EPT
Incognito's TL Mafia XVI
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
I don't like either the idea of lynching the mayor right away, first of all, like most people said then no one would run, but most important, it removes the ability from the town to get additionnal information, which is pretty much the most important think to help us choose who to lynch each day. The voting power grows strong with late game, so early it shouldn't be a problem. By the case we lynch him in the middle of the game, if he hasn't proven by his actions that he is legit (or all bodyguards dead and he' still alive, or w/e reason we choose to lynch him), might be better just because of that mass of information you can get from it afterwards. But really, mayor can pretty much be a double edged sword for each camp, wheter he's mafia or town, it all depend on how he's playing. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 21 2010 09:09 DoctorHelvetica wrote: As far as lynching the mayor or not, that's really going to scare anyone who is running. I also find it strange that you are proposing to immediately lynch the mayor when you are running for elected positions yourself. Well I guess he's hoping to get sheriff or none of them, lol. That makes me think, for anyone saying to lynch the mayor first day, why not sheriff then? He pretty much get only that rolecheck immunity since his incarceration ability isn't that great, and rolecheck immunity is something that benefit only the mafia. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 21 2010 13:30 citi.zen wrote: I think if t_co turns out red we have a great chance to end this very fast. If not, we still get a number of clues, a new list of suspects (I will gladly put myself at the top of that list), and a long-ish one with likely innocent people. That is a lot of info, well worth the risk in my view. Lynching Hobbes on the other hand... not so useful, even if he is guilty/red. Same KP for the mob, no new info. Why would we end it very fast if t_co is red? And by lynching Hobbes or t_co, if one of them flips reds its the same KP anyway... Anyway, I'm still thinking Hobbes should be the mayor's lynch. Clues are much better than all this speculation right now | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 21 2010 13:49 flamewheel91 wrote: However, since Hobbes hasn't posted much, and the main reason we suspect him is because of clues, even if he DOES turn out red it will not let us uncover any new leads. I think that if we lynch Hobbes and he turns out red we'll know that we are doing pretty well with the clue analysis and those first we got the clues on Hobbes are not mafia. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
Anyway, gonna go sleep on this too. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
Also, I really think that double lynch should be reserved for later when we have many mafia suspects and need to lower their KP (i.e. toward the end of the game). | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
# of posts in this thread: DoctorHelvetica : 129 meeple : 72 789 : 61 Bill Murray : 59 citi.zen : 55 t_co : 40 Jugan : 22 Zona : 21 [NyC]HoBbes : 18 flamewheel91 : 17 blue_arrow : 15 Nikoner : 12 The_Master : 10 Ser Aspi : 10 Abenson : 9 Mystlord : 7 CynanMachae : 7 Ng5 : 6 Hyperbola : 4 Jayme : 3 Phrujbaz : 3 tredmasta : 3 ghote : 3 Faronel : 3 keit : 2 dinmsab : 2 derfboy : 1 kane]deth[ : 1 StimiLant : 1 magicbullet : 1 skronch : 1 Fallen_arK : 1 Thanks for the list, though is there a quick way to get this or you really counted it? o.o | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 22 2010 10:23 Nikoner wrote: At first I hadn't realised that Bill Murray has been posting so much... and most, if not all, of his posts are like this: Which doesn't even make sense, since it will most likely lead to us lynching 2 townies, if anything... Most of his posts has been triple-post confusing one liners yea, but that isn't much of an argument for lynching | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 22 2010 10:29 meeple wrote: It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why? Day 1 lynching choices for the mayor? | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 22 2010 10:36 flamewheel91 wrote: I still say we lynch t_co, then move onto Hobbes (by clues) since a disruptive player just adds senseless text to wade through. I'm keeping up with all this whenever I get back to my computer, so it makes it easier on the people like me. Furthermore, if we get the mafia day 1 or 2 it doesn't matter since they are able to have 3 killpower anyway since 7 and 6 are the same. Well, you could say that if we get a mafia on day 1 AND day two their kp would be reduced. But anyway, chances are very low of that lol. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 22 2010 10:29 meeple wrote: It's getting down to the wire guys... can everyone please put their choice and perhaps a short blurb describing why? [NYC]Hobbes - Simply due to clue analysis (hobbes being a tiger -> barbaric noises, NYC -> Big apple). If he flips red, well that's good, and we have some confirmed non-mafias (those that got the clues out). I don't really like lynching t_co for pretty much the same reason that has been said, he's been active, yes no making much sense, but all of this is all much more information that could be used at a later point. But yea, keeping him out of the mayor spot would be pretty important. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
On January 22 2010 10:37 Nikoner wrote: I never said I wanted to lynch him. Methinks you doth protest too much. Well if was only a step forward from you suspecting him, that he might be mafia  . | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
And the day is ending in like 10 minutes? (9 PM EST) I saw in the voting thread some people taking about 9 PST (12 EST) also so I'm not sure. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
Let's wait | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
 | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
I think we need to focus on how much information we get from each lynches. Seems right now the three prime suspects from the voting thread would be keit, Mystlord, and DrH. If we lynch keit and he turns blue/green, could very well mean DrH is red. If he turns red, while DrH advokates that it means he couldn't be red, as it as been said before it could be a mafia sacrifice to save DrH. Also, we don't get others leads from a keit lynch, since it's mostly between him and DrH. If we lynch Mystlord and he turns blue/green, I don't even see what info we get except that we failed again at clue analysis. If he does turn red tho, I gives us an important hint toward DrH. Finally, if we lynch DoctorHelvetica and he turns blue/green, we have one certain mafia member as the "detective". We also have strong lead on those others people citi.zen mentionned that had been advocating a DrH lynch in PMs. It might also be a hint toward keit. If he instead flips red, Mystlord seems a very likely mafia, we have 200+ posts to analyze from a mafia's viewpoint, and a confirmed DT. | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
And I thought that sheriff couldn't use his power if he was lynched? Seems he can >< | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
And while we're at it: 1 of 1 Sheriff remains I think we are down to 0 :o | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
| ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
"31. Jayme" in green is actually JohannesH | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
And I did use a clue check on Night 3, but since I died like 10 minutes after it doesnt matter much | ||
|
CynanMachae
Canada1459 Posts
And yea, waiting before posting DrH's accusation in order to collect more clues and get reactions on differents suspects is what really helped to catch the last mafia members imo. | ||
| ||
