• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 02:18
CET 08:18
KST 16:18
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #238[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over4Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16) Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion NaDa's Body
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 17249 users

Anarcho-capitalism, why can't it work? - Page 32

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 30 31 32 33 34 50 Next All
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-01 02:21:41
September 01 2010 02:17 GMT
#621
On September 01 2010 10:42 Biochemist wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but the more I think about it and read the posts of those defending it, the more I realize that this is a textbook example of taking a good idea to an extreme where it is no longer a good idea.

I'll make you a table:

Good idea ------------------------------------- Bad extreme

Don't eat unhealthy stuff ------------------- Only eat raw food
Don't ingest random chemicals --------- Don't vaccinate your kids
Free market capitalism -------------------- Anarcho-Capitalism

Extremes are arbitrary, ad-hoc argument
And I can make them too.

Slavery -------- State ------------- Freedom
War ---------- some war ----------- Peace
Bad -------- Average ----------- Good

Meaningless.

edit: more accurately, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_to_moderation
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
kidcrash
Profile Joined September 2009
United States626 Posts
September 01 2010 02:19 GMT
#622
On September 01 2010 09:59 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 09:41 kidcrash wrote:
Well, why don't you elaborate on how the Manhattan Project was something so ingeniously managed that no single market actor could compete with it, let alone top it, if not stolen the opportunity?


Coming from the person who said that our entire economic principle should be based on greed. It's not that no single market actor could compete with it, but why should they feel the need to? If they did feel the need to, who's to say they would work at the pace and urgency needed to get the project done in time?

Who's to say government workers do work on time? How can government know what the time is? How can it know how much to tax for it? How many bombs to make? How many scientists to hire? How much to pay them?

It's far more arbitrary and inefficient. I just doubt it was the case that what they did was something so fantastic, that no free man could have done.


Because when you are pro-active in fund-making and hire specialists, things get done quicker. I gave one specific example about advancements in military technology and large scale operations. However I truly believe that the ana-cap private "donation" fund replacements for all currently state funded programs would be inadequate. I strongly disagree with depending on "if there is a will there is a way" to accomplish large scale tasks that produce little to know profit in compensation. Benefits for the disabled and veterans? What about road maintenance and things like that?

Let me give you an example of how laziness rubs off on the ones around you. I want you do then give me your estimated opinion on the percentage of people this applies to.

At your job you frequently open the store in the morning for your shift. You notice that the people who close the night before often leave with the closers tasks undone. You end up having to finish it for them when you get there in the morning and it's hard because you are the only one there for the first few hours. You aren't sure if it's because they are lazy, or they just don't have enough time but the truth is, it's a combination of both. Your boss tells them it's okay to stay passed close in order to make sure everything is wrapped up before they leave.

Next month when one of the closers quits, you are forced to cover a swing shift, working both the morning shift and the night shift, where you will be closing the store. When closing you decide that the most fair option is to leave each night after you've finished an amount of tasks equal to what the other closers finish when they close the store and you open the next day. Your boss continues to tell all closers to stay after in order to finish everything that needs to be done, however your boss is also never pointing anything he/she sees in the morning that's left over and unacceptable to them.

I do not want your opinion on what a person should or should not to in the situation, that is irrelevant. I want to know what percentage of the population you think would go above and beyond their fellow co-workers work habits and what percentage do you think would work equally as hard as they see their co-workers themselves working. Getting a promotion should not be factored into this calculation.

The key point of this scenario is, the person is not being coerced, exploited, or guided into anything and has to choice to make any decision that they want. When you give someone the option to make sacrifices or to not make sacrifices, it's much harder to give them the will to accomplish something. "If there is a will there is a way" takes a back seat to "procrastination over sacrifice". The results are a system that struggles to find a pro-active reason to accomplish anything.
Biochemist
Profile Blog Joined February 2009
United States1008 Posts
September 01 2010 02:21 GMT
#623
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.


Why is it irrelevant? It's the best course of action for me, an amoral individual, if I want to acquire someone else's stuff. Anarcho-capitalism has no solution for this when applied on a large scale, and every time it's brought up you either totally dodge the issue (like this) or don't even reply (like when I brought it up a few hours ago).
Biochemist
Profile Blog Joined February 2009
United States1008 Posts
September 01 2010 02:22 GMT
#624
On September 01 2010 11:17 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 10:42 Biochemist wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but the more I think about it and read the posts of those defending it, the more I realize that this is a textbook example of taking a good idea to an extreme where it is no longer a good idea.

I'll make you a table:

Good idea ------------------------------------- Bad extreme

Don't eat unhealthy stuff ------------------- Only eat raw food
Don't ingest random chemicals --------- Don't vaccinate your kids
Free market capitalism -------------------- Anarcho-Capitalism

Extremes are arbitrary, ad-hoc argument
And I can make them too.

Slavery -------- State ------------- Freedom
War ---------- some war ----------- Peace
Bad -------- Average ----------- Good

Meaningless.


It's not meaningless. This whole idea is simply taking the idea of free market capitalism and taking it to it's total and complete extreme. I was making some analogies to help illustrate how taking good ideas to these extremes are usually bad, but apparently the meaning was lost on you.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 02:42 GMT
#625
On September 01 2010 11:19 kidcrash wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 09:59 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:41 kidcrash wrote:
Well, why don't you elaborate on how the Manhattan Project was something so ingeniously managed that no single market actor could compete with it, let alone top it, if not stolen the opportunity?


Coming from the person who said that our entire economic principle should be based on greed. It's not that no single market actor could compete with it, but why should they feel the need to? If they did feel the need to, who's to say they would work at the pace and urgency needed to get the project done in time?

Who's to say government workers do work on time? How can government know what the time is? How can it know how much to tax for it? How many bombs to make? How many scientists to hire? How much to pay them?

It's far more arbitrary and inefficient. I just doubt it was the case that what they did was something so fantastic, that no free man could have done.


Because when you are pro-active in fund-making and hire specialists, things get done quicker. I gave one specific example about advancements in military technology and large scale operations. However I truly believe that the ana-cap private "donation" fund replacements for all currently state funded programs would be inadequate. I strongly disagree with depending on "if there is a will there is a way" to accomplish large scale tasks that produce little to know profit in compensation. Benefits for the disabled and veterans? What about road maintenance and things like that?

I didn't disagree that proactivity can be better, I was just noting that it isn't always the case. If it were always the case, you'd be preparing for anything that even has a remote chance of happening. You'd carry an umbrella on a sunny day, tranquilizing rifles to the office in case a wild animal appears, wearing seatbelts to go to the convenience store at the corner. It's an evaluation of how to face risk, cost and benefit. Just because you think it was proper of the state to steal from everyone to avoid a certain menace, in HINDSIGHT, might I add, doesn't mean it was 1- justified at the time, and 2- the best means to prevent it.

Why do you think there's a need for a veteran to receive benefits? Any more than any other government employee? Because it's done now? Veterans, assuming they weren't drafted, were aware of the contractual benefits and obligations on his part. To say that an employee of any type deserves more than that which he already had agreed to receive... is as equal of a claim that the employer deserves more work from the employee past what was contractually decided and agreed on.

Disabled.. disabled aren't to be treated as a special class just because they're disabled. No one is entitled to another man working and giving money to him for free. If you want to be taken care of, then do it voluntarily. Have charities, ask family, neighbors, anything, but please god stop jumping for the damn gun(verment).

Road maintenance.. who owns the road? Who paid for it to be built? And who pays for the road to be maintained? How can a business model be made around roads? Think a little yourself. Might as well have asked "who will make the bread that I buy at the grocery".
Search Walter Block on roads...

On September 01 2010 11:19 kidcrash wrote:
Let me give you an example of how laziness rubs off on the ones around you. I want you do then give me your estimated opinion on the percentage of people this applies to.

At your job you frequently open the store in the morning for your shift. You notice that the people who close the night before often leave with the closers tasks undone. You end up having to finish it for them when you get there in the morning and it's hard because you are the only one there for the first few hours. You aren't sure if it's because they are lazy, or they just don't have enough time but the truth is, it's a combination of both. Your boss tells them it's okay to stay passed close in order to make sure everything is wrapped up before they leave.

Next month when one of the closers quits, you are forced to cover a swing shift, working both the morning shift and the night shift, where you will be closing the store. When closing you decide that the most fair option is to leave each night after you've finished an amount of tasks equal to what the other closers finish when they close the store and you open the next day. Your boss continues to tell all closers to stay after in order to finish everything that needs to be done, however your boss is also never pointing anything he/she sees in the morning that's left over and unacceptable to them.

I do not want your opinion on what a person should or should not to in the situation, that is irrelevant. I want to know what percentage of the population you think would go above and beyond their fellow co-workers work habits and what percentage do you think would work equally as hard as they see their co-workers themselves working. Getting a promotion should not be factored into this calculation.

The key point of this scenario is, the person is not being coerced, exploited, or guided into anything and has to choice to make any decision that they want. When you give someone the option to make sacrifices or to not make sacrifices, it's much harder to give them the will to accomplish something. "If there is a will there is a way" takes a back seat to "procrastination over sacrifice". The results are a system that struggles to find a pro-active reason to accomplish anything.

Uh, you know that argument for lazyness is way, way more appliable to the state, right? The state officer has way less incentives to do his work... I've explored the incentives vis-a-vis multiple times in this thread. Not only can the bureaucrat not possibly know how to best serve a demand, but he can indeed be more laid back, and work just enough to get reelected.

If you think government is more proactive than businesses.. I really don't know what to say. They may be more proactive at bombing third world countries, and using the military industrial complex for their own shady reasons, I'll give you that much.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 02:43 GMT
#626
On September 01 2010 11:21 Biochemist wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.


Why is it irrelevant? It's the best course of action for me, an amoral individual, if I want to acquire someone else's stuff. Anarcho-capitalism has no solution for this when applied on a large scale, and every time it's brought up you either totally dodge the issue (like this) or don't even reply (like when I brought it up a few hours ago).


Then do it, I don't care.
I'm talking to cooperative human beings who do care.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
TanGeng
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
Sanya12364 Posts
September 01 2010 02:43 GMT
#627
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.

#2 You'd have to define what can be considered wealth, as that is entirely subjective; and how much wealth one has to have for it to be justifiably redistributed. If I evaluate one's ass to be worth one trillion dollars, do I have the right to smack it?
It can be consistent, but ridiculously inefficient, as you'd have to rely on a central authority to define those things, and starting at that point, intellectual constraints limit how well society could otherwise organize. And that central authority itself would probably be inconsistent, because in its powers are invested the whole wealth of the world, so the central planning itself, should be redistributed.

#3 By how much? How can you quantify coercion to be beneficial? And how is that not subjective on your part? I think you'd need another central authority to figure that one out...


Serious how about this since you still can't seem to get it.

People don't believe in the Non-aggression principle.
Moderator我们是个踏实的赞助商模式俱乐部
geometryb
Profile Blog Joined November 2005
United States1249 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-01 02:47:09
September 01 2010 02:45 GMT
#628
On September 01 2010 10:52 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 10:11 geometryb wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:56 geometryb wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:54 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:30 geometryb wrote:
Is there a mechanism to maintain market competition? What prevents businesses from merging with each other to form super companies?

The point i'm trying to make is there is no way to tell if there will be one, ten, or 10,000 PDAs (i'm leaning towards 1). For example, is it possible that a company comes up with a product so good that others can't compete. And mergers/acquisitions provides the means for several companies to combine into a few. Are there purely market forces that would prevent defense companies from joining together. Especially defense companies, which gain significant benefits from pooling resources.

There are Diseconomies of scale, to begin with.

And I don't think defense companies always benefit from growing larger. Even if they did, at which point it becomes worrisome for the customer, then he can seek smaller ones. There are people who go to moms and pops even with Walmart open half a mile away, meaning, price isn't always everything even in the free market.


it's not about price. it's about who can provide the best protection or the best product. as a customer, i do not worry about the size of the company that gives the product, only the quality of the product and the price they sell it at. i would argue that a large defense company can provide better protection than a smaller one.

it's not very clear to me how a defense company can have diseconomies of scale. can you elaborate?


Every time I compare price, it's implied I'm referring to equally serviceable products, products that provide the same benefit.

A PDA (private defense agency) would not benefit from increased size... examples:
-Additional policemen do not deter crime any better past a certain density. Having one policeman per street corner is hardly necessary, you're paying the next police officer $40000 for an expected return of much, much less in stopping crimes-a-year.
-Additional guns, same deal
-Distance, it is increasingly harder for a company to have adaptive presence in an area the further away from it's headquarters it is (mitigated by technology but still, what isn't). Local PDAs can best know what is needed in the area.

Just a few I can think of...


those are dealing with small criminals. when a PDA is defending you from attacks on a much larger scale...
i'm going to an extreme here, but
a PDA with ballistic missile defense and launches satellites for an advanced warning system is a much nicer product to have than a few police officers.


again, there is nothing intrinsic about a PDA that says there will be 10,000 competing PDAs and nothing about economies or diseconomies of scale that say there will be 1 or 10000. I'm sorry about using PDAs because this really applies to all industries. Pretend an oil monopoly gets established...and then the oil company decides to start its own PDA since all the PDAs are too small to meet its needs.

Uh, how much is a missile worth, and how much crime does it deter? Even if it's cost-beneficial for having one missile, then how much benefit does the second missile give? The third? The fourth?

Diseconomies of scale are much more relevant than economies of scale, because there exists such a thing as diminishing returns. Economies of scale are almost always wrong, because resources aren't infinite, even if demand could arguiably be deemed infinite, so efficiency will always be capped on how many resources are available, and at what cost they come for.



i think you're going off on a tangent with what ifs and focusing too much on scale and ignoring the essence of what i'm saying.
i'm saying that monopolies can exist (and based on what i read anarchocapitalist say they have no problem with natural) and there's no inherent mechanism to prevent them from forming. Diseconomies of scale is not an anti-monopoly or anti-very few very big company measure. And if monopolies can exist, then monopolies in Defense exist. why would markets call for a big energy (or whatever) company (that can create a defence company) and not a big defence company?

again, saying there are diseconomies of scale does not limit the size of the company. especially since you can't say when diseconomies start happening.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 02:46 GMT
#629
On September 01 2010 11:22 Biochemist wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:17 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:42 Biochemist wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but the more I think about it and read the posts of those defending it, the more I realize that this is a textbook example of taking a good idea to an extreme where it is no longer a good idea.

I'll make you a table:

Good idea ------------------------------------- Bad extreme

Don't eat unhealthy stuff ------------------- Only eat raw food
Don't ingest random chemicals --------- Don't vaccinate your kids
Free market capitalism -------------------- Anarcho-Capitalism

Extremes are arbitrary, ad-hoc argument
And I can make them too.

Slavery -------- State ------------- Freedom
War ---------- some war ----------- Peace
Bad -------- Average ----------- Good

Meaningless.


It's not meaningless. This whole idea is simply taking the idea of free market capitalism and taking it to it's total and complete extreme. I was making some analogies to help illustrate how taking good ideas to these extremes are usually bad, but apparently the meaning was lost on you.

And you can make the argument against anything else as long as you put them on the extreme side. It's completely ad-hoc, and doesn't address the merits of the action or product themselves.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Biochemist
Profile Blog Joined February 2009
United States1008 Posts
September 01 2010 02:50 GMT
#630
On September 01 2010 11:46 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:22 Biochemist wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:17 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:42 Biochemist wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but the more I think about it and read the posts of those defending it, the more I realize that this is a textbook example of taking a good idea to an extreme where it is no longer a good idea.

I'll make you a table:

Good idea ------------------------------------- Bad extreme

Don't eat unhealthy stuff ------------------- Only eat raw food
Don't ingest random chemicals --------- Don't vaccinate your kids
Free market capitalism -------------------- Anarcho-Capitalism

Extremes are arbitrary, ad-hoc argument
And I can make them too.

Slavery -------- State ------------- Freedom
War ---------- some war ----------- Peace
Bad -------- Average ----------- Good

Meaningless.


It's not meaningless. This whole idea is simply taking the idea of free market capitalism and taking it to it's total and complete extreme. I was making some analogies to help illustrate how taking good ideas to these extremes are usually bad, but apparently the meaning was lost on you.

And you can make the argument against anything else as long as you put them on the extreme side. It's completely ad-hoc, and doesn't address the merits of the action or product themselves.


Yes it is ad hoc, but that doesn't make the analogy irrelevant or incorrect. See many other posts in this thread, for example the point about civil war that you are becoming very astute at ignoring.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 02:51 GMT
#631
On September 01 2010 11:43 TanGeng wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.

#2 You'd have to define what can be considered wealth, as that is entirely subjective; and how much wealth one has to have for it to be justifiably redistributed. If I evaluate one's ass to be worth one trillion dollars, do I have the right to smack it?
It can be consistent, but ridiculously inefficient, as you'd have to rely on a central authority to define those things, and starting at that point, intellectual constraints limit how well society could otherwise organize. And that central authority itself would probably be inconsistent, because in its powers are invested the whole wealth of the world, so the central planning itself, should be redistributed.

#3 By how much? How can you quantify coercion to be beneficial? And how is that not subjective on your part? I think you'd need another central authority to figure that one out...


Serious how about this since you still can't seem to get it.

People don't believe in the Non-aggression principle.

It's inconsistent to cry wolf if you're being aggressed then. It is inconsistent to both rape, and plead not to be raped. Kill, yet plead not to be killed. Read Kinsella on Estoppel

Also I'd make the argument that people do generally agree with the NAP, but I'm not in the mood of making empirical arguments for now. Just that, if they did not, then society could not sustain itself from all the killing. Humans could not evolve, social beings, etc., etc.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Biochemist
Profile Blog Joined February 2009
United States1008 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-09-01 02:55:02
September 01 2010 02:54 GMT
#632
On September 01 2010 11:43 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:21 Biochemist wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.


Why is it irrelevant? It's the best course of action for me, an amoral individual, if I want to acquire someone else's stuff. Anarcho-capitalism has no solution for this when applied on a large scale, and every time it's brought up you either totally dodge the issue (like this) or don't even reply (like when I brought it up a few hours ago).


Then do it, I don't care.
I'm talking to cooperative human beings who do care.


Wow, way to miss the whole point..

Good luck finding a society filled with "cooperative human beings who do care." The very merits of capitalism are based on the fact that human beings are greedy, selfish individuals. By giving individuals the ability to advance themselves in society, you raise the level of society as a whole.

In an anarcho-capitalist society, these same greedy people are going to destroy each other, and competing PDAs will be in on the action from both sides, not stopping it like a responsible government would.

I hate socialism, and I'm all for the minimization of government, but doing away with it completely is just stupid.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 03:02 GMT
#633
On September 01 2010 11:45 geometryb wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 10:52 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:11 geometryb wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:56 geometryb wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:54 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:30 geometryb wrote:
Is there a mechanism to maintain market competition? What prevents businesses from merging with each other to form super companies?

The point i'm trying to make is there is no way to tell if there will be one, ten, or 10,000 PDAs (i'm leaning towards 1). For example, is it possible that a company comes up with a product so good that others can't compete. And mergers/acquisitions provides the means for several companies to combine into a few. Are there purely market forces that would prevent defense companies from joining together. Especially defense companies, which gain significant benefits from pooling resources.

There are Diseconomies of scale, to begin with.

And I don't think defense companies always benefit from growing larger. Even if they did, at which point it becomes worrisome for the customer, then he can seek smaller ones. There are people who go to moms and pops even with Walmart open half a mile away, meaning, price isn't always everything even in the free market.


it's not about price. it's about who can provide the best protection or the best product. as a customer, i do not worry about the size of the company that gives the product, only the quality of the product and the price they sell it at. i would argue that a large defense company can provide better protection than a smaller one.

it's not very clear to me how a defense company can have diseconomies of scale. can you elaborate?


Every time I compare price, it's implied I'm referring to equally serviceable products, products that provide the same benefit.

A PDA (private defense agency) would not benefit from increased size... examples:
-Additional policemen do not deter crime any better past a certain density. Having one policeman per street corner is hardly necessary, you're paying the next police officer $40000 for an expected return of much, much less in stopping crimes-a-year.
-Additional guns, same deal
-Distance, it is increasingly harder for a company to have adaptive presence in an area the further away from it's headquarters it is (mitigated by technology but still, what isn't). Local PDAs can best know what is needed in the area.

Just a few I can think of...


those are dealing with small criminals. when a PDA is defending you from attacks on a much larger scale...
i'm going to an extreme here, but
a PDA with ballistic missile defense and launches satellites for an advanced warning system is a much nicer product to have than a few police officers.


again, there is nothing intrinsic about a PDA that says there will be 10,000 competing PDAs and nothing about economies or diseconomies of scale that say there will be 1 or 10000. I'm sorry about using PDAs because this really applies to all industries. Pretend an oil monopoly gets established...and then the oil company decides to start its own PDA since all the PDAs are too small to meet its needs.

Uh, how much is a missile worth, and how much crime does it deter? Even if it's cost-beneficial for having one missile, then how much benefit does the second missile give? The third? The fourth?

Diseconomies of scale are much more relevant than economies of scale, because there exists such a thing as diminishing returns. Economies of scale are almost always wrong, because resources aren't infinite, even if demand could arguiably be deemed infinite, so efficiency will always be capped on how many resources are available, and at what cost they come for.



i think you're going off on a tangent with what ifs and focusing too much on scale and ignoring the essence of what i'm saying.
i'm saying that monopolies can exist (and based on what i read anarchocapitalist say they have no problem with natural) and there's no inherent mechanism to prevent them from forming. Diseconomies of scale is not an anti-monopoly or anti-very few very big company measure. And if monopolies can exist, then monopolies in Defense exist. why would markets call for a big energy (or whatever) company (that can create a defence company) and not a big defence company?

again, saying there are diseconomies of scale does not limit the size of the company. especially since you can't say when diseconomies start happening.

Uh, I reject the popular definition of monopoly, and I take it that by natural monopoly, you mean that it may be natural in some circumstances for a company to provide a certain service in some area that no other one does.

And second "uh", diseconomies of scale DO limit company size, that's exactly what the incentives do. If you read anything that I've written, that the wiki site of it says, and the wiki site on diminishing marginal utility, you'd understand there's a limit on how much a company spends or grows, and how much it profits.

There may come to be a big defense company, but that is somewhat irrelevant, and if you're afraid of them, I also already addressed why PDA (protection defense agencies) would not or could not turn to coercion, not nearly as much as the state can, and no matter how big. Basically, if you're worried about it, so would any anarchist be. The bigger a PDA gets, the more worrisome it's anarchic clients would get, and they'd either move out of the PDA, or they'd require it to give them assurances that it would not go unaccounted for any single bullet shot. Third parties could help with foresight. Insurance companies, actuaries, any type of predicative and investigating specialists could help satisfy that demand. And yes, fear asks for assurances, and assurance is a demand to be satisfied, at some cost of course.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
kidcrash
Profile Joined September 2009
United States626 Posts
September 01 2010 03:03 GMT
#634
On September 01 2010 11:42 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:19 kidcrash wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:59 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:41 kidcrash wrote:
Well, why don't you elaborate on how the Manhattan Project was something so ingeniously managed that no single market actor could compete with it, let alone top it, if not stolen the opportunity?


Coming from the person who said that our entire economic principle should be based on greed. It's not that no single market actor could compete with it, but why should they feel the need to? If they did feel the need to, who's to say they would work at the pace and urgency needed to get the project done in time?

Who's to say government workers do work on time? How can government know what the time is? How can it know how much to tax for it? How many bombs to make? How many scientists to hire? How much to pay them?

It's far more arbitrary and inefficient. I just doubt it was the case that what they did was something so fantastic, that no free man could have done.


Because when you are pro-active in fund-making and hire specialists, things get done quicker. I gave one specific example about advancements in military technology and large scale operations. However I truly believe that the ana-cap private "donation" fund replacements for all currently state funded programs would be inadequate. I strongly disagree with depending on "if there is a will there is a way" to accomplish large scale tasks that produce little to know profit in compensation. Benefits for the disabled and veterans? What about road maintenance and things like that?

I didn't disagree that proactivity can be better, I was just noting that it isn't always the case. If it were always the case, you'd be preparing for anything that even has a remote chance of happening. You'd carry an umbrella on a sunny day, tranquilizing rifles to the office in case a wild animal appears, wearing seatbelts to go to the convenience store at the corner. It's an evaluation of how to face risk, cost and benefit. Just because you think it was proper of the state to steal from everyone to avoid a certain menace, in HINDSIGHT, might I add, doesn't mean it was 1- justified at the time, and 2- the best means to prevent it.

Why do you think there's a need for a veteran to receive benefits? Any more than any other government employee? Because it's done now? Veterans, assuming they weren't drafted, were aware of the contractual benefits and obligations on his part. To say that an employee of any type deserves more than that which he already had agreed to receive... is as equal of a claim that the employer deserves more work from the employee past what was contractually decided and agreed on.

Disabled.. disabled aren't to be treated as a special class just because they're disabled. No one is entitled to another man working and giving money to him for free. If you want to be taken care of, then do it voluntarily. Have charities, ask family, neighbors, anything, but please god stop jumping for the damn gun(verment).

Road maintenance.. who owns the road? Who paid for it to be built? And who pays for the road to be maintained? How can a business model be made around roads? Think a little yourself. Might as well have asked "who will make the bread that I buy at the grocery".
Search Walter Block on roads...

Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:19 kidcrash wrote:
Let me give you an example of how laziness rubs off on the ones around you. I want you do then give me your estimated opinion on the percentage of people this applies to.

At your job you frequently open the store in the morning for your shift. You notice that the people who close the night before often leave with the closers tasks undone. You end up having to finish it for them when you get there in the morning and it's hard because you are the only one there for the first few hours. You aren't sure if it's because they are lazy, or they just don't have enough time but the truth is, it's a combination of both. Your boss tells them it's okay to stay passed close in order to make sure everything is wrapped up before they leave.

Next month when one of the closers quits, you are forced to cover a swing shift, working both the morning shift and the night shift, where you will be closing the store. When closing you decide that the most fair option is to leave each night after you've finished an amount of tasks equal to what the other closers finish when they close the store and you open the next day. Your boss continues to tell all closers to stay after in order to finish everything that needs to be done, however your boss is also never pointing anything he/she sees in the morning that's left over and unacceptable to them.

I do not want your opinion on what a person should or should not to in the situation, that is irrelevant. I want to know what percentage of the population you think would go above and beyond their fellow co-workers work habits and what percentage do you think would work equally as hard as they see their co-workers themselves working. Getting a promotion should not be factored into this calculation.

The key point of this scenario is, the person is not being coerced, exploited, or guided into anything and has to choice to make any decision that they want. When you give someone the option to make sacrifices or to not make sacrifices, it's much harder to give them the will to accomplish something. "If there is a will there is a way" takes a back seat to "procrastination over sacrifice". The results are a system that struggles to find a pro-active reason to accomplish anything.

Uh, you know that argument for lazyness is way, way more appliable to the state, right? The state officer has way less incentives to do his work... I've explored the incentives vis-a-vis multiple times in this thread. Not only can the bureaucrat not possibly know how to best serve a demand, but he can indeed be more laid back, and work just enough to get reelected.

If you think government is more proactive than businesses.. I really don't know what to say. They may be more proactive at bombing third world countries, and using the military industrial complex for their own shady reasons, I'll give you that much.


There would be zero incentive for anyone to start a fund for handicap people or any social service. These things would not happen or if they did happen they would be inadequate. Your saying a government official that is being paid and who's job is based essentially on a popularity contest has less incentive to get these things done than a company ceo who has no incentive or motive to donate money to a road construction and maintenance fund or for a fund for the disabled or for a military budget, other than just out of the kindest of their heart?

You're saying a person who is being paid and needs to make a good public impression has less incentive than company executives who you expect to just give their money away for zero compensation. What about jails and a police force and a judicial system? Are you going to tell companies, you can help pay for these things if you want, but we aren't going to force you? Judges and police officers would probably receive like a 50% pay cut.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 03:08 GMT
#635
On September 01 2010 11:50 Biochemist wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:46 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:22 Biochemist wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:17 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:42 Biochemist wrote:
I'm new to this whole idea, but the more I think about it and read the posts of those defending it, the more I realize that this is a textbook example of taking a good idea to an extreme where it is no longer a good idea.

I'll make you a table:

Good idea ------------------------------------- Bad extreme

Don't eat unhealthy stuff ------------------- Only eat raw food
Don't ingest random chemicals --------- Don't vaccinate your kids
Free market capitalism -------------------- Anarcho-Capitalism

Extremes are arbitrary, ad-hoc argument
And I can make them too.

Slavery -------- State ------------- Freedom
War ---------- some war ----------- Peace
Bad -------- Average ----------- Good

Meaningless.


It's not meaningless. This whole idea is simply taking the idea of free market capitalism and taking it to it's total and complete extreme. I was making some analogies to help illustrate how taking good ideas to these extremes are usually bad, but apparently the meaning was lost on you.

And you can make the argument against anything else as long as you put them on the extreme side. It's completely ad-hoc, and doesn't address the merits of the action or product themselves.


Yes it is ad hoc, but that doesn't make the analogy irrelevant or incorrect. See many other posts in this thread, for example the point about civil war that you are becoming very astute at ignoring.

What the hell, I completely addressed civil wars. It's no different than the claim that PDAs will kill everyone, because PDAs are exactly the type of companies with the best means to start a civil war, and try to establish a state again. They have the most guns and able personnel to do it. If they won't do it, then who will? Grampa with a rifle? More inefficient militias? Why would they initiate force and risk being killed, to overthrow what?

The analogy is irrelevant because the same type of argument can be used against or for anything. It's an argument for moderation. Beating seems like a good idea, but no beating is bad; stealing seems like a good idea, but no stealing is bad; religion seems like a good idea, but no religion is bad;

You can say ANYTHING is bad by parting from a more "moderate" point of view. What is MODERATE is subjective, and so is the EXTREME. It's completely ad-hoc because you're working backwards to prove a preconceived value.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 03:09 GMT
#636
On September 01 2010 11:54 Biochemist wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:43 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:21 Biochemist wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.


Why is it irrelevant? It's the best course of action for me, an amoral individual, if I want to acquire someone else's stuff. Anarcho-capitalism has no solution for this when applied on a large scale, and every time it's brought up you either totally dodge the issue (like this) or don't even reply (like when I brought it up a few hours ago).


Then do it, I don't care.
I'm talking to cooperative human beings who do care.


Wow, way to miss the whole point..

Good luck finding a society filled with "cooperative human beings who do care." The very merits of capitalism are based on the fact that human beings are greedy, selfish individuals. By giving individuals the ability to advance themselves in society, you raise the level of society as a whole.

In an anarcho-capitalist society, these same greedy people are going to destroy each other, and competing PDAs will be in on the action from both sides, not stopping it like a responsible government would.

I hate socialism, and I'm all for the minimization of government, but doing away with it completely is just stupid.

Greedy and selfish doesn't mean they're sociopaths, and certainly doesn't mean they can't cooperate.
Read up on egoism.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
TanGeng
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
Sanya12364 Posts
September 01 2010 03:14 GMT
#637
On September 01 2010 11:51 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:43 TanGeng wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.

#2 You'd have to define what can be considered wealth, as that is entirely subjective; and how much wealth one has to have for it to be justifiably redistributed. If I evaluate one's ass to be worth one trillion dollars, do I have the right to smack it?
It can be consistent, but ridiculously inefficient, as you'd have to rely on a central authority to define those things, and starting at that point, intellectual constraints limit how well society could otherwise organize. And that central authority itself would probably be inconsistent, because in its powers are invested the whole wealth of the world, so the central planning itself, should be redistributed.

#3 By how much? How can you quantify coercion to be beneficial? And how is that not subjective on your part? I think you'd need another central authority to figure that one out...


Serious how about this since you still can't seem to get it.

People don't believe in the Non-aggression principle.

It's inconsistent to cry wolf if you're being aggressed then. It is inconsistent to both rape, and plead not to be raped. Kill, yet plead not to be killed. Read Kinsella on Estoppel

Also I'd make the argument that people do generally agree with the NAP, but I'm not in the mood of making empirical arguments for now. Just that, if they did not, then society could not sustain itself from all the killing. Humans could not evolve, social beings, etc., etc.


Ugh.

It doesn't matter if you can make the argument that people do generally agree. It's rather that people don't wholly agree. Basically people in general will take advantage of others to certain degrees if given the chance and will form organizations that allow them to do so. They will do so freely even if they are the ones being conned because they are hopeful that they can out game the system. That's how the government combination of governance and pillaging formed in the first place. The anarcho-capitalist society is unstable because it will devolve into one that has government.

I wish I lived in a society that people wholly agreed with the non-aggression principle. All of them would be a whole lot nicer people.

"cry wolf" - Do you know what that means?


Moderator我们是个踏实的赞助商模式俱乐部
Biochemist
Profile Blog Joined February 2009
United States1008 Posts
September 01 2010 03:20 GMT
#638
On September 01 2010 12:09 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:54 Biochemist wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:43 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:21 Biochemist wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.


Why is it irrelevant? It's the best course of action for me, an amoral individual, if I want to acquire someone else's stuff. Anarcho-capitalism has no solution for this when applied on a large scale, and every time it's brought up you either totally dodge the issue (like this) or don't even reply (like when I brought it up a few hours ago).


Then do it, I don't care.
I'm talking to cooperative human beings who do care.


Wow, way to miss the whole point..

Good luck finding a society filled with "cooperative human beings who do care." The very merits of capitalism are based on the fact that human beings are greedy, selfish individuals. By giving individuals the ability to advance themselves in society, you raise the level of society as a whole.

In an anarcho-capitalist society, these same greedy people are going to destroy each other, and competing PDAs will be in on the action from both sides, not stopping it like a responsible government would.

I hate socialism, and I'm all for the minimization of government, but doing away with it completely is just stupid.

Greedy and selfish doesn't mean they're sociopaths, and certainly doesn't mean they can't cooperate.
Read up on egoism.


Have you ever taken a history class in your life?
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 03:22 GMT
#639
On September 01 2010 12:03 kidcrash wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:42 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:19 kidcrash wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:59 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 09:41 kidcrash wrote:
Well, why don't you elaborate on how the Manhattan Project was something so ingeniously managed that no single market actor could compete with it, let alone top it, if not stolen the opportunity?


Coming from the person who said that our entire economic principle should be based on greed. It's not that no single market actor could compete with it, but why should they feel the need to? If they did feel the need to, who's to say they would work at the pace and urgency needed to get the project done in time?

Who's to say government workers do work on time? How can government know what the time is? How can it know how much to tax for it? How many bombs to make? How many scientists to hire? How much to pay them?

It's far more arbitrary and inefficient. I just doubt it was the case that what they did was something so fantastic, that no free man could have done.


Because when you are pro-active in fund-making and hire specialists, things get done quicker. I gave one specific example about advancements in military technology and large scale operations. However I truly believe that the ana-cap private "donation" fund replacements for all currently state funded programs would be inadequate. I strongly disagree with depending on "if there is a will there is a way" to accomplish large scale tasks that produce little to know profit in compensation. Benefits for the disabled and veterans? What about road maintenance and things like that?

I didn't disagree that proactivity can be better, I was just noting that it isn't always the case. If it were always the case, you'd be preparing for anything that even has a remote chance of happening. You'd carry an umbrella on a sunny day, tranquilizing rifles to the office in case a wild animal appears, wearing seatbelts to go to the convenience store at the corner. It's an evaluation of how to face risk, cost and benefit. Just because you think it was proper of the state to steal from everyone to avoid a certain menace, in HINDSIGHT, might I add, doesn't mean it was 1- justified at the time, and 2- the best means to prevent it.

Why do you think there's a need for a veteran to receive benefits? Any more than any other government employee? Because it's done now? Veterans, assuming they weren't drafted, were aware of the contractual benefits and obligations on his part. To say that an employee of any type deserves more than that which he already had agreed to receive... is as equal of a claim that the employer deserves more work from the employee past what was contractually decided and agreed on.

Disabled.. disabled aren't to be treated as a special class just because they're disabled. No one is entitled to another man working and giving money to him for free. If you want to be taken care of, then do it voluntarily. Have charities, ask family, neighbors, anything, but please god stop jumping for the damn gun(verment).

Road maintenance.. who owns the road? Who paid for it to be built? And who pays for the road to be maintained? How can a business model be made around roads? Think a little yourself. Might as well have asked "who will make the bread that I buy at the grocery".
Search Walter Block on roads...

On September 01 2010 11:19 kidcrash wrote:
Let me give you an example of how laziness rubs off on the ones around you. I want you do then give me your estimated opinion on the percentage of people this applies to.

At your job you frequently open the store in the morning for your shift. You notice that the people who close the night before often leave with the closers tasks undone. You end up having to finish it for them when you get there in the morning and it's hard because you are the only one there for the first few hours. You aren't sure if it's because they are lazy, or they just don't have enough time but the truth is, it's a combination of both. Your boss tells them it's okay to stay passed close in order to make sure everything is wrapped up before they leave.

Next month when one of the closers quits, you are forced to cover a swing shift, working both the morning shift and the night shift, where you will be closing the store. When closing you decide that the most fair option is to leave each night after you've finished an amount of tasks equal to what the other closers finish when they close the store and you open the next day. Your boss continues to tell all closers to stay after in order to finish everything that needs to be done, however your boss is also never pointing anything he/she sees in the morning that's left over and unacceptable to them.

I do not want your opinion on what a person should or should not to in the situation, that is irrelevant. I want to know what percentage of the population you think would go above and beyond their fellow co-workers work habits and what percentage do you think would work equally as hard as they see their co-workers themselves working. Getting a promotion should not be factored into this calculation.

The key point of this scenario is, the person is not being coerced, exploited, or guided into anything and has to choice to make any decision that they want. When you give someone the option to make sacrifices or to not make sacrifices, it's much harder to give them the will to accomplish something. "If there is a will there is a way" takes a back seat to "procrastination over sacrifice". The results are a system that struggles to find a pro-active reason to accomplish anything.

Uh, you know that argument for lazyness is way, way more appliable to the state, right? The state officer has way less incentives to do his work... I've explored the incentives vis-a-vis multiple times in this thread. Not only can the bureaucrat not possibly know how to best serve a demand, but he can indeed be more laid back, and work just enough to get reelected.

If you think government is more proactive than businesses.. I really don't know what to say. They may be more proactive at bombing third world countries, and using the military industrial complex for their own shady reasons, I'll give you that much.


There would be zero incentive for anyone to start a fund for handicap people or any social service. These things would not happen or if they did happen they would be inadequate. Your saying a government official that is being paid and who's job is based essentially on a popularity contest has less incentive to get these things done than a company ceo who has no incentive or motive to donate money to a road construction and maintenance fund or for a fund for the disabled or for a military budget, other than just out of the kindest of their heart?

Yes. Private charities already exist, and charity is a market demand.
Stealing from everyone can hardly be called charity however, for any end at all.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_philanthropists
I couldn't find a non-mixed list, but...
http://www.forbes.com/lists/2005/14/Revenue_1.html

On September 01 2010 12:03 kidcrash wrote:
You're saying a person who is being paid and needs to make a good public impression has less incentive than company executives who you expect to just give their money away for zero compensation. What about jails and a police force and a judicial system? Are you going to tell companies, you can help pay for these things if you want, but we aren't going to force you? Judges and police officers would probably receive like a 50% pay cut.

Hm, you're right in that governments may donate more, or have more incentives to donate more, I had not thought of that. But who do they donate to? How can they access which charity to donate will best satisfy the altruistic feeling of the people he robbed? Even with the incentive, he cannot choose the right ones all the time. He could donate to the big foundations who make TV adverts, and the well known institutions, but it can never access who needs it most, as good as the population itself would.

AAaand, again, it is hardly charity to do anything with stolen property. If a thief is to steal your car, then tell you that he's using it to drive orphans to the school, does that make the thief exempt from repercussion? No, that's a ridiculous excuse to support coercion. Let people donate as they want, and don't try to save face with that. Let people keep what they earn, and then perhaps little to no donations are needed at all.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
September 01 2010 03:29 GMT
#640
On September 01 2010 12:14 TanGeng wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 01 2010 11:51 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:43 TanGeng wrote:
On September 01 2010 11:08 Yurebis wrote:
On September 01 2010 10:23 TanGeng wrote:
How about this for you Yurebis.

Anarcho-capitalism can't work because lots of people believe in one of the following:
1. Might makes right. Domination by force justifies taking and pillaging.
2. We should redistribute wealth and force wealthy individuals to give up their money to the rest of us.
3. When political elites aggrandize themselves at the expense of the common masses, the common masses actually benefits.

#1 Is a consistent description of reality, but it is an irrelevant discussion of social organization. Of course, people that can do stuff, can do stuff, completely disregarding other people's plans. Yet it doesn't follow that it is desirable, or the best course of action for a certain end. For the ends of being a sociopath, yes, I think it may be best to just think that way and disregard everything else. But for the purposes of human cooperation, it is very relevant to discuss what courses of action are desirable; what actions aren't tolerable, and what actions should follow them. It is a discussion of human interaction, not empty morality.

#2 You'd have to define what can be considered wealth, as that is entirely subjective; and how much wealth one has to have for it to be justifiably redistributed. If I evaluate one's ass to be worth one trillion dollars, do I have the right to smack it?
It can be consistent, but ridiculously inefficient, as you'd have to rely on a central authority to define those things, and starting at that point, intellectual constraints limit how well society could otherwise organize. And that central authority itself would probably be inconsistent, because in its powers are invested the whole wealth of the world, so the central planning itself, should be redistributed.

#3 By how much? How can you quantify coercion to be beneficial? And how is that not subjective on your part? I think you'd need another central authority to figure that one out...


Serious how about this since you still can't seem to get it.

People don't believe in the Non-aggression principle.

It's inconsistent to cry wolf if you're being aggressed then. It is inconsistent to both rape, and plead not to be raped. Kill, yet plead not to be killed. Read Kinsella on Estoppel

Also I'd make the argument that people do generally agree with the NAP, but I'm not in the mood of making empirical arguments for now. Just that, if they did not, then society could not sustain itself from all the killing. Humans could not evolve, social beings, etc., etc.


Ugh.

It doesn't matter if you can make the argument that people do generally agree. It's rather that people don't wholly agree. Basically people in general will take advantage of others to certain degrees if given the chance and will form organizations that allow them to do so. They will do so freely even if they are the ones being conned because they are hopeful that they can out game the system. That's how the government combination of governance and pillaging formed in the first place. The anarcho-capitalist society is unstable because it will devolve into one that has government.

I wish I lived in a society that people wholly agreed with the non-aggression principle. All of them would be a whole lot nicer people.

Well the whole point of this ideological talk we're having here is to assert which courses of action are desirable, and which ones aren't.
1-people generally agree with the NAP
2-but people will coerce when they can anyway
3-therefore, the state exists, because it's getting away with coercion
You are correct, which is exactly why I'm in this thread pointing out that the state is coercing, and it is coercive by nature - so that people don't let it, nor any future institution as such, get away with it!

On September 01 2010 12:14 TanGeng wrote:
"cry wolf" - Do you know what that means?

I admit I picked the wrong words, however it still fits, in the sense that it would not be seen as aggression to others, as no one considered anything aggression.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Prev 1 30 31 32 33 34 50 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
08:00
SC2 Kevin Scrim
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
SortOf 97
StarCraft: Brood War
GuemChi 1291
Bisu 566
Hyuk 25
sOs 24
sorry 16
Force[name] 5
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr37
Other Games
summit1g9089
Coldzera 1111
JimRising 363
C9.Mang0242
Happy205
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick679
[ Show 11 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 6
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• lizZardDota2445
League of Legends
• Rush1129
Upcoming Events
Online Event
2h 42m
GSL
4h 12m
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
6h 42m
OSC
8h 42m
Replay Cast
15h 42m
KCM Race Survival
1d 2h
Ultimate Battle
1d 4h
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
2 days
BSL
2 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
3 days
[ Show More ]
IPSL
3 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
3 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
3 days
WardiTV Weekly
4 days
Kung Fu Cup
5 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.