...IDRA VS SDM SHOWMATCH :X
that or a log roll.
(Just wanted to push the drama to 50 pages too)
Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
jeddus
United States832 Posts
...IDRA VS SDM SHOWMATCH :X that or a log roll. (Just wanted to push the drama to 50 pages too) | ||
iNcontroL
![]()
USA29055 Posts
Cannot believe people are blathering about what IdrA said.. was literally NOTHING. | ||
lovelyrose
Canada160 Posts
| ||
JIJIyO
![]()
Canada1957 Posts
| ||
blabber
United States4448 Posts
On June 09 2009 15:09 JIJIyO wrote: So I haven't gone through all pages on this thread, but can non premium users watch the vods on gomtv? Not live, I mean the one's that are uploaded. I try, but it tells me to get premium =( I'm guessing it's following the 3-day wait period like all the other vods on there | ||
Kreedit
Sweden373 Posts
On June 09 2009 14:02 {88}iNcontroL wrote: This is the stupidest debate I have seen on tl.net in a LONG time. IdrA is a jack ass but he didn't deserve this stupid and unprofessional rant by a man who has been an ass to the foreigner community numerous times.. sorry but it is true (whether you know it or not). Cannot believe people are blathering about what IdrA said.. was literally NOTHING. Could you plz elaborate on that, im kinda new to the starcraft community. | ||
nebffa
Australia776 Posts
I wish Idra would be more respectful in general. | ||
![]()
GTR
51415 Posts
On June 09 2009 01:42 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote: wait hold up idra met sean oh at wwi not blizzcon also hes not really a coach hes more like a team manager/agent sorta thing Sean Oh is actually CJ's official PR guy. Such a big plus that he is multilingual in both Korean and English. | ||
Sadistx
Zimbabwe5568 Posts
On June 09 2009 14:02 {88}iNcontroL wrote: This is the stupidest debate I have seen on tl.net in a LONG time. IdrA is a jack ass but he didn't deserve this stupid and unprofessional rant by a man who has been an ass to the foreigner community numerous times.. sorry but it is true (whether you know it or not). Cannot believe people are blathering about what IdrA said.. was literally NOTHING. This. | ||
Kinavca
29 Posts
I can't hide my bias, I'd worship at the feet of Super Daniel Man, but he was definitely too harsh in cutting Idra down I'll admit in retrospect I still say it was an obviously rude comment in a long history of rude comments by Idra though | ||
BaltA
Norway849 Posts
| ||
IreScath
Canada521 Posts
The bottom line is that it doesn't matter that Idra did, he could have cussed and ranted all he wanted...SDM is a commentator, and should have done his job professionally. Imagine a NFL/NHL/NBA, or whatever commentator doing what SDM did, and refusing to cast because Kobe gave the camera the finger or something...lol... See my point? | ||
herda
Germany17 Posts
| ||
bias-
United States410 Posts
On June 08 2009 22:53 FakeSteve[TPR] wrote:+ Show Spoiler + On June 07 2009 08:02 Idle wrote: Show nested quote + On June 07 2009 07:48 arb wrote: On June 07 2009 06:59 Sadistx wrote: Gotta love how the last 25 pages are discussing a bunch of lines in a game chat, and I thought the worst drama queens were on the EVE-online forums. Apparently not. Gotta love SDM's hypocrisy though - he blames Idra for chatting in game and then starts acting like a total whiny 10 year old kid - "waaaah waaah Idra should worship me forever, waaah waaah he typed some stuff and this made me mad, so I'm not going to cast the gameeee". Maybe he should have professionally confronted him after the game or just imposed rules for the next ro ? Yeah it seriously ruined the entire cast, tasteless was trying but daniel just killed the entire thing Imagine how SDM must feel though. He brought Idra over, handed him a progamer license without winning courage (something completely unheard of) and after bending over backwards like this Idra is over the top disrespectful to his opponents and bm. Its incredibly embarrassing for SDM, especially in a culture where respect is so important. He stuck his neck out for Idra and this is how he acts? Its not even trash talking or silly like FBH, its downright malicious and self-absorbed, which is pretty unacceptable for somebody who genuinely is the worst progamer in Korea. lol i'm gonna respond to this one post because i picked it out of a crowd. sorry Idle you are the whipping boy today First let me say that my opinion of Daniel Lee has not changed. There was a positive in Daniel Lee having the balls to freak out mid-broadcast just because he was pissed off that equaled out the negative of Daniel Lee acting like a stupid fucking child and saying a bunch of unsubstantiated bullshit about Idra. Allow me to explain why this is unsubstantiated bullshit. Once upon there was a starcraft tournament for North American players. A wondrous prize was announced, a tip to Korea to live with the eSTRO team and become a real progamer! A young man named Idra entered, and he just so happened to win. Fancy that! Out of a field of competitors with equal chances to win this prize based entirely around their gameplay in that particular tournament, Idra was chosen. Daniel Lee chose Idra from 16 players. But all was not as it seemed in the StarCraft motherland. You know what Idra did when he got to Korea? He played on iccup. That's all. Once the novelty of a white guy in the room wore off, all of the eSTRO B team players refused to play with Idra. This is well documented on TL, go look around. Do a little fucking research, know what you're talking about before you open your goddamned mouth. If Daniel Lee is Idra's savior, the man who saved Idra from the horrible clutches of nonkorean newbiness, what should Daniel Lee have done about the situation Idra found himself in, playing idiots on iccup, lacking any alternative because his new teammates wouldn't play him? Daniel Lee should have done something about that, if Daniel Lee is Idra's savior and not the engineer of a PR stunt. Daniel Lee didn't do a goddamned thing. You want to know who Idra's savior was? Sean motherfucking Oh. Yeah, the CJ coach. After Idra was given a license, something that happens all the fuckin' time, as each team can give a license to two players per year if they want those players on the team and they haven't won courage, a trade happens. Idra certainly did not beg for his progaming license, whether he was handed the license for gameplay or to further the PR stunt & solidify the perception of Daniel Lee as the shining force bridging the gap between Korea and the rest of the world is irrelevant. For how big an expert on Idra and his mannerisms you all seem to think you are, you don't know what the fuck you're talking about. Sean Oh and Idra met at Blizzcon, and shortly after, Idra joined the CJ B team. Now, eSTRO has a pretty bad B team. Their A team ain't too hot, for that matter. They're a bottom-of-the-barrel team. CJ, however, has far and away the strongest B team of ANY progaming team. That's where Idra found himself. From there, he improved his gameplay legitimately by playing against good players for ten hours a day. Daniel Lee's involvement with Idra began with hosting a tournament that Idra won, and ended with Idra being shipped to CJ after playing nothing but iccup as a member of a progaming team house for several months. And Daniel Lee handed everything to Idra on a silver platter? Daniel fucking Lee MADE Idra? What a joke. Now, as for Idra and BM: Idra is an angry fucking nerd. He really is. He hates losing, he hates the Protoss, he hates bad players, he hates just about everything except winning in TvZ. He says a lot of dumb shit for no reason, and all of his friends give him more hell about it than any of you with your passive-aggressive, pathetic comments about how Idra should leave Korea and kill himself or whatever. Idra does not represent foreigners. Idra speaks bluntly with latent rage about StarCraft and plays 10 hours a day. Incidents have happened before and will undoubtedly happen again. This does not matter, because Idra doesn't owe and of you a goddamned thing. Do you really think Idra would go on Korean tv and badmouth some progamer? Of course not, because those games matter relevant to his position & his career. Don't be so naive to think that the CJ team, other progamers who have a vague idea who he is, and his coaches don't know about his mannerisms. Don't be so naive to think that they really give two shits about it. Stork used to talk shit to anyone and everyone when he was a B teamer, no one cares. iloveoov used to be the rudest dude alive, no one cares. Why the hell do you all care? What's wrong with you? Be fans of the game, not some retarded idealogy of "what a progamer should be". What Idra said to Tarson was not bad manner. Oh golly gee, jiminy cripes, oh whillikers, shock and horror! He said the F word!!!! He dared to suggest that foreign terrans don't have a rhyme & reason in their cheeses that is comparable to korean pros!!!! He dared to suggest that foreign terrans generally cheese with the intent of carrying out a specific attack regardless of what the opponent does!!!! He DARED to suggest that foreign players are not nearly as good at cheesing in TvT as korean pros and therefore do it all fuckin wierd with strange results!!!! HOW DARE YOU IDRA? Come on. What Idra said is generally true & was not intended to be rude or demeaning at all. Tarson certainly didn't seem to take offense. There is a clear difference between Korean professional TvT cheese and nonkorean TvT cheese. Pro TvT cheese is fucking surgical, foreign TvT cheese is totally haphazard. It's completely fair for Idra to say that he doesn't FE against foreigners in TvT because he has no idea how to play against them. He is saying that he cannot fast expand because of all the wierd and unpredictable shit foreign Terrans do in the matchup, and there is a higher probability that he will die if he chooses to FE rather than open safer and let his mechanics carry him. This is a reasonable statement and is what you would see if you read between the lines from the perspective of someone who isn't a 14 year old mouth-breathing caveman. This is not an absolute statement, it doesn't apply to every player all the time, but it's reasonable. Tarson asked, and again, he didn't seem to take offense. Why are you all so worked up over something so innocuous? Daniel Lee's outburst was childish and completely unprofessional. Saying 'fuck' during a game you aren't aware will be streamed (previous round was not, announcement didn't come until after the games were played. Read the posts in this thread, read the posts, read them, fuck.) is not the same as losing your shit during a live stream you're supposed to be commentating and then pouting for an extended duration of time, leaving your co-caster to pick up the slack. Mad fucking props to Tasteless for being the real deal and carrying that trainwreck successfully to station. By the way, if you quote this post and intend to respond, please place the word "Muffin-top" in your post somewhere so I can tell you actually read what I wrote and therefore enjoy wasting as much time as I evidently do. And like I said, at the beginning of this gigantic worthless post (which mostly serves as something to fill my idle time, also I like yelling at people look at me look at me), Daniel Lee sure got a pair on him. if anyone said all this more eloquently and delicately than I did between the page I saw the quoted post on and this page: how dare you?! The general consensus seems to side with you, FS (Muffin-top although there are an infinitely large amount of worse 'wastes' of time). Who else is curious to know if SDM knew the games were played prior to the players knowing they were going to be casted? Due credit to Tasteless for being the anchor of the commentating ship - I've appreciated the many other times Tasteless has kept the commentating on track and on the game. I have to ask though, did no one else see the crash coming between Idra's disregard for polite discourse and Korean verbal discourse? I mean... for those you who have not interacted with a decent number of Korean people/Korean families (like I have most of my life), the way strangers interact as well as how new friends or relatives are introduced is more... formal ('rigid' seemed too judgmental). While I think Idra was not BM, he should have probably taken out the unnecessary swear though, you're not 16 and you are in fact payed to play. A progamer types ssibal or 18 or (as we've seen) ANYthing, auto-loss. Welcome to Korea, where the formal rules and a respectful face for other people to see are more than important. | ||
T0fuuu
Australia2275 Posts
On June 09 2009 20:29 B00ts wrote: SDM, in my opinion, is the reason eSports aren't taken seriously outside of Korea... What he did was not professional. The bottom line is that it doesn't matter that Idra did, he could have cussed and ranted all he wanted...SDM is a commentator, and should have done his job professionally. SDM is more than a commentator i think him and and tasteless actually admin and organise the games. Its obvious that they at least had a hand in organising the showmatch with tossgirl. GOM isnt as directly involved in producing or refereeing the games as their Intel classic games. They have a diff observer, and the video production is much more crude. The reason esports isnt taken seriously outside of Korea is purely the attitude of players. Its the reason KESPA in all their infinite evil is trying to introduce formality into the scene. GG, bow, not BG (puts on best christian bale impersonation) , shitfucknoob hacker, *throws mouse at wall* . Rage and elitism get pretty bad at competitive levels of any competition game. Trash talk and banter can only serve to feed negative attitudes and reactions of the players. | ||
InDaHouse
Sweden956 Posts
I don't want to read through 50 pages. | ||
fearus
China2164 Posts
On June 09 2009 20:29 B00ts wrote: SDM, in my opinion, is the reason eSports aren't taken seriously outside of Korea... What he did was not professional. The bottom line is that it doesn't matter that Idra did, he could have cussed and ranted all he wanted...SDM is a commentator, and should have done his job professionally. Imagine a NFL/NHL/NBA, or whatever commentator doing what SDM did, and refusing to cast because Kobe gave the camera the finger or something...lol... See my point? If kobe said fuck on camera during a live cast, he'll probably get slapped with a 1 game ban or a pretty hefty fine at the very least | ||
theobsessed1
United States576 Posts
On June 09 2009 22:29 fearus wrote: Show nested quote + On June 09 2009 20:29 B00ts wrote: SDM, in my opinion, is the reason eSports aren't taken seriously outside of Korea... What he did was not professional. The bottom line is that it doesn't matter that Idra did, he could have cussed and ranted all he wanted...SDM is a commentator, and should have done his job professionally. Imagine a NFL/NHL/NBA, or whatever commentator doing what SDM did, and refusing to cast because Kobe gave the camera the finger or something...lol... See my point? If kobe said fuck on camera during a live cast, he'll probably get slapped with a 1 game ban or a pretty hefty fine at the very least There have been several incidents where cuss words were aired on live NBA TV and there were no consequences. A one game ban is an exaggerated punishment for simply cursing, while offensiev manners would be different. IdrA was only BM, he was not offensive in anyway. Plus, a commentator unprofesionally cussing out the player along with made up accusations doesn't really prove anything right either. | ||
Phrogs!
Japan521 Posts
On June 09 2009 22:16 InDaHouse wrote: Sorry missed this drama. Can someone plz give a summary what has happend between IdrA and Daniel Lee right? I don't want to read through 50 pages. sup Idra swears in ingame chat. Daniel Lee rages hard and calls idra worst progamer in Korea etc and refuses to cast game, several Daniel Lee quotes on page seven. It's really not as big a deal as the number of pages in this thread would suggest don't worry ;; | ||
jaesung
124 Posts
June 09 2009 13:43 GMT
#1000
it really depends how you see it.(i believe you can see some of the text in around page 7) SDM may have over-reacted but idra could have said things nicely. as for fakesteve, you documenting shits from hearing others doesnt make everything true. you type like you know everything from what? just because someone told you? do you actually stalk them? ur long ass story is more biased towards idra. its funny how u can say SDM acted unprofessional yet it was ok for idra to say dumb stuff in public stream? just because his opponent wasn't offended? just because its just the way he is(BM)? even if he hasnt heard about 'stream' there is no need of him acting like this when tasteless&sdm was nice enough to host/stream for us. don't get me wrong.. im not on side with any of them. it was very fun reading your post. | ||
| ||
![]() StarCraft: Brood War Sea Dota 2![]() Pusan ![]() Nal_rA ![]() EffOrt ![]() NaDa ![]() JulyZerg ![]() GoRush ![]() Leta ![]() ToSsGirL ![]() sSak ![]() [ Show more ] League of Legends Counter-Strike Other Games Organizations Dota 2 Other Games StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War
StarCraft 2 • LUISG StarCraft: Brood War![]() • AfreecaTV YouTube • intothetv ![]() • Kozan • IndyKCrew ![]() • LaughNgamezSOOP • Migwel ![]() • sooper7s League of Legends |
The PondCast
Bellum Gens Elite
WardiTV Invitational
Replay Cast
OSC
Bellum Gens Elite
WardiTV Invitational
BSL 2v2 ProLeague
Replay Cast
CranKy Ducklings
[ Show More ] SC Evo League
Bellum Gens Elite
Fire Grow Cup
CSO Contender
BSL: ProLeague
StRyKeR vs MadiNho
Cross vs UltrA
TT1 vs JDConan
Bonyth vs Sziky
Replay Cast
SOOP Global
Creator vs Rogue
Cure vs Classic
SOOP
SHIN vs GuMiho
Sparkling Tuna Cup
AllThingsProtoss
Fire Grow Cup
BSL: ProLeague
HBO vs Doodle
spx vs Tech
DragOn vs Hawk
Dewalt vs TerrOr
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
WardiTV Invitational
GSL Code S
Rogue vs GuMiho
Maru vs Solar
Replay Cast
|
|