch and he probably isn't GF Bill Murray - because he would have recruited me if he was GF - if he is GF that was a great play by not recruiting me BrowneY- obv reasons Others - they will get modkilled so no point in killing them - these are people mafia feel comfortable killing because they know they aren't the GF. Town is also comfortable killing these people because it prevents lost of a town/blue since they would die anyways. So in a way it is a "no lynch". I didn't narrow the list further because I was trying to be objective. I didn't want to rule-out any potential GFs. I will not be modkilled, I have just been very busy. However, Elyas is very likely to be killed tonight whether it be by lynch or modkill. Do we want to use a lynch on him? would we rather have him be modkilled and cut down on the number of suspects? I don't know if we have enough information now to drag up a decent list of suspects so I am not sure of anyone else we want to lynch. Abenson just seems to be new to the game and afraid to post, so I don't like him as a lynch suspect either. Unfortunately, I have to leave now for 6 hours or so so I will not be able to see any last minute bandwagons. I don't really like any of the candidates, but I will vote abenson to make him post more(not that I will be able to see it in time) | ||
|
YellowInk
United States578 Posts
| ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On July 03 2010 05:27 DCLXVI wrote: I will not be modkilled, I have just been very busy. However, Elyas is very likely to be killed tonight whether it be by lynch or modkill. Do we want to use a lynch on him? would we rather have him be modkilled and cut down on the number of suspects? I don't know if we have enough information now to drag up a decent list of suspects so I am not sure of anyone else we want to lynch. Abenson just seems to be new to the game and afraid to post, so I don't like him as a lynch suspect either. Unfortunately, I have to leave now for 6 hours or so so I will not be able to see any last minute bandwagons. I don't really like any of the candidates, but I will vote abenson to make him post more(not that I will be able to see it in time) pretty hard to have real supsects when there's only 1 mafia member who has no more information than any of us do at this point. Hell there might not even be a mafia yet if the gf got unlucky. For the first day it almost always has to be the inactives because they're as good as dead anyways, but if we let them coast by they could come back into the game at some point (and especially in a game like this) we wont know exactly what that means. Or have anything to compare to based on changes over time etc | ||
|
Hesmyrr
Canada5776 Posts
Is there any candidate for roleblock besides YI, Korynne, or esterban? | ||
|
youngminii
Australia7514 Posts
We have to decide who gets roleblocked asap because N1 is quickly approaching. Let me post up a tally for the roleblocker. citi.zen - 2 (Korynne, BM) Korynne - 2 (rastaban, Chezinu) YellowInk - 2 (lakrismamma, youngminii) rastaban - 1 (Hesmyrr) I may have missed a vote or two but we need to break this tie. We need to clearly choose one person to roleblock and the time to vote is now. | ||
|
Divinek
Canada4045 Posts
On July 03 2010 06:32 Hesmyrr wrote: Hmm, for better or worse ElyAs seem to be heading toward mod-kill. Changing my vote to Abenson; this should essentially be nice free double lynch. Is there any candidate for roleblock besides YI, Korynne, or esterban? Have you read none of this to understand why double lynching this early would be a bad thing? You're far more likely to hit a blue than a red if you're voting for no reason. Though I'm all in favour of pressuring inactive people to post more, but I'm not entirely sure if you're doing that or just bandwagoning on with some other people. It's always much better to actually post your reasons for voting for people, cause it could be interpreted poorly if you change without reason. | ||
|
ElyAs
France205 Posts
First, I'm okay with you lynching me. It's a mislynch, but well, better me than a blue role. Why ? Because today I couldn't be in front of my computer until now. The same will happen this week-end because I'm having some trouble I didn't expect. Sorry for wanting to participate in this game and not being able to do it (especially for the host, I'm feeling pretty bad about it tbh.) Next time I'll make sure I can be active in a mafia game before signing up. going to vote for a blank mainly to avoid modkill. (but if you want to modkill me, Darth, I think its legitimate) Death post (Won't be able to do it later) : + Show Spoiler + Townie | ||
|
youngminii
Australia7514 Posts
| ||
|
YellowInk
United States578 Posts
ElyAs, you can PM DTA and say "I can't play because something came up." The modkill would be reduced to a warning if you're giving notice rather than just flaking out. We could also get you an alternate. Anything beyond this is between you and the mod. | ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
lols at Death Posts before dying. Super funny if I get to modkill L though. | ||
|
Abenson
Canada4122 Posts
On July 03 2010 08:14 DarthThienAn wrote: Technically, he posted and voted. So no modkill. lols at Death Posts before dying. Super funny if I get to modkill L though. x2 funny points if he was recruited | ||
|
DarthThienAn
United States2734 Posts
Killing L is enough for me. Once L is out of the picture, I will have won and I will be unstoppable... xD + Show Spoiler + | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
this to me = a green role i am going to vote for the person who has the next most votes after elyas | ||
|
Abenson
Canada4122 Posts
I would actually support a no-lynch at this point. The chances of elyas and I being mafia are extremely slim, and the only inactive/not posting person are elyas and I (L doesn't count) I would propose that we keep more player in the game for now, as randomly lynching isn't very good IMO. Therefore I would like to follow the roleblocking plan. If there was no night hit that day, good, the mafia might have decided not to kill, and the town remains at 20 people + the DT can now investigating. Even if the mafia does hit someone, we would have a confirmed (for now) townie. P.S. I've lost count of how many death note references darth made now =.=" | ||
| ||
