• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 21:26
CET 03:26
KST 11:26
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #233[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over1Dark completes military service, returns to SC215[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon No more SC2 streamers on team liquid?
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 12734 users

New Macro = Good!? - Page 6

Forum Index > Legacy of the Void
Post a Reply
Prev 1 4 5 6 7 Next All
PinheadXXXXXX
Profile Joined February 2012
United States897 Posts
August 10 2015 04:33 GMT
#101
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.
Taeja the one true Byunjwa~
[UoN]Sentinel
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
United States11320 Posts
August 10 2015 14:03 GMT
#102
On August 06 2015 04:04 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 06 2015 04:01 jpg06051992 wrote:
On August 06 2015 03:42 mishimaBeef wrote:
On August 06 2015 03:41 jpg06051992 wrote:
On August 06 2015 03:38 mishimaBeef wrote:
On August 06 2015 03:35 Little-Chimp wrote:
On August 06 2015 03:32 mishimaBeef wrote:
I want to bring up the analogy of a sports team with few superstars vs a sports team with great team cohesion and strategy. Mechanical skill is like the first team. Deep strategic understanding (with still execution being a factor obviously) is the second team. But we can't have the 2nd team winning championships if the rules are rigged such as anyone who can reach top speed of > 40 km/h during a game automatically gets his team extra points.


Sports teams run drills and cardio practices non stop, unless conditioning is at least similar, the team with better "mechanics" will always win. This is a horrible example. Starcraft isn't even a team game god damn.


The idea is that the player with god-like mechanics is able to reach top speed of very high during a game (and is rewarded greatly for it). Whereas the other player might have all the correct pieces in place, in terms of their strategy, and their strategic pieces might be superior to the god-like-mechanics player but they can't get those extra reward boosts.


Ok I see what your saying, but it's just wrong man, your talking like these players with God like mechanics just have those mechanics compared to the poor foreigners that are making all of the right moves but not fast enough.

I'm not trying to be an elitist here man but those players with god like mechanics trained way harder then any foreign player besides Snute maybe to get them that way.

Notice how Snute trains non stop in Korea and therefore he is able to at least semi go toe to toe with Koreans? Yea, so do you want to punish people like him that trained hard to get Korean level mechanics so the rest of the crappy foreigners can "have a chance" so to speak?

O__o


Yeah it's like if they rigged the rules of basketball so if you can jump extra-extra high during a slam dunk you get an extra 5 points. I think Lebron James will suddenly be carrying his team a lot more, but that's okay because he practiced and is skilled in his mechanics right?


Right, except nothing in SC is rigged for anything but the better player to win, frankly man your example is just terrible lol

Even if that was the case, if there was a player that was naturally talented or worked hard enough to use that advantage, should the game be toned down so the lesser players can compete? Or should Lebron James just be better then your average basketball player?

It's like your saying the Koreans are better because they are Koreans and have awesome mechanics and that's just not fair to the poor foreigners who don't train all day everyday to be excellent at the game.

It would actually be like increasing each dimension of the court by 2. So twice as long from end to end, baskets are twice as high off the ground, etc. It would be a different game and disadvantage the players who are more reliant on height/layups, while advantaging the players who shoot from farther away since they're used to the distance and now the basket is bigger. It doesn't mean your average joe is being coddled, it's testing different aspects of your play at the expense of others.

I still defend my own sports analogy.
Нас зовет дух отцов, память старых бойцов, дух Москвы и твердыня Полтавы
Temeter
Profile Joined April 2014
37 Posts
August 10 2015 14:31 GMT
#103
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.
sh1RoKen
Profile Joined March 2012
Russian Federation93 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-08-10 14:58:54
August 10 2015 14:58 GMT
#104
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".
Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet.
[UoN]Sentinel
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
United States11320 Posts
August 10 2015 15:02 GMT
#105
On August 10 2015 23:58 sh1RoKen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".

I'd argue it's a bit of both. StarCraft is a real-time strategy game, so the faster you can do things, the more of an advantage you have. APM is an important part of the game. That being said, I agree with you that macro mechanics that are there for the sake of APM are ridiculous. How you spend your APM should be more of a strategic choice, not a necessity like it is now.
Нас зовет дух отцов, память старых бойцов, дух Москвы и твердыня Полтавы
Crownlol
Profile Blog Joined October 2011
United States3726 Posts
August 10 2015 15:02 GMT
#106
That OP was like the first thing that I've actually gotten excited about in regards to SC2 in a looooooong time.
shaGuar :: elemeNt :: XeqtR :: naikon :: method
sh1RoKen
Profile Joined March 2012
Russian Federation93 Posts
August 10 2015 15:12 GMT
#107
On August 11 2015 00:02 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 10 2015 23:58 sh1RoKen wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".

I'd argue it's a bit of both. StarCraft is a real-time strategy game, so the faster you can do things, the more of an advantage you have. APM is an important part of the game. That being said, I agree with you that macro mechanics that are there for the sake of APM are ridiculous. How you spend your APM should be more of a strategic choice, not a necessity like it is now.

You can spend your APM on 1000 different things but macro. You can attack multiple locations. You can outmicro your opponents. You can drop, run-in and attack meanwhile defending from all of these. But these actions are fun to watch!!! These actions are direct actions against your opponent. And who is better at those actions wins the game.

And it would be 10 times more interesting game for everyone if we will not have to spend 60-80% of our AMP on handling our own buildings, production, expanding, macro merchanics and supply.
Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet.
[UoN]Sentinel
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
United States11320 Posts
August 10 2015 15:18 GMT
#108
On August 11 2015 00:12 sh1RoKen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 11 2015 00:02 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:58 sh1RoKen wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".

I'd argue it's a bit of both. StarCraft is a real-time strategy game, so the faster you can do things, the more of an advantage you have. APM is an important part of the game. That being said, I agree with you that macro mechanics that are there for the sake of APM are ridiculous. How you spend your APM should be more of a strategic choice, not a necessity like it is now.

You can spend your APM on 1000 different things but macro. You can attack multiple locations. You can outmicro your opponents. You can drop, run-in and attack meanwhile defending from all of these. But these actions are fun to watch!!! These actions are direct actions against your opponent. And who is better at those actions wins the game.

And it would be 10 times more interesting game for everyone if we will not have to spend 60-80% of our AMP on handling our own buildings, production, expanding, macro merchanics and supply.

Macro is still crucial. Instead of microing your 5 marines, you can macro, lose the 5, but then you'll have 10 marines which you can attack with. Or you can focus on micro and keep the 5 alive. That's a strategic decision where macro is involved. You can macro different things - do I build 10 marines, or do I tech up and get him with hellions or banshees?

Chrono has some strategic value (what do I chrono, units or upgrades?) but it must always be used, so it can be removed for balance purposes. MULEs have less (save some energy for scan, save more if there's DT's, otherwise, always drop mules), and injects have none at all. You always have to inject and there's no good reason not to.

The reward of high APM is that you can produce more units due to good macro, keep your army alive due to good micro, or do both with really high APM and dominate your opponent. It's a skill that can gradually be learned, but there shouldn't be obstacles in the way with mechanics like inject.
Нас зовет дух отцов, память старых бойцов, дух Москвы и твердыня Полтавы
DinosaurPoop
Profile Blog Joined April 2013
687 Posts
August 10 2015 15:23 GMT
#109
On August 10 2015 23:58 sh1RoKen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".


chessboxing!
When cats speak, mice listen.
sh1RoKen
Profile Joined March 2012
Russian Federation93 Posts
August 10 2015 15:33 GMT
#110
On August 11 2015 00:18 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 11 2015 00:12 sh1RoKen wrote:
On August 11 2015 00:02 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:58 sh1RoKen wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".

I'd argue it's a bit of both. StarCraft is a real-time strategy game, so the faster you can do things, the more of an advantage you have. APM is an important part of the game. That being said, I agree with you that macro mechanics that are there for the sake of APM are ridiculous. How you spend your APM should be more of a strategic choice, not a necessity like it is now.

You can spend your APM on 1000 different things but macro. You can attack multiple locations. You can outmicro your opponents. You can drop, run-in and attack meanwhile defending from all of these. But these actions are fun to watch!!! These actions are direct actions against your opponent. And who is better at those actions wins the game.

And it would be 10 times more interesting game for everyone if we will not have to spend 60-80% of our AMP on handling our own buildings, production, expanding, macro merchanics and supply.

Macro is still crucial. Instead of microing your 5 marines, you can macro, lose the 5, but then you'll have 10 marines which you can attack with. Or you can focus on micro and keep the 5 alive. That's a strategic decision where macro is involved. You can macro different things - do I build 10 marines, or do I tech up and get him with hellions or banshees?

Chrono has some strategic value (what do I chrono, units or upgrades?) but it must always be used, so it can be removed for balance purposes. MULEs have less (save some energy for scan, save more if there's DT's, otherwise, always drop mules), and injects have none at all. You always have to inject and there's no good reason not to.

The reward of high APM is that you can produce more units due to good macro, keep your army alive due to good micro, or do both with really high APM and dominate your opponent. It's a skill that can gradually be learned, but there shouldn't be obstacles in the way with mechanics like inject.


All of that is true. Macro is the ability to take an advantage from doing indirect actions against your opponent.

But it is just not fun to watch and play with this.

Imagine that we have 2 marines and a lurker in a silver league game. You can insane micro your marines and kill the lurker. Instead you can just a+move, lose your marines instantly, build 10 marines behind that, go to the lurker location with them, a+move and kill it instantly.

It is twice less action time, it is boring to watch and it is not fun for a player.
Be polite, be professional, but have a plan to kill everybody you meet.
Temeter
Profile Joined April 2014
37 Posts
August 10 2015 15:38 GMT
#111
On August 11 2015 00:33 sh1RoKen wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 11 2015 00:18 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
On August 11 2015 00:12 sh1RoKen wrote:
On August 11 2015 00:02 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:58 sh1RoKen wrote:
On August 10 2015 23:31 Temeter wrote:
On August 10 2015 13:33 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
On August 10 2015 12:51 TokO wrote:
On August 10 2015 11:08 PinheadXXXXXX wrote:
Everyone pretending that macro mechanics are bad because of some strange analogs they create for actual sports clearly hasn't actually played or watched a lot of sports. Almost every single sport requires a very high level of fitness (much like a very high level macro) to even compete at a high level. And people practice basic mechanical skills in isolation (keepy-uppies anyone?) but it works anyway. In fact, good soccer youth programs focus almost entirely on mechanics and forget formations, tactics, etc. for a very long time. If what the OP says is true then that's actually great news but pretending that every other game or sport doesn't require a very high level of mechanics of some sort to improve is ridiculous.


I think most sports analogies were made in the defense of macro mechanics.

A lot of people said some situations were like giving basketball teams extra points if their players could jump a certain height, or things along these lines.

That comparision doesn't make any sense, tho. Starcraft doesn't reward points for good macro, just as jumping higher doesn't get you points in basketball. The addional units you produce are the reward, which tend to be quite helpful at winning a match.

Compared, removing macro mechanics is more like prohibiting basketball players from jumping over a certain hight.

Starcraft 2 is a Strategy game. It should be like a chess. It is very easy to move figures, but only a very good player make it look like a sport. We are competing here with our minds!
It's not like a basketball or football at all! Your opponent's mind should be the only thing that makes game hard for you. You should not be stopped from achieving an advantage by some activities which are not against your opponent. Right now it's more like "My skill in playing vs computer is better than your skill playing vs computer".

Current mechanic in sport metaphor: "If you want to castle you king, you must walk 50 meters on your hands before".

I'd argue it's a bit of both. StarCraft is a real-time strategy game, so the faster you can do things, the more of an advantage you have. APM is an important part of the game. That being said, I agree with you that macro mechanics that are there for the sake of APM are ridiculous. How you spend your APM should be more of a strategic choice, not a necessity like it is now.

You can spend your APM on 1000 different things but macro. You can attack multiple locations. You can outmicro your opponents. You can drop, run-in and attack meanwhile defending from all of these. But these actions are fun to watch!!! These actions are direct actions against your opponent. And who is better at those actions wins the game.

And it would be 10 times more interesting game for everyone if we will not have to spend 60-80% of our AMP on handling our own buildings, production, expanding, macro merchanics and supply.

Macro is still crucial. Instead of microing your 5 marines, you can macro, lose the 5, but then you'll have 10 marines which you can attack with. Or you can focus on micro and keep the 5 alive. That's a strategic decision where macro is involved. You can macro different things - do I build 10 marines, or do I tech up and get him with hellions or banshees?

Chrono has some strategic value (what do I chrono, units or upgrades?) but it must always be used, so it can be removed for balance purposes. MULEs have less (save some energy for scan, save more if there's DT's, otherwise, always drop mules), and injects have none at all. You always have to inject and there's no good reason not to.

The reward of high APM is that you can produce more units due to good macro, keep your army alive due to good micro, or do both with really high APM and dominate your opponent. It's a skill that can gradually be learned, but there shouldn't be obstacles in the way with mechanics like inject.


All of that is true. Macro is the ability to take an advantage from doing indirect actions against your opponent.

But it is just not fun to watch and play with this.


So Starcraft isn't fun? Because that's always been a central element of Starcraft 2, and Broodwar was actually even more macro-heavy.

Challenging macro is a base the game is build upon. And a lot of that macro doesn't evolve decisions. Following an uninterrupted build order, buildings workers or units is purely 'busywork' too. Compare Dawn of War or Grey Goo, where you can actually toggle constant production.
Pirfiktshon
Profile Joined June 2013
United States1072 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-08-10 15:50:42
August 10 2015 15:48 GMT
#112
So Starcraft isn't fun? Because that's always been a central element of Starcraft 2, and Broodwar was actually even more macro-heavy.

Challenging macro is a base the game is build upon. And a lot of that macro doesn't evolve decisions. Following an uninterrupted build order, buildings workers or units is purely 'busywork' too. Compare Dawn of War or Grey Goo, where you can actually toggle constant production.


Which is actually the reason I don't play those specific games LOL I think Macro is a beautiful thing and I don't think them removing the macro abilities is necessarily a bad thing atleast at this moment in time. We will have to see how it works like DK said at gamescon....

Personally I think we are at a turning point where if we don't test it now we will never know because I don't think they will make a giant test like this like even 2 months from now being so close to release date...
TimeSpiral
Profile Joined January 2011
United States1010 Posts
August 10 2015 15:53 GMT
#113
The chess thing ... People love to invoke chess, and while there are certainly similarities: positional and material advantages, anticipation, etc, the comparison breaks down pretty hard, and pretty fast.

(1) Chess, you can see the whole board. SC2--for some reason--these hyper-advanced space-traveling races cannot. So, full information (save intention) vs. limited information (save intention).

(2) Chess is a mirror match, always. SC2 is not.

(3) Chess is always played on the same board. SC2 is not, unless you're considering "the game" the same thing as "the board", which I would probably argue against.

And ... for the big one ...

(4) Chess is turn-based. SC is real time.

Really, guys. I'd love to put this comparison to rest. Concepts can be borrowed from both, to enhance contextual understanding, and whatnot, but these are just basic strategy and head-to-head competition concepts. Virtually every contest includes these overlaps.

Moving on ...

Real Time basically means that the faster player has an advantage. There is just no way around this. So, the fact that it is real time very much means that part of the skill and fun and interaction with the game is your ability to interface with the game quickly, accurately, and consistently. If the game were only about strategy, then it would be turn-based.

The game is real-time and strategy.

Moving on ...

The inclination to implement regressive policies. Ugh. I suppose there is some room for this inclination, but it really does irritate me sometimes. For those who may not know: regressives want to return the game to a less sophisticated state, like it was "back in the day". Traditional sports hear this argument from over-the-hill commentators all the time. All the sports balance the advancements in technology with the elements of the game: fairness, spectator value, viability, etc ...

Limiting things like: (1) being able to select multiple units, (2) control-grouping buildings and units, (3) key-bindings, etc ... is absurdly regressive. I sincerely doubt the creators of the games of old: Red Alert, Warcraft 2, Starcraft, etc ... said, "the highest level play will be so much more rewarding if we limit the number of units they can select, and if we deny the ability to key bind buildings and queue units!" I strongly suspect that when these developers were pioneering the mechanics of the game, that is what we ended up with because that's (a) what they were able to think of, and/or (b) what they were technically limited to based on a variety of things. But I'm speculating. Maybe there is an old developer on record about this. Not sure.

Games advanced. Programming became more sophisticated. They all competed with each other. The tech running the games got better. And so the capabilities of in-game management and control also became more sophisticated.

The industry will progress. Period. Embrace it, is my humble suggestion.
[G] Positioning, Formations, and Tactics: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=187892
Temeter
Profile Joined April 2014
37 Posts
August 10 2015 15:58 GMT
#114
On August 11 2015 00:48 Pirfiktshon wrote:
Show nested quote +
So Starcraft isn't fun? Because that's always been a central element of Starcraft 2, and Broodwar was actually even more macro-heavy.

Challenging macro is a base the game is build upon. And a lot of that macro doesn't evolve decisions. Following an uninterrupted build order, buildings workers or units is purely 'busywork' too. Compare Dawn of War or Grey Goo, where you can actually toggle constant production.


Which is actually the reason I don't play those specific games LOL I think Macro is a beautiful thing and I don't think them removing the macro abilities is necessarily a bad thing atleast at this moment in time. We will have to see how it works like DK said at gamescon....

Personally I think we are at a turning point where if we don't test it now we will never know because I don't think they will make a giant test like this like even 2 months from now being so close to release date...

I honestly got doubts they can even test enough the remaining 2 to 4 months. This would completely throw over the current balance and how the races work at their core. Zerg are build around larva, terran buildorders around Orbitals, and protoss tech/economy around chronoboost. Might recreate an early WoL situation.
Sogetsu
Profile Joined July 2011
514 Posts
August 10 2015 16:39 GMT
#115
It doesn't matter right now... David Kim is gonna cut them in the next patch so we can TEST IT and see ourselves how the game goes without them

I can't wait to try it instead theorycrafting the whole wee about it.
Raptor: "Es hora de salvar a los E-Sports..." http://i3.minus.com/ibtne3liprtByB.png
Temeter
Profile Joined April 2014
37 Posts
August 10 2015 16:56 GMT
#116
On August 11 2015 01:39 Sogetsu wrote:
It doesn't matter right now... David Kim is gonna cut them in the next patch so we can TEST IT and see ourselves how the game goes without them

I can't wait to try it instead theorycrafting the whole wee about it.

I can tell you: If they keep it as it is, then the beta is going to be completely broken. Zerg will be OP like nothing else.

Can't remove two race's heavy macro booster and then slightly nerf the other. Zerg is build around a scalable economy, so they just drop a bunch of macro hatches. Why can they do that? Because the others have next to no pressure potencial.
[UoN]Sentinel
Profile Blog Joined November 2009
United States11320 Posts
August 10 2015 16:57 GMT
#117
On August 11 2015 00:58 Temeter wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 11 2015 00:48 Pirfiktshon wrote:
So Starcraft isn't fun? Because that's always been a central element of Starcraft 2, and Broodwar was actually even more macro-heavy.

Challenging macro is a base the game is build upon. And a lot of that macro doesn't evolve decisions. Following an uninterrupted build order, buildings workers or units is purely 'busywork' too. Compare Dawn of War or Grey Goo, where you can actually toggle constant production.


Which is actually the reason I don't play those specific games LOL I think Macro is a beautiful thing and I don't think them removing the macro abilities is necessarily a bad thing atleast at this moment in time. We will have to see how it works like DK said at gamescon....

Personally I think we are at a turning point where if we don't test it now we will never know because I don't think they will make a giant test like this like even 2 months from now being so close to release date...

I honestly got doubts they can even test enough the remaining 2 to 4 months. This would completely throw over the current balance and how the races work at their core. Zerg are build around larva, terran buildorders around Orbitals, and protoss tech/economy around chronoboost. Might recreate an early WoL situation.

Considering their original intent was to create a sort of "SC2.5" with radical changes like 12 workers, new economy, mechanics that destroy existing staples like ravager shot destroying force fields or changing the warp gate mechanic, I think the loss of macro might be right in line with these changes. Obviously there will have to be new balancing accordingly, but it won't be game-breaking.
Нас зовет дух отцов, память старых бойцов, дух Москвы и твердыня Полтавы
Temeter
Profile Joined April 2014
37 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-08-10 16:59:41
August 10 2015 16:59 GMT
#118
On August 11 2015 01:57 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 11 2015 00:58 Temeter wrote:
On August 11 2015 00:48 Pirfiktshon wrote:
So Starcraft isn't fun? Because that's always been a central element of Starcraft 2, and Broodwar was actually even more macro-heavy.

Challenging macro is a base the game is build upon. And a lot of that macro doesn't evolve decisions. Following an uninterrupted build order, buildings workers or units is purely 'busywork' too. Compare Dawn of War or Grey Goo, where you can actually toggle constant production.


Which is actually the reason I don't play those specific games LOL I think Macro is a beautiful thing and I don't think them removing the macro abilities is necessarily a bad thing atleast at this moment in time. We will have to see how it works like DK said at gamescon....

Personally I think we are at a turning point where if we don't test it now we will never know because I don't think they will make a giant test like this like even 2 months from now being so close to release date...

I honestly got doubts they can even test enough the remaining 2 to 4 months. This would completely throw over the current balance and how the races work at their core. Zerg are build around larva, terran buildorders around Orbitals, and protoss tech/economy around chronoboost. Might recreate an early WoL situation.

Considering their original intent was to create a sort of "SC2.5" with radical changes like 12 workers, new economy, mechanics that destroy existing staples like ravager shot destroying force fields or changing the warp gate mechanic, I think the loss of macro might be right in line with these changes. Obviously there will have to be new balancing accordingly, but it won't be game-breaking.

Lets hope so! Even Hots had a bunch of gamebreaking things being abused (think blink era).
Pirfiktshon
Profile Joined June 2013
United States1072 Posts
August 10 2015 19:46 GMT
#119
Considering their original intent was to create a sort of "SC2.5" with radical changes like 12 workers, new economy, mechanics that destroy existing staples like ravager shot destroying force fields or changing the warp gate mechanic, I think the loss of macro might be right in line with these changes. Obviously there will have to be new balancing accordingly, but it won't be game-breaking


Dare I say it I agree with sentinel. I think there is going to be some re-balancing and some changes with units to make it more intense with micro... actually to really think about it I feel like DK is setting this up to be like BW .... don't be surprised if we have 12 unit max in control groups and workers have to be micro managed to mine next!!! LOL
ROOTFayth
Profile Joined January 2004
Canada3351 Posts
August 10 2015 19:51 GMT
#120
it's probably going to be easier to balance without macro mechanics, they were all so different and affected the game in different ways sometimes in the late game, sometimes in the early game... either way I'd be pretty happy if they removed it, might be an incentive to play again
Prev 1 4 5 6 7 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
PiGosaur Cup
10:00
#108
PiGStarcraft652
CranKy Ducklings56
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
PiGStarcraft652
CosmosSc2 82
SpeCial 39
RuFF_SC2 39
StarCraft: Brood War
Artosis 676
Rush 109
Force[name] 3
GuemChi 0
Counter-Strike
taco 541
SPUNJ524
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr97
Other Games
summit1g16584
Day[9].tv993
shahzam537
JimRising 523
C9.Mang0498
ViBE96
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick1193
BasetradeTV145
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 87
• EnkiAlexander 43
• CranKy Ducklings SOOP11
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Azhi_Dahaki13
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Other Games
• Day9tv993
Upcoming Events
The PondCast
7h 34m
University League
7h 34m
LiuLi Cup
8h 34m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
13h 34m
Replay Cast
20h 34m
GSL
1d 9h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
1d 11h
OSC
1d 13h
Replay Cast
1d 20h
KCM Race Survival
2 days
[ Show More ]
Ultimate Battle
2 days
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
3 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
4 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
4 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
4 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.