On July 14 2013 11:07 biology]major wrote:
if you guys want objectivity all you need to do is have tladt users rate anime. boom
if you guys want objectivity all you need to do is have tladt users rate anime. boom
Everything would be rated 4.7 then
Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
ragz_gt
9172 Posts
July 14 2013 02:11 GMT
#59541
On July 14 2013 11:07 biology]major wrote: if you guys want objectivity all you need to do is have tladt users rate anime. boom Everything would be rated 4.7 then | ||
OutlaW-
Czech Republic5053 Posts
July 14 2013 02:33 GMT
#59542
I love this thread's sarcasm. What else. Monogatari is suffering imo a little from the absence of koyomi, but it's consistent and I like it. Railgun is obviously excellent, they even improved the whole bridge scene when compared to index. I'm a little perplexed by the fact that Dangan's blood was pink, but I have to say that overall I like the whole "comedical edginess" atmosphere that the show has going on, I even downloaded the game. I kinda liked Love Lab and I'm looking forward to TWGoK. Playing dota and watching top gear has made me quite busy recently so I haven't checked out anything else. Que picture dump. + Show Spoiler + Also, ZNF is correct. Like what you like and don't care about what other people say (about it). We have differences in tastes and we all believe that our taste is the best, but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't discuss it. | ||
Zergneedsfood
United States10671 Posts
July 14 2013 02:35 GMT
#59543
On July 14 2013 11:07 biology]major wrote: if you guys want objectivity all you need to do is have tladt users rate anime. boom shooooot this guy gets it. Basically, anything I don't like bad is bad and everything I like is good. That's basically how simple life is, really. It's just objective truth guyz. | ||
Itsmedudeman
United States19229 Posts
July 14 2013 02:39 GMT
#59544
But in that guy's defense, the show hasn't finished yet, and scores before the season ends are usually untrustworthy. SAO was near like 9.0 before the 2nd arc finished. Although imo 8.3 is still pretty high for that show. | ||
Zergneedsfood
United States10671 Posts
July 14 2013 02:42 GMT
#59545
I think some people have more well-informed opinions than others. For instance just by sheer volume of things read/watched, I'd trust certain people's opinions here on manga/anime just because they have more experience than me. | ||
OutlaW-
Czech Republic5053 Posts
July 14 2013 02:43 GMT
#59546
| ||
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
July 14 2013 02:47 GMT
#59547
| ||
Itsmedudeman
United States19229 Posts
July 14 2013 02:52 GMT
#59548
When good shows are rated poorly, and bad shows are rated well? Again, that's your opinion, and to say certain shows aren't getting the ratings they deserve would be a biased opinion. | ||
OutlaW-
Czech Republic5053 Posts
July 14 2013 02:55 GMT
#59549
| ||
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
July 14 2013 02:55 GMT
#59550
Look, even if you say that I have a "biased opinion" in thinking a show doesn't deserve its MAL score, the same exact thing can be said about each and every person who rates things on MAL. If you are saying lots of people's ratings matter more, then that is by definition an appeal to its popularity, or lack there of. | ||
Itsmedudeman
United States19229 Posts
July 14 2013 02:59 GMT
#59551
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/grown_ups_2/ 7% of critics liked grown ups 2 while 90% of the audience liked it. Let's face it, it's probably not gonna win a golden globe, but most people enjoyed the show. | ||
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
July 14 2013 03:01 GMT
#59552
| ||
Itsmedudeman
United States19229 Posts
July 14 2013 03:04 GMT
#59553
| ||
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
July 14 2013 03:07 GMT
#59554
| ||
Ecael
United States6703 Posts
July 14 2013 03:27 GMT
#59555
On July 14 2013 11:33 OutlaW- wrote: What else. Monogatari is suffering imo a little from the absence of koyomi, but it's consistent and I like it. Hanekawa is actually a pretty good narrator, just that we don't seem to be getting much narrating with this adaptation. I guess if nothing else it means Hana should be less of a pain. | ||
OutlaW-
Czech Republic5053 Posts
July 14 2013 03:34 GMT
#59556
On July 14 2013 12:27 Ecael wrote: Show nested quote + On July 14 2013 11:33 OutlaW- wrote: What else. Monogatari is suffering imo a little from the absence of koyomi, but it's consistent and I like it. Hanekawa is actually a pretty good narrator, just that we don't seem to be getting much narrating with this adaptation. I guess if nothing else it means Hana should be less of a pain. She might very well be, but I don't really like her. I don't know if you've been pausing to read all the bits in the flash screens (black, red, purple, etc.) but some good narration can be found there. At least there's lots of crab, though I always end up imagining how much better she would look if she still had long hair | ||
Ecael
United States6703 Posts
July 14 2013 03:36 GMT
#59557
On July 14 2013 12:34 OutlaW- wrote: Show nested quote + On July 14 2013 12:27 Ecael wrote: On July 14 2013 11:33 OutlaW- wrote: What else. Monogatari is suffering imo a little from the absence of koyomi, but it's consistent and I like it. Hanekawa is actually a pretty good narrator, just that we don't seem to be getting much narrating with this adaptation. I guess if nothing else it means Hana should be less of a pain. She might very well be, but I don't really like her. I don't know if you've been pausing to read all the bits in the flash screens (black, red, purple, etc.) but some good narration can be found there. At least there's lots of crab, though I always end up imagining how much better she would look if she still had long hair I don't need to since they just quote book directly, has been the case since bake. So I know pretty much whatever they are flashing anyway lol Also gahara-san is growing her hair back out some, it is longer by koi. | ||
biology]major
United States2253 Posts
July 14 2013 03:50 GMT
#59558
On July 14 2013 11:35 Zergneedsfood wrote: Show nested quote + On July 14 2013 11:07 biology]major wrote: if you guys want objectivity all you need to do is have tladt users rate anime. boom shooooot this guy gets it. Basically, anything I don't like bad is bad and everything I like is good. That's basically how simple life is, really. It's just objective truth guyz. man its almost as if I was trying to make that point | ||
Dark_Chill
Canada3353 Posts
July 14 2013 03:52 GMT
#59559
On July 14 2013 11:55 Sentenal wrote: So you think shows like SAO, Code Geass R2, and SnK deserve their scores? Look, even if you say that I have a "biased opinion" in thinking a show doesn't deserve its MAL score, the same exact thing can be said about each and every person who rates things on MAL. If you are saying lots of people's ratings matter more, then that is by definition an appeal to its popularity, or lack there of. Do I think shows like those deserve their scores? Nope. Do other people? Yes. What's so freaking hard to understand about this. Your opinion on a show is not the end all be all. Maybe if you were getting into an argument about quality of voice acting, quality of sound, quality of art, all sorts of objective ratings, fine you could do that. But that's not it. Mal measures enjoyment. Whether it be for reasons of fanservice, so bad it's good, unique plot/characters/setting, whatever. If people enjoyed it, then they give it a good mark. If lots of people enjoyed it, then it gets an overall good mark. This is actually getting really stupid. 216 789 people rated Code Geass and it got an score of 8.99. Are you seriously arguing that all of those people gave it a high rating because they were sheep who gave in to its reputation? Saying multiple ratings as a source is an appeal to its popularity is just wrong. It's using common sense. Of course 2 people saying it's good is more valuable to me than one person saying it's good. Two people saying it's bad is more valuable to me than one person saying it's bad. If they were the only three people who had watched it, would it be an appeal to its popularity trusting the two people over the one? People are different, and if multiple people like the same thing, that seems to me like I might like it too. Basically, no, your opinion on what's good and what's bad is not worth more than Mal. It is actually worth a lot less. The reason it's worth more here on TL is because most of the active posters know each other to some degree and value each other's opinions. If my friend who likes a lot of the same things as I do told me to watch something, I'd probably watch it. | ||
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
July 14 2013 04:05 GMT
#59560
On July 14 2013 12:52 Dark_Chill wrote: Show nested quote + On July 14 2013 11:55 Sentenal wrote: So you think shows like SAO, Code Geass R2, and SnK deserve their scores? Look, even if you say that I have a "biased opinion" in thinking a show doesn't deserve its MAL score, the same exact thing can be said about each and every person who rates things on MAL. If you are saying lots of people's ratings matter more, then that is by definition an appeal to its popularity, or lack there of. Do I think shows like those deserve their scores? Nope. Do other people? Yes. What's so freaking hard to understand about this. Your opinion on a show is not the end all be all. Maybe if you were getting into an argument about quality of voice acting, quality of sound, quality of art, all sorts of objective ratings, fine you could do that. But that's not it. Mal measures enjoyment. Whether it be for reasons of fanservice, so bad it's good, unique plot/characters/setting, whatever. If people enjoyed it, then they give it a good mark. If lots of people enjoyed it, then it gets an overall good mark. This is actually getting really stupid. 216 789 people rated Code Geass and it got an score of 8.99. Are you seriously arguing that all of those people gave it a high rating because they were sheep who gave in to its reputation? Saying multiple ratings as a source is an appeal to its popularity is just wrong. It's using common sense. Of course 2 people saying it's good is more valuable to me than one person saying it's good. Two people saying it's bad is more valuable to me than one person saying it's bad. If they were the only three people who had watched it, would it be an appeal to its popularity trusting the two people over the one? People are different, and if multiple people like the same thing, that seems to me like I might like it too. Basically, no, your opinion on what's good and what's bad is not worth more than Mal. It is actually worth a lot less. The reason it's worth more here on TL is because most of the active posters know each other to some degree and value each other's opinions. If my friend who likes a lot of the same things as I do told me to watch something, I'd probably watch it. Holy shit, where did I say my opinion was the end all be all? You have a hard-on for Strawmen, don't you? My opinion is what it is. A bunch of other people's opinions are what they are. WHAT DOES ANY OF THAT HAVE TO DO WITH SOMETHING'S QUALITY???? Does me liking something make it better? Does a random guy liking something make it worse? Does a bunch of people hating something make that something worse? Does a bunch of people liking something make it better??? The answer to all of these questions are NO. In which case, when talking about how good something is (aka discussing its quality), what is the point of bringing it up??? There is no point. At all. Period. Additionally, I didn't say anything about those people being sheep, please don't put words into my mouth. You seem to like doing that. But I would say that of the 200k people who rated Code Geass R2 well are all shittaste plebs. But them being shittaste plebs has nothing to do with how good the anime actually is. What is so freaking hard to understand about this? | ||
| ||
Next event in 25m
[ Submit Event ] |
StarCraft: Brood War Stormgate Dota 2 Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Heroes of the Storm Other Games Organizations Dota 2 Other Games StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2 • practicex 86 StarCraft: Brood War• Sammyuel 17 • LUISG 8 • AfreecaTV YouTube • intothetv • Kozan • IndyKCrew • LaughNgamezSOOP • Laughngamez YouTube • Migwel • sooper7s League of Legends |
Premier Star League
CranKy Ducklings
LiuLu Cup
Clem vs MaxPax
Rogue vs TBD
SOOP Global
Spirit vs ShoWTimE
SKillous vs MaxPax
DaveTesta Events
Online Event
CSO Cup
Online Event
Premier Star League
Sparkling Tuna Cup
[ Show More ] OSC
Online Event
Tenacious Turtle Tussle
SOOP StarCraft League
Wardi Open
Kaelaris Steadfast Rott…
SOOP StarCraft League
The PondCast
The Goblin Cluckfest
|
|