EPTMad Men Mafia
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
| ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On July 30 2012 09:15 Zorkmid wrote: Spam lol. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 01 2012 14:09 talismania wrote: nope if you don't post alot we'll all lynch you for being scum If you do post we'll tunnel you for a few days for a bad post, lynching lurkers along the way and then lynch you. Turns out you were town. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
| ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 05 2012 07:58 talismania wrote: this is a post that is just for fun and should not be read if you don't want to be distracted + Show Spoiler + ok bc refused to give me the names of characters in the game. But there aren't that many characters in mad men so I thought why not just make my own little setup for fun. We'll see how much of this ends up being right, if at all: 1 Primary characters 1.1 Don Draper - Vigilante (for firing people) or Townie Miller (because he isn't who he says he is) 1.2 Peggy Olson - Medic 1.3 Pete Campbell - Mafia 1.4 Betty Francis (Betty Draper) - Townie Mason? 1.5 Joan Harris (Joan Holloway) - Medic 1.6 Roger Sterling - Veteran 2 Supporting characters 2.1 Trudy Campbell - Townie 2.2 Bert Cooper - Townie Mason 2.3 Ken Cosgrove - Townie Mason 2.4 Harry Crane - Townie 2.5 Bobby Draper - Townie 2.6 Gene Draper - Townie 2.7 Megan Draper - Townie Mason 2.8 Sally Draper - Townie 2.9 Henry Francis - Townie 2.10 Michael Ginsberg - Townie 2.11 Paul Kinsey - Townie Miller 2.12 Duck Phillips - Mafia 2.13 Lane Pryce - Detective 2.14 Stan Rizzo - Townie 2.15 Sal Romano - Townie 2.16 Freddy Rumsen - Townie 3 Other characters 3.1 Allison - Townie 3.2 Joey Baird - Townie 3.3 Jimmy and Bobbie Barrett - Mafia 3.4 Glen Bishop - Townie Miller 3.5 Helen Bishop - Mafia 3.6 Ida Blankenship - Townie 3.7 Andrew and Dorothy Campbell 3.8 Bud and Judy Campbell 3.9 Tammy Campbell 3.10 Émile and Marie Calvet 3.11 Carla 3.12 Dawn Chambers 3.13 Ted Chaough - Mafia 3.14 Toni Charles 3.15 Cynthia Cosgrove 3.16 Jennifer Crane 3.17 Midge Daniels 3.18 Anna Draper 3.19 Abe Drexler 3.20 Suzanne Farrell 3.21 Lee Garner, Sr. 3.22 Lee Garner, Jr. - Mafia 3.23 Father Gill 3.24 Francine Hanson 3.25 Greg Harris - Mafia 3.26 Conrad Hilton - Vigilante? 3.27 Gene Hofstadt 3.28 William and Judy Hofstadt 3.29 Hollis 3.30 Gail Holloway 3.31 John Hooker 3.32 Edna Keener 3.33 Gloria Massey 3.34 Rachel Menken 3.35 Faye Miller 3.36 Katherine Olson and Anita Olson Respola 3.37 Phoebe 3.38 St. John Powell - Mafia 3.39 Rebecca Pryce 3.40 Robert Pryce 3.41 Joyce Ramsay 3.42 Lois Sadler 3.43 Danny Siegel 3.44 "Smitty" Smith and Kurt Smith 3.45 Jane Sterling 3.46 Margaret Sterling 3.47 Mona Sterling 3.48 Brooks Stanford Hargrove 3.49 Bethany Van Nuys 3.50 Tom and Jeannie Vogel 3.51 Arnold Wayne 3.52 Adam Whitman 3.53 Archie Whitman This sort of stuff needs to come after the game. Ive so far found your posts to be sub-optimal town play. At this point Im against a prphlz for the reasons that his case had merit and he has been afk for a long time. In the past this is how bandwagons on Day 1 have started. Im examining those who have been throwing around their votes so far. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 05 2012 08:12 talismania wrote: 1) It's just a little side-game, like sidebets in poker purely for my own amusement. 2) I've so far found your posts oh wait I haven't found any of your posts because you haven't made any You're going to try and nail me for real life issues? GL. My description of your filter is asking BC for the name list and if WBG will be modkilled for self-voting. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
WBG: calling out the mason was a good move in my book. But it doesn't make shit sense from the scum POV, scum can kill him regardless of whether or not the town knows the mason. His feud with Eran seems to be long standing and I could believe bugs could get frustrated and rage. prplphz: Although his play has been poor I agree with his initial case against Glasse. Glasse's play was poor and lynch worthy at the time. Furthermore this lynch seems too much like a wagon on an inactive. I feel much more comfortable lynching Eran. Seems like he could be mason scum manipulating bugs, looking to create trouble. He said himself he wanted to create a scumhunting environment, yet he helps initiate a shitstorm in a mason PM. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
| ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 05 2012 10:17 MrZentor wrote: Glasse, I REALLY don't like how you have played so far. Are you smurfing? | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 03 2012 11:41 Erandorr wrote: I am just used to wbg being dead all the time in dota and dont wanna adjust You seemed pretty set on starting a shitstorm in the beggining. I dont believe you masoned WBG to help the town figure out if he was scum, because you PM'ed after the vote. Which means you masoning had no town intent whatsoever. WBGs desicion to out masons doesnt make sense from scum POV, because Mafia can commuinicate out of thread. Worst case scenario he undermined town consensus. Prphlz's three points had merit. Glasses first post was strange even for TL's standards, second post is noncommital, and the third sounded more like a doubt plant. Other than that prphlz's was AFK, so I wasn't going to get behind a lynch where the canidate cant defend himself. What more should I say? | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
1) Glasses first post was strange even for TL's standards 2) second post is noncommital 3) third sounded more like a doubt plant. Other than that prphlz's was AFK, so I wasn't going to get behind a lynch where the canidate cant defend himself. I agree fine if you have a different opinion on the matter. WBGs mason claim needs at most one explanation, and the PM correspondence makes sense from what I know about WBG. You still haven't given me a straight answer to why as town you needed to double mason WBG. Funny you try to get on me for not looking at facts with a response like this: | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 05 2012 03:16 CountDropula wrote: I really think the most important issue for us right now is getting people active. Were giving mafia too much space to hide. Nevertheless, I'm voting wbg right now though that can change. For sure watching zeph though, but I need a better case. When you get back can you shed some light on your WBG vote? Up to this post you had only mentioned Zephirdd. Funny post considering you (and I) were basically inactive up to that point. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
This post is also super scummy. He throws doubt on the two main lynch candidates, but his alternative is... Erandorr? If he wanted an actual switch it was going to take way more than that. This reads more to me like scum not wanting to be on a town lynch of prplhz or wbg if he's town, and not wanting to lynch his buddy if wbg is scum. I start reading the thread about 3 hours before the vote, when the was basically 4 people active. Im not expecting a flood of people to switch last minute -_-. The post was made more to explain why I didn't like the two lynch canidates. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
| ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
Erandorr has been doing scummy things all game long and its time they get splayed out for everyone to see. The WBG case. Eran's points: 1) The mason out The majority of Erandorr's earlier posts addressed this issue. There were flaws in the thinking that outing is anti-town. Mafia's ability to PM each other being one of them. His main argument that mason alignment is unknown only makes sense from a town POV. A scum WBG knows mason alignment, so outing them makes no sense. You also have to remember that Erandorr outed himself as well. His explantion: On August 04 2012 01:37 Erandorr wrote: Its a completely anti town move to out people like that without thoughts on alignment or actually any information. They may have been context with VE, but I thought of it as trading my role for confirming wbg as sctiateum. it is that easy. Really? What was WBGs first point (the point you so thought was so blatantly wrong)? The reasoning doesn't make sense either as outing your self isn't alignment indicative. 2) Mason Logs As a mason Erandorr has two reasons for picking someone: he has suspicions and wants to get a better read on them or he wants to talk about the game with a townread without giving info to mafia. Picking WBG he already chose the second option. Yet he tries for an hour to get an answer, when it was quite clear that he wasn’t going to get shit. I dont see the advantage of asking the question in the PM at all, the thread was a much better way to get that info from WBG as it forces him to make semi rational posts. You could say that he was trying to bait out WBG, but that seems like a viable scum option. 3) Not analyzing posts: Funny cause he isn’t doing it either. Calling the townbase bad and not addressing certain cases. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
| ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 08 2012 02:06 JingleHell wrote: I've got to say, right now VE is pretty much the number one scumread. Most damning of all, the whole rolefishing thing on Talis. It was really bizarre timing to ask, but if the host actually made roles and names line up (which doesn't seem to be the case), that would just be kind of dumb, making it the core of a case doesn't fly. And then certain things don't line up. Townies don't need to "establish" their innocence, that just happens through proper behavior. Along with everything else, you've pretty much topped my reads for the day. You'e never played a game with VE have you. Establishing his innocence is something he mentions every game. I dont think anyone agrees that Talis' rolefishing had any place in this town, so why not call it out? This reasoning is too shabby for you to be making votes. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 08 2012 09:26 VisceraEyes wrote: Except the point is not that he targeted Bugs alone - it's that he targeted Bugs knowing he would out him as mason. He can say he didn't know Bugs would do that all he wants, but he claims the reason he did it was to see if he'd do it again, implying that he saw him do it once before. I can't imagine that he would think Bugs would out me as mason and not him - he had to know what Bugs was going to do. @Bugs If Erand flips town, I'll literally eat my hat. (  )Dont lie. Eran outed himself there was no intention for him to get WBG to out him again. If that's your whole case against Eran, it's pretty shitty to vote for them. | ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
| ||
|
BroodKingEXE
United States829 Posts
On August 08 2012 16:58 wherebugsgo wrote: wait a minute. BKE VOTED Erandorr. Man you're full of shit, attacking VE for voting Erandorr for that reason when you sheeped him A townies gotta have the right info otherwise the whole town is fucked. Towns advantage is they can make consensus and informed desicions, its our job to find the scum leading us off track and look for people who have gone off track. I dont get you you keep saying you wont play the game but your still making accusations (small if that). | ||
| ||
