To Abenson: If you don't have something constructive to contribute, it's better not to contribute. We don't need you to outline really, really self-explanatory things to everyone. Nearly everything you've said in this game so far has fallen under one of two patterns:

1)- Say something everyone who has played a game of TL mafia before understands
2)- Defend yourself against people who want to lynch you by saying they're obviously mafia for wanting to lynch you.

I'm currently personally trying to decide if your play suggests scum or is just misguided

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 26 2010 04:09 GMT

#98

OK, pointless conversation about LAL is basically the entire content of this thread at this point. Considering that Abenson is best-case an exceptionally useless townie and worst case mafia, I'm going to have to agree with D3 and say

Vote: Abenson

Other than someone we're confident is mafia, the best place to put a night 1 lynch is on a useless poster, it gets us more information than lynching an inactive at the same cost to the town

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 27 2010 16:32 GMT

#135

My posts were about the Abenson lynch because, as I said in one of my posts, the vast majority of the thread was at the time discussing either the Abenson lynch or Abenson's ideas. I will try to be more active today, but this game is pretty inactive in general right now.

On the topic of Abenson, I stand by the lynch, as we now have more info to discuss, and we don't have to deal with the entire freaking thread being people offering their viewpoints on LAL

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 28 2010 17:12 GMT

#176

Brownbear, your entire analysis falls apart due to the fact that d3 didn't claim to have a night action. Your posts generally are fairly nonsensical and contain scummy analysis. As of now, Vote: Brownbear

Otherwise, however, my suspicions lie with Johnny. Abenson's mislynch has given you a perfect opportunity to incessantly paint everyone in the game red pretty credibly. You've taken this and run with it in a big way, and your play in general suggest to me mafia in the style of DrH from Incognito's game, in which the mafia takes control of the thread, becoming the most frequent poster and "leading" the town. I don't know about you, it's mainly a feeling, so my vote is with Brownbear for now. Still, I want to make it clear that at least one person is extremely wary of you

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 28 2010 18:50 GMT

#178

Tell us what you find on Brownbear in the other game, should be fascinating

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 28 2010 22:05 GMT

#181

On April 29 2010 06:46 Korynne wrote:
XeliN, I saw that you fail-removed your vote. But that's when you said you were going to be busy for the next 10 hours, it wasn't related to you warning the town not to immediately jump onto d3.

I never said your reasons for voting d3 was a problem, I'm just saying that revealing some info, if d3 turns out to be not mafia, is bad for town.

Hobbes, why do you post so little? Dx (nothing wrong with the content of your posts, just so little of em...)

So now we need to hear from RoL... =\

I post so little because I'm a student and a musician who plays gigs on a pretty regular basis, meaning I have very little time. I try to make as many insightful posts as I can, but I'm always pretty insanely busy. I've only had the opportunity to post today because I'm home sick.

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 29 2010 01:33 GMT

#193

Bill I love that you manage to post 4 times in a row even in your own games

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 29 2010 03:36 GMT

#199

I want to deliberate for a moment before Brownbear is killed, therefore, I switch my vote to Abstain for the moment

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

April 29 2010 04:28 GMT

#201

Just the kind of thing I was hoping would happen before BrownBear went down. As I stated before, I get a huge scum feeling from johnny. Now that some other people share my views,

Vote:Johnnyspazz

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

May 01 2010 03:38 GMT

#265

Im thinking we get rid of RoL first, since there seems to be no debate as to his status as red

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

May 01 2010 04:11 GMT

#272

Vote:RebirthOfLegend

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

May 01 2010 05:17 GMT

#295

God Xelin whichever one of us is alive tomorrow is gonna feel so unbelievably stupid if we guess wrong

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

May 01 2010 05:33 GMT

#307

On May 01 2010 14:30 Korynne wrote:

Show nested quote +

Oh great, being an idiot is apparently good now (even though we're lynching two idiots in the other gave and hoping they turn out mafia). This is my second mafia game people, same as BrownBear. I just refuse to play the idiot card to get by (even if it means I risk getting myself killed because I can make wrong analysis, this mostly applies to the other game since it's so big, here I feel like we can actually win and then you're flipping on me again XeliN).

So he's idiotic enough to do something really retarded, but even if he was completely retarded he would not do that as a mafia? That makes a whole lot of sense. If he doesn't know how to play then he'd probably do something completely far-fetched and idiotic as mafia to try and get back in your favour.

XeliN you might as well take back your 100% winning while you're at it.

You still haven't presented any proof other than BrownBear going OMG I AM INNOCENT. I've presented plenty of proof why BrownBear is scum. You're making this way too easy to win for him.

He just flipped his view based on something BrownBear said. If you're mafia, good job, we're not voting for you, regardless of which one of us gets killed tonight. Like Xelin said, nothing we can do now but sit back and hope we got it right.

[NyC]HoBbes

United States803 Posts

May 01 2010 05:43 GMT

#312

On May 01 2010 14:38 XeliN wrote:
And brown if you end up being town I am going to spend an entire day in silence slowly hitting my head against a wall intersperced with staring out blankly rocking in a rocking chair and lying in the foetal position sucking my thumb...

I'll probably end up playing incredibly depressing organ music on my keyboard inbetween fits of hysterical sobs