EPTxDark.Carnivalx and ShadowDrgn
Anyways, this isn't to muddy up the water and try to undermine their thoughts. I simply want to state my thoughts so everyone can be looked at and observed. Worst thing you can do in Mafia is start killing your own. You want to have a fairly high percentage chance of someone being a Mafia in your mind before voting on them to be lynched. Let's try not to do the Mafia's job for them and look closely at everyone and not start singling people out unless it is warranted.
We'll start with ShadowDrgn's post. I've added my thoughts under each clue and are in bold.
Day 1
Clue: you get to taste lead for dinner
Suspect: Caller
Reason: Sig contains "lead" and other food items that could be related to "dinner"
Very loose and could refer to anyone with food in their name or profile but the addition of lead and food items in the sig it makes Caller the most likely candidate.
Clue: either you're with us or you're permanently not
Suspect: unsoundlogic
Reason: Clue contains unsound logic!
My thoughts lean towards
-qrs
“It requires a very unusual mind to undertake the analysis of the obvious”
It's obvious that if he is not with them he is dead
Loose but better than unsoundlogic, simply because it is logically, just phrased poorly.
Suspect: GrayArea
Reason: Clue lacks a gray area.
I don't even have a response to this one
.Clue: Sidewinder stumbled forward trying to stop the inevitable
Suspect: MidnightGladius
Reason: Sig contains "It's time to acknowledge the inevitable"
Solid clue that I will stand behind. Couldn't come up with someone more or equally appropriate for this clue.
Clue: he was cut off by Mr. Blonde, coming out of nowhere it seemed
Suspect: CDRdude
Reason: Sig mentions lurkers unburrowing, which can "come out of nowhere" and cut armies off.
Suspect: Ninja4ever
Reasons: Ninja come out of nowhere! I think this connection is stronger than Dark Carnival does.
Another loose one and could also lean towards
-Alethios
“there's somebody here... they stole your underpants”
Someone came out of nowhere and stole your underpants
-Empyrean
“Humble yourselves before the Lord, and he will lift you up.”
If in fact thee Lord showed up it would be out of nowhere
-JeeJee
“i dont deal with ppl who proxy everything. its like the map is ur base”
Proxy players seem to bring the armies out of nowhere.
All of them are equally capable of being Mafia by this clue, and I think it would be bad to act on one til we could come up with a more sound argument. Along with xDark.Carnivalx's recommendation of G.s)Naruto.
Clue: [Dapperdan] met [King Brown Snake] face to face halfway
Suspect HotZhot
Reasons: Extremely weak, but his name sort of fits the description. His profile picture is a half-covered face too.
-Siefu
“He walks among us, but he is not one of us”
Fairly loose as well, but if you could be face to face with someone and not know if he is with you or against you. I think it's a little more solid than the HotZhot clue, but I could be mistaken.
Clue: Taipan Snake automatically knocked him to the ground and proceeded to kick him, being unarmed at the time.
This seems like two separate clues ("automatically" and "being unarmed"), but I can't fit either of them to anyone.
-Hittegods
“This street violence, pure self defiance”
Unarmed fighting can relate to street fighting, and kicking someone on the ground etc etc.
That was the only one I could come up with for that one. Not condemning Hittegods, but he is top on my list for this clue.
Clue: The Wolf approached "Sorry Chuiu, I gotta do this I hope you understand"
Suspect: CTStalker
Reason: Sig contains "I bear no grudge against you" plus the Wolf-Stalker connection. Credit to Dark.Carnival for this one - I think he's dead on. If we're going to lynch anyone based on clues, I think it should be CTStalker.
-CTStalker
Is my prime suspect for this clue just as the other two have stated. It could also be a bit obvious as well, which could mean it is not him. Unfortunately I don't see it connecting to any other person at the moment.
And onto xDark.Carnivalx's post
For 'The Wolf' - "The Wolf approached "Sorry Chuiu, I gotta do this I hope you understand" - part of CTStalker's quote in his profile is "I bear no grudge against you" which relates to the wolf apologizing etc. also 'the wolf' meaning a wolf, which a wolf stalks it's prey and chases them down relatively fast, which relates to 'Stalker' in ctstalkers username. So far that's the best connection i've made with that clue.
We came to the same conclusion on CTStalker.
"He almost made it out until finally someone pumped DapperDan's back full of lead." - not much to go on but it semi-relates to suresh0t's name as sure shot may refer to being of good aim and 'back full of lead' relates to a gun, so gun and shooting = sureshot. not much... but something to take note of.
It relates loosely I'll concur. I would recommend everyone note this. If I am Mafia I would imagine more compelling clues may come. However if this is enough for you to suspect me so be it.
Mr. Blonde - "Coming out of nowhere it seemed." - maybe connection to G.s)Naruto, which naruto is an anime character who has blondehair(i think, unfornatunly i cant remember exactly?lol), and is a ninja, which ninja's are known to be stealthy which fits into 'coming out of nowhere' meaning wasn't expected. not much else really just that connection. also Ninja4ever may have some connection, but his quote iirc doesn't really fit much.
I added G.s)Naruto to my list as well, but there are still many people that go on the list for this clue.
Next, Eddie, eddie is portrayed as the mafia leader. which i agree with caller could mean someone in teamliquid who has a high position or is seen as a leader, but zeks quote is "With great power comes great responsibility." Which may relate to having a position of power, which running the mafia would be. Again just a connection, i'm not saying anyone is mafia just connection clues to things.
If that is a clue, I would have to concur with Zeks as a suspect.
Enigma - "An enigma is a puzzle, something mysterious or inexplicable, or a riddle or difficult problem." Siefu's quote is 'He walks among us, but he is not one of us' which may connect to someone mysterious, and the sentence sounds something of a riddle.
We both have Siefu but for different clues, that could mean something, it could be nothing. I will lean towards something.
Mr. Pink - "Yes, but lets not be hasty, we should take care when proceeding" - BlindAblino may relate to this because blind people are cautious; but there isn't much else to go on though, perhaps albino can be connected with pink.
Anyway that's what i have for now, i have other theories and connections but their more minor then these and will require further analysis before i can even consider making more then a small note on them. Again i'm not saying any of these people are mafia, i'm just pointing out what i found relating clues to them and perhaps other people will make similar connections.
He has many good thoughts and suspicions in this, and seeing as I am one of them everyone will need to take my advice however they see fit. If I am Mafia then I will be trying to cloud your judgment from the real mafia under suspicion. If I'm not Mafia, well then I am just trying to open up leads to follow while we decide who should be suspected and lynched as being Mafia. I can say I am not Mafia, I obviously wouldn't say I am Mafia if I was. Either way here are my thoughts, take them as you want.
