As host of the last game, I hope to be able to use some of the experience from that for scumhunting this game. At the very least, we can prevent mafia from doing the same shit they pulled in that game; spam the game with useless info that confuses town. This game is far smaller so it'll be easier for town to not get confused by lots of information.

As for LSB's claim; I think it's highly important for the real tracker to report if LSB isn't the real one. We'll have one guaranteed mafia or force him to yakuza out if we get a counter claim. Just please, do not lie when claiming as town. As seen in previous games, this always ends in disaster where both players are townies and get lynched. See aeres last game.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 13 2010 13:51 GMT

#112

I would suggest the doctor to RNG between LSB and another player so mafia doesn't know who's protected. In the case of LSB being yakuza, he wouldn't be guaranteed to live after mind control this way too. For mafia, it'd still be too risky to hit him.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 13 2010 23:12 GMT

#127

I have been hit last night.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 13 2010 23:19 GMT

#128

Ugh, didn't know doctors/their target didn't get notified until I read deconduo's full post >_>. So now mafia knows I'm calm/clam. Did LSB find anything?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 14 2010 02:02 GMT

#135

I don't think this play would make much sense as mafia. Their best bet would be to hope for a medic save, since if they fakeclaim and the real person that got hit claims it's 50/50 for them to get lynched. The chance of a mafia taking that risk this early is unlikely, as proven by LSB's tracker claim without any counterclaim. They seem to be hesitant to do so as of yet.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 14 2010 02:41 GMT

#139

Deconduo, if mafia MC's someone and are protected by a doctor during it, will you update the post displaying 2/2 mafia?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 14 2010 03:22 GMT

#141

##Vote Coagulation
Has only made three posts in this thread, none of which were very impressive.

On November 12 2010 13:08 Coagulation wrote:

Show nested quote +

i assume the real tracker would also claim and then there would be 2 people and we would have to decide what one to lynch. a mis-lynch would be terrible for us.

This is the closest he has come to making a contribution. Hopefully this is enough incentive for him to post. I may still change my vote later if a better candidate comes up.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 14 2010 03:45 GMT

#144

On November 14 2010 12:36 LSB wrote:
The problem is that lynching Coag is wayyyy to easy to pull off now. I'd rather not lynch him unless he gives us a good reason to.

The problem with waiting with suspects in this game is that if they're mafia and we let them live for a night, they can MC someone at night. If we get a good suspect, we HAVE to kill them the same day. Furthermore, I mostly just want coag to post.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 14 2010 03:58 GMT

#146

On November 14 2010 12:54 LSB wrote:

Show nested quote +

I mean, is it such a good idea to be putting pressure on Coag? We just did it in Kingmaker, and he didn't respond well.
I am neutral on Coag's alignment

In that game he had crucial information for the mafia party though. In this game, he can't know the roles of others and the setup is completely different so I doubt his posting would be able to harm town enough to outweigh chance of him making a mafia slipup should he be one.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 14 2010 17:00 GMT

#162

On November 15 2010 01:47 Pandain wrote:
So here: Artanis, since it doesn't matter, are you calm or clam. then if someone counter claims, we caught ya'.

We aren't told in the role PM if we're calm or clam. It says you don't remember which one you are. I presume this is done to give mafia a chance to roleclaim.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

November 15 2010 03:28 GMT

#245

Guys, I couldn't claim to be calm/clam as I was not confirmed yet. If I did, people could have thought I was mafia. If I thought I was viewed as confirmed already I would've considered it though, it crossed my mind before posting.

That said, a summary of the previous three pages:
[image loading]

I would actually consider Pandain's withdrawal less scummy rather than more. From his play in insane mafia he just likes choosing a target and going through with it regardless. He's not doing that here which makes me less inclined to believe he's mafia.

Regarding the lynch: Not lynching anyone seems rather counterintuitive to me. It means no chance to hit a mafia and we're basically just giving them another day when we have no kp at night. If we have no real suspects, I'd say Coagulation is a good bet given that his play in previous games has been poor which means that if he's town, we will not have lost that much. I'm worried about the inactivity of Glasse as well though, and Kenpachi has been flying under the radar too. For now I'm going to leave my vote here but will consider changing to either one of those barring unforeseen developments.