EPTHarry Potter Mafia! - Page 8
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
why
United States215 Posts
| ||
|
zeks
Canada1068 Posts
hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm........ | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
easily. that's how. But yeah, that's a good question, how will the MoM decide who to kill first, whoever he is (will be). | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
What will I do as mayor I will hold a secrete ballot for the first elections. And I will post who voted for who afterwards. You know, mafia loves to redirect the first election? This will make it harder for them to. This is important for many reasons. Say we're going to lynch inactives. One is mafia, one is town Mafia: "Yo! Lets bandwagon this guy!" Town: "We'll their both inactive so I guess I'll vote for the town" Annul: "You guys lynched a townie. Sheep =P" Now. Imagine my system LSB: "Person A and Person B are inactive, please send me pm for who you vote for" Town sends PMs. Each person has about a 50% chance of dieng. Mafia doesn't have that much influence. Annul: "This person is mafia! Woot Woot!" In addition, I will not be able to influence the vote because I will post who voted for who afterwards. So if you see something messed up, you can call me out of it. (Of course, this also means that we got a great way to catch mafia). | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
Your just mad that I killed you. BTW. Another one of my accomplishments! I lynched the SK!!!!! | ||
|
why
United States215 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:36 CubEdIn wrote: But yeah, that's a good question, how will the MoM decide who to kill first, whoever he is (will be). My sense is that, as this is the MoM's only official power, a significant part of each player's campaign will revolve around their answer to this question. | ||
|
annul
United States2841 Posts
YOU CANNOT CLAIM YOUR NAME. IF YOUR NAME IS REVEALED BY SOME ABILITY, YOU MAY FIGHT IT (OR ACCEPT IT), BUT THAT IS THE ONLY EXCEPTION. it was revealed to me that the strategy of "omfg mass name claim" would break the game. so that isnt allowed. | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:47 annul wrote: NEW RULE YOU CANNOT CLAIM YOUR NAME. IF YOUR NAME IS REVEALED BY SOME ABILITY, YOU MAY FIGHT IT (OR ACCEPT IT), BUT THAT IS THE ONLY EXCEPTION. it was revealed to me that the strategy of "omfg mass name claim" would break the game. so that isnt allowed. Annnd that's the noise of my plan being ruined. | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:38 LSB wrote: What will I do as mayor I will hold a secrete ballot for the first elections. And I will post who voted for who afterwards. You know, mafia loves to redirect the first election? This will make it harder for them to. This is important for many reasons. Say we're going to lynch inactives. One is mafia, one is town Mafia: "Yo! Lets bandwagon this guy!" Town: "We'll their both inactive so I guess I'll vote for the town" Annul: "You guys lynched a townie. Sheep =P" Now. Imagine my system LSB: "Person A and Person B are inactive, please send me pm for who you vote for" Town sends PMs. Each person has about a 50% chance of dieng. Mafia doesn't have that much influence. Annul: "This person is mafia! Woot Woot!" In addition, I will not be able to influence the vote because I will post who voted for who afterwards. So if you see something messed up, you can call me out of it. (Of course, this also means that we got a great way to catch mafia). Let me tell you the loophole in your plan there, buddy. Say you're mafia. People choose two people to lynch, townie and mafia. You rig the "anonymous" votes and lynch the townie, even though most people voted for the mafia. You can never be checked/blamed for that since people agreed to secret votes. So yeah, that's not gonna be in the best interest of town IMO. | ||
|
Airbag
Japan77 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:38 LSB wrote: What will I do as mayor I will hold a secrete ballot for the first elections. And I will post who voted for who afterwards. You know, mafia loves to redirect the first election? This will make it harder for them to. This is important for many reasons. Say we're going to lynch inactives. One is mafia, one is town Mafia: "Yo! Lets bandwagon this guy!" Town: "We'll their both inactive so I guess I'll vote for the town" Annul: "You guys lynched a townie. Sheep =P" Now. Imagine my system LSB: "Person A and Person B are inactive, please send me pm for who you vote for" Town sends PMs. Each person has about a 50% chance of dieng. Mafia doesn't have that much influence. Annul: "This person is mafia! Woot Woot!" In addition, I will not be able to influence the vote because I will post who voted for who afterwards. So if you see something messed up, you can call me out of it. (Of course, this also means that we got a great way to catch mafia). call me stupid but how would that prevent people from voting for townie versus mafia what if both inactives are just town. doesnt seem like it makes a difference. if things are in private you can manipulate results pretty easily | ||
|
Airbag
Japan77 Posts
the amount of effort LSB put into his campaign makes me suspicious of his real intents. its only the day 1 lynch and it seems mafia is almost never found on day 1 anyway so why do u care so badly im still voting meapak | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:51 CubEdIn wrote: Let me tell you the loophole in your plan there, buddy. Say you're mafia. People choose two people to lynch, townie and mafia. You rig the "anonymous" votes and lynch the townie, even though most people voted for the mafia. You can never be checked/blamed for that since people agreed to secret votes. So yeah, that's not gonna be in the best interest of town IMO. In addition, I will not be able to influence the vote because I will post who voted for who afterwards. So if you see something messed up, you can call me out of it. (Of course, this also means that we got a great way to catch mafia). People will be like, "YOU ARE WRONG!" if I try to manipulate votes. | ||
|
CubEdIn
Romania5359 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:58 LSB wrote: People will be like, "YOU ARE WRONG!" if I try to manipulate votes. Oh right, I didn't read that part, but it still gives you a certain degree of manipulation by hiding some mafia votes, if you are mafia. Like say the townie is winning by 7 votes, you switch 3 of the mafia votes to hide them, the difference is less significant, town is more confused. Just saying tho, I don't really care since it's just one night. | ||
|
GGQ
Canada2653 Posts
On December 11 2010 11:58 LSB wrote: People will be like, "YOU ARE WRONG!" if I try to manipulate votes. If you are mafia then you'd have 8 votes to manipulate that your mafia mates wouldnt complain about. Given that everyone would be voting their own targets, 8 votes would be enough to swing it onto whoever you want. | ||
|
Airbag
Japan77 Posts
| ||
|
Beneather
Canada451 Posts
| ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
On December 11 2010 12:04 CubEdIn wrote: Oh right, I didn't read that part, but it still gives you a certain degree of manipulation by hiding some mafia votes, if you are mafia. Like say the townie is winning by 7 votes, you switch 3 of the mafia votes to hide them, the difference is less significant, town is more confused. Just saying tho, I don't really care since it's just one night. Firstly, vote manipulation is always done by the mafia. In public it can be done easily. All the mafia has to do is make sure they either vote for other people or push a townie bandwagon. In private, they won't be able to predict who is going to be lynched. Secondly, if I'm mafia, you can examine the votes a wee bit more carefully. This way you'll have a better indication of who is mafia. See? Even if I'm mafia it's better for you! Thirdly, I'll accept someone to be the 'auditor' who also recieves votes | ||
|
Airbag
Japan77 Posts
i dont see why it makes any difference if its public or private | ||
|
Mr.Zergling
United States141 Posts
| ||
|
Thegilaboy
United States2018 Posts
On December 11 2010 12:10 LSB wrote: Firstly, vote manipulation is always done by the mafia. In public it can be done easily. All the mafia has to do is make sure they either vote for other people or push a townie bandwagon. In private, they won't be able to predict who is going to be lynched. Secondly, if I'm mafia, you can examine the votes a wee bit more carefully. This way you'll have a better indication of who is mafia. See? Even if I'm mafia it's better for you! Thirdly, I'll accept someone to be the 'auditor' who also recieves votes Would we vote for this auditor too, or would you be picking them? | ||
| ||
