Fuck that, let the kids fight it out. Waiting to calling the police is stupid. Taking those punches while waiting for the police will set a precedent where any kid knows they have a window of opportunity to just beat the crap of someone before the police arrives. Allowing that to happen is idiotic.

The punishment should be a slap on the wrist by the law. The school should take whatever measure necessary for teaching's sake.

Z.Kw

China297 Posts

May 03 2009 04:37 GMT

#22

On May 03 2009 13:32 catbert1 wrote:
"It bothers me alot when someone moves to another country, working hard and doing nothing but living life and get beaten up, yet wind up as the guilty. WHERE IS THE FUCKING JUSTICE."

this is pretty lol

are you aware that america/canada are the absolute nicest countries in the world for immigrants? if you are white and living in an asian country the racism is absolutely overwhelming, you can not expect in any way to live any kind of normal life, and everything is your fault
i can't believe someone like susie who has lived in korea and america can come here and spout nonsense about america being in any way a worse place for minorities to live in than korea

just random shit i have seen in korea:
i was coming back to korea and at the airport they had about ~70 vietnamese people that were obviously being imported as slave labor to work in the factories up north near the dmz... the viets were being screamed at and hit by customs agents

koreans backed by the police import south east asian girls on the premise of being dancers to work in brothels for sleezy salaryman

sometimes i'll try to go to some places and they'll tell me "korean only", so ill be like what why, and they'll say oh one time a white guy came here and had a fight or something retarded

lol

if american businesses did that, they'd get sued
if america started importing slave labor, the world would go fucking nuts
even half koreans trying to go to school in korea end up committing suicide for all the abuse they get from insanely racist LITTLE KIDS taught by their parents to hate everything not korean

god i could go on but its pointless if you have lived this long and not realized such a simple truth. we have a black president ffs, i've never seen so many stupid posts in such a short amount of time

He didn't say America/Canada on it's own just 'another country' , every country is racist, you should come visit Australia.

stroggos

New Zealand1543 Posts

May 03 2009 04:37 GMT

#23

Korean kid had every right to break the other kids nose imo, and he should get a medal for punching him instead of punishment.

on a sidenote, and in genera i think japan is the most racist country in the world..followed by israel possibly.

DV8

United States1623 Posts

May 03 2009 04:40 GMT

#24

Every Time I hear about punishment to this extremity I am further saddened by how pussified our kids are becoming. They should let them duke it out and toughen up.

Rekrul

Korea (South)17174 Posts

May 03 2009 04:43 GMT

#25

On May 03 2009 13:32 catbert1 wrote:

sometimes i'll try to go to some places and they'll tell me "korean only", so ill be like what why, and they'll say oh one time a white guy came here and had a fight or something retarded

lol

well it's not purely racism, it's semi realistic. koreans simply don't start shit ever, meanwhile US army guys in korea are always starting fights giving all whites a bad name

but man do i love it when they try to say 'sorry koreans only' to me

then u just say 'but i am korean...' in korean and they are like wtf and let u in LOL

stroggos

New Zealand1543 Posts

May 03 2009 04:45 GMT

#26

On May 03 2009 13:43 Rekrul wrote:

Show nested quote +

lmao

aRod

United States758 Posts

May 03 2009 04:47 GMT

#27

On May 03 2009 13:19 Jayme wrote:

Show nested quote +

Huh? I think you underestimate just how easy it is to break someones nose when you give them a good punch to the face.

I'm pretty sure the white kid hit hard enough to cause a broken nose but just didn't hit the kids nose the right way... You should be looking for intent here. If there was intent to cause harm, bam assault charge (assuming they went through with it... which they did)

Also if someone attacks you then you have EVERY right to fight back. You can pretty much be assured you aren't going to get beat to death in a school setting but you never really know. To just stay there and say "well call the police" is only said by people that haven't been jumped before.

I completely agree intent matters, but you speak as if the results of the violence doesn't matter. The results are what people see and have to deal with. Practically, we as a society dole out punishments based on results and intent. Attempted murder gets a lesser sentence than murder and punching a kid in the face gets a lesser sentence than breaking a kids nose. This is perfectly reasonable. The white lad is getting the standard sentence for punching, and the korean is getting the standard sentence for breaking a kids nose.

The teasing and bullying also has results. I think there should be a little extra in there for mocking and making fun of the korean lad. Nevertheless, we don't expell every student who makes fun of another student, we'd lose every boy in middle school otherwise.

And for those of you who think otherwise, a little clarification about fighting back. You're allowed to fight back ONLY IF there is no other option. This means, you couldn't get out of the situation in some other way. I don't know the particulars of this fight, but I doubt the Korean boy was in a situation where he could not have ran to an administrator and reported the issue.

The white kid is a little bastard and I'm glad his nose is broken, but it shouldn't be broken.

Rekrul

Korea (South)17174 Posts

May 03 2009 04:53 GMT

#28

yea, his whole face should be broken

Pieguy314

Canada262 Posts

May 03 2009 04:56 GMT

#29

I remember seeing this on the news and I recall it saying that the korean kid had a black belt in karate or tae-kwon do or something.

arsonist

Canada80 Posts

May 03 2009 04:56 GMT

#30

If you've got a black belt in some form of martial art and are involved in a fight, you can be charged with assault with a deadly weapon based solely on your expertise. Can't say I know the reasoning behind the police's charges, just thought it was an interesting (and possibly relevant) tidbit.

A friend of mine from high school actually has certification saying that his body is classified as a deadly weapon, so if he were to beat someone up, he'd be in much more trouble than the average kid in a school yard scrap.

Luddite

United States2315 Posts

May 03 2009 04:57 GMT

#31

On May 03 2009 13:15 il0seonpurpose wrote:

Show nested quote +

What, a B in math for an asian?? OMGZ

jk

Nah, for most US schools a 90% is still an A (probably A-).

catbert1

Korea (South)111 Posts

May 03 2009 05:00 GMT

#32

On May 03 2009 13:43 Rekrul wrote:

well it's not purely racism, it's semi realistic. koreans simply don't start shit ever, meanwhile US army guys in korea are always starting fights giving all whites a bad name

but man do i love it when they try to say 'sorry koreans only' to me

then u just say 'but i am korean...' in korean and they are like wtf and let u in LOL

believing the stereotypes about a certain people and acting based on those prejudices is the definition of racism, rekrul

-orb-

United States5770 Posts

May 03 2009 05:02 GMT

#33

Wow that is ridiculous

AttackZerg

United States7577 Posts

May 03 2009 05:04 GMT

#34

I have heard some fucked up stories about kids I went to high school with and what they've done in asian countries. I would fully understand if I went to certain areas of japan and was treated badly. Alot of members of the united states military give us all a bad name (Not a majority of our armed forces at all, please take it in the context of 'a few bad apples' rather then dissing our military, I'm not looking to start that kind of flame war)

Ilikestarcraft

Korea (South)17743 Posts

May 03 2009 05:05 GMT

#35

On May 03 2009 13:43 Rekrul wrote:

Show nested quote +

HAHAHA

{CC}StealthBlue

United States41117 Posts

May 03 2009 05:06 GMT

#36

WTF is with the name of the OP...?

stroggos

New Zealand1543 Posts

May 03 2009 05:08 GMT

#37

probably would've been tae kwon do since that is the korean martial art. Anyway, he was acting in self defence which is what tae kwon do trains people to do and i doubt he intended to break his nose, though its a good thing he did. Should've punched him in the throat then gouged his eyes, ripped out his intestines and strangled him with them imo.