Instead of asking everyone if this is a good idea or not, I'm just going to go ahead and try it tomorrow (Friday) at 6 pm EST. If it works out all right I'll do it again, if not then oh well.
So if you want your replay analyzed live on stream, just create an appropriate [H] thread in the strategy forums and tune in tomorrow at 6 pm EST!
EDIT: Sorry guys, my internet is being a bit slow atm so I'm going to have to postpone this. Also there hasn't been any new protoss [H] threads so... yeah I'll wait a day or so