Though with Eri it was a jest, but this should be known. PhiL's thoughts on brood war should never be taken seriously. He has attempted this thread more than once and failed miserably.

evanthebouncy!

United States12796 Posts

July 16 2007 05:29 GMT

#27

On July 16 2007 14:17 hasuprotoss wrote:
Well, seeing how nothing can kill it (I'm actually trying to think of one), the observer would tie everything, no?

Templar can kill it ~_~

OneOther

United States10774 Posts

July 16 2007 05:33 GMT

#28

ok this is retarded haha

.dragoon

United States749 Posts

July 16 2007 05:36 GMT

#29

yeah this thread is retarded

every unit owns every other unit, the strategy is circular that's why sc's so pimp

you oughta be playing c&c and its super weapons crap

mikeymoo

Canada7170 Posts

July 16 2007 05:42 GMT

#30

Ghost > Carrier if it has all upgrades and lockdown, no?

PhilGood2DaY

Germany7424 Posts

July 16 2007 05:44 GMT

#31

On July 16 2007 14:27 MYM.Testie wrote:
Though with Eri it was a jest, but this should be known. PhiL's thoughts on brood war should never be taken seriously. He has attempted this thread more than once and failed miserably.

i never hacked enough to get the huge understanding of the game some others have..

edit : if this is too harsh i'll edit it.. but you probably know im just making fun ; ) And i know how good u are ( even without hack ) haha.. ;P

but seriously now..

if u really think im a total noob at this game i have to apologize..
im easily top 50 Germany and probably better than 90% of the guys on teamliquid net..

<3

AcrossFiveJulys

United States3612 Posts

July 16 2007 05:56 GMT

#32

On July 16 2007 14:44 MaGic~PhiL wrote:

Show nested quote +

Did you have imaginary friends as a child?

Anyway, taking out all spells and having detection, best unit 1v1 = archon

Tyrio

United States3248 Posts

July 16 2007 06:04 GMT

#33

No, the Goliath would be everything with simple walk-stop micro. Except for the tank. Everything loses to a golly except for a tank.

PhilGood2DaY

Germany7424 Posts

July 16 2007 06:05 GMT

#34

On July 16 2007 15:04 Tyrio wrote:
No, the Goliath would be everything with simple walk-stop micro. Except for the tank. Everything loses to a golly except for a tank.

!?
How does a goon lose to a goli if the goon has range !?

[terGTOss]

Canada46 Posts

July 16 2007 06:22 GMT

#35

I think DA would be one of the strongest w/ MC. Basically DA > all that is visible. Even if BC spots DA and yamato guns it, won't be able to kill the DA.

So now onto DA vs invisible units. Well, I believe Maelstorm reveals biological units? So basically if that's true then DA would win vs all zerg units, dt, ghost. The only thing it'd have problem with is wraiths and observer ('cause I don't think maelstorm reveals robotic units?)

As for vs wraith, a high templar w/ 3 storms might be able to kill it off. Ghost might be able to kill it w/ lockdown (keep in mind ghost could have 2 if there's enough mana). And a burrowed hydra might be able to do damage to the wraith when energy runs out, then burrow and repeat, since hydra regenerates I think wraith has the lower hand?

HT also could win vs most, with storm capable of dealing damages to air, ground, cloak, noncloak, biological, robotic, whatever. Just have to be able to kill off before it dies.

So DA Wraith Temp prolly the top 3 IMHO.

PhilGood2DaY

Germany7424 Posts

July 16 2007 06:29 GMT

#36

but a ht doesnt win vs SO many units..
he wont win vs a properl microed dt, ultralisk, carrier,well basicaly ht is fucked vs soo much..

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12971 Posts

July 16 2007 06:41 GMT

#37

DA beats anything except wraith/obs, so DA would logically be the winner.
Ghost can't beat Wraith. If they both cloak, they both run out of energy at the same time, then ghost loses, and if ghost stays uncloaked it simply dies.
Wraith can't beat a properly microed hydralisk, it can lose vs HT, even vs a dragoon if it manages to stay alive, and ties against DT/obs.
Without the DA, I'd give it to the wraith though. Removing special abilities, carrier in case you can go over unwalkable terrain.