• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
TeamLiquid Liquipedia LiquidDota LiquidLegends
EST 16:40
CET 22:40
KST 06:40
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • WCS
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
NationWars: Italy, Finland, Korea, France to semis14NationWars 2019: Quarterfinals Preview8[HotS] New Year, New Faces1HomeStory Cup XX Preview - The New Season10Pretty Cool: NationWars 2019 Ro1624
Community News
Toodming joins Chivo14Cure joins DPGaming14JinAir part with Cure and Creator, re-sign Maru, sOs, Rogue, Trap37TY and Stats depart Splyce194.11.0 Patch - Major balance changes, Mengsk Commander186
StarCraft 2
General
JinAir part with Cure and Creator, re-sign Maru, sOs, Rogue, Trap What does it take to become GM? Awesome/Confusing SC2 BM Bonus pool FanTaSy retires, joins Sandbox as LoL coach
Tourneys
[Alpha Pro Series] Astrea (P) vs Namshar (Z) WESG 2019 Qualifiers GBL (GOOKBAP LEAGUE) Season 2 WardiTV Christmas Invitational #4 The Pizza Pie: Season 2 Tournament 8
Strategy
Diamond 1 TvZ 1 base allin: Reaper Hellion The LotV Protoss Help Me Thread [G] TheCore Lite - Advanced Keyboard Layout [G] TheCore - Advanced Keyboard Layout
Custom Maps
[M] (4) Autumn Fields [M] (2) Seaside Resort [M] (2) Ruins of Nafrut [UMS] Entropy TD
External Content
Mutation Week 187 Onslaught Ranks/Tiers Mutation #187 Onslaught Mutation #186 Medieval Times Mutation Week 185 Never Say Die Ranks/Tiers
Brood War
General
BSL Season 8 Announcement BW General Discussion Patch 1.23.2 Cursor Jump While Playing noglues cheat does nothing
Tourneys
NAASL Round of 4 Nation Wars Week 5 [KCM Race Survival] Season 12 The Casual Games of the Week Thread
Strategy
Simple Questions, Simple Answers 2vs2 strategies for (almost) all MUs Collection of tricks? cadenzie muta micro tutorial 2019
Other Games
Heroes of the Storm
HotS: WP and Funny Moments Deathwing is the next new hero [HotS] New Year, New Faces QQ/Rage Thread. [HotS] Blurred Lines: Heroes and the FGC
General Games
Path of Exile World of Warcraft Classic WoW: Shadowlands Diablo IV Loot results for 100 runs of the 980 Ordeal Nightf
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Liquid Arcanon News [0]Paper TL Mafia Plays: Diplomacy
Hearthstone
LiquidHearth.com closing on April 10th
LoL General
LoL Tournaments
LoL Strategy
Community
General
If you're seeing this topic then another mass shooting happened and people disagree on what to do US Politics Mega-thread Ask and answer stupid questions here! South American Politics thread The Big Programming Thread
Fan Clubs
The Polt Fan Club Serral Fan Club MarineKing Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker SPOILERS ALLOWED Series you have seen recently... Anime Discussion Thread Korean Music Discussion Movie Discussion!
Sports
2019 NFL and CFB Season NBA Season 2019-2020 TL Fantasy Football '19 2019 - 2020 Football Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2019
Tech Support
Simple Questions Simple Answers Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread router issues
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
TvP Guide
Archangelsc2l
Sport vs SC2
NeoBlade
Dialysis
Jockmcplop
Last news
c0mp1exx
Still Teaching in Korea
TheGloob
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 833 users

High IQ Questions

Blogs > linestein
Post a Reply
1 2 3 Next All
linestein
Profile Blog Joined June 2018
89 Posts
September 05 2019 22:56 GMT
#1
The renowned universal genius, Rick Rosner, who has a verified IQ of 192 posed this question to his twitter followers:

A guard walks around a pool three times faster than you swim. You are in the pool swimming. Can you escape?

The pool is a square, and you are swimming in the pool.

I thought this was a great puzzle when I finally figured it out. I hope my answer is right!

***
linestine is an evil-user
Alejandrisha
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States6147 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-06 06:07:59
September 06 2019 01:19 GMT
#2
i believe so. if you start an infinitesimally small distance from the middle and then go the opposite direction, you will travel ~.5000001 the length of one side of the pool and the guard has to travel 4 times that distance to stop you

edit: upon further thought i was thinking the guard could counter this by hugging a corner while you are in the middle of the pool. but the guard gets to the opposite corner just a tad slower than you do if you both go to the opposite corner at the same time. so i stand by my answer. curious what you came up with
get rich or die mining.
TL+ Member
Harris1st
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Germany2790 Posts
September 06 2019 06:08 GMT
#3
On September 06 2019 10:19 Alejandrisha wrote:
i believe so. if you start an infinitesimally small distance from the middle and then go the opposite direction, you will travel ~.5000001 the length of one side of the pool and the guard has to travel 4 times that distance to stop you


I believe you are wrong.
I'm to tired to do higher maths right now so I used number ^^

+ Show Spoiler +

Worst case:
You are in the middle, guard is in a corner
Pool is 4x4
Your distance (going to the opposite corner) is 4/2 ² + 4/2 ² = Root of 8
Guards distance is 4+4 =8
Root of 8 *3 > 8
TheDougler is the master of signature bets, he is the two-time Blizzcon SigBet Champ. Also, Serral let me down.
Alejandrisha
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States6147 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-06 06:14:08
September 06 2019 06:13 GMT
#4
On September 06 2019 15:08 Harris1st wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 06 2019 10:19 Alejandrisha wrote:
i believe so. if you start an infinitesimally small distance from the middle and then go the opposite direction, you will travel ~.5000001 the length of one side of the pool and the guard has to travel 4 times that distance to stop you


I believe you are wrong.
I'm to tired to do higher maths right now so I used number ^^

+ Show Spoiler +

Worst case:
You are in the middle, guard is in a corner
Pool is 4x4
Your distance (going to the opposite corner) is 4/2 ² + 4/2 ² = Root of 8
Guards distance is 4+4 =8
Root of 8 *3 > 8

ah true. in the corner guard case i was using root 2 when i shouldn't have been. should have used side length of 2 rather than 1. thanks!
get rich or die mining.
TL+ Member
calh
Profile Joined March 2013
381 Posts
September 06 2019 06:33 GMT
#5
On September 06 2019 10:19 Alejandrisha wrote:
i believe so. if you start an infinitesimally small distance from the middle and then go the opposite direction, you will travel ~.5000001 the length of one side of the pool and the guard has to travel 4 times that distance to stop you

edit: upon further thought i was thinking the guard could counter this by hugging a corner while you are in the middle of the pool. but the guard gets to the opposite corner just a tad slower than you do if you both go to the opposite corner at the same time. so i stand by my answer. curious what you came up with


That is essentially correct.

Assuming you start in the center:
- If the guard is not at any corner, you swim to the opposite side to him and escape.
- If he is at one corner, you swim to the opposite corner slowly while watching him. If he never moves, you escape. If he commits to one side, you swim to the opposite side and escape (basically reduces to the previous case with extra advantage for you).
Harris1st
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Germany2790 Posts
September 06 2019 07:08 GMT
#6
On September 06 2019 15:33 calh wrote:
Show nested quote +
On September 06 2019 10:19 Alejandrisha wrote:
i believe so. if you start an infinitesimally small distance from the middle and then go the opposite direction, you will travel ~.5000001 the length of one side of the pool and the guard has to travel 4 times that distance to stop you

edit: upon further thought i was thinking the guard could counter this by hugging a corner while you are in the middle of the pool. but the guard gets to the opposite corner just a tad slower than you do if you both go to the opposite corner at the same time. so i stand by my answer. curious what you came up with


That is essentially correct.

Assuming you start in the center:
- If the guard is not at any corner, you swim to the opposite side to him and escape.
- If he is at one corner, you swim to the opposite corner slowly while watching him. If he never moves, you escape. If he commits to one side, you swim to the opposite side and escape (basically reduces to the previous case with extra advantage for you).


You are absolutely right. With changing directions mid-swim you can easily evade the guard
TheDougler is the master of signature bets, he is the two-time Blizzcon SigBet Champ. Also, Serral let me down.
Ej_
Profile Blog Joined January 2013
45996 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-06 08:48:03
September 06 2019 08:46 GMT
#7
Fun. Obviously the optimal start for the swimmer is from the center.
There are 2 "boundary" scenarios:
-the guard's in the corner (1)
-the guard's in the exact middle of a pool side (2)

Let t_s be the time it takes the swimmer to reach the side and t_g the time it takes the guard to reach the same spot. Let v be the speed of the swimmer and a the lenght of the pool side.

For (2), the solution is trivial, as the desired spot of the swimmer is directly across the guard and t_s=a/2v; t_g=2/3v, then t_s<t_g

For (1), the swimmer has to change their trajectory in relation to the guard (if a solution exists at all)
Let us examine then:
Let (0,0) denote the middle of a perpendicular coordinate system OXOY, let us set (0,0) in the center of the pool.
Let's assume that the guard is initially in (a/2, - a/2) (bottom right).
Then, the swimmer's initial trajectory is y=-x (towards top left).
The guard will follow, traversing x=a/2. The swimmer should then change their trajectory to such that the guard has to travel the longest possible path, let's denote that as A. Let's denote swimmer's path as B.
A solution exists only if:
t_s<t_g => B/v<A/3v => B<A/3 (*).
For B>2a, the guard would have to walk past a point of where the optimal strategy would be to walk around and approach the corner from the other side.
Therefore, he would need to be in (a/2, -a/2+x) such that x<z and the swimmer's final trajectory point is (-a/2, a/2-z).
Therefore, the swimmer's optimal trajectory is the initial y=-x, but after certain time, assuming y=a/2-z. That time is equal the time that the guard walks the distance of x (boundary case for x=z), therefore it's equal to z/3v. In z/3v, the swimmer would have swam a distance of z/3 along y=-x, so his position would be
(-z/3/sqrt2, z/3/srtq2).
So, the above solution exists if
(B=a/2-z/3/sqrt2 and A=a-z+a+a/2-z/3/sqrt2) (1)
and
(B=a/2-z/3/sqrt2 and A=z+a+a/2+z/3/sqrt2) (2)
Both satisfy (*). Let's check then:

For (1) and (*)
z<3sqrt2/14 * a
Satisfies the solution

For (2) and (*)
We arrive at a/z<(3+4/3/sqrt2)/4<1

Which is bollocks and even if the proof above had been without errors (and I'm sure some are there), the swimmer wouldn't ne safe using a non-continously changing trajectiry :D

Let me look for a simpler solution
"Technically the dictionary has zero authority on the meaning or words" - Rodya
Ej_
Profile Blog Joined January 2013
45996 Posts
September 06 2019 11:08 GMT
#8
Ok, I solved and, I can confirm the swimmer is free to escape.

The actual solution is also much much eaaier than what I initially did and boiled down to basic trig in my case :D
"Technically the dictionary has zero authority on the meaning or words" - Rodya
Harris1st
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Germany2790 Posts
September 06 2019 11:51 GMT
#9
Soooo what's the official word on this? Did we miss sth?
TheDougler is the master of signature bets, he is the two-time Blizzcon SigBet Champ. Also, Serral let me down.
raynpelikoneet
Profile Joined April 2007
Finland36609 Posts
September 06 2019 12:09 GMT
#10
Depends on how fast can the guard swim.
table for two on a tv tray
Harris1st
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
Germany2790 Posts
September 06 2019 12:26 GMT
#11
On September 06 2019 21:09 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Depends on how fast can the guard swim.


He is obviously afraid of water
TheDougler is the master of signature bets, he is the two-time Blizzcon SigBet Champ. Also, Serral let me down.
brickrd
Profile Blog Joined March 2014
United States4794 Posts
September 06 2019 16:13 GMT
#12
pull the guard into the water by the leg and run because he's a guard and already called backup so you better get the fuck out either way
TL+ Member
Nakajin
Profile Blog Joined September 2014
Canada5428 Posts
September 06 2019 16:25 GMT
#13
On September 06 2019 21:09 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Depends on how fast can the guard swim.


Also depend how fast you can run once your outside of the water.
http://i.imgur.com/9p6ufcB.jpg
Clazziquai10
Profile Blog Joined August 2011
Singapore1925 Posts
September 06 2019 19:38 GMT
#14
Haha nice question, I actually spent some time trying to work out the exact solution to this.

Assuming the swimmer starts at the centre and the guard starts at one of the corners and you try to escape by swimming towards the opposite corner, you can escape by making a juke towards the opposite edge that the guard is running along.

[image loading]

As long as you make the juke anytime between the start of your 45-degree diagonal swim and when you are (1 - 2 / (3 Sqrt(2) - 2) ) X from the edge of the pool, you're safe
linestein
Profile Blog Joined June 2018
89 Posts
September 07 2019 00:19 GMT
#15
dudes thanks for the creative responses. unfortunately, i'm no better off than anyone here. my iq isn't 190 and i have no idea what the canonical solution is.

here were what i thought of as the two bounding cases. you swim to the middle of the pool and then either

A)

[image loading]

or

B)

[image loading]


now obviously in case A you escape but in case B you don't.

e.g. 1.41421356237*3 = 4.2426 which is greater than 4.

so finally i would refer to clazziquai's solution where you make a little turn to gain ground
linestine is an evil-user
Chairman Ray
Profile Blog Joined December 2009
United States11469 Posts
September 07 2019 01:15 GMT
#16
The problem itself is quite simple to solve by guess and check, but if we rephrase the question, we can solve for the intended solution the problem was looking for. One problem might be "What is the fastest speed the guard can walk such that the swimmer is still able to escape". Another might be "What is the shortest time that the swimmer can escape in"

For the problem "What is the fastest speed the guard can walk such that the swimmer is still able to escape", here is the optimal solution:
[image loading]

The swimmer should start in middle and guard should start in corner. The swimmer should always swim towards to point on the edge opposite of the guard such that the guard is indifferent whether to go forward or turn around, with a slight adjustment towards the point on the edge closest to the swimmer. Using this solution, the swimmer should swim in a curve like in the picture. Calculating that curve involves some calculus that I have forgotten since college.

For the problem "What is the shortest time that the swimmer can escape in", here is the optimal solution:
[image loading]

You also need some tricky calculus to get the exact curve and end point, but the optimal path for the swimmer is to travel below the indifference curve from the previous solution, such that the guard will walk one direction, and then turn around so that the swimmer reaches the edge just before the guard reaches it.

For the original problem, using guess and check, all I did was have the swimmer swim towards the opposite corner, and then head straight left after traveling 1/4 of the way. The swimmer makes it.

[image loading]
Alejandrisha
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States6147 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-07 07:06:52
September 07 2019 07:02 GMT
#17
this thread is becoming such awesome. i posed this question to my students today (yes they actually let me tutor people) and they pretty much all assumed the scenario in which guard starts on one side. when i suggested the guard could start in a corner i got a collective gasp
get rich or die mining.
TL+ Member
Alejandrisha
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States6147 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-07 07:09:58
September 07 2019 07:09 GMT
#18
On September 06 2019 21:09 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Depends on how fast can the guard swim.

he's a cat person. and i don't mean he prefers cats to dogs i mean he can't go in water
get rich or die mining.
TL+ Member
fluidrone
Profile Blog Joined January 2015
France1465 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-07 09:56:51
September 07 2019 09:54 GMT
#19
No one puts the guard in the corner
+ Show Spoiler +

"not enough rights"
Chef
Profile Blog Joined August 2005
10738 Posts
Last Edited: 2019-09-07 17:17:50
September 07 2019 17:13 GMT
#20
Does this question assume that once I'm out of the pool I'm faster than the guard? I think I'm probably expending more energy just by swimming or treading water, so I'm already going to have a tough time. Plus even if I can swim at that speed, it takes time to get out of the pool, more than enough to catch up for the guard unless I've got the strength of a dolphin to leap out in one go.

I think the best strategy in this case is to try to catch the guard running to get to you, splash water in his path, and hope he slips and splits his skull or otherwise really hurts himself. Then you've got a shot to find some clothes and skedaddle. Alternatively maybe you can quickly pull his leg and get him to fall into the pool and buy yourself some time that way, that is probably easier to pull off but less likely to incapacitate him. Also risks getting hit in the head with a baton when you go to do it, depends how vicious the guard is.

The mathematics are kind of irrelevant to the problem, you don't give yourself much of a head start even in the best case.
LEGEND!! LEGEND!!
1 2 3 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
Alpha Pro Series
21:00
Series 131
Astrea vs NamsharLIVE!
Alpha X58
LiquipediaDiscussion
Proxy Tempest
19:00
EU Open #273
Belair 67
proxy_tempest11
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
Polt 747
Beastyqt 366
Spanishiwa 341
IndyStarCraft 314
PiGStarcraft259
ViBE 216
Kas 206
JuggernautJason 123
Nathanias 83
UpATree 83
AcerBly 71
Temp0 31
PvP 19
StarCraft: Brood War
Rain 980
GuemChi 632
Bale 141
Shinee 95
Bonyth 80
Shine 23
Hyun 16
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
Fnx 546
jdm6473
Super Smash Bros
ArmadaUGS307
PPMD222
Other Games
summit1g7048
Grubby2967
Destiny2528
[A] Tabzz777
ToD533
WinterStarcraft178
KnowMe110
ZombieGrub73
QueenE62
missharvey42
EmSc Tv 20
merz0
Organizations
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
ESL CS:GO74037
StarCraft 2
StarCraft475
OGamingTV SC2 359
OgamingTV Inter225
ESL.tv109
Other Games
WardiTV98
Counter-Strike: Global Offensive
dreamhackcs72
StarCraft 2
SC2 Vod Archives23
Other Games
EmSc Tv 20
StarCraft 2
EmSc2Tv 20
StarCraft: Brood War
Classic BW VODs19
StarCraft 2
TaKeTV26
[ Show 9 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• DisKSc2 24
• Raxxes6
• AqueroN1 3
• Chelch 2
• nixIMBA2
• Raphtor 2
• SarahBW1
StarCraft: Brood War
• 80smullet 18
• sscaitournament4
Upcoming Events
The Recall
2h 20m
NA Autumn Starleague
8h 20m
DragOn vs Yaj
TT1 vs Nyoken
Alpha Pro Series
12h 20m
Hurricane vs Dream
WardiTV Invitational
13h 20m
PassionCraft
19h 20m
ESChamp Toronto
20h 20m
BWCL
20h 20m
vT- vs aSh.
Alpha X Event
21h 20m
Astrea vs InZaNe
Cham vs Gerald
Vanya vs Vindicta
Bly vs AqueroN
The NA Apprentice
1d 1h
ESChamp Toronto
1d 2h
[ Show More ]
Afreeca Global
1d 5h
Bomber vs Solar
Zest vs Dream
Grand Platypus Open
1d 9h
BW Jeez Weekly
1d 15h
Proxy Tempest
1d 19h
IndyK Event
1d 21h
Angry vs BluE
OSC
2 days
OSC
2 days
Blazing Series
2 days
Rex vs Hurricane
Nice vs Bomber
StarCraft2.fi
2 days
The Pizza Pie
3 days
OlimoLeague
3 days
StarCraft2.fi
3 days
Path of Star
4 days
StarCraft2.fi
4 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

BW Jeez weekly 48
HomeStory Cup XX
Fight Night #19
ECS Season 8 - Finals

Ongoing

Titanes Del Ring Nation Wars
BWCL Season 49
KCM Race Survival Season 12
2019 Liquipedia Shinhan Tank Proleague
North American Autumn Starleague
StarCraft II: NationWars 2019
HotS League: REVIVAL S4
H. Lounge Div. S S2 EU Qual.
EPL Season 10 - Finals

Upcoming

Torch Up: Brood War AI Tournament
Bombastic StarLeague 8
BW Jeez weekly 52
BW Jeez weekly 51
BW Jeez weekly 50
BW Jeez weekly 49
Have At You! #29
IEM Katowice 2020
OSC Championship Season 7
Copa América 2019 Season 3
Cheeseadelphia XI
WESG 2019 - China Qualifier
GPL 2019 - Grand Finals
WESG 2019 - North America Qualifier
Agon Amateur League: Season 1
H. Lounge Div. S S2 EU Crucible
H. Lounge Div. S S2 NA Qual. 5
H. Lounge Div. S S2 NA Qual. 3
H. Lounge Div. S S2 NA Qual. 4
Nexus Cup 3
Champions Cup Finals
EPICENTER 2019
ESEA S32 - Global Challenge
DH Open Sevilla 2019
cs_summit 5
BLAST Pro Series: Global Final
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2019 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.