EPTSettle this Fight Debate - Page 2
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Jonoman92
United States9110 Posts
| ||
|
BlackJack
United States10574 Posts
| ||
|
Polemarch
Canada1564 Posts
On November 26 2006 09:58 alffla wrote: but maybe in mid lunge the bat would've knocked the brains out of the lunging small knife guy already ;O!!! i think it depends on how good both people are. if they're both tough enough to be willing to take a hit and do some quick moves i think the knife guy would win. i think that's not asking too much of average people if it's a noob game though, the knife guy would piss his pants and just run cuz he doesn't want to get hurt | ||
|
Way
Canada565 Posts
On November 26 2006 09:58 alffla wrote: but maybe in mid lunge the bat would've knocked the brains out of the lunging small knife guy already ;O!!! LoL | ||
|
exalted
United States3612 Posts
On November 26 2006 10:04 BlackJack wrote: very important detail being left out is where the fight will be taking place and how much space the fighers have. W Assume a basketball-court, all outside entrances sealed for the fight. | ||
|
Way
Canada565 Posts
On November 26 2006 10:04 BlackJack wrote: very important detail being left out is where the fight will be taking place and how much space the fighers have. W i think there are just too many factors to take into consideration and the scenario needs to be more specific in general  | ||
|
lawl mart v2.0
United States108 Posts
| ||
|
Polemarch
Canada1564 Posts
On November 26 2006 10:01 Wysp wrote: lets assume a normal person can do 20 push-ups :op well in order for batman to knock knife guy's skull out or whatever, he's gonna have to do a huge swing. otherwise knife guy can just take the pussy hit and start stabbing. | ||
|
Wysp
Canada2299 Posts
On November 26 2006 10:08 lawl mart v2.0 wrote: well if it was an open area i would go with the knife, because you run faster with a knife and you can get away ;; all exits sealed, you'd just tire yourself out to a steady pursuit. | ||
|
CuddlyCuteKitten
Sweden2904 Posts
On November 26 2006 09:56 Way wrote: he just said they have equal skill.. u're just saying the knife guy's faster than the bat guy and can dodge him better, wtf o.O No I didn't. I said that it takes longer to use the bat efficently. It's almost impossible to dodge a butterfly in melee so it doesn't matter much, it's a much faster weapon. Furthermore while the bat has range you need a good swing to transmit power efficently so you can't move around as much because that leaves you open. The knife will be on the offensive jumping back and forth and probing for a weakness, the bat needs to be lined up to get 1 good shot in before the knife guy closes. Since getting such a hit is hard for a normal person I'm with the guy who has the knife. If both were perfect it would be no contest because whoever hits first wins in such a situation, but they aren't. | ||
|
Polemarch
Canada1564 Posts
On November 26 2006 10:08 lawl mart v2.0 wrote: well if it was an open area i would go with the knife, because you run faster with a knife and you can get away ;D haha, if this was a CS forum they'd be saying the other guy could just switch weapons to knife to match your speed | ||
|
Wysp
Canada2299 Posts
| ||
|
zulu_nation8
China26351 Posts
| ||
|
Way
Canada565 Posts
| ||
Chill
Calgary26004 Posts
| ||
|
OverTheUnder
United States2929 Posts
| ||
|
Way
Canada565 Posts
![[image loading]](http://www.mediabistro.com/fishbowlny/original/sword.jpg) if you think of the bat as a sword instead then you tell me how the hell in the world the guy with the butterfly knife is going to get first hit? what kind of pussies are holding these sluggers, if its too heavy then why isnt it baby tyke bat vs butter knife | ||
|
pooper-scooper
United States3108 Posts
YOu can take 1 bat swing, you can't take one knife stab. Plus as soon as the knife guy closes to the 1 ft distance the bat is ineffective. (imagine trying to hit someone with a bat that is right up against you, you can't get a good hit). I have knife, I try to bait him into swinging. Once he swings I jump in and stabb him and take his weak ass off balance arms in wrong position swing. Alternatively if I can't get him to swing I jump in, put up my left arm to take his bat swing while I stabb him in the belly with my right arm. My left arm breaks, and I crawl away while he bleeds out and dies | ||
|
Polemarch
Canada1564 Posts
knife ftw. | ||
|
Polemarch
Canada1564 Posts
On November 26 2006 10:22 pooper-scooper wrote: Knife > bat. YOu can take 1 bat swing, you can't take one knife stab. Plus as soon as the knife guy closes to the 1 ft distance the bat is ineffective. I have knife, I try to bait him into swining. Once he swings I jump in and stabb him and take his weak ass off balance arms in wrong position swing. Alternatively if I can't get him to swing I jump in, put up my left arm to take his bat swing while I stabb him in the belly with my right arm. My left arm breaks, and I crawl away while he bleeds out and dies woot, nice. i figure most knife guys could get in range without taking a really hard hit anyway. if batman doesn't swing early... get in really quick towards batman's back where the swing would be weaker and start knifing. | ||
| ||
