EPTAnime Discussion Thread - Page 2180
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.gg For currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net | ||
|
KazeHydra
Japan2788 Posts
| ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:08 Dingotrold wrote: I was pretty much expecting what I got, it's just nowhere near the level of something like Fate/Zero or LOGH. I found it closer to Code Geass, which I guess may be what most anime is like, I am just learning about it now. Fighting nasty aliens in giant robots is cool, maybe cool enough to carry a show but still... Girl-only cast, giggling and playing around in schoolgirl outfits/skintight suits, teasing eachother... Even something like Gundam 00 (which has a quite similar premise to me, again I am an anime nub) at least takes its characters deeply serious and delves into them. Being alittle harsh here, but I guess since they don't have tits they can have personalities... EDIT: "Interesting dialogue" WTF - Let me try and explain my thoughts: Fate/Zero episode 11, interesting dialogue into amazing action. ML:TE (or Code Geass), pretty people saying nonsense, they better make up for this with the robots. Like has been said, the first 2 episodes were "prologue/introduce you to the setting" episodes. Yui isn't even the main character of Total Eclispe, if you can believe that. Episode 3 will probably start the actual story for TE, and it includes male characters/the real cast of the show. Also, I dunno why you are so obsessed on a smaller part of episode 1 when talking about the first two episodes. The first half of episode 1 started with what seems like generic highschool stuff (probably trying to simulate some of the feel you get out of ML Extra). And then it starts getting more serious, more grim as the episode progresses, until you have girls breaking down and crying at dead-loved ones, and the enemy right on the horizon. Then you get episode 2, where it pounds the reality of the world into your head as bloodily as possible. I think the first two episodes took itself really seriously. Didn't seem like light-hearted fun to me. | ||
|
EMIYA
United States433 Posts
On July 10 2012 08:48 Dullahan wrote: Kuroko alone made me love Railgun + Show Spoiler [Oneeeeeeeesamaaaaaaaa] + :D ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/4rypt.jpg) Having what was my top favorite OP theme for quite a long time probably didn't hurt either Only My Railgun:+ Show Spoiler + Index felt really disjointed and had me confused as to what was going on half the time. Not having read the LN probably didn't help. Index II was more of the same, only slightly redeemed by having a little more Kuroko action. good man + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/Ssaac.jpg) | ||
|
Maxie
Sweden2653 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:28 Sentenal wrote: Like has been said, the first 2 episodes were "prologue/introduce you to the setting" episodes. Yui isn't even the main character of Total Eclispe, if you can believe that. Episode 3 will probably start the actual story for TE, and it includes male characters/the real cast of the show. Also, I dunno why you are so obsessed on a smaller part of episode 1 when talking about the first two episodes. The first half of episode 1 started with what seems like generic highschool stuff (probably trying to simulate some of the feel you get out of ML Extra). And then it starts getting more serious, more grim as the episode progresses, until you have girls breaking down and crying at dead-loved ones, and the enemy right on the horizon. Then you get episode 2, where it pounds the reality of the world into your head as bloodily as possible. I think the first two episodes took itself really seriously. Didn't seem like light-hearted fun to me. I saw people writing "lol it's another Infinite Stratos" when they had watched the first episode. Well, they were wrong, lol. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:34 Maxie wrote: I saw people writing "lol it's another Infinite Stratos" when they had watched the first episode. Well, they were wrong, lol. If only Infinite Stratos' episode 2 was like TE's episode 2... | ||
|
Tabbris
Bangladesh2839 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:24 Dingotrold wrote: I understand what you're saying, but please, if you won't accept episode 11, just use episode 1 of Fate/Zero instead, and forget about the action part... I thought the first episode of Fate/zero was great! But then your not making a fair comparison here. Muv/luv TE was trying to get you in with the Action/horror of the setting. Fate zero spent 3! episodes just telling you about the holy grail war and the people who would fight in it. There are alot of people I know that thought the beginning of Fate/zero was boring as fuck. It basically spent 1:30 mins explaining shit with no action. If most people would base their entire opinion on the first episode of a series then Fate/zero wouldn't look awesome either. From what people are saying Muv luv TE will mostly be dialoge heavy with little beta now but idk. If you didnt like it then you didnt like it and i cant tell you different. Again Im just stating why I think your reasons are alittle weird. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
| ||
|
Maxie
Sweden2653 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:36 Sentenal wrote: If only Infinite Stratos' episode 2 was like TE's episode 2... Except you have to kill off the male mc too. He's even denser than Takeru, how that even is possible, I don't know. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:43 Maxie wrote: Except you have to kill off the male mc too. He's even denser than Takeru, how that even is possible, I don't know. Naww dude. Takeru may have been a horrible dense Harem MC at the start, but that dude is develops like crazy through the course of the trilogy. Just compare him how he is when Extra starts to how he is towards the end of Alternative. If whats-his-name in IS went through the same PTSD and shit, he might emerge as a good character. | ||
|
Tabbris
Bangladesh2839 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:42 Sentenal wrote: Well, I doubt TE will be dialogue heavy. I've been under the impress that TE is gonna be very Top Gun-like, except with alot nationalists from different countries interacting. I don't think there are any more battles with the BETA until the end. Eh that was something I read on /M I really dont know much about TE at all. Also for the record I thought 1st episode of Fate.zero was better than the 1st 2nd of TE. But again it would be unfair to compare the two right now | ||
|
Dingotrold
Denmark622 Posts
I tried not to focus too much on anything, I just used the most obvious examples to clarify my issues. | ||
|
Maxie
Sweden2653 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:45 Sentenal wrote: Naww dude. Takeru may have been a horrible dense Harem MC at the start, but that dude is develops like crazy through the course of the trilogy. Just compare him how he is when Extra starts to how he is towards the end of Alternative. If whats-his-name in IS went through the same PTSD and shit, he might emerge as a good character. True. Sorry, I just had to express my hate for the IS mc. And yeah, anyone would develop if one were to go through the same shit Takeru did. | ||
|
Tabbris
Bangladesh2839 Posts
| ||
|
Maxie
Sweden2653 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:59 Tabbris wrote: Takeru goes through one of the most intense developments Ive seen from any character. You'll definitely be hard pressed to find such a smooth and deep charater development in any anime. You could only could compare it to other novels since anime don'tt really use internal dialogue that makes watching his character development so effective. But even comparably to other novels I read Takeru really developeds Yeah, I meant the early Takeru... well, if you want a character to develop a lot, why not start at the bottom? Okay, a bit of exageration there.  Hm, I wonder what to play once I'm done with Fate/Stay Night, any other VN:s that are "similar" to MLA and F/SN? As in "shit gets serious and the story is good" (god what a bad description). | ||
|
Heh_
Singapore2712 Posts
On July 10 2012 09:25 Maxie wrote: Comparing MLA:TE ep 1+2 with Ga Rei Zero ep 1 would be more like it... lol. + Show Spoiler + Actually it was pretty obvious that they would get wiped out (I didn't expect Yui to survive, didn't read the VNs). The OP of episode 2 only showed screens from episode 1 .They were trying to prevent people from guessing what's gonna happen, but it was pretty obvious.. | ||
|
Tabbris
Bangladesh2839 Posts
On July 10 2012 10:05 Maxie wrote: Yeah, I meant the early Takeru... well, if you want a character to develop a lot, why not start at the bottom? Okay, a bit of exageration there. Hm, I wonder what to play once I'm done with Fate/Stay Night, any other VN:s that are "similar" to MLA and F/SN? As in "shit gets serious and the story is good" (god what a bad description). Was mostly talkin to myself ^^. As for VNs. I heard Ever 17 was really good but havent read it. P.S If anyone reccomends youG-senjou no Maou dont fucking believe them | ||
|
Tabbris
Bangladesh2839 Posts
| ||
|
Southlight
United States11768 Posts
| ||
|
Dullahan
United States248 Posts
*high five* <3 Teleporter On July 09 2012 08:43 Sentenal wrote: MLA: Total Eclipse: + Show Spoiler + Apparently that was Yuuhi, according to the director, and not Ikaruga. This makes me happy - was actually just wondering about that this morning when I finally made the connection in my head between + Show Spoiler + seeing the Takemikazuchi in TE and the part from MLA where Yuuhi mentioned having piloted it back during the initial fighting. Also happy I can finally discuss TE - looks like most of the stuff I wanted to say has already been mentioned, so just adding: I felt they really did a great job duplicating the emotions associated with the naval support a la the Sadogashima retreat in MLA, given how they've only had 2 episodes to work with. Too bad we didn't get to see Heavy Laser class or Fort class in combat (lol roadblock). Speaking of which, Takeru's 20+ Fort-kill streak is even more impressive now. Edit: On July 10 2012 10:05 Maxie wrote: Hm, I wonder what to play once I'm done with Fate/Stay Night, any other VN:s that are "similar" to MLA and F/SN? As in "shit gets serious and the story is good" (god what a bad description). Sharin no Kuni: Himawari no Shoujo is pretty good And there's always Steins;Gate Ever17 and Clannad make up my top favorites (together with MLA and FSN) though I wouldn't call them similar to those http://vndb.org/u27930/list | ||
|
Maxie
Sweden2653 Posts
On July 10 2012 10:15 Dullahan wrote: *high five* <3 Teleporter This makes me happy - was actually just wondering about that this morning when I finally made the connection in my head between + Show Spoiler + seeing the Takemikazuchi in TE and the part from MLA where Yuuhi mentioned having piloted it back during the initial fighting. Also happy I can finally discuss TE - looks like most of the stuff I wanted to say has already been mentioned, so just adding: I felt they really did a great job duplicating the emotions associated with the naval support a la the Sadogashima retreat in MLA, given how they've only had 2 episodes to work with. Too bad we didn't get to see Heavy Laser class or Fort class in combat (lol roadblock). Speaking of which, Takeru's 20+ Fort-kill streak is even more impressive now. Not a huge Kuroko fan but honestly, teleport is just so awesome, lol. Regarding MLA:TE:+ Show Spoiler + I wish I had a solid (as in linkeable) source on it being Yuuhi, I wrote that it was her somewhere else and I'm not a fan of not having solid, presenteable proof Q.Q. Edit: I just wonder how much having watched the anime will have ruined Clannad/Steins Gate for me... not as much as the first Fate/Stay Night route, I hope. Oh well, heaven's feel time :o | ||
| ||
