• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 12:29
CET 18:29
KST 02:29
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
Disasterpiece Theater: Soulkey vs sOs (2013-05-21)11WTL 2022 Winter - Regular Season Awards + Wrap-up24WTL Winter - The 2v2 Tour25WTL 2022 Winter - Regular Season Finale7Reynor wins HomeStory Cup XXII17
Community News
SC2 shut down in China, WTL to continue335.0.11 Patch Released - Balance Changes139New Worlds Map Contest III: All Submissions (VOTE HERE)74ESL Open Cup #158: RagnaroK, HeroMarine, Cure win4IEM Katowice 2023 - groups and brackets announced21
StarCraft 2
General
Serral joins BASILISK Serral leaves ENCE Red Boost - Health Results, Uses, Benefits, Scam O New Ladder Maps Announced - Used at IEM Katowice Disasterpiece Theater: Soulkey vs sOs (2013-05-21)
Tourneys
WardiTV 2023 Opens (Monthly) $5000 #PassionCraft Knockout TournyCraft free tourny management web app NorCal StarFest I [EPT 2021-22] ESL Open Cups
Strategy
Custom Maps
[A] (Minigames) Raynor Party [A] [TPS RPG] Transformers: Open World (WIP) Work In Progress Melee Maps
External Content
Mutation # 353 Hostile Territory Mutation # 352 Railroad Switch Mutation # 351 Assembly of Vengeance Mutation # 350 Burning Evacuation
Brood War
General
BW General Discussion [Interview] skb9728_CyGnus – Legendary Mapmaker [ASL15] Afreeca Starleague To Start On Feb 14 BGH auto balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ Practice Partners (Official)
Tourneys
[Megathread] Daily Proleagues New Worlds Map Contest III: All Submissions (VOTE HERE) Artosis vs Apes with Clubs BSL16 - RO32 Group F - Saturday 18:00 CET
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Valkyrie dmg formula? 2v2 Spell Combos Marine rate of fire
Other Games
General Games
The XBox Thread Fire Emblem The PlayStation 5 Destiny 2 - PC/Xbox/PS4 Path of Exile
Dota 2
Official Dota and Chess General Discussion [DPC 23] Tour 1 Discussion
League of Legends
[Spring 2023] LoL E-sports General Discussion [Patch Notes] Release General Discussion
Heroes of the Storm
HotS: WP and Funny Moments
Hearthstone
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Plays: Diplomacy TL Mafia Community Thread Team Liquid Maria L
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread NASA and the Private Sector Russo-Ukrainian War Thread UK Politics Mega-thread Coronavirus and You
Fan Clubs
The GoOdy Fan Club The TY Fan Club The Scarlett Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
[Manga] One Piece Anime Discussion Thread Korean Music Discussion Movie Discussion! [TV] HBO The Last Of Us series
Sports
2022 - 2023 Football Thread NBA General Discussion 2021 NFL/CFB Season TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2022
World Cup 2022
FIFA World Cup 2022 - Knockout Stage FIFA World Cup Qatar 2022 Thread
Tech Support
Which Gaming Laptop Should I Buy? Simple Questions Simple Answers Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
Happy Birthday R1CH! Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
It's that time of year YET A…
Umpteen
I'm still around doodling and…
Glider
Someone Crashed my Plane …
micronesia
A spiritual journey th…
mewithoutDrew
The Kitty Arcade Saga
MrBitter
My Goals for 2023
DeNikSSB
State of StarCraft II
Jealous
Burning it all down - Reti…
BreAKerTV
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 1265 users

What do you think about a nice map?

Forum Index > BW General
Post a Reply
1 2 Next All
bovienchien
Profile Joined March 2014
Vietnam1091 Posts
November 23 2021 08:55 GMT
#1
In my opinion, a nice map needs 3 elements: good looking, difference and exciting to watch competition.

We are going to go to the end creation of maps. Although, there are so many maps that were made these days. But they have not difference each other.

Let's look at maps in ASL, BSL, Ladder... They have 12-16 bases, a huge ground in the center that occupy than 80% map. Maps have no or have too less island/semi-island, high/low ground, flank, narrow path, special spot to drop Lurker, Tank, Dark Templar...

This is typical map in 2021
[image loading]

This is typical map in 2022?
[image loading]

I still don't understand why people like standard maps (balance all matchup). We have map pool, best of 3/5/7, veto and tournaments. Clearly, we don't need 100% maps are standard. A nice tournament just needs to announce time and map pool. Candidates will decide to come or not. If they play, they will choose their race that they want to play (Flash chose Random to counter map pool of ASL).

Maybe you don't know that standard maps will favor Terran. This is why Terran has so much title champion, isn't Tesagi like people think.

I really would like to play these maps and watch gosu play on them

(2)Broken bridge
[image loading]

(2)Phogna Bologna
[image loading]

(2)Stupid Mind
[image loading]

(3)White Dragons Valley
[image loading]

(3)Cool Runnings
[image loading]

(4)Sand Castle
[image loading]

(4)Holy Place of Life 0.91
[image loading]
https://www.facebook.com/StarcraftRemasteredVN/
oxKnu
Profile Joined December 2017
1073 Posts
Last Edited: 2021-11-23 11:07:39
November 23 2021 11:07 GMT
#2
Your first 3 maps are basically unplayable: Zerg will go Mutas and kill everyone or harass for 15 minutes before they tech up at a clear advantage.

There's a reason most competitions have conservative map-pools. Players can work on similar builds and optimize over a significant volume of games played, whoever finds the best strat and can execute under pressure has most to win, which is what a strategy game should be about. If you were to have those kind of random maps, everything would turn into a gimmick all-in fest (with all sorts of gotcha builds). That's nice for memes but what's the point for a high-skill player to put in the time in practicing those maps if everyone else is incentivized to just find one or two good gotcha builds that they can bust out at a later stage in a tournament?
M3t4PhYzX
Profile Joined March 2019
Poland3101 Posts
November 23 2021 11:24 GMT
#3
I admire your passion, dude.

Keep it up.
odi profanum vulgus et arceo
JoinTheRain
Profile Blog Joined September 2018
Bulgaria357 Posts
November 23 2021 11:52 GMT
#4
A nice map should not be severely detrimental to any of the three races. That's all I'd require from a map to call it nice.
The subject-matter of the art of living is each person's own life.
A.Alm
Profile Joined September 2012
Sweden468 Posts
November 23 2021 13:33 GMT
#5
We want balanced maps between races because it leads to close and exciting games. It's okay if you don't understand, because professional map makers with decades of experience do.
bovienchien
Profile Joined March 2014
Vietnam1091 Posts
November 24 2021 03:08 GMT
#6
@oxKnu
StarCraft isn't simple like you think.

Practicing and preparing make you are better but it's not sure make you win games. Have you ever heard "just play like Flash", "Flash would have won"?. Although people want to become Flash. Do you know why we have no second Flash? Because we have practice and prepare but we are not real Flash. StarCraft has high personal but maps, gamers, race are basic/general and they are not important to lead win.

Every players, pro-gamers even have their own limit. In the ladder, we have veto but veto just helps avoid boring maps, it doesn't help improve our rank. Arto has 3 vetoes and he is in A rank forever. Whether he has 6 vetoes, can he take S rank? of course no. Because he can veto maps but he can't veto his iq and skill. This thing still is alive in the highest level of StarCraft. Tier 1, 2, 3 almost never changes after so many years.

When I was a child, I noted reasons why I won, I lost after my games.

I realized quickly that StarCraft has 100000000000000 reasons lead to result of a game. Because all of units in the StarCraft even have amplitude of strength. They cause so much different circumstances in the game.

If I fixed some my mistake that mean I would make some other mistakes. So note, try to do the best is impossible.

Besides that, StarCraft is a game that belongs to subconscious. Most of us who play this game from 10 to 20 years. We did some things so much time again and again. We do it automatically, don't need to think and try, just do it. Some things of them are so bad. They lead to difference of our level, don't except gosu.

Anyway, Python 1.3 was similar my 3 first maps. Firebathero beat sAviOr 2 times in 2007 GOMTV MSL Season 2/Quarterfinals. In a PL final, there was a TvT in this map instead of ZvZ.

[image loading]

Horizon lunar colony in ASL season 9 was similar Python 1.3. We have statistics: TvZ 7-9 43.8%, ZvP 6-5 54.5%, PvT 3-10 23.1%.

[image loading]

https://www.facebook.com/StarcraftRemasteredVN/
Freakling
Profile Joined October 2012
Germany1514 Posts
November 24 2021 07:31 GMT
#7
Looking at overall matchup statistics doesn't tell you much on a 4p map. You also have to take into account, how games on different relative spawn positions play out.
Single game examples do not represent an overall trend.
Less than 20 games in a matchup is not a meaningful statistic either way.
bovienchien
Profile Joined March 2014
Vietnam1091 Posts
November 24 2021 10:04 GMT
#8
@M3t4PhYzX
Thank you!

@JoinTheRain
I think you are a nice guy

@A.Alm
We are different each other from definition exciting games. With me, exciting games are surprise, hard to guess, hard to play. I don't like to watch one or two players sit their home, buy 200 units and then come out... When I was a child, I played a game with my friend. I have to play by his regulation: we would fight when one of us reach 200/200.

@ Freakling
I see you. I just want to say, we can play on many kind of maps. Most of them even are playable from 3 race.


https://www.facebook.com/StarcraftRemasteredVN/
oxKnu
Profile Joined December 2017
1073 Posts
November 24 2021 10:33 GMT
#9
Pro play (so ASL players) is substantially different compared to amateur play (A rank, lower, whatever).

If you take a pro player: P, T or Z and ask him what would be the win-rate of Protoss versus Zerg on Largo if everyone was to play 3 months on it non-stop, all of them would come up with a number that is far from 50%.

That's all it boils down to. It doesn't matter if on some map some lower rank player can clown a win against a higher ranked player.
TMNT
Profile Joined January 2021
529 Posts
November 24 2021 12:54 GMT
#10
Some of the maps you present do look "nice". Sandcastle's best of the bunch.

They are totally appropriate for Artosis's bad map tournament. For ASL, no thanks.
ajmbek
Profile Joined November 2008
Italy452 Posts
November 24 2021 14:34 GMT
#11
am a really big fun of alternative maps. I have bunned FS and CB.

Of course not all the different maps are good, but at least they are something new.

I really like HBR and BS, good maps where either the meta is a bit different or you can just do some tricks, witch forces you to know all the counters to them.

A good non standard map adds something potentialy unexpected. But it also lowers your skill. My macro is alwasy bad on island maps, or my units are not in position in time on some new maps, or i do not scaut for all the possible hidden expos. But it is all my fault. I really hope to be able to try to play on some new maps with regular people on ladder.
Sic iter ad astra
XenOsky
Profile Blog Joined March 2008
Chile1997 Posts
Last Edited: 2021-11-24 23:29:26
November 24 2021 23:29 GMT
#12
#1 map ever made

[image loading]
disturbed Mind... siempre al final de la sala
Lavalisk
Profile Joined July 2020
Argentina28 Posts
November 25 2021 00:39 GMT
#13
Although some variety may be good, I think the outcome will be predictable for pro players. If the map is unbalanced then there will be just a single particular strategy that would benefit the most. A badly designed map would only offer monotonous gameplay.
My body, my mind and my soul belong to God.
MineraIs
Profile Joined September 2020
United States616 Posts
November 25 2021 02:05 GMT
#14
Why don't you make a map for our map contest?
www.broodwarmaps.net
ox.tQ
Profile Joined November 2010
775 Posts
Last Edited: 2021-11-25 03:36:26
November 25 2021 03:34 GMT
#15
First, there is still a lot of variability possible on the same standard "boring" map. For example, different builds and strategies exist for the three different race matchups. Different spawn positions play into that 'unpredictability' factor. Different outcomes are also possible depending on how small, medium or large scale micro battles go.

Second, I think players have enough variables to control for inside the game, irrespective of the map, especially in this day and age where everything is so technical and precise. So adding in new map features can overwhelm and throw them off their game.

Third, players also have a lot of different events and leagues which they are expected to participate in. If some of them had newer/different maps, then how will the players be able to practice for their matches? Even different leagues/events with different standard "boring" maps make it difficult for players to properly train for them because of the variability in map pools. They have personal lives too and a limited amount of time to practice.

Fourth, I have not really heard any complaints from actual players about standard maps. Sure they enjoy switching things up once in a while and playing on a different map for fun or a different race matchup (or playing a UMS game). But as a rule, I believe most players are content with the standard maps. Sometimes they can even complain about some of them not being standard (boring!) enough. Most of these complaints tend to come from viewers in my experience who don't seem to always appreciate how difficult, demanding and frustrating this game is on a very high competitive level. I have always found it amusing when viewers, for example, mock S rank foreigners (for shits and giggles in streams), comparing them to Koreans in a negative light, when I am pretty sure they wouldn't even be able to get C rank themselves.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, let those who make such arguments be the first to present themselves as examples. Get to S rank and achieve a high level competitive status, and then let us hear how you want to see and play on new or different maps
https://www.twitch.tv/TeamThinkQuickTTV *** https://trovo.live/TeamThinkQuickTTV *** https://play.afreecatv.com/axtqttv
bovienchien
Profile Joined March 2014
Vietnam1091 Posts
November 25 2021 07:52 GMT
#16
@oxKnu
Gosu, normal players can play different ways from all maps. That's why I said: StarCraft isn't simple like you think. Let's watch Mini played ASL 12, everyone knows he will cheese but we didn't know where and when he will do it.

My mean is kind of maps (standard or non standard) doesn't impact to how we play. Even in island maps, we doesn't know where, when and number of army that opponent will attack. Standard maps just look the same, boring, some of them are made to counter cheese. Maybe people like to play and watch marco games. I don't hate standard maps, just they shouldn't appear so much. I still enjoy games in 2001-2007.

@TMNT
I am looking forward to seeing some look nice maps from you

@ajmbek
I love alternative too. I like island bases near the main base and 3rd base was prevented by a building
[image loading]

@XenOsky
I love how Boxer played in this map (Legacy of Char)

@Lavalisk
You are still right if you mention to standard maps

@MineraIs
When I was a child, I made some maps to play with computer. Now, I know I can't make a map as good as I expect. I only play with them from 2002-2006. No one around me played StarCraft, they played Half Life and AOE. In 2006, I have Internet at home and my mind was opened.

@ox.tQ
I know opportunity cost of gosu. They don't want to spend so much their resource for minimum profit. Maybe StarCraft taught them that thing.

Finally, I still enjoy tournaments, ladder games, channel streams. Because StarCraft is my life
https://www.facebook.com/StarcraftRemasteredVN/
M3t4PhYzX
Profile Joined March 2019
Poland3101 Posts
November 25 2021 08:24 GMT
#17
"@ox.tQ
I know opportunity cost of gosu. They don't want to spend so much their resource for minimum profit. Maybe StarCraft taught them that thing."

minimum effort, maximum profit

you nailed it 100%
odi profanum vulgus et arceo
oshibori_probe
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States2929 Posts
November 25 2021 08:27 GMT
#18
Experimental maps are great. I think what we are forgetting though is that when they do get figured out they can be as homogeneous as fighting spirit.

How much do you need to pay washed-up ex pros to make them play on old/new maps that don't pass the smell test? Seeing some PvT on 815 or sparkle would be something I'd gladly throw 20$ down on. Maybe get some old fucks like Pusan and Nada.
Fuck KeSPA.
KD_MAN
Profile Joined April 2021
Korea (South)13 Posts
November 25 2021 10:17 GMT
#19
I can see my maps. Did you get them from the Korean community?
oxKnu
Profile Joined December 2017
1073 Posts
Last Edited: 2021-11-25 10:50:06
November 25 2021 10:49 GMT
#20
My take-away from all of these type of threads is that there's always a few people that are obsessed with the aesthetics of a map. Sure, decorations, symmetry, color are all meaningful properties of a map but ultimately what matters is how the games on it play out and if they're balanced enough for competition and ladder.

In the current ladder we have two of the best maps in the history of the game: Eclipse and Polypoid.

Check out the initial impressions when those maps came out: a string of people booing them because they're not perfectly symmetric (Eclipse) and that they're another FS clone (Poly) when the reality of it, after thousands of games played is that both are perfectly playable in all matchups and at all stages of the game.
1 2 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Big Brain Bouts
17:00
#15
Dolan vs MindelVKLIVE!
Epic vs Mixu
Krystianer vs YoungYakov
MaxPax vs Spirit
RotterdaM1142
IndyStarCraft 139
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
RotterdaM 1142
UpATreeSC 156
TKL 153
IndyStarCraft 139
BRAT_OK 54
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 30963
Shuttle 4401
Jaedong 2892
Mini 732
firebathero (twitch) 291
Stork 281
Rush 281
Soma 261
sorry 220
Sharp 115
[ Show more ]
firebathero 109
sas.Sziky 69
Rock 26
Purpose 0
Dota 2
Gorgc13629
Fuzer 185
monkeys_forever106
febbydoto22
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
fl0m2823
shoxiejesuss1461
kennyS1382
byalli621
Foxcn414
Other Games
hiko9910
singsing2468
Beastyqt1064
Lowko542
crisheroes464
Tasteless216
sgares215
Trikslyr111
Mew2King86
Organizations
Dota 2
PGL Dota 2 - Main Stream55618
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
ESL CS:GO347
StarCraft 2
Esl_sc2211
ESL.tv211
Dota 2
BeyondTheSummit142
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
[ Show 21 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• ZERG-TV 47
• MindelVK 39
• StrangeGG 32
• 80smullet 13
• Adnapsc2 12
• Poblha
• Migwel
• Laughngamez YouTube
• LaughNgamez Trovo
• IndyKCrew
• Kozan
• Gussbus
• intothetv
• aXEnki
• Alpha X_
StarCraft: Brood War
• HerbMon 18
• Michael_bg 6
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• AfreecaTV YouTube
League of Legends
• Nemesis5033
Upcoming Events
The PiG Daily
4h 31m
herO vs Dark
Scarlett vs Cure
herO vs ByuN
Reynor vs ByuN
PSISTORM Gaming Misc
6h 31m
Wardi Open
18h 31m
BSL: ProLeague
23h 31m
ESL Pro Tour
1d 9h
BSL: ProLeague
1d 23h
ESL Pro Tour
2 days
ESL Pro Tour
3 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Ultimate Battle: Snow vs Light
OSC Championship Season 10
NGS Storm Division S6 Quals
ESL Challenger League S43 EU

Ongoing

BSL Season 16
Strength Challenge 30K
Tournament of Honor
FS Mania
RISS Season 1
KOR-CHN Invitational League 1: Paralyze vs XiaoShuai
WTL 2022 Winter
NGS Storm Division S6
ESL Challenger League S44 NA
ESL Challenger League S44 EU
ESL Challenger League S44 AP
BLAST Premier Spring Groups

Upcoming

Spring Cup 4: Chinese Qualifier 2
CHN vs KOR Week30
ASL Season 15: Online Qualifier Day 2
Spring Cup 4: Chinese Qualifier 1
Spring Cup 4: Chinese Qualifier
Spring Cup Season 4: Korea
ASL Season 15: Online Qualifier Day 1
#PassionCraft Knockout
IEM Katowice 2023
BLAST.tv Paris Major 2023
ESL Challenger Melbourne 2023
ESL Pro League Season 17
CCT Central Europe Finals #1
IEM Katowice 2023
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2023 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.