• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 12:41
CET 18:41
KST 02:41
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
RSL Revival - 2025 Season Finals Preview8RSL Season 3 - Playoffs Preview0RSL Season 3 - RO16 Groups C & D Preview0RSL Season 3 - RO16 Groups A & B Preview2TL.net Map Contest #21: Winners12
Community News
ComeBackTV's documentary on Byun's Career !8Weekly Cups (Dec 8-14): MaxPax, Clem, Cure win4Weekly Cups (Dec 1-7): Clem doubles, Solar gets over the hump1Weekly Cups (Nov 24-30): MaxPax, Clem, herO win2BGE Stara Zagora 2026 announced15
StarCraft 2
General
When will we find out if there are more tournament ComeBackTV's documentary on Byun's Career ! Weekly Cups (Dec 8-14): MaxPax, Clem, Cure win RSL Revival - 2025 Season Finals Preview Weekly Cups (Dec 1-7): Clem doubles, Solar gets over the hump
Tourneys
$5,000+ WardiTV 2025 Championship RSL Offline Finals Info - Dec 13 and 14! Master Swan Open (Global Bronze-Master 2) Winter Warp Gate Amateur Showdown #1: Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament
Strategy
Custom Maps
Map Editor closed ?
External Content
Mutation # 504 Retribution Mutation # 503 Fowl Play Mutation # 502 Negative Reinforcement Mutation # 501 Price of Progress
Brood War
General
BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ FlaSh on: Biggest Problem With SnOw's Playstyle How Rain Became ProGamer in Just 3 Months screp: Command line app to parse SC rep files [BSL21] RO8 Bracket & Prediction Contest
Tourneys
Small VOD Thread 2.0 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL21] WB SEMIFINALS - Saturday 21:00 CET [BSL21] RO8 - Day 2 - Sunday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Game Theory for Starcraft Current Meta Simple Questions, Simple Answers Fighting Spirit mining rates
Other Games
General Games
PC Games Sales Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Nintendo Switch Thread Path of Exile General RTS Discussion Thread
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
Mafia Game Mode Feedback/Ideas Survivor II: The Amazon Sengoku Mafia TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine The Games Industry And ATVI YouTube Thread
Fan Clubs
White-Ra Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece Movie Discussion!
Sports
2024 - 2026 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
TL+ Announced Where to ask questions and add stream?
Blogs
The (Hidden) Drug Problem in…
TrAiDoS
I decided to write a webnov…
DjKniteX
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
Thanks for the RSL
Hildegard
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 2164 users

The Balance and Redesign of Protoss in LOTV - Page 3

Forum Index > Legacy of the Void
Post a Reply
Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All
Lexender
Profile Joined September 2013
Mexico2655 Posts
July 20 2015 04:55 GMT
#41
On July 19 2015 09:42 Cloak wrote:
What's the true harm of uncapping MsC? Multi pronged recall seems like an attractive goal. They also don't stack that well.


The MsC is already one of the strongest spell casters there is, having 1 Msc is already a lot, having more than 1 would be too broken. Specially recall, there shouldn't be a spell that allows for a player to take bad positions with just 1 button to save all his units.
InfidiumX
Profile Joined April 2013
United States9 Posts
July 20 2015 08:06 GMT
#42
I really hope they address and give protoss the big buff it need to survive with zerg and terran. I don't understand why remove FF's, buff collsi, nothing feels strong. Adepts are a harass unit. Terrans and zerg will have excuses to why protoss is 'ok'. There a big reason why you almost never see protoss in LoTV tournaments or being played much. I hope they fix the game. I know it's a beta but why are Zerg and Terran so strong? and Protoss is clearly weak. They never got buffs in HoTS and the community complain about 'power of protoss'. Feel like there alot of bias players out there being the most vocal. And not Open minded honest players that really want to see the race on a fair playing field as the other 2 races. It their own expansion. It's very disappointing to see.
"They come for our blood, but drown in their own."
deacon.frost
Profile Joined February 2013
Czech Republic12129 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-20 09:15:22
July 20 2015 09:14 GMT
#43
On July 20 2015 13:55 Lexender wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 19 2015 09:42 Cloak wrote:
What's the true harm of uncapping MsC? Multi pronged recall seems like an attractive goal. They also don't stack that well.


The MsC is already one of the strongest spell casters there is, having 1 Msc is already a lot, having more than 1 would be too broken. Specially recall, there shouldn't be a spell that allows for a player to take bad positions with just 1 button to save all his units.

Recall was added to T1 because Protoss doesn't have any retreat possibility. Both sentry and zealot are slower than marines or zerglings/roaches(on creep). And one of the 1st upgrades in the game is research of speed buff to these mentioned units(stim, speed bufs).
(and not mentioning idiotic concussive shells)

Otherwise we would return to WoL level, where you could go only early game all in(especially in PvZ where you cannot retreat with sentries which are tons of gas).

It's a stupid fix and everyone knows it, there's a reason why recall was so far in tech tree in BW/WoL.
I imagine France should be able to take this unless Lilbow is busy practicing for Starcraft III. | KadaverBB is my fairy ban mother.
Couguar
Profile Joined April 2010
Russian Federation54 Posts
July 20 2015 09:24 GMT
#44
one thing about recall, that i think needs to be removed in lotv is after-recall-lag. I understand why it is in hots, but protoss need this to defend bases in lotv.
corn322
Profile Joined July 2015
United States16 Posts
July 20 2015 10:05 GMT
#45
I got some thoughts on this.

What if the colossus had a manual cast only attack that cost 25 gas to charge? Maybe a single laser that does 70 damage. 5 seconds to charge the attack with some animation for the opponent to see. I'm thinking something like this would help make them more effective in small numbers to help support a buffed gateway army, but not worth the expense to rely solely on colossi to smash through everything.

On warp gate. I have a vision of a warp gate that works more like nydus worm. Say you would turn only one gateway into a warp gate, and you would put units into it to be able to warp them around the map. Units would warp out in the order they went in. Would it be OP if this wasn't limited to only gateway units? Like you could put other non massive units in and warp around probes and immortals.

I also think it would be neat if it was possible to warp units out of a warp prism while it is immobile. Imagine being able to send colossus back home from a failed attack if you can warp them back to your base before the prism gets shot down. This assumes the mothership core and/or recall doesn't exist.
Krikkitone
Profile Joined April 2009
United States1451 Posts
July 20 2015 22:11 GMT
#46
On July 16 2015 16:57 TedCruz2016 wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 16 2015 15:04 Quineotio wrote:
Warpgate: make it take longer to warp-in units than to build them from a gateway. What warpgates do is shorten the resupply route, but at the moment they have no down-side. Making gateways build faster allows you to choose between getting units out faster (but having to reinforce from across the map), or getting units where you want them immediately (but less often). This change wouldn't effect a passive protoss, but would make protoss all-ins weaker.


Totally agree with this. Some fundamental changes should be made on warpgate mechanic. In the early game, Z, when with a handful of larvas, has to choose between a round of workers and zerglings; to T, it's mules or scans. P shouldn't make an exception. It should make a similar choice between a passive style - with gateway - and an aggressive style - with warpgate. That could certainly diversify P's strategies throughout the whole game.



What I'd really like to see (although it would require a lot of rebalancing)

Gateways (and Stargates) give you a unit instantly and then cool down (similar to a warpgate), but it gives you the unit at the same location. To warp it in anywhere under Pylon power requires
1. a longer cooldown
And/Or
2. an investment in each individual warpgate (ie 100 gas to change 1 Gateway into 1 Warpgate)

[Stargates could have the ability to warp a unit directly to the Mothership]

That way something uniquely Protoss (cooldown based production) could be expanded (mostly compensated for by longer time to build the buildings and advanced units coming out 'unready'..Templars need more energy & Carriers need more interceptors)

But it would avoid the advantage of 'location independence' being something you get easily and automatically
xPrimuSx
Profile Joined January 2012
95 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-21 07:18:36
July 21 2015 07:18 GMT
#47
Tossing out another Colossus change idea, bringing back something I thought was interesting about its original presentation with the single target fire. The Colossus loses its auto-attack and gains an active ability instead. [Insert SC2 is not a MOBA arguments here]. The Colossus ability would have it scan an area, identify all enemy units present, and then it would fire on each one until it kills it.

Once the scan ability is off cooldown the Colossus can scan again to identify additional units but will keep firing on previously scanned units. New units entering would not be fired upon until scanned, and old units would not be fired upon if the unit previously disappeared (was picked up, runs outside of the Colossus' attack range, burrows, cloaks, recalls away, etc...), otherwise the Colossus does not stop firing until either it or its target dies (the lore does state it caused an accidental genocide afterall). This ability also gives multiple areas for balance like the cooldown duration, the scan radius, the speed of the scan, the cast range, the attack range, and the DPS.
Plantarbre
Profile Joined July 2014
France45 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-21 09:56:06
July 21 2015 09:45 GMT
#48
On July 12 2015 22:09 weikor wrote:
In addition to that, probes are the weakest to harass - considering certain units even do bonus damage to shields and they have 40 hp as opposed to 45 of other races.
Probes also cost 50 minerals - against terran and mules, a protoss is considered on even footing, only if he has a significant lead in probes. If both players get harrassed stronly, it will end up with the terran ahead - since the loss of workers can usually be absorbed by mules.
Also consider that 22 probes also cost 1.100 minerals - which is more than a 50% mineral patch of lotv.


Uh. No. Just no.

1) The drones have 40 hp. The 5 bonus hp for scvs barely changes anything. The bonus damages to shield isn't an issue.
Indeed, if you didn't pay attention, whatever went in your mineral line, you're doomed. Mines or not mines.
And I think that you shouldn't lose 3 probes every 40s when you let a medivac enter your mineral line without pulling the probes. You should take reasonable damages for this.

2) The MULE. PLEASE, stop arguing about how OP the mule is, just stop.
The protoss is considered on even footing when is has more probes. WELL, that's the point of chronoboosting and the production time of the OC. The protoss is always ahead in probes.

"If both players get harrassed stronly, it will end up with the terran ahead - since the loss of workers can usually be absorbed by mules."

No.
A : number of workers represented by mules : 3-4

Protoss worker count before harass : 50
Terran worker count before harass : 43 + 2A

Both lose 20 workers.

Protoss : 50 - 20 = 30
Terran : 43 + 2A - 20 = 23 + 2A

I mean, that's basic maths here.. Mules DON'T absorb the loss of workers, it only works in late game when the terran reaches the protoss worker count, around 70 workers. However, the protoss will have faster upgrades and production thanks to the chronoboost. It is even.

3) Consider that 22 scvs and drones also cost the same that 22 probes.

---------------------

@tokinho

I appreciate your thinking here, it went way further than the basic stuff about how mules are OP (see above).

However, there is one thing I didn't understand. In the "Game breaking changes in Legacy" part.
You explain a good number of changes, and most of them are seen as negative. However, the fifth part "adept oracle openers" seem to be the only one that is not. It seems that these openers are very strong, as they counter the classical defense against oracle.

What I don't understand is : How such builds could be dealt with as terran if the first adepts come earlier, the protoss don't have a mineral fallout, with a small boost on probes with the starting nexus, cheapers adepts, adepts stronger against their "counter", the colossus comeback, an already very strong storm boosted, a third source of AOE and... less effective drops ?

I mean, I'm okay with these, but terrans won't be able to do anything. As I recall, the cyclone is going to be nerfed and will lose its ability to attack without vision.
You need two mines deal with oracles (a protoss should be able to see there's no marines in the mineral line, so if you can't see the one mine in the mineral line, it's probably hidden behind the vespene thing. Just go on top of the CC and kill every scv, if the mine doesn't move, it's lost, and when it does, you just have to move where it isn't burrow to finish the job..)
But if you rush mines, can you defend the early stuff ?
If you go full marines, how can you deal with adept/oracles ?
More important, if you rush mines and your opponent go for an early expansion, what do you do ? He will be able to defend whatsoever, and probably scouted your early gas.
Can you defend it without commiting too much with turrets/ebay ? (you will probably lose some workers anyway, if you spent as many ressources in the defense as the protoss, you're losing)

I'm afraid we can't really answer to these questions with such protoss buffs.


EDIT:

I forgot.
If you go for marauders against adept with turrets against oracles. Say the protoss keeps producing oracles and adepts.
How do you expand ? Mines would be pretty tough to use because of the adepts. Marines are obviously not the answer. Few adepts' shot will kill enough marines for oracles to kill the whole army. And turrets...Don't move. I hope I won't have to wait for fusion core + cylcone upgrade to expand.
TedCruz2016
Profile Joined November 2014
Hong Kong271 Posts
July 21 2015 10:11 GMT
#49
On July 21 2015 18:45 Plantarbre wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 12 2015 22:09 weikor wrote:
In addition to that, probes are the weakest to harass - considering certain units even do bonus damage to shields and they have 40 hp as opposed to 45 of other races.
Probes also cost 50 minerals - against terran and mules, a protoss is considered on even footing, only if he has a significant lead in probes. If both players get harrassed stronly, it will end up with the terran ahead - since the loss of workers can usually be absorbed by mules.
Also consider that 22 probes also cost 1.100 minerals - which is more than a 50% mineral patch of lotv.


Uh. No. Just no.

1) The drones have 40 hp. The 5 bonus hp for scvs barely changes anything. The bonus damages to shield isn't an issue.
Indeed, if you didn't pay attention, whatever went in your mineral line, you're doomed. Mines or not mines.
And I think that you shouldn't lose 3 probes every 40s when you let a medivac enter your mineral line without pulling the probes. You should take reasonable damages for this.

2) The MULE. PLEASE, stop arguing about how OP the mule is, just stop.
The protoss is considered on even footing when is has more probes. WELL, that's the point of chronoboosting and the production time of the OC. The protoss is always ahead in probes.

"If both players get harrassed stronly, it will end up with the terran ahead - since the loss of workers can usually be absorbed by mules."

No.
A : number of workers represented by mules : 3-4

Protoss worker count before harass : 50
Terran worker count before harass : 43 + 2A

Both lose 20 workers.

Protoss : 50 - 20 = 30
Terran : 43 + 2A - 20 = 23 + 2A

I mean, that's basic maths here.. Mules DON'T absorb the loss of workers, it only works in late game when the terran reaches the protoss worker count, around 70 workers. However, the protoss will have faster upgrades and production thanks to the chronoboost. It is even.

3) Consider that 22 scvs and drones also cost the same that 22 probes.


Another reason that BLZ gave mule to T is that in the early game T always has at least two scvs working on construction of new buildings, so the overall worker count is always a bit lower and the mule is somewhat a compensation. Also, since MMM is mineral-intensive, that extra income that mules bring forth is well needed.
Make DC listen!
Salteador Neo
Profile Blog Joined August 2009
Andorra5591 Posts
July 21 2015 11:38 GMT
#50
I don't think the uncapping of Mothership Core would be that imba, considering the recall can only be used to defend bases. Feels like it deserves some testing.

Maybe remove the slowing field thing (anti-micro and just boring), uncap the unit limit and give it faster speed so it can be used with faster units all over the place, instead of just one big slow deathball.
Revolutionist fan
Cascade
Profile Blog Joined March 2006
Australia5405 Posts
July 21 2015 12:04 GMT
#51
On July 19 2015 09:42 Cloak wrote:
What's the true harm of uncapping MsC? Multi pronged recall seems like an attractive goal. They also don't stack that well.

Yeah, you know when you have 8 sentries, 20 stalkers and a msc, and youu can kill 50 roaches by cutting them off 10 at a time? But you die if there are 80 roaches? But you can only force field, blink AND slow time once, or at most twice, because you only have one msc. If you could bring like 4 msc, you could go FF, blink and slow time as many times as you want, so that the fight with the roaches and lings become a bit more fair also the fifth engagement. Yeah, that'd make more fair, fun and entertaining games.
Insidioussc2
Profile Joined March 2015
Germany96 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-21 12:31:08
July 21 2015 12:29 GMT
#52
Finnaly some discussion about the MSC and Mothership. I think they are some very iconic units, but fit in gameplywise poorly, especially in LotV. So to begin my thoughts, i'd like a replace of Photon Overcharge (for both) with Energy boost:

- Ability that quadruples the Energy regeneration of an allied unit for 30 seconds (hots time). It would cost 25 Energy and gives around 50 over that time. Note: can't be casted on the mothership or msc itself.
This ability could be used on a nexus for more chrono boosts, sentries to defend or to increase potential of an oracle. I think it fits Protoss fine and there must be better ways to strengthen toss' defenses than Nexus Cannon.



To build on that, I would also like the Mothership to change its role drasticly. My proposals:

- Costs less (the morph maybe 150/150)
- Requires only Stargate
- Lowered stats (keeps MSC attack and lower Hitpoints to about 200/200)
- Smaller Model
- No more cloaking field (most deathball promoting passive there is)

Now let's talk about the abilities. It keeps timewarp and Energy boost from the MSC, it would feel inconsistant if you lose abilities. Replaces Mass Recall with Teleport Beacon:

- For 75 Energy you can create a 100 hp, 100 shield structure on a pylon field. Lasts 3 minutes.
This Teleport Beacon may cast Recall once, teleporting a group of units from any point on the map to the Beacon. It dies after the cast.
Because it must be cast on a pylon field it is harder to abuse than the old WoL Recall, but also it overcomes limitations of the MSC Mass Recall. There can be multiple Teleport Beacons on the map, which allows you to not only teleport one big army once. Also you can leave the Mothership behind to boost your macro.

Another ability I thought about to fit a different, more macro orientated role of the Mothership is a speed built Nexus. For a higher cost the Mothership creates (or "warps in") a Nexus in a few seconds, much like the Tiny Great Hall for Orcs in Frozen Throne. It seems like a bandaid to the hard impact of Mineral Fallout in LotV, but on the other hand it fits perfectly the role of a mothership lore-wise, right? Creating new homes, colonizing and stuff. Together with Teleport Beacon it allows Protoss to expand faster and more secure.
deacon.frost
Profile Joined February 2013
Czech Republic12129 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-21 14:48:52
July 21 2015 14:42 GMT
#53
On July 21 2015 21:29 Insidioussc2 wrote:
Finnaly some discussion about the MSC and Mothership. I think they are some very iconic units, but fit in gameplywise poorly, especially in LotV. So to begin my thoughts, i'd like a replace of Photon Overcharge (for both) with Energy boost:

- Ability that quadruples the Energy regeneration of an allied unit for 30 seconds (hots time). It would cost 25 Energy and gives around 50 over that time. Note: can't be casted on the mothership or msc itself.
This ability could be used on a nexus for more chrono boosts, sentries to defend or to increase potential of an oracle. I think it fits Protoss fine and there must be better ways to strengthen toss' defenses than Nexus Cannon.



To build on that, I would also like the Mothership to change its role drasticly. My proposals:

- Costs less (the morph maybe 150/150)
- Requires only Stargate
- Lowered stats (keeps MSC attack and lower Hitpoints to about 200/200)
- Smaller Model
- No more cloaking field (most deathball promoting passive there is)

Now let's talk about the abilities. It keeps timewarp and Energy boost from the MSC, it would feel inconsistant if you lose abilities. Replaces Mass Recall with Teleport Beacon:

- For 75 Energy you can create a 100 hp, 100 shield structure on a pylon field. Lasts 3 minutes.
This Teleport Beacon may cast Recall once, teleporting a group of units from any point on the map to the Beacon. It dies after the cast.
Because it must be cast on a pylon field it is harder to abuse than the old WoL Recall, but also it overcomes limitations of the MSC Mass Recall. There can be multiple Teleport Beacons on the map, which allows you to not only teleport one big army once. Also you can leave the Mothership behind to boost your macro.

Another ability I thought about to fit a different, more macro orientated role of the Mothership is a speed built Nexus. For a higher cost the Mothership creates (or "warps in") a Nexus in a few seconds, much like the Tiny Great Hall for Orcs in Frozen Throne. It seems like a bandaid to the hard impact of Mineral Fallout in LotV, but on the other hand it fits perfectly the role of a mothership lore-wise, right? Creating new homes, colonizing and stuff. Together with Teleport Beacon it allows Protoss to expand faster and more secure.

What is so wrong about cloaking field? Arbiter was a fun unit and I would really appreciate its return and getting rid of stupid mothership hero unit. Mothership is just a hero version of arbiter(with a huge model) anyway.

Edit: I mean, the reason why you go deathball with mothership(core) is because it is only one and you must have it with you otherwise the recall is not working. Back in WoL where recall worked differently you could sent 2 killing squads of insanely expensive units to snipe 2 different bases and then recall them back to you. You could do really fun things with MS(MS rush with recall into base ) Now you cannot do this because recall works differently :/
The same applies to the cloaking field. it doesn't work unless you are with the one and only Chesney Hawks... oh, sorry,... with the one and only MS
I imagine France should be able to take this unless Lilbow is busy practicing for Starcraft III. | KadaverBB is my fairy ban mother.
TedCruz2016
Profile Joined November 2014
Hong Kong271 Posts
July 21 2015 14:48 GMT
#54
On July 21 2015 23:42 deacon.frost wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 21 2015 21:29 Insidioussc2 wrote:
Finnaly some discussion about the MSC and Mothership. I think they are some very iconic units, but fit in gameplywise poorly, especially in LotV. So to begin my thoughts, i'd like a replace of Photon Overcharge (for both) with Energy boost:

- Ability that quadruples the Energy regeneration of an allied unit for 30 seconds (hots time). It would cost 25 Energy and gives around 50 over that time. Note: can't be casted on the mothership or msc itself.
This ability could be used on a nexus for more chrono boosts, sentries to defend or to increase potential of an oracle. I think it fits Protoss fine and there must be better ways to strengthen toss' defenses than Nexus Cannon.



To build on that, I would also like the Mothership to change its role drasticly. My proposals:

- Costs less (the morph maybe 150/150)
- Requires only Stargate
- Lowered stats (keeps MSC attack and lower Hitpoints to about 200/200)
- Smaller Model
- No more cloaking field (most deathball promoting passive there is)

Now let's talk about the abilities. It keeps timewarp and Energy boost from the MSC, it would feel inconsistant if you lose abilities. Replaces Mass Recall with Teleport Beacon:

- For 75 Energy you can create a 100 hp, 100 shield structure on a pylon field. Lasts 3 minutes.
This Teleport Beacon may cast Recall once, teleporting a group of units from any point on the map to the Beacon. It dies after the cast.
Because it must be cast on a pylon field it is harder to abuse than the old WoL Recall, but also it overcomes limitations of the MSC Mass Recall. There can be multiple Teleport Beacons on the map, which allows you to not only teleport one big army once. Also you can leave the Mothership behind to boost your macro.

Another ability I thought about to fit a different, more macro orientated role of the Mothership is a speed built Nexus. For a higher cost the Mothership creates (or "warps in") a Nexus in a few seconds, much like the Tiny Great Hall for Orcs in Frozen Throne. It seems like a bandaid to the hard impact of Mineral Fallout in LotV, but on the other hand it fits perfectly the role of a mothership lore-wise, right? Creating new homes, colonizing and stuff. Together with Teleport Beacon it allows Protoss to expand faster and more secure.

What is so wrong about cloaking field? Arbiter was a fun unit and I would really appreciate its return and getting rid of stupid mothership hero unit. Mothership is just a hero version of arbiter(with a huge model) anyway.

Edit: I mean, the reason why you go deathball with mothership(core) is because it is only one and you must have it with you otherwise the recall is not working. Back in WoL where recall worked differently you could sent 2 killing squads of insanely expensive units to snipe 2 different bases and then recall them back to you. You could do really fun things with MS(MS rush with recall into base ) Now you cannot do this because recall works differently :/

And nonetheless, heroic unit is not a thing of Starcraft, even for Protoss of which the basic conception is "quality over quantity".
Make DC listen!
Insidioussc2
Profile Joined March 2015
Germany96 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-21 15:21:38
July 21 2015 15:19 GMT
#55
On July 21 2015 23:42 deacon.frost wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 21 2015 21:29 Insidioussc2 wrote:
Finnaly some discussion about the MSC and Mothership. I think they are some very iconic units, but fit in gameplywise poorly, especially in LotV. So to begin my thoughts, i'd like a replace of Photon Overcharge (for both) with Energy boost:

- Ability that quadruples the Energy regeneration of an allied unit for 30 seconds (hots time). It would cost 25 Energy and gives around 50 over that time. Note: can't be casted on the mothership or msc itself.
This ability could be used on a nexus for more chrono boosts, sentries to defend or to increase potential of an oracle. I think it fits Protoss fine and there must be better ways to strengthen toss' defenses than Nexus Cannon.



To build on that, I would also like the Mothership to change its role drasticly. My proposals:

- Costs less (the morph maybe 150/150)
- Requires only Stargate
- Lowered stats (keeps MSC attack and lower Hitpoints to about 200/200)
- Smaller Model
- No more cloaking field (most deathball promoting passive there is)

Now let's talk about the abilities. It keeps timewarp and Energy boost from the MSC, it would feel inconsistant if you lose abilities. Replaces Mass Recall with Teleport Beacon:

- For 75 Energy you can create a 100 hp, 100 shield structure on a pylon field. Lasts 3 minutes.
This Teleport Beacon may cast Recall once, teleporting a group of units from any point on the map to the Beacon. It dies after the cast.
Because it must be cast on a pylon field it is harder to abuse than the old WoL Recall, but also it overcomes limitations of the MSC Mass Recall. There can be multiple Teleport Beacons on the map, which allows you to not only teleport one big army once. Also you can leave the Mothership behind to boost your macro.

Another ability I thought about to fit a different, more macro orientated role of the Mothership is a speed built Nexus. For a higher cost the Mothership creates (or "warps in") a Nexus in a few seconds, much like the Tiny Great Hall for Orcs in Frozen Throne. It seems like a bandaid to the hard impact of Mineral Fallout in LotV, but on the other hand it fits perfectly the role of a mothership lore-wise, right? Creating new homes, colonizing and stuff. Together with Teleport Beacon it allows Protoss to expand faster and more secure.

What is so wrong about cloaking field? Arbiter was a fun unit and I would really appreciate its return and getting rid of stupid mothership hero unit. Mothership is just a hero version of arbiter(with a huge model) anyway.

Edit: I mean, the reason why you go deathball with mothership(core) is because it is only one and you must have it with you otherwise the recall is not working. Back in WoL where recall worked differently you could sent 2 killing squads of insanely expensive units to snipe 2 different bases and then recall them back to you. You could do really fun things with MS(MS rush with recall into base ) Now you cannot do this because recall works differently :/
The same applies to the cloaking field. it doesn't work unless you are with the one and only Chesney Hawks... oh, sorry,... with the one and only MS


If you look at its place in hots right now, the only reason to build it is the cloaking field in ultra late game. Sure timewarp is nice, but you don't build multiple 400/400 units (or even just cores at that time) for this. Also I want the MS to be more of a macro unit, on which the limit of one would hurt less than a fighting unit I think.
They changed the recall mechanic after WoL because it was too easy and too effective, used just the ways you mentioned. But I also think it was pretty fun and thats what I try to archieve with Teleport Beacon. You'd need a energy field, and maybe some time to set it up, but with a warpprism you could use it aggressively again >

I get that the cap seems very arteficial, but as long as it doesn't level up or earn xp I'm fine with the mothership
Krikkitone
Profile Joined April 2009
United States1451 Posts
July 21 2015 15:35 GMT
#56
On July 20 2015 12:42 TedCruz2016 wrote:
Both Mass Recall and Photon Overcharge should become nexus's abilities, then the MSC could be removed from the game.



That would also give some interesting tension with Chronoboost (give Nexus a higher energy cap)
TedCruz2016
Profile Joined November 2014
Hong Kong271 Posts
July 21 2015 15:52 GMT
#57
On July 22 2015 00:35 Krikkitone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 20 2015 12:42 TedCruz2016 wrote:
Both Mass Recall and Photon Overcharge should become nexus's abilities, then the MSC could be removed from the game.



That would also give some interesting tension with Chronoboost (give Nexus a higher energy cap)


At least Photon Overcharge should.
Make DC listen!
ZenithM
Profile Joined February 2011
France15952 Posts
Last Edited: 2015-07-21 15:55:13
July 21 2015 15:54 GMT
#58
On July 21 2015 21:04 Cascade wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 19 2015 09:42 Cloak wrote:
What's the true harm of uncapping MsC? Multi pronged recall seems like an attractive goal. They also don't stack that well.

Yeah, you know when you have 8 sentries, 20 stalkers and a msc, and youu can kill 50 roaches by cutting them off 10 at a time? But you die if there are 80 roaches? But you can only force field, blink AND slow time once, or at most twice, because you only have one msc. If you could bring like 4 msc, you could go FF, blink and slow time as many times as you want, so that the fight with the roaches and lings become a bit more fair also the fifth engagement. Yeah, that'd make more fair, fun and entertaining games.

And if all of that fails by some weird happenstance, you can always mass recall. Twice.

That's also the problem with putting MSC spells on the Nexus, Mass recall becomes way too powerful. Probably would have to be under some global cooldown for it to be handleable.
gTank
Profile Joined January 2011
Austria2601 Posts
July 21 2015 15:59 GMT
#59
On July 21 2015 21:04 Cascade wrote:
Show nested quote +
On July 19 2015 09:42 Cloak wrote:
What's the true harm of uncapping MsC? Multi pronged recall seems like an attractive goal. They also don't stack that well.

Yeah, you know when you have 8 sentries, 20 stalkers and a msc, and youu can kill 50 roaches by cutting them off 10 at a time? But you die if there are 80 roaches? But you can only force field, blink AND slow time once, or at most twice, because you only have one msc. If you could bring like 4 msc, you could go FF, blink and slow time as many times as you want, so that the fight with the roaches and lings become a bit more fair also the fifth engagement. Yeah, that'd make more fair, fun and entertaining games.


Can you explain what you mean by that? You have stuff to kill an army but you die if he has more than you do...?
One crossed wire, one wayward pinch of potassium chlorate, one errant twitch...and kablooie!
Samx
Profile Joined August 2013
Singapore149 Posts
July 21 2015 16:16 GMT
#60
I propose a simple but elegant way of balancing Protoss slightly.
Make a warped in unit start without shield, but buff gateway units.
The main grouse of many here is that warp in mechanic is too strong offensively, and thus gateway units must be weak to counter this. It makes gateway timing attack weaker with units warped in without shield and gets thrown into combat immediately. It force the Protoss to 'macro' normally like terran. The percentage of units without shield drop with each warp in cycle.
Our enemies are a legion and STILL you procrastinate
Prev 1 2 3 4 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Big Brain Bouts
17:00
#102
YoungYakov vs Jumy
TriGGeR vs Spirit
RotterdaM623
IndyStarCraft 604
Liquipedia
OSC
14:00
King of the Hill #234
SteadfastSC110
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RotterdaM 623
IndyStarCraft 604
Lowko509
SteadfastSC 110
Liquid`VortiX 94
BRAT_OK 45
MindelVK 21
DivinesiaTV 13
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 24057
Rain 1978
Bisu 1964
Stork 518
Horang2 479
Shuttle 356
Larva 135
Mini 124
firebathero 118
Hyun 100
[ Show more ]
Aegong 69
Dewaltoss 60
Mind 59
Zeus 58
Killer 53
JYJ 50
910 49
ggaemo 46
Mong 36
Shinee 22
soO 18
JulyZerg 17
Yoon 16
GoRush 15
sorry 15
ajuk12(nOOB) 11
Sacsri 11
SilentControl 8
Dota 2
Gorgc6520
singsing4032
qojqva3463
Counter-Strike
Foxcn87
Other Games
FrodaN830
hiko535
crisheroes359
XaKoH 133
KnowMe94
Trikslyr64
Chillindude26
Organizations
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• poizon28 29
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota236
League of Legends
• Nemesis3394
Other Games
• tFFMrPink 4
Upcoming Events
The PiG Daily
3h 20m
SHIN vs ByuN
Reynor vs Classic
TBD vs herO
Maru vs SHIN
TBD vs Classic
CranKy Ducklings
16h 20m
WardiTV 2025
17h 20m
Reynor vs MaxPax
SHIN vs TBD
Solar vs herO
Classic vs TBD
SC Evo League
18h 50m
Ladder Legends
1d 1h
BSL 21
1d 2h
Sziky vs Dewalt
eOnzErG vs Cross
Sparkling Tuna Cup
1d 16h
Ladder Legends
1d 23h
BSL 21
2 days
StRyKeR vs TBD
Bonyth vs TBD
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
Wardi Open
2 days
Monday Night Weeklies
2 days
WardiTV Invitational
4 days
Replay Cast
5 days
WardiTV Invitational
5 days
ByuN vs Solar
Clem vs Classic
Cure vs herO
Reynor vs MaxPax
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Acropolis #4 - TS3
RSL Offline Finals
Kuram Kup

Ongoing

C-Race Season 1
IPSL Winter 2025-26
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 4
YSL S2
BSL Season 21
Slon Tour Season 2
CSL Season 19: Qualifier 1
WardiTV 2025
META Madness #9
eXTREMESLAND 2025
SL Budapest Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 8
BLAST Rivals Fall 2025
IEM Chengdu 2025
PGL Masters Bucharest 2025
Thunderpick World Champ.
CS Asia Championships 2025
ESL Pro League S22

Upcoming

CSL Season 19: Qualifier 2
CSL 2025 WINTER (S19)
BSL 21 Non-Korean Championship
Acropolis #4
IPSL Spring 2026
Bellum Gens Elite Stara Zagora 2026
HSC XXVIII
Big Gabe Cup #3
OSC Championship Season 13
ESL Pro League Season 23
PGL Cluj-Napoca 2026
IEM Kraków 2026
BLAST Bounty Winter 2026
BLAST Bounty Winter Qual
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.