Ace, just wondering if we can have the night/day end at 9EST instead of 10EST.

Has nothing to do with this lynch, but I thought I'd mention it again.

chaoser

United States5541 Posts

August 26 2010 23:50 GMT

#723

Hey guys, so I just finished reading everything through the pain of my mouth ;_;. Seems like we've settled on Hess being lynched. I was confused as to why if he's townie, I'm a confirmed townie. Maybe I missed something? Also, since I'm bad Santa, should I make my list public as soon as I get the ability to kill someone so we can deliberate?

LSB

United States5171 Posts

August 26 2010 23:59 GMT

#724

On August 27 2010 08:50 chaoser wrote:
Hey guys, so I just finished reading everything through the pain of my mouth ;_;. Seems like we've settled on Hess being lynched. I was confused as to why if he's townie, I'm a confirmed townie. Maybe I missed something? Also, since I'm bad Santa, should I make my list public as soon as I get the ability to kill someone so we can deliberate?

Oh oops. that was me accidentally mixing up you and Rastaban.

So if Hess flips town, Rasta is confirmed.

It has been said that you should make your list public. That way we can know if the mafia hits someone in the list.
But your idea is better, that way it's like a DT

Ace

United States16096 Posts

August 27 2010 00:00 GMT

#725

On August 27 2010 08:50 Radfield wrote:
Ace, just wondering if we can have the night/day end at 9EST instead of 10EST.

Has nothing to do with this lynch, but I thought I'd mention it again.

I'd love to but there might be a Pardoner role in the game so that's why the 3 hours are needed

Fishball

Canada4788 Posts

August 27 2010 00:06 GMT

#726

I think he means to have all the game cycles to end at 9 EST.

Subversion

South Africa3627 Posts

August 27 2010 00:07 GMT

#727

hey guys, sorry didnt post anything last night, was my b-day party

was just catching up but i see Hes got majority neways.

hope we got lucky

Ace

United States16096 Posts

August 27 2010 00:09 GMT

#728

Sure, I'll make it so that Night 1/Day2 ends/starts tomorrow night @9PM ET.

Radfield

Canada2720 Posts

August 27 2010 00:17 GMT

#729

On August 27 2010 09:09 Ace wrote:
Sure, I'll make it so that Night 1/Day2 ends/starts tomorrow night @9PM ET.

Perfect, thanks Ace.

SouthRawrea

Canada608 Posts

August 27 2010 01:03 GMT

#730

No defenses for Hesmyrr? I was kind hoping to have a balanced discussion in case I overlooked anything crucial. Well I've said everything I needed/wanted to say so hopefully I didn't miss anything and I'm right.

Subversion

South Africa3627 Posts

August 27 2010 01:06 GMT

#731

The day 1 lynch is often such a crapshoot, its nice to have had something even slightly reasonable to go on anyways.

Right or wrong SR, was a good idea

Hesmyrr

Canada5776 Posts

August 27 2010 01:55 GMT

#732

Sorry guys. I really should have tried to get most of my thoughts out before the day ended, but since it's still day 1 I couldn't really find myself motivated enough to iso through specific players. First I think these points should be obvious:

* rastaban is confirmed Compulsive Vigilante, not confirmed Townie.
* SouthRawrea's alignment has nothing to do with the alignment of players above him (#1~5) since traitor and mafia don't know who each other are.
* Do not deviate from the plan of lynching SouthRawrea unless something significant occurs; if he is anti-town role, he can only be traitor so he really won't show up guilty to most of the investigative roles until he is recruited.

Also I just wanted to say I found this post from Radfield pretty noteworthy. Let me explain why. Mafia wants as much mislynch to occur before the traitor is killed, and his spontaneous push for #3 spot seems to do exactly that. Current town concensus is that traitor is likely to be found at #4~6, for right reasons because it would take quite an gambit from player #2 and #3 to take the traior. As scum do not know which one of us are Traitor, it makes sense that scum may try to argue for lynch of player with low probability of being one.

The thing I have is that he completely skirts around the issue of traitor after promptly bringing up the possibility of #3 being one to support his argument. He just says that traitor will be in #2-4 spot, and completely forgets about the role and goes into tangent about how the PoD is most dangerous in hands of mafia. #3 lynch - unless low chance that he does turn out to be traitor - does absolutely nothing to solve conflict between SR and I either.

It's pretty nice actually. Twilight period ensures that player being lynched has plenty of time to have his opinions out for the town, just reveal everything you are withholding

Btw, I parrot everyone else and will say people should be revealing what numbers they picked, even their second numbers. I tried iso'ing SR and found that he picked 10 but had no idea what was the second number he picked. Probably 6?

glhf!

~OpZ~

United States3652 Posts

August 27 2010 01:58 GMT

#733

...Yea, Radfield, I see that, but roles do not give us alignment. Roles are useless if we all RNG'd are roles. Alignment cannot be ascertained by role cop. So...How do we find alignment...

-________-

Also, Sorry Hes...

I said the PoD should of been lynched instead of you, just because, but nobody listened.

Hesmyrr

Canada5776 Posts

August 27 2010 01:58 GMT

#734

I did say I picked [7][13], right?

Hesmyrr

Canada5776 Posts

August 27 2010 02:00 GMT

#735

Of course, I really may not be understanding the benefits of PoD case since ~OpZ~ ninja post seem to be supporting it, but if Radfield suddenly starts acting scummy it is something to take note.

citi.zen

2509 Posts

August 27 2010 02:03 GMT

#736

On August 27 2010 11:00 Hesmyrr wrote:
Of course, I really may not be understanding the benefits of PoD case since ~OpZ~ ninja post seem to be supporting it, but if Radfield suddenly starts acting scummy it is something to take note.

You said it was "noteworthy" instead of "odd" or something stronger, and Opz misunderstood the rest of your post it seems.