On September 21 2011 03:37 Cyber_Cheese wrote: ^that aside, it's still a good idea that everybody follow through with the plan, and with this in mind Forumite Curu and Lucidity are my current mafia suspects, Forumite and Curu because chaos FoS'd them both and Lucidity is self explanatory.
This post does not make sense, if Forumite and Cury are mafia, then I must be mafia too (unless GM is epic trolling me). You're starting to get to dangerously close to WBG's level.
If this isn't distancing then I don't know what is.
On September 19 2011 11:07 GMarshal wrote: It is now night 2! You have 24 actions to get actions in to me. Dreamflower did not vote, and will be replaced in the next 24 hours or modkilled with the day post. I still need 2 replacements
On September 21 2011 03:37 Cyber_Cheese wrote: ^that aside, it's still a good idea that everybody follow through with the plan, and with this in mind Forumite Curu and Lucidity are my current mafia suspects, Forumite and Curu because chaos FoS'd them both and Lucidity is self explanatory.
This post does not make sense, if Forumite and Cury are mafia, then I must be mafia too (unless GM is epic trolling me). You're starting to get to dangerously close to WBG's level.
If this isn't distancing then I don't know what is.
I mentioned Forumite and Curu were my suspects for reasons outside of them being in the cutie mark crusaders. He seems to have panicked so hard that he didn't even bother thinking through what I was saying.
On September 19 2011 11:07 GMarshal wrote: It is now night 2! You have 24 actions to get actions in to me. Dreamflower did not vote, and will be replaced in the next 24 hours or modkilled with the day post. I still need 2 replacements
What happened with this?
I had someone who possibly was able to replace but needed to check something about their schedule. this was about 18 hours ago, waiting to hear back from him.
On September 19 2011 11:07 GMarshal wrote: It is now night 2! You have 24 actions to get actions in to me. Dreamflower did not vote, and will be replaced in the next 24 hours or modkilled with the day post. I still need 2 replacements
On September 21 2011 03:37 Cyber_Cheese wrote: ^that aside, it's still a good idea that everybody follow through with the plan, and with this in mind Forumite Curu and Lucidity are my current mafia suspects, Forumite and Curu because chaos FoS'd them both and Lucidity is self explanatory.
This post does not make sense, if Forumite and Cury are mafia, then I must be mafia too (unless GM is epic trolling me). You're starting to get to dangerously close to WBG's level.
I actually agree with this. I cannot believe that GM would put 1 town with 2 scum . Forumite is giving me really bad vibes and is right now my number one target. We cannot lynch based on the assumption that 1 out of three people are mafia anymore. If dreamflower is getting modkilled then we will be dangerously close to mylo/lylo already. that forumite is in that circle is a bonus , though :D
On September 19 2011 11:07 GMarshal wrote: It is now night 2! You have 24 actions to get actions in to me. Dreamflower did not vote, and will be replaced in the next 24 hours or modkilled with the day post. I still need 2 replacements
What happened with this?
Changing the subject so soon?
could you guys stop at some point you are only shitting up the thread. That is actually a decent point, because dreamflower getting modkilled would change our situation pretty quickly (assuming he isnt scum which would be awesome :D )
On September 21 2011 03:37 Cyber_Cheese wrote: ^that aside, it's still a good idea that everybody follow through with the plan, and with this in mind Forumite Curu and Lucidity are my current mafia suspects, Forumite and Curu because chaos FoS'd them both and Lucidity is self explanatory.
This post does not make sense, if Forumite and Cury are mafia, then I must be mafia too (unless GM is epic trolling me). You're starting to get to dangerously close to WBG's level.
I actually agree with this. I cannot believe that GM would put 1 town with 2 scum . Forumite is giving me really bad vibes and is right now my number one target. We cannot lynch based on the assumption that 1 out of three people are mafia anymore. If dreamflower is getting modkilled then we will be dangerously close to mylo/lylo already. that forumite is in that circle is a bonus , though :D
Is that a scumslip?
GM had no problem instakilling 3 townies in XLIV, so this delay makes me think dreamflower might be mafia ;p
On September 21 2011 02:41 Cyber_Cheese wrote: I've been going about this all the wrong way, I tried to write an epic wall of text on who the mafia were to make up for my lurking, and it was horrible, so I'm thinking we take a different approach So far the discussion is too based on elements, pm circles and pony lore. We all know there is probably three scum left, and I think it would be best if town got organized and sorted out who is most likely to be scum, so I'm thinking everybody post the three people you think most likely to be mafia and why Mine is the cutie mark crusaders for the reasons I listed a page ago An organized town is mafias worst enemy, we can analyse people that appear on everybodys lists and crosscheck with the lynch today etc with that information.
Fluff.
Bad logic.
Lurker.
Scum.
##Vote Cyber_Cheese
Explain to me why all 3 scum would out themselves and talk about their QT in the thread?
So what exactly about the plan is bad logic or scummy? I'm a replacement who's been largely inactive in this game, rather than need to go through and make a very solid case that explained everything I thought about everyone, I could go about it and lay a trap for scum to waltz into, and you waltz'd perfectly. Especially since your strongest 'evidence' in throwing that vote on me was the arguments I admitted to being particularly weak yesterday AND you are not a part of those three people that declared to have a circle. If we needed evidence on Lucidity, this seems to be it. ##Unvote Forumite ##Vote Lucidity
Cyber, you are not helping your case when you post bad plans as traps, and react instantly with OMGUS on anyone disagreeing. Your plan was bad, posting what everyone thinks helps scum to blend in, it´s not surprising that Lucidity reacted the way he did.
First it´s Me+Jackal+tnkted, then it´s Me+Curu+Nisani, then it´s Me+Curu+Lucidity, and you do this without considering the implications of the changes, you just change to include the latest suspects. With removing Nisani, does that mean that the CMC has 2 scum and one town? That you base it all around your idea that I MUST be scum makes it even worse, not only because I´m Town, but also because you miss things, and see scumtells where there are towntells. When reading this post, I expect you are thinking "Lucidity and Forumite both attack me when I attack them, they must both be scum", right? If it only took one post from Lucidity to change your mind on the make-up of the scumteam, how can you be sure on this last one? If tnkted disagree with your bad posting, does that make him scum too?
On September 19 2011 11:07 GMarshal wrote: It is now night 2! You have 24 actions to get actions in to me. Dreamflower did not vote, and will be replaced in the next 24 hours or modkilled with the day post. I still need 2 replacements
What happened with this?
I had someone who possibly was able to replace but needed to check something about their schedule. this was about 18 hours ago, waiting to hear back from him.
If the player does show up, do we get an extended day to hear more from him/her?
On September 21 2011 03:37 Cyber_Cheese wrote: ^that aside, it's still a good idea that everybody follow through with the plan, and with this in mind Forumite Curu and Lucidity are my current mafia suspects, Forumite and Curu because chaos FoS'd them both and Lucidity is self explanatory.
This post does not make sense, if Forumite and Cury are mafia, then I must be mafia too (unless GM is epic trolling me). You're starting to get to dangerously close to WBG's level.
I actually agree with this. I cannot believe that GM would put 1 town with 2 scum . Forumite is giving me really bad vibes and is right now my number one target. We cannot lynch based on the assumption that 1 out of three people are mafia anymore. If dreamflower is getting modkilled then we will be dangerously close to mylo/lylo already. that forumite is in that circle is a bonus , though :D
Is that a scumslip?
GM had no problem instakilling 3 townies in XLIV, so this delay makes me think dreamflower might be mafia ;p
And just ignore Cyber_Cheese's posts.
Seriously ? :D
He took his time replacing Sev as well btw, does that make me scum too ?
On September 19 2011 11:07 GMarshal wrote: It is now night 2! You have 24 actions to get actions in to me. Dreamflower did not vote, and will be replaced in the next 24 hours or modkilled with the day post. I still need 2 replacements
What happened with this?
I had someone who possibly was able to replace but needed to check something about their schedule. this was about 18 hours ago, waiting to hear back from him.
If the player does show up, do we get an extended day to hear more from him/her?