• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 04:58
CET 10:58
KST 18:58
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #2312[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over6Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
XUN appreciation thread List of top players active on ShieldBattery Potentially helpful Shield Battery feedback. People still play BW? SC4ALL: II Indiegogo Campaign Announcement
Tourneys
2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4 SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19)
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread The PlayStation 5 Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine US Politics Mega-thread The Games Industry And ATVI Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 16807 users

Are Unions Necessary in the Modern World? - Page 16

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 14 15 16 17 18 19 Next All
Shanlan
Profile Joined August 2010
United States41 Posts
March 09 2011 04:38 GMT
#301
On March 09 2011 13:20 Rashid wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 12:20 Shanlan wrote:
On March 09 2011 12:10 Rashid wrote:
On March 09 2011 11:57 Shanlan wrote:
First, we examine the role of unions in a market where labor supply is less than demand. Companies in this scenario will be glad to increase wages, benefits, and conditions for workers. The problem arises when unions dictate that those increases apply to all employees. Even in a labor scarce market employers will want to replace poor workers with good ones, but the union will prevent that. So the result is less proficient workers will be hired than in a free market, so there will be better workers in a less profitable firm who could have been hired to a better wage and position but aren't due to union restrictions. Also overall the improvement to the rest of the workers will be less because the poor workers will need to be compensated as well. I don't feel the improvement to the poor worker justifies the losses sustained by the proficient ones.


You know, i have somebody in the neighborhood who owns a carwash business. He hires about 15-20 indian illegal immigrants and pays them each roughly US$100 a MONTH.

Do you want any one of your loved ones to work like donkeys for US$100 a month? Your brother or sister perhaps? Or maybe your mother? Or even yourself?


Perhaps you should actually read what I wrote. The excerpt you quoted refers to a labor scarce market, which in your case isn't. I also don't see how it applies.

I wouldn't work for $100/month and I doubt anyone I know would either. This is because I know I can get a better job that pays better. If I had a choice between not eating and working for $100/month then yes I would.


Simply stating that low wages exist and asking if I would like to do it doesn't serve a purpose. I'm sure the Indians working there would like to work for more money or be a CEO and live in a big house, but they can't because they don't have the skills or abilities to do it.

I'm sure you might have a valid opinion but I don't see one in this post or how it serves to further this discussion.


That's the point. You yourself aren't willing to work for US$100 a month, and i'm pretty sure the guy who hired those indians isn't willing to do the same either, but for some reason you think it's ok for these indians to do the low-pay hard -labor job that you or even anybody you know is willing to do. But just because those indians are so desperate that they are willing to work for US$100 a month, doesn't mean that i should take advantage of them. JUST BECAUSE I CAN, DOESN'T MEAN I SHOULD.

As a socially responsible employer, if i wanted to hire them, I should pay them the proper salary and give them the proper benefits, REGARDLESS of what he is willing to sell himself for.



You're assuming the employer can afford to pay them more. If the employer raises wages then he'll have to raise prices, which then makes the wage raise meaningless if we assume the price increase to affect the whole economy.

If the employer could afford to pay the workers more and keep the same price then it is the duty of the worker to ask for a higher wage, or find a job where he'll get paid more, ie another car wash where theoretically they could pay him more based on his performance. Alternatively, the worker can open his own car wash and charge a lower price and still earn a higher "wage".

You're example is really complicated because of the many factors affecting the wage and profits. The legality of the workers, and the competition of employers. These factors can force your example to be a non-ideal market which is inefficient and does not generate the most utility.

You're arguments are not ground in economic principles. If it was up to me I would pay everyone millions of dollars, but we live in a world of limited resources and we need a way to distribute it. I believe a free market is the most efficient way of doing it. Perhaps you have a better way, in which case I would love to hear it.
Shanlan
Profile Joined August 2010
United States41 Posts
March 09 2011 04:53 GMT
#302
On March 09 2011 13:37 Signet wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 13:22 Shanlan wrote:
Good points, but I think the main cause stems from labor surplus, which makes firms price setters. There weren't any of these problems with unions when the economy was expanding and there was a labor shortage.

That's why I advocate for unions to be a lobbying group that promotes education, combating information asymmetry, and lobbies for market reforms. I believe in solutions that drive towards a more ideal free market vs ad hoc solutions that don't work in the long term.

The 90s/tech boom were a nice time for most people indeed

And yes, unions could do a lot more to work on educating/improving their members as more skilled workers (that'd also give people more incentive to join). In many ways, unions have fought hard on a few issues that affect the workforce while completely ignoring others. A professor named Barry Pump pointed this out in contrasting state unionization vs state tax regressiveness and vs state welfare spending - his conclusion being that unions haven't done a good job making state/local taxes more fair for the lower class, but they may have helped people earn wages that get them off of welfare.

But I think, especially in sectors where firms are consolidating, some form of collective bargaining is probably a necessity.


I agree, unions do act as a counter to monopolistic markets, but I think the goal there is to break up the monopoly not create another one. I have said before that unions do create benefits, but I don't think those benefits justify the harm they do. The ideal case would be for new policy to be implemented as unions are slowly limited to more of an activist group that influence policy making vs the decisions of firms.

To summarize, unions act on firms directly, when I believe the problems lay with the market. I believe the unions are addressing the issues at the result end vs the source.

Aside: I find it funny you point to Mr. Pump's papers when I have attended some of the same classes as he.
thebigdonkey
Profile Joined September 2010
United States354 Posts
March 09 2011 05:08 GMT
#303
On March 09 2011 11:45 Offhand wrote:
That scenario is less and less true in today's world, as the rich/poor gap is increasing, companies are reporting record profits right out of the recessions (note, because people are willing to work for less). Americans earn, on average, less then they did 10 years ago.

TL:DR: The difference between high and low wages for workers isn't the difference between everyone on subsistence wage or a privileged few working while the rest starve. The difference is how many yachts the CEO has.


Actually it's worse than that. When adjusted for inflation, wages have declined since the late 70's. In the same time period, CEO pay has increased exponentially.
TributeBoxer
Profile Joined November 2010
United States163 Posts
March 09 2011 05:27 GMT
#304
On March 09 2011 14:08 thebigdonkey wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 11:45 Offhand wrote:
That scenario is less and less true in today's world, as the rich/poor gap is increasing, companies are reporting record profits right out of the recessions (note, because people are willing to work for less). Americans earn, on average, less then they did 10 years ago.

TL:DR: The difference between high and low wages for workers isn't the difference between everyone on subsistence wage or a privileged few working while the rest starve. The difference is how many yachts the CEO has.


Actually it's worse than that. When adjusted for inflation, wages have declined since the late 70's. In the same time period, CEO pay has increased exponentially.


Thats what you get when you open up a vast labor pool to be taken advantage of. The Chinese slave labor pool has made CEO's and Communist China very rich. The middle class has gotten material goods that price did not go up with inflation, but neither have their wages.
"Violence and corruption, seldom strangers to the human scene, appear to be increasing today."
Signet
Profile Joined March 2007
United States1718 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-03-09 05:31:30
March 09 2011 05:29 GMT
#305
On March 09 2011 13:53 Shanlan wrote:
I agree, unions do act as a counter to monopolistic markets, but I think the goal there is to break up the monopoly not create another one. I have said before that unions do create benefits, but I don't think those benefits justify the harm they do. The ideal case would be for new policy to be implemented as unions are slowly limited to more of an activist group that influence policy making vs the decisions of firms.

To summarize, unions act on firms directly, when I believe the problems lay with the market. I believe the unions are addressing the issues at the result end vs the source.

Aside: I find it funny you point to Mr. Pump's papers when I have attended some of the same classes as he.

The issue I have is - I don't doubt that policy changes can be made to increase the number of firms in a sector at equilibrium. Things like reducing subsidies to established firms, eliminating corporate tax loopholes, restricting offshore "tax shelter" accounts, etc could lessen the advantage that existing firms have over potential competitors.

Still, economies of scale play a major role in determining market equilibrium, particularly in markets involving production of physical goods. Even if government-imposed barriers to entry/competition are removed, or even if they go further to say subsidize start-up costs (reduce entry fees), I think we'll still end up with monopolistic competition or oligopoly due to scaling and the importance of branding in the consumer market, with more firms than before but still not a great situation for unorganized laborers who would face an imbalanced market. What policy changes could be made to bridge this gap?

Offhand, I could see implementing a real full-throttle free market system, maxing out domestic firm competitiveness regardless of how hard it skews pre-tax earnings, eliminating wage/health/pension and some other worker laws (not workplace/environmental/consumer safety, but things that can be corrected later), then providing these essentials as social programs to those who are making too little to afford them. But while I can see that working in theory, I can't see Americans going for it in practice. And I don't see it going anywhere with our political parties.

Alternatively, how would you feel about multiple unions in the same sector that basically compete against each other? (ie, the 3 companies / 3 unions hypothetical I gave to another poster)


Hah, what a small world it is that you actually know the guy who wrote those posts. Are you a student/professor at UW? I found his blog via Nate Silver's twitter.
dp
Profile Joined August 2003
United States234 Posts
March 09 2011 05:37 GMT
#306
Unions are good.. if you are in them. I don't personally have a problem with them in the private sector, but not for all jobs. For example, teachers in WI. Teachers union donates to campaign - politician get elected, gives in to union demands on salaries for votes/future donations. Who cares right, he'll be out of office before the state is bankrupt and its someone elses problem then.

I am sorry but this won't work. It eventually does have to end.
:o
thebigdonkey
Profile Joined September 2010
United States354 Posts
March 09 2011 06:16 GMT
#307
On March 09 2011 14:27 TributeBoxer wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 14:08 thebigdonkey wrote:
On March 09 2011 11:45 Offhand wrote:
That scenario is less and less true in today's world, as the rich/poor gap is increasing, companies are reporting record profits right out of the recessions (note, because people are willing to work for less). Americans earn, on average, less then they did 10 years ago.

TL:DR: The difference between high and low wages for workers isn't the difference between everyone on subsistence wage or a privileged few working while the rest starve. The difference is how many yachts the CEO has.


Actually it's worse than that. When adjusted for inflation, wages have declined since the late 70's. In the same time period, CEO pay has increased exponentially.


Thats what you get when you open up a vast labor pool to be taken advantage of. The Chinese slave labor pool has made CEO's and Communist China very rich. The middle class has gotten material goods that price did not go up with inflation, but neither have their wages.


What is this middle class you speak of?
lofung
Profile Joined October 2010
Hong Kong298 Posts
March 09 2011 06:20 GMT
#308
its not really that 'necessary' in a sense that every worker with a brain would be smart enough to form a union for collective bargaining.
How do you counter 13 carriers? Well first of all you gave me brain cancer. -Tasteless
NEOtheONE
Profile Joined September 2010
United States2233 Posts
March 09 2011 06:21 GMT
#309
In this age of twitter, facebook, and social networking which was used to help organize protests in Egypt, labor unions seem rather obsolete. Furthermore, unions charge their members for their services, and this drives up their pay which drives up costs of goods and services. Companies could pay their workers less and the workers would still be earning more than they are in a union.
Abstracts, the too long didn't read of the educated world.
hiawatha
Profile Joined December 2010
United States120 Posts
March 09 2011 06:27 GMT
#310
Damn this thread is one economic hyperbole after another. Anyone feel like backing up their posts? At all?
hmsrenown
Profile Joined July 2010
Canada1263 Posts
March 09 2011 06:28 GMT
#311
YES. Unless you want to live like simple manual labourers in China.
Rashid
Profile Joined March 2011
191 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-03-09 07:20:40
March 09 2011 07:03 GMT
#312
On March 09 2011 13:38 Shanlan wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 13:20 Rashid wrote:
On March 09 2011 12:20 Shanlan wrote:
On March 09 2011 12:10 Rashid wrote:
On March 09 2011 11:57 Shanlan wrote:
First, we examine the role of unions in a market where labor supply is less than demand. Companies in this scenario will be glad to increase wages, benefits, and conditions for workers. The problem arises when unions dictate that those increases apply to all employees. Even in a labor scarce market employers will want to replace poor workers with good ones, but the union will prevent that. So the result is less proficient workers will be hired than in a free market, so there will be better workers in a less profitable firm who could have been hired to a better wage and position but aren't due to union restrictions. Also overall the improvement to the rest of the workers will be less because the poor workers will need to be compensated as well. I don't feel the improvement to the poor worker justifies the losses sustained by the proficient ones.


You know, i have somebody in the neighborhood who owns a carwash business. He hires about 15-20 indian illegal immigrants and pays them each roughly US$100 a MONTH.

Do you want any one of your loved ones to work like donkeys for US$100 a month? Your brother or sister perhaps? Or maybe your mother? Or even yourself?


Perhaps you should actually read what I wrote. The excerpt you quoted refers to a labor scarce market, which in your case isn't. I also don't see how it applies.

I wouldn't work for $100/month and I doubt anyone I know would either. This is because I know I can get a better job that pays better. If I had a choice between not eating and working for $100/month then yes I would.


Simply stating that low wages exist and asking if I would like to do it doesn't serve a purpose. I'm sure the Indians working there would like to work for more money or be a CEO and live in a big house, but they can't because they don't have the skills or abilities to do it.

I'm sure you might have a valid opinion but I don't see one in this post or how it serves to further this discussion.


That's the point. You yourself aren't willing to work for US$100 a month, and i'm pretty sure the guy who hired those indians isn't willing to do the same either, but for some reason you think it's ok for these indians to do the low-pay hard -labor job that you or even anybody you know is willing to do. But just because those indians are so desperate that they are willing to work for US$100 a month, doesn't mean that i should take advantage of them. JUST BECAUSE I CAN, DOESN'T MEAN I SHOULD.

As a socially responsible employer, if i wanted to hire them, I should pay them the proper salary and give them the proper benefits, REGARDLESS of what he is willing to sell himself for.



You're assuming the employer can afford to pay them more. If the employer raises wages then he'll have to raise prices, which then makes the wage raise meaningless if we assume the price increase to affect the whole economy.

If the employer could afford to pay the workers more and keep the same price then it is the duty of the worker to ask for a higher wage, or find a job where he'll get paid more, ie another car wash where theoretically they could pay him more based on his performance. Alternatively, the worker can open his own car wash and charge a lower price and still earn a higher "wage".

You're example is really complicated because of the many factors affecting the wage and profits. The legality of the workers, and the competition of employers. These factors can force your example to be a non-ideal market which is inefficient and does not generate the most utility.

You're arguments are not ground in economic principles. If it was up to me I would pay everyone millions of dollars, but we live in a world of limited resources and we need a way to distribute it. I believe a free market is the most efficient way of doing it. Perhaps you have a better way, in which case I would love to hear it.


No, i'm not saying that we should pay employees a kabajllion bucks. I'm saying that employers should pay their employees relative to how much they profit from their business. If business is making a lot of profit, companies should increase the pay of their employees in all levels, not just the top brass.

But this is rarely the case. Instead most employers strive to pay the least amount of salary to their employees as they can, regardless of how much they profit. That guy i mentioned who hired indians for US$100? He's got a big house and drives an S-Class now. What excuse does the guy have to not raise his employee's salaries to acceptable levels?
solistus
Profile Joined April 2010
United States172 Posts
March 09 2011 07:47 GMT
#313
Unions are simply a way for workers to collectively bargain for their mutual interests. I don't see how anyone can be against that. The whole concept behind wage labor is that people are freely making an agreement to work based on their self interest, right? Unions are the logical way of promoting that self interest. Workers shouldn't have to prove they're being horrifically exploited to have the right to try and get the best terms possible in a negotiated contract.

Yes, unions push for higher pay and better benefits for their people, and try and protect their people from getting laid off. That's the whole point; they're just a tool for workers to fight for their own interests. Maybe you think sometimes they ask for things they don't "deserve," but how many times has your employer made a decision you thought was unfair? You don't have to support the things they are asking for to support their right to get together and decide to ask for them in the first place. Capitalism is about everyone trying to get as much for themselves as possible, not about everyone deciding what is fair for everyone else to have, right? If you oppose unions because they ask for too much, you should oppose corporations and private companies whenever they are "greedy" and try to make "too much" profit.

Also, it's easy to say things are pretty good now for workers in the west and they don't need unions anymore... But if you get rid of unions, workers next year or next decade may find some of those very freedoms and privileges you mention that unions helped earn for them withering away.

As for legislation to replace them... I like the idea of workers having a way to express their own demands and fight for them a lot better than trusting Congress to write one bill that anticipates every present and future need of every different worker perfectly. I don't even know what that bill would look like to begin with. Most of what unions do is negotiate pay and benefits. Are you suggesting it would be better to have Congress dictate how much every employer pays each of its employees? I think some people might object to that...
Units don't counter units. Strategies counter strategies.
Shanlan
Profile Joined August 2010
United States41 Posts
March 09 2011 08:01 GMT
#314
On March 09 2011 14:29 Signet wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 13:53 Shanlan wrote:
I agree, unions do act as a counter to monopolistic markets, but I think the goal there is to break up the monopoly not create another one. I have said before that unions do create benefits, but I don't think those benefits justify the harm they do. The ideal case would be for new policy to be implemented as unions are slowly limited to more of an activist group that influence policy making vs the decisions of firms.

To summarize, unions act on firms directly, when I believe the problems lay with the market. I believe the unions are addressing the issues at the result end vs the source.

Aside: I find it funny you point to Mr. Pump's papers when I have attended some of the same classes as he.

The issue I have is - I don't doubt that policy changes can be made to increase the number of firms in a sector at equilibrium. Things like reducing subsidies to established firms, eliminating corporate tax loopholes, restricting offshore "tax shelter" accounts, etc could lessen the advantage that existing firms have over potential competitors.

Still, economies of scale play a major role in determining market equilibrium, particularly in markets involving production of physical goods. Even if government-imposed barriers to entry/competition are removed, or even if they go further to say subsidize start-up costs (reduce entry fees), I think we'll still end up with monopolistic competition or oligopoly due to scaling and the importance of branding in the consumer market, with more firms than before but still not a great situation for unorganized laborers who would face an imbalanced market. What policy changes could be made to bridge this gap?

Offhand, I could see implementing a real full-throttle free market system, maxing out domestic firm competitiveness regardless of how hard it skews pre-tax earnings, eliminating wage/health/pension and some other worker laws (not workplace/environmental/consumer safety, but things that can be corrected later), then providing these essentials as social programs to those who are making too little to afford them. But while I can see that working in theory, I can't see Americans going for it in practice. And I don't see it going anywhere with our political parties.

Alternatively, how would you feel about multiple unions in the same sector that basically compete against each other? (ie, the 3 companies / 3 unions hypothetical I gave to another poster)


Hah, what a small world it is that you actually know the guy who wrote those posts. Are you a student/professor at UW? I found his blog via Nate Silver's twitter.


I'll point to high tech as an example of relatively competitive market. It faces a lot of the problems other markets face, the only difference is the cost of entry is lower, less hardware. It also has a different type of labor force, one that is better educated and well informed. But this example does show that the true limits on a free market is the cost of entry and possibly the "informed-ness" of the labor force.

I believe this is why in an economic boom, markets tend to become more open and free, the loans available for start-ups are greater, and in the short-run sunk costs are ignored when calculating production costs. When the market becomes open then the wages become more competitive and reach a more natural equilibrium. It is also in economic booms where unions are the most harmful, they hinder the speed and magnitude a firm can expand and adapt. It is my opinion that only in a recession will labor rights require protection. When the market contracts the dual factors of labor surplus and lowered production give firms an advantage and shift the equilibrium to where they become price setters vs price takers.

If that is true then we can determine when government intervention, or greater vigilance over the labor market should occur. I say this because as much as I believe in minimal government interference I do understand that any human system is imperfect and require a tune-up in times of trouble. I believe the periodic government intervention, and/or policy change can replace the role of unions in protecting labor rights.

In my opinion, as we understand things more we can get peel off old systems and institutions that were needed as stop gap solutions to problems. I believe it is especially important in times of crisis to take the time to examine what we can get rid of. The less laws and barriers we have the smoother things can run, and that applies to everything in an ever more complex world.

I'm a senior at UW. I don't know Mr. Pump personally, but I've friends who've had him as a TA or maybe instructor.
DrainX
Profile Blog Joined December 2006
Sweden3187 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-03-09 08:11:03
March 09 2011 08:10 GMT
#315
On March 09 2011 12:39 Shanlan wrote:
That only serves to prove his point. Only the rich can afford to be "morally" righteous in their economic decisions. The next step is to force the rich who have worked for their money to turn around and support the rest of the country? Would you want to work hard and start a successful business only to have 99% of it taken away and spent on the drug-addicts on the street or the gangs roaming the ghettos? Social welfare doesn't fix the problem and wealth redistribution is theft with a prettier name.

This is such a bad argument. I might as well go to the other political extreme and say that property is theft. Letting capitalism run amok is not a fair way of distributing resources in the first place. Wealth redistribution is no more theft than wealth distribution is. Our entire economic system is just one big game we have designed. If we don't like the outcomes of that game, we can change the rules at any time.
Velr
Profile Blog Joined July 2008
Switzerland10992 Posts
March 09 2011 08:11 GMT
#316
To weak unions lead to harsh work conditions for employes which can lead to a ton of "bad" stuff like uprisings.
To strong unions lead to low profits for the business which leads probably to an unfair and posible to big advantage for organisations that are not "bound" by unions.

As long as neither side is "overdoing" it, everything is fine and unions wouldn't be needed... But that there are unions should tell you something .
Shanlan
Profile Joined August 2010
United States41 Posts
March 09 2011 08:15 GMT
#317
On March 09 2011 16:03 Rashid wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 13:38 Shanlan wrote:
On March 09 2011 13:20 Rashid wrote:
On March 09 2011 12:20 Shanlan wrote:
On March 09 2011 12:10 Rashid wrote:
On March 09 2011 11:57 Shanlan wrote:
First, we examine the role of unions in a market where labor supply is less than demand. Companies in this scenario will be glad to increase wages, benefits, and conditions for workers. The problem arises when unions dictate that those increases apply to all employees. Even in a labor scarce market employers will want to replace poor workers with good ones, but the union will prevent that. So the result is less proficient workers will be hired than in a free market, so there will be better workers in a less profitable firm who could have been hired to a better wage and position but aren't due to union restrictions. Also overall the improvement to the rest of the workers will be less because the poor workers will need to be compensated as well. I don't feel the improvement to the poor worker justifies the losses sustained by the proficient ones.


You know, i have somebody in the neighborhood who owns a carwash business. He hires about 15-20 indian illegal immigrants and pays them each roughly US$100 a MONTH.

Do you want any one of your loved ones to work like donkeys for US$100 a month? Your brother or sister perhaps? Or maybe your mother? Or even yourself?


Perhaps you should actually read what I wrote. The excerpt you quoted refers to a labor scarce market, which in your case isn't. I also don't see how it applies.

I wouldn't work for $100/month and I doubt anyone I know would either. This is because I know I can get a better job that pays better. If I had a choice between not eating and working for $100/month then yes I would.


Simply stating that low wages exist and asking if I would like to do it doesn't serve a purpose. I'm sure the Indians working there would like to work for more money or be a CEO and live in a big house, but they can't because they don't have the skills or abilities to do it.

I'm sure you might have a valid opinion but I don't see one in this post or how it serves to further this discussion.


That's the point. You yourself aren't willing to work for US$100 a month, and i'm pretty sure the guy who hired those indians isn't willing to do the same either, but for some reason you think it's ok for these indians to do the low-pay hard -labor job that you or even anybody you know is willing to do. But just because those indians are so desperate that they are willing to work for US$100 a month, doesn't mean that i should take advantage of them. JUST BECAUSE I CAN, DOESN'T MEAN I SHOULD.

As a socially responsible employer, if i wanted to hire them, I should pay them the proper salary and give them the proper benefits, REGARDLESS of what he is willing to sell himself for.



You're assuming the employer can afford to pay them more. If the employer raises wages then he'll have to raise prices, which then makes the wage raise meaningless if we assume the price increase to affect the whole economy.

If the employer could afford to pay the workers more and keep the same price then it is the duty of the worker to ask for a higher wage, or find a job where he'll get paid more, ie another car wash where theoretically they could pay him more based on his performance. Alternatively, the worker can open his own car wash and charge a lower price and still earn a higher "wage".

You're example is really complicated because of the many factors affecting the wage and profits. The legality of the workers, and the competition of employers. These factors can force your example to be a non-ideal market which is inefficient and does not generate the most utility.

You're arguments are not ground in economic principles. If it was up to me I would pay everyone millions of dollars, but we live in a world of limited resources and we need a way to distribute it. I believe a free market is the most efficient way of doing it. Perhaps you have a better way, in which case I would love to hear it.


No, i'm not saying that we should pay employees a kabajllion bucks. I'm saying that employers should pay their employees relative to how much they profit from their business. If business is making a lot of profit, companies should increase the pay of their employees in all levels, not just the top brass.

But this is rarely the case. Instead most employers strive to pay the least amount of salary to their employees as they can, regardless of how much they profit. That guy i mentioned who hired indians for US$100? He's got a big house and drives an S-Class now. What excuse does the guy have to not raise his employee's salaries to acceptable levels?


Employers have a constraint on them, the market, they can't pay more than they'll make from the product, and the reason they aim for lower wages is so they can produce the product at the cheapest price possible. You want cheaper goods? Then that means companies need to push for lower wages, simple as that. The employee needs/does push for higher wages, but when gathered together they can collude to raise wages above the equilibrium level, meaning more expensive product and less of it for everyone. Also when a company does well it generally pays it out to the employees as bonuses of some sort, stock, bond, etc.

For your example there are multiple costs you haven't considered. If the employer is caught with illegal workers he can be fined, and/or jailed. How much is a year in jail worth to you? 5 years? 10? 20? Also he's not saying you have to work here, and I'm only going to pay you $100. He gave them a choice, he can afford to pay them $100, and they accepted.

You're also effectively saying that people shouldn't be allowed to have X amount of money, because there are others who could use it. Well maybe you shouldn't have a computer, that money could've gone to feed the hungry in Africa. Why don't you take a pay cut so the janitor can make more? Or donate it to charity? Also have you thought about what would happen to luxury companies if everyone earned the same? All those workers that make Mercedes would be out of a job, all those people who build large houses would be out of a job.

If you're so against him making money, you should open a car wash and steal him workers over, since you're willing to earn less that means you're willing to pay them more.Instead of bashing on people who've found a way to make money and be successful, go out and make things better.
Shanlan
Profile Joined August 2010
United States41 Posts
March 09 2011 08:22 GMT
#318
On March 09 2011 17:10 DrainX wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 12:39 Shanlan wrote:
That only serves to prove his point. Only the rich can afford to be "morally" righteous in their economic decisions. The next step is to force the rich who have worked for their money to turn around and support the rest of the country? Would you want to work hard and start a successful business only to have 99% of it taken away and spent on the drug-addicts on the street or the gangs roaming the ghettos? Social welfare doesn't fix the problem and wealth redistribution is theft with a prettier name.

This is such a bad argument. I might as well go to the other political extreme and say that property is theft. Letting capitalism run amok is not a fair way of distributing resources in the first place. Wealth redistribution is no more theft than wealth distribution is. Our entire economic system is just one big game we have designed. If we don't like the outcomes of that game, we can change the rules at any time.


Nice job of saying absolutely nothing useful.

I would like to hear you explain your reasoning behind "property is theft".

Wealth distribution via free markets doesn't involve forcefully taking something from someone and giving it to another, simply because the mob says so.
DrainX
Profile Blog Joined December 2006
Sweden3187 Posts
Last Edited: 2011-03-09 09:23:36
March 09 2011 08:59 GMT
#319
On March 09 2011 17:22 Shanlan wrote:
Show nested quote +
On March 09 2011 17:10 DrainX wrote:
On March 09 2011 12:39 Shanlan wrote:
That only serves to prove his point. Only the rich can afford to be "morally" righteous in their economic decisions. The next step is to force the rich who have worked for their money to turn around and support the rest of the country? Would you want to work hard and start a successful business only to have 99% of it taken away and spent on the drug-addicts on the street or the gangs roaming the ghettos? Social welfare doesn't fix the problem and wealth redistribution is theft with a prettier name.

This is such a bad argument. I might as well go to the other political extreme and say that property is theft. Letting capitalism run amok is not a fair way of distributing resources in the first place. Wealth redistribution is no more theft than wealth distribution is. Our entire economic system is just one big game we have designed. If we don't like the outcomes of that game, we can change the rules at any time.


Nice job of saying absolutely nothing useful.

I would like to hear you explain your reasoning behind "property is theft".

Wealth distribution via free markets doesn't involve forcefully taking something from someone and giving it to another, simply because the mob says so.

I don't want to go too far off topic since this is a thread about unions but if you are interested, I was referring to Proudhon's book "What is Property?" and Atheist political philosophy in general.

In his 1849 treatise What is Property?, Pierre Proudhon answers with "Property is theft!" In natural resources, he sees two types of property, de jure property (legal title) and de facto property (physical possession), and argues that the former is illegitimate. Proudhon's conclusion is that "property, to be just and possible, must necessarily have equality for its condition."

His analysis of the product of labor upon natural resources as property (usufruct) is more nuanced. He asserts that land itself cannot be property, yet it should be held by individual possessors as stewards of mankind with the product of labor being the property of the producer. Proudhon reasoned that any wealth gained without labor was stolen from those who labored to create that wealth. Even a voluntary contract to surrender the product of labor to an employer was theft, according to Proudhon, since the controller of natural resources had no moral right to charge others for the use of that which he did not labor to create and therefore did not own.

Proudhon's theory of property greatly influenced the budding socialist movement, inspiring anarchist theorists such as Mikhail Bakunin who modified Proudhon's ideas, as well as antagonizing theorists like Karl Marx.
Severedevil
Profile Blog Joined April 2009
United States4839 Posts
March 09 2011 09:23 GMT
#320
Property is an odd beast. It's obvious why a person who makes a thing should get to decide who can have that thing. But land and natural resources have no inherent owner.
My strategy is to fork people.
Prev 1 14 15 16 17 18 19 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Next event in 3h 3m
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
ByuN 265
ProTech120
Rex 1
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 23089
Calm 4303
Bisu 856
Horang2 637
BeSt 382
Hyuk 312
Zeus 215
actioN 201
Soulkey 145
Mind 81
[ Show more ]
EffOrt 69
Shinee 57
PianO 41
Hm[arnc] 26
sSak 22
sorry 20
ZergMaN 19
Yoon 14
yabsab 14
Sacsri 10
sOs 7
Super Smash Bros
Mew2King31
Other Games
summit1g10379
singsing1913
JimRising 384
Fuzer 174
Organizations
StarCraft: Brood War
UltimateBattle 47
lovetv 8
[ Show 9 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• Stunt494
Upcoming Events
RSL Revival
3h 3m
Clem vs Serral
herO vs Rogue
OSC
3h 3m
IPSL
7h 3m
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
10h 3m
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
13h 3m
WardiTV Weekly
1d 2h
Kung Fu Cup
2 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
2 days
The PondCast
4 days
KCM Race Survival
4 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
RSL Offline Finals
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3

Upcoming

CSL Season 23: Qualifier 1
Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
CSL 2026 Winter (S23) - 3v3
CSL 2026 Winter (S23)
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.