EPT![[image loading]](http://i608.photobucket.com/albums/tt161/discwalls/sav22copy.jpg)
feedback pls. dont be easy on me, I just started doing this kind of stuff, point my mistakes so I can improve
savior drawing attempt
| Blogs > disciple |
disciple
9070 Posts
feedback pls. dont be easy on me, I just started doing this kind of stuff, point my mistakes so I can improve | ||
|
Sadness
Brazil552 Posts
| ||
|
Spanxxx
United States408 Posts
On October 21 2009 01:36 Sadness wrote: looks like kwanro i agree. looks like ya just traced over a image very roughly. your line is too thick. looks like a cartoon, unless that's what you were going for. | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i608.photobucket.com/albums/tt161/discwalls/blavla.jpg) I want to find my own stuff and develop some sort of a style ![[image loading]](http://i608.photobucket.com/albums/tt161/discwalls/shhh.jpg) | ||
|
Necosarius
Sweden4042 Posts
| ||
|
Lemonwalrus
United States5465 Posts
| ||
|
gumbum8
United States721 Posts
 | ||
|
Hittegods
Stockholm4641 Posts
| ||
DivinO
United States4796 Posts
| ||
|
omninmo
2349 Posts
skyhigh's nose and lips. great job otherwise | ||
|
freelander
Hungary4707 Posts
| ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
| ||
|
caldo149
United States469 Posts
Also I agree that the noses need some work, it would make your drawings look a lot more like Savior and Skyhigh respectively if you fixed them. Savior's seems too wide and Skyhigh's seems not wide enough and also a it might be a bit too low. Lips are too distinct, adds femininity as stated before.Perhaps back off a little on the outline but make the line across the middle (where his mouth would open) more pronounced, bolder. and the shadow on Savior's face makes it look like he got punched. | ||
|
zcxvbn
United States257 Posts
On October 21 2009 02:50 freelander wrote: That is go.go without glasses! Was about to post this. Nice drawing nonetheless. | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
On October 21 2009 02:59 caldo149 wrote: the hair swooshes where the light hits it should go in the actual direction that their hair is going in the real picture, it makes it look different from reality otherwise.Try to make the edges go off in the same direction more or something. Also I agree that the noses need some work, it would make your drawings look a lot more like Savior and Skyhigh respectively if you fixed them. Savior's seems too wide and Skyhigh's seems not wide enough and also a it might be a bit too low. Lips are too distinct, adds femininity as stated before.Perhaps back off a little on the outline but make the line across the middle (where his mouth would open) more pronounced, bolder. and the shadow on Savior's face makes it look like he got punched. thanks a lot ! | ||
|
Husky
United States3362 Posts
If so I think its really good. As others suggested I would try making the lips and nose a little less prominent. The outlines are not only black but also pretty thick for the style you're doing. Other than that I think its really good. The next big step is drawing a picture that is in a unique pose that you made :D Keep it up though, I like looking at your work | ||
|
ludic123
Norway161 Posts
I suggest trying to look at the drawing through a camera or a mirror. It will most likely help you notice your mistakes. Try it, and see for yourself. =) | ||
|
ShoCkeyy
7815 Posts
| ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
| ||
|
Mortality
United States4790 Posts
On the other hand, I really like your SkyHigh drawing. Ironically, the same shading technique used on SkyHigh works much better, probably because of how much shading there is and where on the body it's located. But I still think you should darken up some of the lines to add definition. | ||
|
rredtooth
5459 Posts
| ||
|
pH)ggbOy
Philippines142 Posts
| ||
|
BookTwo
1985 Posts
| ||
|
CheeC[h]
United States137 Posts
skyhigh is much easier because of the glasses | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
![[image loading]](http://www.starcraft2.com/images/artwork/ss27-hires.jpg) Samwise Didier | ||
|
fanatacist
10319 Posts
| ||
|
CheeC[h]
United States137 Posts
also i dont see anything incredibly proportionally inaccurate( like your picture of savior) in the samwise picture other than the fact that his battlecruiser and i think wraith? are the same size, but those aren't what he wants the viewer to focus on and dont really detract from the overall flow of the picture. edit: you said not to "be easy on you" dont say something like that and then rage lol edit2: + Show Spoiler + I dont rage, obviously you lack a basic understanding of what the proportions are, when you should stick to them completely and when you can exaggerate a detail or the whole shape of the body or whatever you do in order to achieve the goal that you want. You can make a green blop look like savior, you really can, if that will achieve your artistic idea. Will that be unrealistic and flawed? you are completely correct. The beauty in art is obviously in the eye of the beholder, that said the artist can see something completely different than the viewer. I see a very well done savior, I gave my opinion based on how I feel you could possibly improve it. nothing more. + Show Spoiler + When I said you can go hard on me I meant bringing valid criticism having in mind the concept of the drawing. Many ppl did exactly that and I'm very thankful. I cant judge my work, cause after spending 5 hours working on it, I'm no longer objective. Thats why I posted the thing here, and reading ppls posts, excluding yours, I really see what should be done otherwise. But the moment you say there is nothing unorthodox with the proportions of Sam's drawing, all your 5 paragraphs of "going hard on me" advices become completely meaningless cause you just showed you know nothing about drawing and art in general. I'm sorry, I think I misunderstood you, and the style you are trying to develop. If you feel that Sam's drawing has unorthodox proportions there is nothing wrong with that. because its a snapshot from a fantasy universe everyone will have differing opinions based on there past experiences in viewing a "marine" or a "hydra" or a "battlecruiser" because these are all made up things. their proportions can be altered and not lost in translation. however with a real life figure as specific as savior it becomes much more difficult to change him proportionally and still have the viewer see a "savior". this is why in MY opinion savior looks goofy to some people, mainly in the face. | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
On October 21 2009 07:10 CheeC[h] wrote: theres a difference between changing the proportions of a fantasy made up figure( can usually be done and the viewer will not be confused if they have knowledge of what is trying to be displayed). and an actual photograph of a human..(proportions are the backbone to making the viewer understand the person you are trying to display) also i dont see anything incredibly proportionally inaccurate( like your picture of savior) in the samwise picture other than the fact that his battlecruiser and i think wraith? are the same size, but those aren't what he wants the viewer to focus on and dont really detract from the overall flow of the picture. get the fuck out of my blog | ||
|
ShoCkeyy
7815 Posts
On October 21 2009 04:48 disciple wrote: I dont even know how illy looks like Then what was it done on?! | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
| ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
On October 21 2009 07:10 CheeC[h] wrote: edit: you said not to "be easy on you" dont say something like that and then rage lol I dont rage, obviously you lack a basic understanding of what the proportions are, when you should stick to them completely and when you can exaggerate a detail or the whole shape of the body or whatever you do in order to achieve the goal that you want. You can make a green blop look like savior, you really can, if that will achieve your artistic idea. Will that be unrealistic and flawed? When I said you can go hard on me I meant bringing valid criticism having in mind the concept of the drawing. Many ppl did exactly that and I'm very thankful. I cant judge my work, cause after spending 5 hours working on it, I'm no longer objective. Thats why I posted the thing here, and reading ppls posts, excluding yours, I really see what should be done otherwise. But the moment you say there is nothing unorthodox with the proportions of Sam's drawing, all your 5 paragraphs of "going hard on me" advices become completely meaningless cause you just showed you know nothing about drawing and art in general. | ||
|
ShoCkeyy
7815 Posts
On October 21 2009 07:27 disciple wrote: photoshop 6.0 very nice, very nice. It's actually very good! | ||
|
ghostWriter
United States3302 Posts
| ||
|
PhailSoBaller
United States281 Posts
| ||
|
fusionsdf
Canada15390 Posts
From the nexk down, savior is perfect. From the face alone there is absolutely no way to tell who it is. You have to find what makes people recognize savior's face and emulate it, even if just in a cartoonish style. | ||
|
Boardin
234 Posts
Basically I agree with cheech and am not sure why you raged when asking for advice | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
On October 21 2009 12:59 fusionsdf wrote: its not about being photorelistic, its about looking on some level like the subject. A caricature shouldnt be photorealistic, but if the average person looks at it and can't tell who it is, you have a problem. From the nexk down, savior is perfect. From the face alone there is absolutely no way to tell who it is. You have to find what makes people recognize savior's face and emulate it, even if just in a cartoonish style. exactly Thats what I meant by "you can make a green blob look like savior" Its not about the proportions. Its about capturing the details which are typical for the person. skyhigh was easy with his glases and big nose. | ||
|
Boardin
234 Posts
On October 21 2009 18:05 disciple wrote: exactly Thats what I meant by "you can make a green blob look like savior" Its not about the proportions. Its about capturing the details which are typical for the person. skyhigh was easy with his glases and big nose. proportions are a great way to capture those details without even meaning to.... | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
On October 22 2009 04:35 Boardin wrote: proportions are a great way to capture those details without even meaning to.... ![[image loading]](http://pds15.egloos.com/pds/200906/09/97/d0030897_4a2e496a7ed04.jpg) the idea of the artist was to create a manga chick that looks like Jaedong. Does it look like jaedong to you? If yes why, if no why again? Are the proportions the fucking reason behind the resemblance or the lack of it? | ||
|
Boardin
234 Posts
Pay attention to the important proportions and you will capture the important details that will help viewers to associate your art with savior. | ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
| ||
|
Boardin
234 Posts
| ||
|
disciple
9070 Posts
| ||
|
-orb-
United States5770 Posts
| ||
| ||
