EPTThus, the bat is ineffective at short range.
Therefor I would rather take the butterfly and wait for the batterguy to make his move.
Settle this Fight Debate - Page 13
| Forum Index > General Forum |
|
Tezumai
Sweden19 Posts
Thus, the bat is ineffective at short range. Therefor I would rather take the butterfly and wait for the batterguy to make his move. | ||
|
besiger
Croatia2452 Posts
| ||
|
HeadBangaa
United States6512 Posts
| ||
|
besiger
Croatia2452 Posts
| ||
|
iNcontroL
USA29055 Posts
/afk poking eyes out with butterfly knife and smashing head with baseball bat | ||
|
besiger
Croatia2452 Posts
| ||
|
coolio
Finland196 Posts
Starcraft jokes stop here... | ||
|
SweeTLemonS[TPR]
11739 Posts
On November 27 2006 01:35 Tezumai wrote: If you were to miss with the bat you would be fucked. 5 stabs in the throat, ggnore. Thus, the bat is ineffective at short range. Therefor I would rather take the butterfly and wait for the batterguy to make his move. Once again, there is more than one way to attack with a baseball bat. You don't have to swing it like you're hitting a baseball. It's a far more versatile tool than that. You can poke/jab with it right to the other guys face, kinda like a spear stab. | ||
|
besiger
Croatia2452 Posts
baseball bat takes shit from noone | ||
|
sdpgposd
United Kingdom1464 Posts
The bat imo  | ||
|
KovacsFlorian
204 Posts
On November 26 2006 11:04 BeSiGeR wrote: for the knife to be used to its full potential the person has to have some kind of training, the bat does not, any retard can swing, its just about keeping distance, and you dont only have the bat, kicking is also a good way for keeping distance True. Using the knife effectively is not easy. Anyone used a bat before to hit something. I don't know if the same goes for knife... How many of you used a bat before to hit something and how many of you used a knife to stab something? The guy with the knife would hesitate to rush with an all-in forward move against the guy that swings the bat. The guy with the bat doesn't need precision. He'll just hit in a general area, starting from knees, up to the head. The blow is circular; if it's in range, it will not miss. The guy with the knife can not go for the head or hands because they are too fast moving targets. It will go for the torso. But to get in range, he needs to avoid the bat swing. And as I said, the determined bat swing has very high changes of sucess. Any serious fight has an very important emotional part. The system is full of adrenaline. A full bat swing is like a discharge of anger. Hit like a train whatever mother fucker it is in front of you! The guy with the knife must control he's anger to get in range without being hit. And control is hard to achieve of you are not trained in fighting. When you are angry and full of adrenaline, there is no room for logical thoughts, reason. You won't even see the bat coming. It will smash you like a potato. | ||
|
Kochen
Denmark154 Posts
1) People assume a knife stab is lethal no matter where on the body you hit. 2) People assume the bat man knows exactly when the knife man is going to attack for real. 3) People assume they can take a bat blow anywhere on the body without staggering the least. 4) People assume the bat man can swing the bat five times a second at full speed without losing balance for as much as a nanosecond. 5) People assume too much about an average guy. I would personally go for the knife, and keep my distance until the bat man loses his precious balance a short second while he misjudged a swing. | ||
|
KovacsFlorian
204 Posts
On November 27 2006 04:27 Kochen wrote: There are a lot of misconceptions in this thread 1) People assume a knife stab is lethal no matter where on the body you hit. 2) People assume the bat man knows exactly when the knife man is going to attack for real. 3) People assume they can take a bat blow anywhere on the body without staggering the least. 4) People assume the bat man can swing the bat five times a second at full speed without losing balance for as much as a nanosecond. 5) People assume too much about an average guy. I would personally go for the knife, and keep my distance until the bat man loses his precious balance a short second while he misjudged a swing. In a real fight, if you have no training, you'll never get the counter timming right. Timming is the most hard thing to achieve. You can train your strength, execution... But you'll get the timming right, only after alot of training. The bat guy doesn't need timming. The knife guy does. We are talking here about 0.2 / 0.3 seconds timing. | ||
|
testpat
United States565 Posts
So we square off, sizing each other up. The sock/battery has a longer range, but to do damage it needs to be moving. So i decide to I ducked just inside his swinging range, he swung, i ducked back, then stepped back in, putting my right arm over his neck and shoulder, and drove the plywood into his stomach - where it shattered. I look back at this and wonder - wtf was i thinking? btw - i didn't win the argument, he said all it proved is i was better with a weapon. | ||
|
Deleted User 3420
24492 Posts
but I say the knife, definitely with the bat you get one swing. if you swing too hard and put too much behind it, it wouldn't be that hard to dodge it or at least block it well(which isn't going to even break the arms of the most guys). the knife, however, is deadly in close combat, which is where this fight is going to quickly go. not to mention that if one of them is good at it, they can throw the knife. | ||
|
pyrogenetix
China5094 Posts
On November 26 2006 13:05 alffla wrote: yea w/e rigged toss LOLZ yea k then i'll like just block his knife stab and then bleed from my forearm and then counter swing, then he wont be able to stab again. yes but joo need two hands on bat to swing it hard. unless you stick the bat up ur ass and do a beyonce ass wiggle and crack pavement... then... no. | ||
|
Deleted User 3420
24492 Posts
anyways, i think this is close either way and definitely depends on the environment | ||
|
pyrogenetix
China5094 Posts
the US government for some reason (not at all completely unlikely) made a clone of you. he (or she... for the female forumers) is an exact copy of you because this time the scientists didnt fuck up and make a retard clone. you two are going to fight to the death. would you honestly choose a long piece of blunt wood instead of a sharp piece of metal. would you honestly want to go 1v1 all in fight club shit vs yourself with a bat, knowing that if you miss, that knife from your clone is going straight into your body somewhere. i sure as hell dont. knife for the mother fucking win. | ||
|
Heen
Korea (South)2178 Posts
for all combat skill levels imo. | ||
|
besiger
Croatia2452 Posts
my allstar team: SKT1 coach KTF coach (the one with the bat) Samsung coach MBC coach Lecaf coach Hanbit coach AND OF COURSE -------------> CJ COACHHHHH~~~~~~~~~~~ the one with the bat what more is there to say, noone wants a coach with a knife. I dont think this will ever get settled, unless someone wants to experiment ^^ | ||
| ||
