DRTL 5 Official League Thread - Page 19
Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
Orite
Germany140 Posts
| ||
Birdie
New Zealand4438 Posts
On September 03 2013 17:20 Kopp wrote: Birdie, thats really unfair from your side. The cl is in 2-2 if you dont count the 3rd set, which wasnt played, and actually you guys asked for postpone for that, and now taking a walkover? This is a little unortodox in my opinion. Should just play that 3rd set and let the players decide who wins the CW, besides thats why we here for, to play, not to get w.o.-s all day. Frankly, you can do what you want, it really depends on what you prefer, fair play or win by using rules. Cheers. There was already one walkover taken by Pebble444, does that not also fall under the same unfairness? If so then there's one set of unfairness on each side, which is balanced. | ||
Orite
Germany140 Posts
| ||
Kopp
Hungary22 Posts
| ||
INFAMOUS_MVP
81 Posts
![]() what do we have here fellas, a smurfer must i say? mhm what do you have to say for yourself in defense to my claims sync? p.s. i took the liberties of uploading this shit p.s.s i feel confident this may be a smurfer p.s.s.s im furious right now, moooO!! http://img4.hostingpics.net/pics/165329redaxisB.png User was banned for this post. | ||
CityShuffle
France57 Posts
[B]On September 03 2013 19:07 INFAMOUS_MVP wrote: http://img4.hostingpics.net/pics/165329redaxisB.png I knew it. Now i'm less ashamed of my 2-3 loss on that showmatch. So now that the ugly truth is out, tell me, who i was playing against ? Bizzy ? | ||
INFAMOUS_MVP
81 Posts
![]() | ||
Orite
Germany140 Posts
never mind | ||
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
On September 03 2013 19:07 INFAMOUS_MVP wrote: ![]() what do we have here fellas, a smurfer must i say? mhm what do you have to say for yourself in defense to my claims sync? p.s. i took the liberties of uploading this shit p.s.s i feel confident this may be a smurfer p.s.s.s im furious right now, moooO!! http://img4.hostingpics.net/pics/165329redaxisB.png I wish I could truly reach B+... :[ Edit: I wish I could sleep in and tell you guys that it's pretty BM to take a walkover for me sleeping in T_T | ||
Orite
Germany140 Posts
| ||
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
On September 03 2013 20:55 orite wrote: ok, maybe not bm, but I can see a lack of balls in that move, since they pp'ed in first place and it's the deciding match. You realize that any of the matches can be considered the decider match? It just so happens that you and Noddy was the last game that was played (or not played). What if in the situation that everyone but Pebble and Vaskan had played their games, and Pebble took the walkover? Same scenario, but I'm willing to bet that you wouldn't be bothered as much, simply because you had the win. If anything, Stealth Bunnies should be applauded in this scenario has icedraco and Noddy both could have taken a walkover in response to Pebble taking a walkover, but instead, only Noddy took the walkover and icedraco played his game. What if the reason for Vaskan not showing up was serious, such as a family member that passed away or an accident happened? Your reasoning that since you needed to sleep in and that they shouldn't have taken the walkover is flawed and hypocritical. The way the games work out in this league ensure that every game is important, not just the last games played. As I should point out, last DRTL, a team didn't make the playoffs simply based off of one map difference. A word of advice, simply to avoid that type of situation, every player on each team should be playing out their games as if was indeed the decider match. | ||
Orite
Germany140 Posts
| ||
![]()
BigFan
TLADT24920 Posts
On September 03 2013 21:35 SynC[gm] wrote: You realize that any of the matches can be considered the decider match? It just so happens that you and Noddy was the last game that was played (or not played). What if in the situation that everyone but Pebble and Vaskan had played their games, and Pebble took the walkover? Same scenario, but I'm willing to bet that you wouldn't be bothered as much, simply because you had the win. If anything, Stealth Bunnies should be applauded in this scenario has icedraco and Noddy both could have taken a walkover in response to Pebble taking a walkover, but instead, only Noddy took the walkover and icedraco played his game. What if the reason for Vaskan not showing up was serious, such as a family member that passed away or an accident happened? Your reasoning that since you needed to sleep in and that they shouldn't have taken the walkover is flawed and hypocritical. The way the games work out in this league ensure that every game is important, not just the last games played. As I should point out, last DRTL, a team didn't make the playoffs simply based off of one map difference. A word of advice, simply to avoid that type of situation, every player on each team should be playing out their games as if was indeed the decider match. On September 03 2013 22:38 orite wrote: I dont know what you're up to with all these hypothetic scenarios. Fact is, Noddy cant play at playdate, I agreed to pp, didn't appear to it and they took w.o. If they wanna take the win like that, then whatever. Sync[gm]'s example makes perfect sense tbh. He was saying that if the situation was reversed, you wouldn't have raised an argument about it since it would be beneficial for your team. Pebble444 took a WO so we merely equalized that ![]() On September 03 2013 17:16 Birdie wrote: How is it BM? We asked for a postponement before the match, you agreed, you didn't show to the first arranged time. We arranged a second time and you didn't show again. Even your captain says it's fair. | ||
DarkNetHunter
1224 Posts
Orite if what Birdie says is correct then you should just accept that you didn't make your commitment. If you're late or don't show up then deal with the consequences, just like everything else in life. | ||
Orite
Germany140 Posts
| ||
Gao Xi
Hong Kong5178 Posts
+ Show Spoiler + | ||
LetMeTouchIT
Canada9 Posts
| ||
CrystalDrag
173 Posts
And who would have taken that screenshot? | ||
Birdie
New Zealand4438 Posts
![]() If he is then I beat a B+ terran with my D- ZvT ^_^ | ||
tonight
United States11130 Posts
| ||
| ||