• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 21:21
CET 03:21
KST 11:21
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Team Liquid Map Contest #238[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over4Dark completes military service, returns to SC217[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Team Liquid Map Contest #23 Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 StarCraft open world shooter announced at BlizzCon
Tourneys
Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Light introduces ShieldBattery on his YouTube
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL23] Ro16 Group D - Sunday 21:00 CET [BSL23] Ro16 Group B - Saturday 21:00 CET
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc List of Game Threads
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Trading/Investing Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
James Bond movies ranking - pa…
Topin
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 18158 users

Anarcho-capitalism, why can't it work? - Page 10

Forum Index > General Forum
Post a Reply
Prev 1 8 9 10 11 12 50 Next All
Djzapz
Profile Blog Joined August 2009
Canada10681 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:17:18
August 29 2010 05:16 GMT
#181
Anarcho-capitalism can't work because of human nature. You think I'm wrong? You really misunderstand the humankind then. It's a shame it can't work because your utopia would be sweet. Unfortunately it won't and can't work the way you imagine it. Sorry!
"My incompetence with power tools had been increasing exponentially over the course of 20 years spent inhaling experimental oven cleaners"
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
August 29 2010 05:18 GMT
#182
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote:
Uh, anarcho-capitalism doesn't address monopolies and cartels?

Anarcho-capitalism assumes perfect competition and perfect information

No it doesn't. If by perfect competition you mean, homogenic products, homogenic prices, everything is the same, it's a ridiculous concept. It's not even demonstrably desirable. Perfect competition would be everyone making some type of product and there's no more desirable product than another. Markets are best at diversity. I don't get the perfect competition argument at all. People are different, there can't be perfect competition even if the government mandated it; and plus why would you want to anyway.

On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote: -- far from realistic. Information asymmetry and imperfect competition means economic inequalities translate to political inequalities.

What you fail to notice is that the same applies to the government; The state can't have perfect information either, and logically, it should know less, as it has less incentives to know more; as it has less people to know more. As it is a rat hole of sociopaths. Okay the last one is just my opinion. But the rest is true!
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote: Even most libertarians draw the line at night watchman states.

That is true, but also an appeal to popularity if you mean that.. "therefore, minarchism>anarchism"
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Half
Profile Joined March 2010
United States2554 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:26:52
August 29 2010 05:23 GMT
#183

Someone has to pay those bureaucrats that otherwise wouldn't exist, and that's the overhead.
But that's not the main problem of course; even if those bureaucrats worked for free and were the most brilliant men of the land, they still would not compare to the entrepreneurial efficiency of thousands of entrepreneurs each acting on their own localities, figuring out ways to profit, or in other words, finding new things to do, improve, undercut the leading brand, etc.


In other words, if I'm not mistaken, your saying an open market would produce more qualified individuals for the job, resulting in higher efficiency...though these individuals of course would still have to be payed, supposedly resulting in a more efficient system, yet still with overhead costs in "management".

I get it, and it doesn't make sense. You can't have "competing" departments of say, police. The entire point of a state is centralization, (supposedly) all peoples interests are considered, and the stepping on of toes is minimalized.

At a certain point you enter the domain of common interest, where the actions of one individual is going to detriment another individual, and individuals would want to join a collaborative body for protection.

A state is formed to protect common interest.

The result is centralization (the formation of a state) or fragmentation (the formation of several smaller states), because private corporations will be forced to do so in order to provide satisfy consumer need.

but you seem to be a trolling anarchist of sorts so I wasn't going to bother anymore :D no offense intended.

wut. I'm idealistically a Anarchist, but I'm also to level headed to believe in what I preach. So I guess your right lol.


I like this thread :3
Too Busy to Troll!
gyth
Profile Blog Joined September 2009
657 Posts
August 29 2010 05:24 GMT
#184
At some level people enjoy being told what to do.
Until you subvert that, a leader will always be able to take over an anarchy.
Anarchy may ideally be preferred to democracy, but its so ubiquitously unstable that it boils down to the only system worse than despotism.

P.S. did OP ever define ancap? Wiki left me vague.
The plural of anecdote is not data.
Severedevil
Profile Blog Joined April 2009
United States4839 Posts
August 29 2010 05:26 GMT
#185
I think gangsters are the best model of government, so gogo anarchy.
My strategy is to fork people.
dvide
Profile Joined March 2010
United Kingdom287 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:31:50
August 29 2010 05:26 GMT
#186
No sorry your completely wrong. Egyptian and Nubian Kingdoms had already risen and fell before the whole "Pharaohs as Gods thing you learned in School History Class started".

How do you know these kingdoms had no gods (ignoring royalty as a superstition itself since that is obviously in question)? How do we know these gods were not appealed to in order to create the state in some manner? If not outright "ruler being a god", but a "divine rights of kings" style appeal? Or even less but still there to some extent. I doubt we can even really know (unless you can show me otherwise and I'm genuinely curious if you can).

My guess is it must have involved some level of propagandising, as I cannot see how a state could possibly arise from the pure overwhelming power of violence from individuals and organisations alone. It just could not possibly be overwhelming enough without acceptances and compliance from the people.

Stop asking my for redundant definitions like its relevant to your point. I am using any definition of subject you so chose in the political sense that is widely regarded as right, I'm hardly arguing off semantics. In fact you are.

Sigh. What? How is I just arguing semantics? I'm asking for YOUR definitions so we can both use them and understand each other. Semantic arguments is just to mix up definitions relating to an argument and is therefore usually just confused and futile. I'm trying to a avoid semantic dispute by asking for the meaning in your terms. So from your definition of subject, am I a subject to the Coca-Cola company? Just answer the question straight up so we can progress past this bullshit?


Even if their ISNT a monopoly on security firms lol. You can move to the US if you dun like the UK, does that make the government any less controlling?

No it doesn't because the UK (in the context of the nation) does not legitimately own the UK (in the context of the landmass). That's kinda the whole point. But I don't get what the relevance is to your argument at all.


You really are just argueing semantics. Just think of the US and insurance package A and the UK as insurance Package B, and maybe like China as shitty insurance policy C (I'm chinese so no offense). You can choose any one of them as a citizen of the UK lol. Just move.

So nation states equal companies now? Well if that's how you define "company" it's no wonder we disagree. I don't agree that nation states own the area that they claim to have authority over in the same way that a company has authority over a factory that it owns. That's the crux of the issue.


AMG ANARCHOCAPITALISM? Its just semantics. Power arises from demand, if you remove government corporations step in to fill their shoes, and in the end its more or less the same.

Well, that's a nice sound-bite. But you've really failed to convince me of anything. I'm trying to understand why and how, but you refuse to answer claiming it's just semantics when it's nothing of the sort.
adrenaLinG
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
Canada676 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:30:46
August 29 2010 05:29 GMT
#187
On August 29 2010 14:18 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote:
Uh, anarcho-capitalism doesn't address monopolies and cartels?

Anarcho-capitalism assumes perfect competition and perfect information

No it doesn't. If by perfect competition you mean, homogenic products, homogenic prices, everything is the same, it's a ridiculous concept. It's not even demonstrably desirable. Perfect competition would be everyone making some type of product and there's no more desirable product than another. Markets are best at diversity. I don't get the perfect competition argument at all. People are different, there can't be perfect competition even if the government mandated it; and plus why would you want to anyway.

Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote: -- far from realistic. Information asymmetry and imperfect competition means economic inequalities translate to political inequalities.

What you fail to notice is that the same applies to the government; The state can't have perfect information either, and logically, it should know less, as it has less incentives to know more; as it has less people to know more. As it is a rat hole of sociopaths. Okay the last one is just my opinion. But the rest is true!
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote: Even most libertarians draw the line at night watchman states.

That is true, but also an appeal to popularity if you mean that.. "therefore, minarchism>anarchism"


So you're saying that you don't want perfect competition -- the most efficient market system -- in favour of something more inefficient? And then you complain about government being inefficient?

Your idea that markets are best 'at diversity' doesn't make sense at all. The only reason there are 'diverse markets' are presumably your assumption of 'diverse' agents.

The reason Austrian economists reject perfect competition is because they don't like the idea of governments enforcing authority to break up imperfect competition, e.g. inefficient markets or market failures. It's absolutely nonsensical because here we have a situation where government is trying to be pro-capitalist but also pro-government. Anarcho-capitalists are thus anti-capitalist because they hate government.

Simply put, perfect competition is the most efficient market structure, and Austrians reject the most efficient market structure, because they dislike government. But they can't have it both ways, in complaining about how government is inefficient and trying to use the free market as a solution.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Half
Profile Joined March 2010
United States2554 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:36:51
August 29 2010 05:33 GMT
#188
Well, that's a nice sound-bite. But you've really failed to convince me of anything. I'm trying to understand why and how, but you refuse to answer claiming it's just semantics when it's nothing of the sort.


I read your post and I missed any kind of central, connecting point :/. What exactly is your point? Everyone one of your responses seemed kind of anecdotal rather then direct refutations or new propositions.

Its really quite simple. You defined an Anarcho-Capitalism and then failed to distinguish it from a somewhat libertarian Government. Explain to me how it is different? Choice? No, it isn't choice, not substantially more then it is now.


No it doesn't because the UK (in the context of the nation) does not legitimately own the UK (in the context of the landmass). That's kinda the whole point. But I don't get what the relevance is to your argument at all.


The word "own" is not a philosophical proposition just as "is Anarchy possible" is not one either. The UK does have control over the UK regardless of philosophy and Sustained long term Anarchy is indeed impossible equally regardless of philosophy.


Well, that's a nice sound-bite. But you've really failed to convince me of anything. I'm trying to understand why and how, but you refuse to answer claiming it's just semantics when it's nothing of the sort.


I refused to answer your definition of subject because it felt needless and arbitrary and you didn't seem to have a point. But if you insist, subject means "under partial or total power of".

If you honestly think the only reason governments exist is because of religion, I don't even feel like properly refuting that becauses its such an insular viewpoint, no offense.
Too Busy to Troll!
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
August 29 2010 05:34 GMT
#189
On August 29 2010 14:10 Sadist wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 10:57 Yurebis wrote:
On August 29 2010 10:20 Sadist wrote:
On August 29 2010 10:00 HunterX11 wrote:
On August 29 2010 09:53 Yurebis wrote:
On August 29 2010 09:35 HunterX11 wrote:
On August 29 2010 09:31 Yurebis wrote:
Goddamn so many replies, I can't answer them all anymore

On August 29 2010 09:24 HunterX11 wrote:
On August 29 2010 09:15 Yurebis wrote:
On August 29 2010 08:55 HunterX11 wrote:
How does one reconcile an aversion to coercion with the fact that "property" is an artificial construct enforced through government coercion? Consider owning a deed to land, for example: what this means is that the state will agree to coerce others using physical force not to use the land to which you have the deed, or at the very least it gives you to right to use physical force against other who encroach onto your land. If one were really committed to voluntary association and non-coercion, how would private property exist?

It's not artificial, it's natural. Almost everyone feels entitled to what they make. You plant a seed, you feel entitled to the plant. You build a house, you feel entitled to the house. If people weren't entitled for what they make, then they would produce less higher graded capital; no one, or less people would build a factory that people don't respect his entitlements for it. People would spend most of their time producing only that which they're immediately consuming, or their direct relatives and friends. Large scale projects are impossible to be built if people are like "you could have made it, but now I'm using it and it's mine LOL". Division of labor is extremely dependent on the formalization of property rights.
Unless you can explain to me how would there be incentives for an engineer to plan factories for people without the recognition that the factory at least partially does belong to him, and no one can take it from him by force.


Isn't saying that people are entitled to what they make an argument made by communism? After all, if people were entitled to what they make, an employee for example would be entitled to all the profits from his work minus what his employer provided him with.

You also talk about incentives and division of labor, but this seems to have nothing to do with anarcho-capitalism itself: you are talking about a particular social order which you feel is desirable, but anarcho-capitalism isn't supposed to impose any social order at all, but rather allow people to freely choose their own. What if people wanted a different division of labor that what exists? Should coercion be used to prevent this? Wouldn't that go against anarcho-capitalism?

Communism ignores the cost of entrepreneurial activity. For them, it's like the factory came from the sky. They completely ignore the market incentives that brought about even the idea of such factory to be made, let alone the savings that enabled such investment. Of course, if you assume that the factory owner didn't have any part on making the factory, you can come to the conclusion that it is not wrong for the workers to claim it for themselves, but it's ridiculously obvious how such action is simple theft.


In my post I even said that employees should only be entitled to the profit minus what their employer provided, i.e. entrepreneurial costs. I do not deny the cost of entrepreneurial activity; however, anarcho-capitalism does. Entrepreneurs should be entitled to all profits derived from entrepreneurial activity, but under anarcho-capitalism, they are entitled to all profits, period. This is completely ignoring the value of the labor of everyone who isn't an entrepreneur. This is more complex than "simple theft", but it also certainly does not reflect the principle that people should be entitled to the fruit of their labor.

Uh... how do you really think someone can open a firm and get people to work for them for free?
I recommend this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catallactics if you're stuck on the idea of exploitation.
The entrepreneur can only exploit as much as the next entrepreneur will pay more simply put... and there can be no such thing as a voluntarily employed worker being exploited. He will quit if he has a better choice.


The problem is that things such as food are biological necessities, and not market priorities: if a human being decides that none of the jobs available to him satisfy an equilibrium of income supplied and labor demanded, he will earn no money, and die if he cannot afford biological necessities and has none provided for him. The argument against this is that the need to live is a part of supply and demand, but this means that employers can take advantage of this fact to set wages arbitrarily low. How does anarcho-capitalism deal with this, the Iron Law of Wages.



I agree with this completely. Its as if the cost and time of travel is thrown out the window and someone can move instantly to somewhere with the best wages. People can easily fall victim to their surroundings much like they did in medieval Europe.

You probably think the minimum wage is what stops evil entrepreneurs from exploiting their employees?
Hokay.



Thanks for avoiding my point entirely!

Douche.

Allow me to redeem myself. The "environment" is no one's fault. Scarcity is a matter of physical nature, and human action seeks to end the scarceness as much as it can, always approaching the impossible. That man has to work hard to get what he wants is a fact that's going to perpetuate humanity to the point where man may have entire worlds at his disposal and still not be satisfied. What you may call poor now, a rich king in medieval times often could not have; heating, light at night, clothing, electricity, waste disposal, clean water from a pipe.

That some man may be doomed to his environment is not a valid complaint as much as "I hate that the sky is blue". What I'm tackling here is not scarcity, it's not the solution to poverty, it is the rejection that coercion can provide man with relief of his desires.

The cost of time and travel is not any more disregarded than the cost of production of a loaf of bread. Everything is accounted for when everything is someone's property, it is as regarded as the owner wants it to be. And as catallactics explain, the worker's body is also accounted for by the worker himself. He will put his efforts into what seems to give him the most return.

The statist solution to the issue of scarcity is not to facilitate the exchange between employer and employee, no sir, because if it were, the state would back of and let them resolve how they can best meet each others ends voluntarily. The state can only act through coercion, and by coercing one to give another a piece of his capital, he has made no one better off in net, and very much possibly and demonstrably made everyone worse off, for he disallowed the exchange to be established spontaneously and sustainable. It would be bad enough if he merely coerced people into paying him tribute, but he must also temper voluntary interactions and act like he did someone a favor? In the long run, the cheated party will simply either do less of what it's being tributed for, or charge more from those who want him to keep his business going. The poor also pay for the rich's taxes by proxy.

I don't have much else to say on that before going on even wider tangents that you may not appreciate as much as the effort I put into writing them.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
August 29 2010 05:36 GMT
#190
On August 29 2010 14:13 adrenaline.CA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:08 Yurebis wrote:
On August 29 2010 14:00 Half wrote:
@ Yurebis- I haven't read the entire thread, but a core component of your argument is built around avoiding "overhead costs" of a State that is essentially coercing money from you.

What makes you think that private companies would have any less overhead? In fact, if recent history shows anything their would even be more mismanagement. If your assuming these corporations can avoid the mismanagement of the state why cant the state just avoid the mismanagement of the state?

Half, the state are basically just bureaucrats, the central planners, who write the law, regulations, and determine how taxpaying money is spent. They don't administrate anything directly. They form bureaus, agencies, comittees which are more comparable to the private institutions that would do the work intended otherwise (but with incentives perverted ofc)

Someone has to pay those bureaucrats that otherwise wouldn't exist, and that's the overhead.
But that's not the main problem of course; even if those bureaucrats worked for free and were the most brilliant men of the land, they still would not compare to the entrepreneurial efficiency of thousands of entrepreneurs each acting on their own localities, figuring out ways to profit, or in other words, finding new things to do, improve, undercut the leading brand, etc.

I was going to make a big post out of things that you said but you seem to be a trolling anarchist of sorts so I wasn't going to bother anymore :D no offense intended.


You conflate arguing against government 'bureaucracy' with arguing against 'government' in general. Politicians are lawmakers -- they make laws such as the Antitrust Act. Without these laws, the 'free market' that you love to say is more 'efficient' than government would not exactly be efficient at all.

In fact, unregulated markets can delve into high levels of inefficiency -- they're called market failures. Things such as monopolies and cartels are example of market failures, which government is supposed to help prevent. Anarcho-capitalism does nothing to address this.

Tell me, what is a monopoly, and why is it bad?
What is market failure, and why does it justify coercion?

I would explain everything but I'm getting rather tired of repeating myself. Perhaps you can help yourself in solving those dilemmas.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
August 29 2010 05:38 GMT
#191
On August 29 2010 14:16 Djzapz wrote:
Anarcho-capitalism can't work because of human nature. You think I'm wrong? You really misunderstand the humankind then. It's a shame it can't work because your utopia would be sweet. Unfortunately it won't and can't work the way you imagine it. Sorry!

Yes, I think you're wrong, because that's no argument for or against anything. Every institution is comprised of man, so every institution is susceptible to the flaws of man. The state is also comprised of man. My argument doesn't rely on human nature too much, but rather a-priori rationalizations on why the state is a worse mechanism of human organization than freely exchanging individuals. If you read anything I wrote you could better understand the argument at least.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
adrenaLinG
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
Canada676 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:39:16
August 29 2010 05:38 GMT
#192
On August 29 2010 14:36 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:13 adrenaline.CA wrote:
On August 29 2010 14:08 Yurebis wrote:
On August 29 2010 14:00 Half wrote:
@ Yurebis- I haven't read the entire thread, but a core component of your argument is built around avoiding "overhead costs" of a State that is essentially coercing money from you.

What makes you think that private companies would have any less overhead? In fact, if recent history shows anything their would even be more mismanagement. If your assuming these corporations can avoid the mismanagement of the state why cant the state just avoid the mismanagement of the state?

Half, the state are basically just bureaucrats, the central planners, who write the law, regulations, and determine how taxpaying money is spent. They don't administrate anything directly. They form bureaus, agencies, comittees which are more comparable to the private institutions that would do the work intended otherwise (but with incentives perverted ofc)

Someone has to pay those bureaucrats that otherwise wouldn't exist, and that's the overhead.
But that's not the main problem of course; even if those bureaucrats worked for free and were the most brilliant men of the land, they still would not compare to the entrepreneurial efficiency of thousands of entrepreneurs each acting on their own localities, figuring out ways to profit, or in other words, finding new things to do, improve, undercut the leading brand, etc.

I was going to make a big post out of things that you said but you seem to be a trolling anarchist of sorts so I wasn't going to bother anymore :D no offense intended.


You conflate arguing against government 'bureaucracy' with arguing against 'government' in general. Politicians are lawmakers -- they make laws such as the Antitrust Act. Without these laws, the 'free market' that you love to say is more 'efficient' than government would not exactly be efficient at all.

In fact, unregulated markets can delve into high levels of inefficiency -- they're called market failures. Things such as monopolies and cartels are example of market failures, which government is supposed to help prevent. Anarcho-capitalism does nothing to address this.

Tell me, what is a monopoly, and why is it bad?
What is market failure, and why does it justify coercion?

I would explain everything but I'm getting rather tired of repeating myself. Perhaps you can help yourself in solving those dilemmas.


monopoly: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monopoly

market failure: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_failure

I'm not explaining things that you should know yourself if you made a thread about economics and philosophy.

A monopoly is bad because consumers get screwed over. Monopolies are one form of market failures.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Half
Profile Joined March 2010
United States2554 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:45:51
August 29 2010 05:42 GMT
#193
^
Adding onto that

A ancap driven by monopolistic systems is one indistinguishable from government, and government requires monopoly to protect common interest.

You can't have two police departments catering to two different interest groups in one area with selective service.

You can't have one police department "stop murders" and the other "not stop murders", because as you see there is a conflict of public interest. These two companies cannot compete (outside of the oldest form of competition, killing each other), because they intrinsically cannot coexist with each other. The result is a monopoly on any given area by one "company", in order to preserve common interest.

So an area with one set of laws which everyone must follow and funded by everyone if you want to live there.

Sounds a lot like government.
Too Busy to Troll!
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
August 29 2010 05:51 GMT
#194
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
Show nested quote +

Someone has to pay those bureaucrats that otherwise wouldn't exist, and that's the overhead.
But that's not the main problem of course; even if those bureaucrats worked for free and were the most brilliant men of the land, they still would not compare to the entrepreneurial efficiency of thousands of entrepreneurs each acting on their own localities, figuring out ways to profit, or in other words, finding new things to do, improve, undercut the leading brand, etc.


In other words, if I'm not mistaken, your saying an open market would produce more qualified individuals for the job, resulting in higher efficiency...though these individuals of course would still have to be payed, supposedly resulting in a more efficient system, yet still with overhead costs in "management".

You're not seeing it properly. Remember we are talking about the state. The state isn't merely "paid", it coercively expropriates the money from it's citizens to pay for its departments. Some problems that come from that, is that the government, compared to the free market 1- can't know as well how much to spend on each deparment 2- can't know as well how much to tax ("charge"), 3- it has a monopoly on almost whatever it provides, so it can't simply follow exchange prices from a market competitor 4- it has less incentives to do a good job, as the government employee not only is usually overcompensated, but his pay is assured no matter what he does. No matter how shitty the service is, it's still the only provider of it, and lawfully so. So, all the arguments people have against monopoly? Yeah, how about applying that criticism to the biggest monopoly of all, and be consistent for once?

On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
I get it, and it doesn't make sense. You can't have "competing" departments of say, police. The entire point of a state is centralization, (supposedly) all peoples interests are considered, and the stepping on of toes is minimalized.

You can, there already exists today private security. Guards and body guards. The point of a state is being the final arbiter of all disputes, the enforcers could very well all be private even in a minarchist setting. It's ok that you can't imagine cops being private; the people in communist russia couldn't imagine bread being sold in the market either. Oh wow second time I pull that one.
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
At a certain point you enter the domain of common interest, where the actions of one individual is going to detriment another individual, and individuals would want to join a collaborative body for protection.

You mean, there will be disputes, therefore, we need a common arbiter?
Okay, even if I concede that, it still doesn't mean the arbiter needs to force everyone to be a member of it. I'm not doing anything to you, why do you bother if I'm a member of your group or not? Just don't trade with me and you're risk free. If I overstep your boundaries you can surely call your agency or remove me from your property risk-free of retaliation. If I insisted, I'm seen as a criminal for everyone else, and I'd have difficulties buying food, driving on the street (every street is private, remember), and worse stuff could happen to me.
Anarcho-capitalism handles criminals differently; but that's not to say it's impossible to deal with them. Just have a bit of creativity and let go of the arguments from ignorance.

On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
A state is formed to protect common interest.

The result is centralization (the formation of a state) or fragmentation (the formation of several smaller states), because private corporations will be forced to do so in order to provide satisfy consumer need.

Yeah? You're starting to get it?
Man, economy, and the state - murray rothbard. Skim through defense chapters...

On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
Show nested quote +
but you seem to be a trolling anarchist of sorts so I wasn't going to bother anymore :D no offense intended.

wut. I'm idealistically a Anarchist, but I'm also to level headed to believe in what I preach. So I guess your right lol.
I like this thread :3

Okay
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
adrenaLinG
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
Canada676 Posts
August 29 2010 05:51 GMT
#195
On August 29 2010 14:42 Half wrote:
^
Adding onto that

A ancap driven by monopolistic systems is one indistinguishable from government, and government requires monopoly to protect common interest.

You can't have two police departments catering to two different interest groups in one area with selective service.

You can't have one police department "stop murders" and the other "not stop murders", because as you see there is a conflict of public interest. These two companies cannot compete (outside of the oldest form of competition, killing each other), because they intrinsically cannot coexist with each other. The result is a monopoly on any given area by one "company", in order to preserve common interest.

So an area with one set of laws which everyone must follow and funded by everyone if you want to live there.

Sounds a lot like government.


Yes yes yes -- which is why even libertarians draw the line at security and defense -- because the common interest has such high marginal utility that it's imperative. I know a libertarian that was forced to at least supporting government-funded Medicare simply because of the effects of disease -- that a private system would be much more inefficient when it deals infectious diseases that spread easily -- or any general 'vector' in epidemiology.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 05:53:35
August 29 2010 05:52 GMT
#196
On August 29 2010 14:24 gyth wrote:
At some level people enjoy being told what to do.
Until you subvert that, a leader will always be able to take over an anarchy.
Anarchy may ideally be preferred to democracy, but its so ubiquitously unstable that it boils down to the only system worse than despotism.

P.S. did OP ever define ancap? Wiki left me vague.

A society absent of rulers, yet with general respect towards private property

On August 29 2010 14:26 Severedevil wrote:
I think gangsters are the best model of government, so gogo anarchy.

Indeed, the state already is, and by definition always was.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
adrenaLinG
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
Canada676 Posts
August 29 2010 05:55 GMT
#197
Here is paradise for anarcho-capitalists: http://mises.org/daily/2066

Somalia, most developed country in the world!
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Yurebis
Profile Joined January 2009
United States1452 Posts
August 29 2010 06:00 GMT
#198
On August 29 2010 14:29 adrenaline.CA wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:18 Yurebis wrote:
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote:
Uh, anarcho-capitalism doesn't address monopolies and cartels?

Anarcho-capitalism assumes perfect competition and perfect information

No it doesn't. If by perfect competition you mean, homogenic products, homogenic prices, everything is the same, it's a ridiculous concept. It's not even demonstrably desirable. Perfect competition would be everyone making some type of product and there's no more desirable product than another. Markets are best at diversity. I don't get the perfect competition argument at all. People are different, there can't be perfect competition even if the government mandated it; and plus why would you want to anyway.

On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote: -- far from realistic. Information asymmetry and imperfect competition means economic inequalities translate to political inequalities.

What you fail to notice is that the same applies to the government; The state can't have perfect information either, and logically, it should know less, as it has less incentives to know more; as it has less people to know more. As it is a rat hole of sociopaths. Okay the last one is just my opinion. But the rest is true!
On August 29 2010 14:02 adrenaline.CA wrote: Even most libertarians draw the line at night watchman states.

That is true, but also an appeal to popularity if you mean that.. "therefore, minarchism>anarchism"


So you're saying that you don't want perfect competition -- the most efficient market system -- in favour of something more inefficient? And then you complain about government being inefficient?

Your idea that markets are best 'at diversity' doesn't make sense at all. The only reason there are 'diverse markets' are presumably your assumption of 'diverse' agents.

The reason Austrian economists reject perfect competition is because they don't like the idea of governments enforcing authority to break up imperfect competition, e.g. inefficient markets or market failures. It's absolutely nonsensical because here we have a situation where government is trying to be pro-capitalist but also pro-government. Anarcho-capitalists are thus anti-capitalist because they hate government.

Simply put, perfect competition is the most efficient market structure, and Austrians reject the most efficient market structure, because they dislike government. But they can't have it both ways, in complaining about how government is inefficient and trying to use the free market as a solution.

The idea of perfect competition as put forth by interventionists, is flawed on those two grounds that I can see...
Is it or is it not "homogeneous products, homogeneous prices"?
1-How is that desirable for every, or even just most consumers? If it isn't, then it isn't perfect. Because the end of production should be to satisfy the consumer's wants
2-How can there be such a thing? You'd end up with a supermarket full of white boxes that don't do anything but are all exactly the same and all serve for absolutely nothing. Who the fuck would buy that shit? I want my products to be original, cheap, and the best on the rack. From a monopoly or not, I don't give a fuck. And so don't most people.

I don't like the idea of the state coming with a lame excuse of a nirvana fallacy to intervene in the market, to provide an even worse product than it was before, and establish oligarchies just by collateral side effects from raising the barriers of entry so much. I just want no coercion. It isn't asking much.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
adrenaLinG
Profile Blog Joined August 2010
Canada676 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 06:05:57
August 29 2010 06:04 GMT
#199
So you're complaining about perfect competition being "homogeneous products" -- do you instead prefer to spend money on brand names and reputations instead of the actual product? In perfect competition, brand names don't matter -- the products are identical. Think of wheat and corn markets. Food companies don't care about the brand of corn is supplied by them by farms -- they just want corn.

I think you need to understand some general economic concepts before going this far into economic philosophy. The example of market failures is where the state intervenes to improve the market.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Half
Profile Joined March 2010
United States2554 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-08-29 06:09:28
August 29 2010 06:04 GMT
#200
On August 29 2010 14:51 Yurebis wrote:
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:

Someone has to pay those bureaucrats that otherwise wouldn't exist, and that's the overhead.
But that's not the main problem of course; even if those bureaucrats worked for free and were the most brilliant men of the land, they still would not compare to the entrepreneurial efficiency of thousands of entrepreneurs each acting on their own localities, figuring out ways to profit, or in other words, finding new things to do, improve, undercut the leading brand, etc.


In other words, if I'm not mistaken, your saying an open market would produce more qualified individuals for the job, resulting in higher efficiency...though these individuals of course would still have to be payed, supposedly resulting in a more efficient system, yet still with overhead costs in "management".

You're not seeing it properly. Remember we are talking about the state. The state isn't merely "paid", it coercively expropriates the money from it's citizens to pay for its departments. Some problems that come from that, is that the government, compared to the free market 1- can't know as well how much to spend on each deparment 2- can't know as well how much to tax ("charge"), 3- it has a monopoly on almost whatever it provides, so it can't simply follow exchange prices from a market competitor 4- it has less incentives to do a good job, as the government employee not only is usually overcompensated, but his pay is assured no matter what he does. No matter how shitty the service is, it's still the only provider of it, and lawfully so. So, all the arguments people have against monopoly? Yeah, how about applying that criticism to the biggest monopoly of all, and be consistent for once?

Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
I get it, and it doesn't make sense. You can't have "competing" departments of say, police. The entire point of a state is centralization, (supposedly) all peoples interests are considered, and the stepping on of toes is minimalized.

You can, there already exists today private security. Guards and body guards. The point of a state is being the final arbiter of all disputes, the enforcers could very well all be private even in a minarchist setting. It's ok that you can't imagine cops being private; the people in communist russia couldn't imagine bread being sold in the market either. Oh wow second time I pull that one.
Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
At a certain point you enter the domain of common interest, where the actions of one individual is going to detriment another individual, and individuals would want to join a collaborative body for protection.

You mean, there will be disputes, therefore, we need a common arbiter?
Okay, even if I concede that, it still doesn't mean the arbiter needs to force everyone to be a member of it. I'm not doing anything to you, why do you bother if I'm a member of your group or not? Just don't trade with me and you're risk free. If I overstep your boundaries you can surely call your agency or remove me from your property risk-free of retaliation. If I insisted, I'm seen as a criminal for everyone else, and I'd have difficulties buying food, driving on the street (every street is private, remember), and worse stuff could happen to me.
Anarcho-capitalism handles criminals differently; but that's not to say it's impossible to deal with them. Just have a bit of creativity and let go of the arguments from ignorance.

Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
A state is formed to protect common interest.

The result is centralization (the formation of a state) or fragmentation (the formation of several smaller states), because private corporations will be forced to do so in order to provide satisfy consumer need.

Yeah? You're starting to get it?
Man, economy, and the state - murray rothbard. Skim through defense chapters...

Show nested quote +
On August 29 2010 14:23 Half wrote:
but you seem to be a trolling anarchist of sorts so I wasn't going to bother anymore :D no offense intended.

wut. I'm idealistically a Anarchist, but I'm also to level headed to believe in what I preach. So I guess your right lol.
I like this thread :3

Okay


I guess what your saying. Your saying that "laws" would be privately applied to private property, then privately enforced depending on whos property it was. So if I wanted to buy property and allow people hunting, sure, I could, but only on my property and without violating the local rules on other peoples property (plus people would probably kind of hate me lol). Which is workable. Likewise, in less extremes, it would basically be like everywhere you went had a shopping mall system, local rules.

Sounds awesome and workable right? Totally! No conflicts of interest, the consumers needs are satisfied, nobody is coercing money from you, a society built on mutual respect. And conflicting security companies aren't killing each other Deus Ex style on the streets.

Except that's the problem. Its still built upon mutual interest, and people with mutual interests will gravitate towards each other. Your not going to want to be the only guy on your block whos property has the "Murder and Rape allowed rule". Nobody is going to come to your dinner parties.

Likewise, in a poor neighborhood, people are going to maybe share one security company, and hang out with people who have similar rules.

Logistically, you can't have 10 security companies enforcing 10 rule sets on a single block. It would be absolute chaos. Moreover, people aren't going to want to live in that kind of situation.

The end result is simple, the one I already said. A bunch of little states, built on common interest. People who have common interests gravitate towards each other and eventually the system becomes set in stone due to a monopoly over the area.


I think the differences in our viewpoints are caused by one thing. I don't view Government as a state artificially imposed upon us by what? Aliens? Government is an intrinsic part of human cooperation on a larger scale. Systems of government, or structures of power, exist everywhere, in the office, in the family. Sometimes these systems can become too power, or too bureaucratized, and the freedoms of the individual are infringed.

But these systems are so basic, so intrinsic, that it isn't even something that can be removed. The basic structure of government -someone telling you what to do-, isn't something that can be removed.

If you don't like it, you have three options, become a hermit, start a revolution, or be powerful.
Too Busy to Troll!
Prev 1 8 9 10 11 12 50 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Replay Cast
08:00
SC2 Kevin Scrim
CranKy Ducklings122
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft: Brood War
GuemChi 1399
Artosis 550
Noble 28
Terrorterran 6
Dota 2
NeuroSwarm76
capcasts54
Counter-Strike
Coldzera 1216
fl0m941
taco 340
Super Smash Bros
AZ_Axe152
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr92
Other Games
summit1g15697
Day[9].tv651
C9.Mang0291
PiGStarcraft243
ToD149
Maynarde103
ViBE75
Organizations
Other Games
gamesdonequick789
BasetradeTV135
[ Show 14 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• Hupsaiya 119
• davetesta22
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• Azhi_Dahaki14
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• masondota2725
Other Games
• Day9tv651
• Shiphtur558
Upcoming Events
Online Event
7h 40m
GSL
9h 10m
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
11h 40m
OSC
13h 40m
Replay Cast
20h 40m
KCM Race Survival
1d 7h
Ultimate Battle
1d 9h
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
2 days
BSL
2 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
3 days
[ Show More ]
IPSL
3 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
3 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
3 days
WardiTV Weekly
4 days
Kung Fu Cup
5 days
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
5 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-17
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.