EPT[Round 2] SBWI Nation Wars - Page 5
| Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
|
trutaCz
Poland686 Posts
| ||
|
skzlime
Hungary462 Posts
| ||
|
Game
3191 Posts
On February 17 2013 06:23 skzlime wrote: i am gravely disappointed by Game's way of handling a negligible dispute today. i ask the other organiser(s) of this league to overturn his decision regarding set 2 of this week's NW and keep his authority in check. i find the decision unacceptable and, quite frankly, petty. You're confusing a player made decision with one I'd make as an organizer. | ||
|
skzlime
Hungary462 Posts
i most certainly am not. in my eyes you got a shot at a cheap win that decided the series, and you took it instantly. i understand both the rules and your actions. i am simply strongly disagreeing with the outcome. i feel cheated, and i am sure i'm not the only one. i bet there are even some NA players who wouldn't want to advance this way. i would also like to officially apologise for v0rti not saying gg and getting angry after losing game 2. seriously, this incident reminds me of pros getting DQ'd for typing pp instead of ppp. | ||
|
FyRe_DragOn
Canada2056 Posts
I dont support getting wins on technicalities, but in this case I wouldve done the same thing as game. Its vortis mistake of not saving reps, and then relying on some1 he shat on to save him. edit: im not saying refusing to provide reps is all good, im saying vorti cant expect any favors after how he acted, and even though the score being reversed is much harsher that what he did, he brought it on himself. | ||
|
hacklebeast
United States5090 Posts
| ||
|
mca64[KDV]
Poland463 Posts
On February 17 2013 09:13 FyRe_DragOn wrote: So as far as i understand, vorti didnt save all the replays and only sent 2 in, and because he didnt have them all, game as an organizer reversed the score. However, game as a player refused to provide the missing replay to vorti because vorti was apparently a dick in the game by bitching about cheese and not saying gg. Game as an organizer made the only logical decision, to abide by the rules, while game as a player fucked over vorti. I am not a fan of advancing this way, but neither am I a fan of immature players that rage for no reason. I think vorti got what he deserved, and vorti fucked over CE himself by being a dick and then expecting game to cover for his mistake of not saving replays. I dont support getting wins on technicalities, but in this case I wouldve done the same thing as game. Its vortis mistake of not saving reps, and then relying on some1 he shat on to save him. edit: im not saying refusing to provide reps is all good, im saying vorti cant expect any favors after how he acted, and even though the score being reversed is much harsher that what he did, he brought it on himself. wtf is this? Logicial decision is ban Game for his attitude | ||
|
soujiro_
Uruguay5195 Posts
| ||
|
dRaW
Canada5744 Posts
On February 17 2013 07:37 skzlime wrote: + Show Spoiler + i most certainly am not. in my eyes you got a shot at a cheap win that decided the series, and you took it instantly. i understand both the rules and your actions. i am simply strongly disagreeing with the outcome. i feel cheated, and i am sure i'm not the only one. i bet there are even some NA players who wouldn't want to advance this way. i would also like to officially apologise for v0rti not saying gg and getting angry after losing game 2. seriously, this incident reminds me of pros getting DQ'd for typing pp instead of ppp. all reps are saved, I just remembered if you goto wDetector folder in replays (if you are using wLauncher that is) else... chaos launcher doesnt have the feature unless enabled | ||
HawaiianPig
Canada5155 Posts
On February 17 2013 09:13 FyRe_DragOn wrote: So as far as i understand, vorti didnt save all the replays and only sent 2 in, and because he didnt have them all, game as an organizer reversed the score. However, game as a player refused to provide the missing replay to vorti because vorti was apparently a dick in the game by bitching about cheese and not saying gg. Game as an organizer made the only logical decision, to abide by the rules, while game as a player fucked over vorti. I am not a fan of advancing this way, but neither am I a fan of immature players that rage for no reason. I think vorti got what he deserved, and vorti fucked over CE himself by being a dick and then expecting game to cover for his mistake of not saving replays. Is this real life? hahaha | ||
|
ninazerg
United States7291 Posts
Yeah, that just happened. | ||
|
LuMiX
China5757 Posts
| ||
|
Sinedd
Poland7052 Posts
wut wut ? hahaha.. this is just some major bullshit lol well played from both sides ! GJ... | ||
SirJolt
the Dagon Knight4003 Posts
On February 17 2013 09:13 FyRe_DragOn wrote: So as far as i understand, vorti didnt save all the replays and only sent 2 in, and because he didnt have them all, game as an organizer reversed the score. However, game as a player refused to provide the missing replay to vorti because vorti was apparently a dick in the game by bitching about cheese and not saying gg. Game as an organizer made the only logical decision, to abide by the rules, while game as a player fucked over vorti. I am not a fan of advancing this way, but neither am I a fan of immature players that rage for no reason. I think vorti got what he deserved, and vorti fucked over CE himself by being a dick and then expecting game to cover for his mistake of not saving replays. I dont support getting wins on technicalities, but in this case I wouldve done the same thing as game. Its vortis mistake of not saving reps, and then relying on some1 he shat on to save him. edit: im not saying refusing to provide reps is all good, im saying vorti cant expect any favors after how he acted, and even though the score being reversed is much harsher that what he did, he brought it on himself. This is genuinely amazing. I had to read it twice to make sure that I hadn't misunderstood. | ||
|
mca64[KDV]
Poland463 Posts
| ||
|
chrisolo
Germany2606 Posts
On February 17 2013 09:13 FyRe_DragOn wrote: So as far as i understand, vorti didnt save all the replays and only sent 2 in, and because he didnt have them all, game as an organizer reversed the score. However, game as a player refused to provide the missing replay to vorti because vorti was apparently a dick in the game by bitching about cheese and not saying gg. Game as an organizer made the only logical decision, to abide by the rules, while game as a player fucked over vorti. I am not a fan of advancing this way, but neither am I a fan of immature players that rage for no reason. I think vorti got what he deserved, and vorti fucked over CE himself by being a dick and then expecting game to cover for his mistake of not saving replays. I dont support getting wins on technicalities, but in this case I wouldve done the same thing as game. Its vortis mistake of not saving reps, and then relying on some1 he shat on to save him. edit: im not saying refusing to provide reps is all good, im saying vorti cant expect any favors after how he acted, and even though the score being reversed is much harsher that what he did, he brought it on himself. But as an organizer it is tbh quite obvious that you save the replays and have them by yourself. You can expect by natural logic that if you play against an organizer, he will definitly already save that replays to have them. "Dividing" yourself as a player, while being a organizer, seems douchy and it does not only seem so, it is. No matter how much BM vorti was, if you are an Organizer of this league you should be a good model for Good manners and stuff. Also this Stuff is much more BM then anything else. Not granting the win, is whiny attitude. It kind of creates a shady situation if you act like this and discredits your whole league. I mean this would be acceptable if Game was not an Organizer, but as he is, I think he should be forced to use his own Autoreplay folder (btw how in hell you do not play with Autoreplay on t.t). So Game if you have those replays, share them and shine as a good person and try not to discredit this Nation Wars, which is not even financially supported by you, but by SBWI. This game was played (since you did not claim it wasnt), so be a man and account for that win and thus share those replays... | ||
|
LRM)TechnicS
Bulgaria1565 Posts
I feel sorry to see skzlime disappointed though. I know I won't be able to make him feel good. I've been in similar to his place recently SBWIwise and I know there is no way to do that. But his words "i understand both the rules and your actions. i am simply strongly disagreeing with the outcome. i feel cheated" are nicely describing in short how I felt when EE didn't have the chance to advance further into this league. | ||
|
NotJumperer
United States1371 Posts
| ||
|
PiKe
Poland181 Posts
+ On February 17 2013 20:18 chrisolo wrote: But as an organizer it is tbh quite obvious that you save the replays and have them by yourself. You can expect by natural logic that if you play against an organizer, he will definitly already save that replays to have them. "Dividing" yourself as a player, while being a organizer, seems douchy and it does not only seem so, it is. No matter how much BM vorti was, if you are an Organizer of this league you should be a good model for Good manners and stuff. Also this Stuff is much more BM then anything else. Not granting the win, is whiny attitude. It kind of creates a shady situation if you act like this and discredits your whole league. I mean this would be acceptable if Game was not an Organizer, but as he is, I think he should be forced to use his own Autoreplay folder (btw how in hell you do not play with Autoreplay on t.t). So Game if you have those replays, share them and shine as a good person and try not to discredit this Nation Wars, which is not even financially supported by you, but by SBWI. This game was played (since you did not claim it wasnt), so be a man and account for that win and thus share those replays... +100, Dave be a man, don't act like a hurt girl | ||
|
radley
Poland582 Posts
| ||
| ||
