EPTMicro-MAFIA (The Second) - Page 5
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
RebirthOfLeGenD
USA5860 Posts
On March 31 2010 11:25 CynanMachae wrote: Lack of activity is indeed a bad thing, but so far there has been really little to talk about. The one right now that drew my attention the most would be RoL, spamming stuff and "starting drama" as he said. Also, as someone (Flamewheel?) pointed out, comparing people's behavior with past games is a good part of what we should do; is this game KF91's first on TL? I NEED INFORMATION TO WORK WITH, ITS WHY I POST. At this point I have nothing to say. There is no plan to establish, everything obvious has been said. No lynch is a dumbfuck move. Don't lynch RC blues because they aren't mafia. If someone RC blue and you are that role. Counterclaim immediately. Trading blue for red is beneficial to the town. ALRIGHT? | ||
|
Vivi57
United States6599 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
didn't work first time | ||
|
KF91
Canada221 Posts
On March 31 2010 11:58 Bill Murray wrote: ##vote kf## didn't work first time  Still voting to lynch me? May I ask why? :/ | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
we got each other killed day 1 in ace's game and we were trying to help each other! lol | ||
|
KF91
Canada221 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
 | ||
|
Zona
40426 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
| ||
|
KF91
Canada221 Posts
By the way, your vote wasn't recognized again by the system again.. :/ So you might wanna try it a third time. XD | ||
|
madnessman
United States1581 Posts
On March 31 2010 12:01 KF91 wrote: Uh-oh; I hope I didn't just vote for myself by accidentally quoting you XD lol. why would it? L, i think it's a little unfair for you to dismiss anyone who hasn't proposed a lynch target. so far, there have scarcely been any posts with substance. on what basis am i to decide who to lynch? at this point, it'd be like taking a wild stab at the dark. this is basically what has gone down thus far: kf91: proposes random lynching. takes back proposal, says he'll wait for more people to post. repeats that he'll wait for more people to post. defends L. says we ought to target who talks the least. foolish: argues against kf91's suggestion of random lynching. thinks L's posting warrants his infamous "NOBODY CARES." likes how people are randomly voting. thinks town activity is more important than coordinating blue roles. L: something about english law. chocolate is delicious. says that he's just too good at arguing, so he should hold back, but the rest of us should all declare who we want to lynch. asks the town to get working please. cynan: says that there's not enough info for behavioral analysis till day 2. rol: attempts to start drama to get more info. flamewheel: wordy posts advising BM not to do anything stupid, L not to bring his grudges into the game, and rest of us townies to analyze peoples' previous mafia behavior. vivi: is sad that ace isnt playing. is suspicious of bm for drastically different posting style. bm: is not spamming! appears as though he's trying to turn over a new leaf...or using a different strategy? -.^ i dont know if i want to propose a lynch target so early on in the game. because there's so little to work from, it's very possible that a townie is unintentionally appearing suspicious in his grand total of 1 or 2 posts in this thread. the remedy for this is for everyone to post more; more activity = more opportunity for each of us to prove ourselves to everyone else. if i absolutely had to choose, i'd say im leaning towards flamewheel. he writes a huge wall of text, saying things that could be concisely said in one sentence. it struck me as though he is trying to make a simple piece of advice/comment sound like a grand strategy, bursting with town-favorable motivations. is he trying too hard to sound pro-town, or just naturally loquacious? things to think about i guess. | ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
L, i think it's a little unfair for you to dismiss anyone who hasn't proposed a lynch target. so far, there have scarcely been any posts with substance. on what basis am i to decide who to lynch? at this point, it'd be like taking a wild stab at the dark. That's kinda the point. Unless you kids grow some balls and point some fingers there's zero incentive for mafia to stir up discussion; why bother when silence automatically favors them? I'm not saying you need to go balls to the wall and kamikaze push someone for our lynch, but if you aren't posting rationales for our day 1 lynch, what exactly else are you doing? There's literally nothing else to talk about. | ||
|
madnessman
United States1581 Posts
On March 31 2010 12:42 L wrote: That's kinda the point. Unless you kids grow some balls and point some fingers there's zero incentive for mafia to stir up discussion; why bother when silence automatically favors them? I'm not saying you need to go balls to the wall and kamikaze push someone for our lynch, but if you aren't posting rationales for our day 1 lynch, what exactly else are you doing? There's literally nothing else to talk about. if i absolutely had to choose, i'd say im leaning towards flamewheel. he writes a huge wall of text, saying things that could be concisely said in one sentence. it struck me as though he is trying to make a simple piece of advice/comment sound like a grand strategy, bursting with town-favorable motivations. is he trying too hard to sound pro-town, or just naturally loquacious? things to think about i guess. did that and done. what i've noticed has warranted (for me) a closer look at flamewheel's posting. but at this point, it's pure speculation; how is flamewheel supposed to defend himself to these crumbles of suspicion that have gathered? "lol i just like to typez a lot  " also from what i can tell you've said nothing to kf, who is basically advocating a "sit back and wait for ppl to post" approach. if you won't, then i will. kf: your strategy, my friend, is detrimental to the town and has got to change. | ||
|
L
Canada4732 Posts
No one's really going to nail a killer argument for why they should or shouldn't be voted for lynch today because its day one. We have very little information in general. A potential defense, however, could be of the simple variety. Instead of saying you aren't mafia, prove that you're going to contribute to the town. For instance: "I promise to summarize everyone's positions once per day and make an analysis based on that". Even if the kid is mafia, now we know he'll be held to a certain standard throughout the game and we can see if he's intentionally playing down certain arguments as the game goes on. | ||
|
Vivi57
United States6599 Posts
This looks super characteristic of the "I'm mafia pretending to contribute" gameplan. ##vote CynanMachae## Also, now that bm has joined the party, he's acting like himself again and he's slightly pro town to me. As long as he's posting, there's no reason we should lynch bm day1 because it should be painfully obvious in a day or two if he's mafia based on his posts. | ||
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26782 Posts
@madnessman: Unfortunately, you said it best yourself. I like to be loquacious. No, nothing I've espoused in my "walls of text" is particularly novel or groundbreaking--I just want to list out the "obvious" (as L would say) things to preface how I am going to play this game. And I'm glad you've decided to take a closer gander at my posts^^ Makes me happy that people are reading? I've left KF91 alone for now after the initial "we should vote for a random lynch" because there are enough people hassling him that at this point I don't want to add the proverbial salt to the metaphorical wound >.> | ||
|
flamewheel
FREEAGLELAND26782 Posts
Any findings, CynanMachae? I believe that KF91 played in Mafia 2 (and was mafia), if my search is correct. However, he seems to be acting a bit "new" to the scene. If you don't report on this, I'll go through tomorrow and look for stuff, but as of now it's still very early on to be forming anything based off of that, especially since I've never even seen KF before this game. As for now, sleep for me. Getting up in 4 hours to watch Flash wipe the floor with Kwanro. | ||
|
Bill Murray
United States9292 Posts
I've given up trying to vote on KF91 | ||
| ||
