Liar Game Mini Mafia - Page 51

On May 07 2012 11:54 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
Thats everything.

And I PM'ed Palmar other things. Why don't you post all of your coorespondance with everyone. Sheesh this is getting ridiculous. Why doesn't everyone just post everything they've ever said in PM as you're asking me. - .-;

On May 07 2012 12:06 Mr. Wiggles wrote:

So you only ever sent BC one PM, and that was the extent of all your communications with him? Also, I never asked you anywhere to post all your PMs with everyone, so I'm not sure why you're bringing that up. I'm also not the one in immediate danger of getting lynched and who should be trying to show they're not scum.

On May 07 2012 12:09 wherebugsgo wrote:
It makes no sense for a town Sheth to tell BC he was bluffing about the Cephiro votes but not have any other PM logs with BC.

Indeed I wasn't even sure why he would tell meapak.

On May 07 2012 12:11 wherebugsgo wrote:
As opposed to telling palmar, since that would actually make sense?

Syllo was right, this should teach you not to unnecessarily lie as scum.

On May 07 2012 12:16 Liquid`Sheth wrote:


Why would I tell Palmar? Hes pretty much one of the ppl I coudn't tell. I wanted a reaction from syllogism and his group. If I told Palmar he'd tell Syllogism. You're point is terribly bad.

On May 07 2012 12:27 wherebugsgo wrote:


-_-

So you want me to believe that you thought BC was town, considered giving him votes yesterday, and based this all on having precisely one PM sent to him with nothing in response.

And you chose BC, of all people. The person who everyone was trying to kill. Who flipped scum. Who you have no PM logs with, despite the fact that he replied to every single PM I sent him, even up to just a few hours before lynch.

You have no other logs with BC.

It is quite frankly impossible for me to believe that as town you would be in such a situation.

On May 07 2012 12:35 Liquid`Sheth wrote:


Congratz you are closed minded.

Also he never responded to me so its nice that he responded to you.

On May 07 2012 12:55 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
Why would I forge a PM to BC if I could have simply said I didn't PM him?

Just give me an answer to that please.

On May 07 2012 13:01 wherebugsgo wrote:


because you said you PMed more than one person about the bluff, and Meapak was only one person.

derp.

On May 07 2012 13:10 gonzaw wrote:
Guess I'm in the majority again.

About Sheth:

What wbg says makes sense. You could have lied about telling people you PMed more than 1 person, and so you forged a PM with your scumbuddy.
Even if you hadn't lied, you could have forged the PMs before saying it and planning it too to gain town cred if BC flipped.

The way I see it your PM doesn't make sense in the context of the game:

• If you didn't think BC was town:
  Why would you PM him about your bluff then? That wouldn't make sense, you would PM your town reads about it
  
• If you thought BC was town:
  Then why didn't you PM him more? You are telling me that you PMed a town read of yours ONLY ONCE, and only did that to explain your "bluff"? It would make sense that if you thought BC was town you would have PMed him more and not just have a lousy PM that doesn't even talk about the game at all

Either way, even if this is false, then you are still mafia from the other team, so it's irrelevant.
What's relevant is the fact that you haven't defended yourself against any accusations. I've called you out on not giving a single read or contributing at all, and when you DID it was wishy-washy as hell and just wrong, like you didn't even cared about making those reads.
Yet here you are still doing nothing and just defending yourself, and you don't even care about scumhunting nor about the game

We should kill Sheth today.