| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
This is a thread that is dedicated to discussing One Piece. Do not read this thread if you are not currently caught up as there are spoilers in here. If an episode or a chapter has already been officially released, then it is not necessary to post using spoilers. If you have knowledge on a chapter that has not been officially released yet, do NOT post it in this thread. Ignoring this public note will result in a mod action. | ||
Shellshock
United States97276 Posts
On April 02 2022 03:12 Zambrah wrote: Fighting about manga/anime on the internet? Sign me the fuck up There’s a lot of Goda is a genius vs the is the worst thing in the history of manga being thrown around | ||
|
lestye
United States4178 Posts
On March 31 2022 09:06 Slaughter wrote: You laugh but the moon people being a thing and potentially important to the history of the world has been a thing for a long time in OP. I'm still eaglerly looking forward to the day where Toei has to explain to animation only people about the moon people. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On April 01 2022 10:28 Hyperbola wrote: New chapter is out. I actually like this new powerup, although it does make Kaido look like the underdog in this fight. I only wish that Oda didn't bother with the whole chosen one nonsense and just left it at awakening. But nothing's perfect I guess. I feel like a bit of pre-timeskip One Piece has come back with the goofiness! Hopefully it continues. Yea, I like how its been used thus far. Its entertaining. One Piece is at its best when its being goofy, and this is like the perfect ability for it | ||
|
Shinokuki
United States923 Posts
On April 02 2022 05:07 Sentenal wrote: Yea, I like how its been used thus far. Its entertaining. One Piece is at its best when its being goofy, and this is like the perfect ability for it are we reading the same manga here? One piece at peak (which was in romance dawn ~ marineford) was serious when it mattered and goofy when it didn't. Goffy as in strawhats shooting the shit together and partying. Luffy acting all dumb before going into arc. When shit was on line and it needed to be done i liked how the crew was serious. Post Time skip i feel like oda really wanted luffy to be like joy boy embodiment and ruined the fun of it all. (hence why one piece is declining in sales) | ||
Olli
Austria24420 Posts
The magic of One Piece was always that it managed to tread the line between being goofy and serious, because Oda picked his moments excellently. Now he's trying to conflate them and it doesn't work for me at all. Personally, I really hope this is just the fruit's personality acting out (they do supposedly have personality after all) and Luffy still has to figure out how to keep it in check. But even then, we're going to get a ton of stupid shit at the climax of every important fight because that's just the ability now. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
On April 02 2022 04:25 Shellshock wrote: There’s a lot of Goda is a genius vs the is the worst thing in the history of manga being thrown around If its in the normal one piece subreddit Ill be honest, Im disappointed, but I guess reddit rarely lends itself to the long ass posts I tend to prefer lol I think both of those reactions are nonsensical overreactions, though. Its bad, but its bad by One Piece's higher standards (imo) this is 100% the norm for basically any shonen series lol The magic of One Piece was always that it managed to tread the line between being goofy and serious, because Oda picked his moments excellently. Now he's trying to conflate them and it doesn't work for me at all. Also this is dead on. Its about knowing when to pick your moments. | ||
|
Slaughter
United States20254 Posts
On April 02 2022 13:46 Shinokuki wrote: are we reading the same manga here? One piece at peak (which was in romance dawn ~ marineford) was serious when it mattered and goofy when it didn't. Goffy as in strawhats shooting the shit together and partying. Luffy acting all dumb before going into arc. When shit was on line and it needed to be done i liked how the crew was serious. Post Time skip i feel like oda really wanted luffy to be like joy boy embodiment and ruined the fun of it all. (hence why one piece is declining in sales) You mean the same marineford that saw luffy crashing down from the sky in a super absurd entrance? What does that mean luffy being a joy biy embodiment? We know nothing about Joy Boy. Luffy has almost *always* been some embodiment of some nebulous concept (Will of D has been a thing for a long ass time). Just because now we are getting perhaps the origin story of the Will of D suddenly its an asspull that Oda is forcing? Like wat. | ||
|
Byo
Canada208 Posts
I hate this chapter, literal 1 panel I'm too tired let's power down into SIKE!!!! Into full chapter of everyone takes massive damage but gets recovery = damage taken. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
On April 02 2022 21:19 Slaughter wrote: You mean the same marineford that saw luffy crashing down from the sky in a super absurd entrance? What does that mean luffy being a joy biy embodiment? We know nothing about Joy Boy. Luffy has almost *always* been some embodiment of some nebulous concept (Will of D has been a thing for a long ass time). Just because now we are getting perhaps the origin story of the Will of D suddenly its an asspull that Oda is forcing? Like wat. Its one thing to be Joy Boy because of your magnetic personality drawing tons of allies by virtue of your words and deeds and being Joy Boy by virtue of eating The Joy Boy Fruit of Destiny though, Luffy had enough special background as is without being truly full Naruto of S tier family lineage plus an S tier additional superpower of destiny, its just too much. | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On April 02 2022 13:46 Shinokuki wrote: are we reading the same manga here? One piece at peak (which was in romance dawn ~ marineford) was serious when it mattered and goofy when it didn't. Goffy as in strawhats shooting the shit together and partying. Luffy acting all dumb before going into arc. When shit was on line and it needed to be done i liked how the crew was serious. Post Time skip i feel like oda really wanted luffy to be like joy boy embodiment and ruined the fun of it all. (hence why one piece is declining in sales) Thats what I'd like to ask you. One Piece as been full of goofy and silly stuff since the very first chapter. The vast majority of the major battles in the manga contain goofiness and silliness. Are you suggesting that pre-time skip, when "shit was on the line", it was always completely serious? I guess Luffy using Gear 3rd vs Lucci and turning into a little chibi guy was serious. Or when hes fighting Enel, his immunity to electricity prompting one of the most ridiculous faces the series had seen at that point ouf of Enel? Or Luffy fighting Crocodile, swallowing a bunch of water to become "Mizu-Luffy", and then started leaking was serious. I guess Luffy fighting Arlong, and using Arlong's own teeth to bite him was serious. And I could go on. And this isn't even bringing up examples involving people like Usopp and Nami, who also have fights fully of silly shit. One Piece has always had its humor, even in the "serious" parts. And lets not ignore what we are actually talking about here. People are mad at the goofiness of this fight, and cite stuff like the emotional parts of Enies Lobby or Marineford, and act like things are different now. And thats complete horseshit. This arc has had tons of serious moments. But this past chapter where everyone is complaining about it being silly? This chapter was 100% a fight chapter, and all fights in One Piece involving Luffy have him doing silly, wild shit. And thats what this chapter was. | ||
|
Hyperbola
United States2540 Posts
On April 03 2022 01:54 Zambrah wrote: Its one thing to be Joy Boy because of your magnetic personality drawing tons of allies by virtue of your words and deeds and being Joy Boy by virtue of eating The Joy Boy Fruit of Destiny though, Luffy had enough special background as is without being truly full Naruto of S tier family lineage plus an S tier additional superpower of destiny, its just too much. Stupid Kaido, tryna be JoyBoy through his actions. Shoulda just eaten the chosen one fruit. What an idiot. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
I like the use of making Kaido rubber, that feels like natural comedic comedy, making his body rubber and grabbing his rubber eyeballs to escape his stomach and inflating himself to fuck with Kaido after he got eaten, I like those. I still really dont like the Toon World shit. Imagination Crazy Fighting feels so much more Bleach or another abstract-fighting-power sort of manga. One Piece is at its best when it's using more concrete powers in creative and interesting ways, at least when it comes to characters we see a lot of. Like, if youre going to do funny-combat, this chapter shows how to do it, and its not by making use of the stupid fuckin Nika Nika magic, its by making use of the Gum Gum's qualities, the properties of rubber. Dunno, I really dont like the idea that now we're going to get Luffy imaginating his hard fights away as opposed to creatively abusing the properties of rubber, or bounciness, or flexibility, or some property of the power hes had and we've been seeing him explore for two decades. | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + You've been warned, + Show Spoiler + Kaido has a Final Form, + Show Spoiler + Apparently its an actual fucking fish, I dont know if anyone remembers when we first got his fruit name, but wasnt it classified as a Fish Fish fruit? Man Im looking forward to seeing what this looks like lmao. | ||
|
Shellshock
United States97276 Posts
On April 06 2022 04:42 Zambrah wrote: WARNING: Spoilers for next chapter are out, + Show Spoiler + You've been warned, + Show Spoiler + Kaido has a Final Form, + Show Spoiler + Apparently its an actual fucking fish, I dont know if anyone remembers when we first got his fruit name, but wasnt it classified as a Fish Fish fruit? Man Im looking forward to seeing what this looks like lmao. + Show Spoiler + Yeah he should be a carp. Based on the same legend that inspires magikarp and gyarados. Although the more popular theory was that the carp was normal form and dragon is awakened form | ||
|
mounteast0
59 Posts
On April 06 2022 08:15 Shellshock wrote: + Show Spoiler + Yeah he should be a carp. Based on the same legend that inspires magikarp and gyarados. Although the more popular theory was that the carp was normal form and dragon is awakened form + Show Spoiler + Does that mean he can swim? | ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + Asking the real questions | ||
|
evilfatsh1t
Australia8711 Posts
because 1046 is out now and i dunno wtf u guys are talking about lol | ||
|
Hyperbola
United States2540 Posts
| ||
|
Zambrah
United States7366 Posts
On April 08 2022 16:52 evilfatsh1t wrote: are the spoilers above referring to chapter 1046? or 1047? because 1046 is out now and i dunno wtf u guys are talking about lol Yeah, I thought Twitter was trustworthy since the last time I saw their spoilers they were spot on, maybe its for 1047? Or maybe Twitter is just not as reliable as I had though lol | ||
|
Shellshock
United States97276 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
Map Test Tournament
PiGosaur Monday
Map Test Tournament
Tenacious Turtle Tussle
The PondCast
Map Test Tournament
Map Test Tournament
OSC
Korean StarCraft League
CranKy Ducklings
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
