|
On March 20 2012 03:04 Snarfs wrote:
Sigh, I'm sorry. I'm tired and am rushing things because deadline is in 4 hours. Another reason I'm suspicious of both johnny and Tobon, one which I alluded to earlier when I said that johnny's claim was off, is because they both claimed "Vanilla Town". I'm a "Vanilla Towny". See that? With a 'y' at the end? Why would they have a different title if they're actually townies? It looks like they were trying to match it up with the posts at the beginning of the thread, when that's not what the title that was sent out says.
That's interesting. He's right, the title in my role PM does say "Vanilla Towny" rather than "Town". Is that exact role name public anywhere else? If not, then I may have to reconsider Snarfs....
|
Oh crap, am I breaking rule 6?
|
Can you guys please give me something concrete to defend myself against?
I've explained already that I was not on my computer all day yesterday and the day before that I was at a St. Patty's party. When Wiggles started I was on my computer, ready to go and was able to respond to things as they happened in the thread. This time, I have not had a chance to respond to things until just this morning.
I thought my reasoning for Nemesis was solid. There wasn't much to go on for most people and Nemesis was spending most of his time either calling out lurkers or simply asking questions of people then disappearing. Since my vote, he has provided solid scum hunting and I no longer feel like he is a good lynch candidate for today.
First off ,I don't think Nemesis is going down today, and I liked how collected he was in responding to my vote so that's off. He didn't get overly emotional or respond irrationally, which is what I would have expected from scum in his position.
I was wrong to say that first part. I can definitely see how scummy it looks and you guys are very right to bring that up. I don't have a lot I can say about that. It was just before my morning coffee and if I was typing that over again, I would say it.
|
Sigh Snarfs, if that's indeed true I'm not sure if it's allowed in the game. The thing you pointed out about johnny/tobon is a good catch, but not damning because if you know you are vanilla you don't necessarily go back to your role and look at the exact naming. Also it's possible that wbg provides scum with the true role names or just messed up on your pm since the op says Vanilla town and hosts normally use the same name to avoid this type of confirmation based on role pms to happen. Anyway I need to rethink my stance on you. Care to contribute something original in the meanwhile? You may get modkilled for that so if you are town you need to get out your thoughts quickly.
|
On March 20 2012 03:09 slOosh wrote:
Are mafia given example PMs of town roles? Also are we allowed to talk about this or is this infraction of
rule 6. Posting or sharing any PM you receive from a host. ?
I've seen in other games people get noted for claiming a role that doesn't match up with what the actual role is. People called Palmar out in my last game for claiming Vanilla Town when the role was just Town. That's why I figured the titles of the roles were okay.
|
Honestly, I think if I'm going to be mod killed it's best if I don't post any more. It wouldn't be fair. If I misinterpreted the rule then that's my own fault and I should have asked for clarification before posting that.
|
It's actually rule 11. Breadcrumbing the specific phrasing of your role PM. Do not compare the phrasing in your role PM to prove your alignment. You can claim the abilities you have, but you can't use the specific phrasing of your role PM.
But I agree it's probably fair to wait for wbg to respond.
|
On March 20 2012 03:04 Snarfs wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2012 02:37 sandroba wrote:
I changed my mind about xsksc and I'm willing to give jackal time to step up. However Snarfs dude needs to die. I played last game as scum with him as town and he went around questioning people and trying to find scum, which is not what he is doing right now. His post on nemesis is pretty retarded and now his switch to tobon does not feel genuine at all and it seems he is just trying to get his vote somewhere and try to rise the minimum amount of suspicion.
Remember people, the ones that we are really looking after are people that are actively avoiding to say anything that could be considered scummy, trying to blend in and hide, while not actually doing anything thing useful and that's what can be observed about Snarfs posting.
##Unvote
##Vote: Snarfs Sigh, I'm sorry. I'm tired and am rushing things because deadline is in 4 hours. Another reason I'm suspicious of both johnny and Tobon, one which I alluded to earlier when I said that johnny's claim was off, is because they both claimed "Vanilla Town". I'm a "Vanilla Town y". See that? With a 'y' at the end? Why would they have a different title if they're actually townies? It looks like they were trying to match it up with the posts at the beginning of the thread, when that's not what the title that was sent out says.
Are you freaking kidding me? Because nobody EVER uses towny/townie when talking about a town player, amirite?
On March 20 2012 03:11 Tobon wrote:Show nested quote +On March 20 2012 03:04 Snarfs wrote:
Sigh, I'm sorry. I'm tired and am rushing things because deadline is in 4 hours. Another reason I'm suspicious of both johnny and Tobon, one which I alluded to earlier when I said that johnny's claim was off, is because they both claimed "Vanilla Town". I'm a "Vanilla Towny". See that? With a 'y' at the end? Why would they have a different title if they're actually townies? It looks like they were trying to match it up with the posts at the beginning of the thread, when that's not what the title that was sent out says. That's interesting. He's right, the title in my role PM does say "Vanilla Towny" rather than "Town". Is that exact role name public anywhere else? If not, then I may have to reconsider Snarfs....
The possible sample PMs are in the OP.
|
United Kingdom1044 Posts
Just woke up and caught up with the thread.
On March 20 2012 03:22 sandroba wrote:
It's actually rule 11. Breadcrumbing the specific phrasing of your role PM. Do not compare the phrasing in your role PM to prove your alignment. You can claim the abilities you have, but you can't use the specific phrasing of your role PM.
But I agree it's probably fair to wait for wbg to respond.
If snarf does end up getting modkilled for that, who's your next best pick for a lynch?
|
Sample role PMs are in the OP. Mafia is allowed to ask me for fake role-PMs.
However I do not know if you're allowed to talk about the phrasing of your PMs and I'd like you to stop talking about that stuff as long as WBG isn't here.
|
On March 20 2012 03:29 xsksc wrote:Just woke up and caught up with the thread. Show nested quote +On March 20 2012 03:22 sandroba wrote:
It's actually rule 11. Breadcrumbing the specific phrasing of your role PM. Do not compare the phrasing in your role PM to prove your alignment. You can claim the abilities you have, but you can't use the specific phrasing of your role PM.
But I agree it's probably fair to wait for wbg to respond. If snarf does end up getting modkilled for that, who's your next best pick for a lynch?
I'm not sure I'll read the thread a couple more times. I don't really like jonny or tobon as lynches though.
|
TIPD I expect way higher activity from you guys. Where do you stand on who is scummy right now?
|
Layabout is especially lax this game - I'm not even moved into the "Dumb" category of his reads jpg yet. Sup TIPD?
|
After some deliberation, I'm moving my vote to Dirkzor. This Snarfs' thing needs to be dealt with, but I'm observing the possibility that with this "breadcrumbing" thing (whether it was against the rules or not) might show him to be town.
I'll be gone until after the cycle flip (sports practice), so I'm throwing my vote somewhere it might be useful.
##unvote
##vote Dirkzor
|
Also it's absolutely rule infraction to discuss the wording of PMs. This should go without saying. Just stop.
|
In light of all this, I'm not sure if tobon is the correct lynching candidate. I've got an hour here to post and I'll make my judgement then.
##unvote tobon
|
Discussing the specific wording of role PMs is against the rules.
However, I will not be punishing players for it right now because the in-game punishment for trying to confirm alignment with out-of-game relevant material should be enough.
On the other hand, if players abuse my leniency and continue to blatantly discuss it, I will begin cracking down.
Example role PMs have been provided in the third post of this thread. There is no guarantee that your role PM will look like that.
|
thanks for clearing that up, WBG.
|
We disagree about johnnywub, (BL thinks he scummy LB thinks the case against him was empty and that he is not scummy)
We both think Jackal looks about as scummy as he typically does
BL thinks Tobon looks scummy and LB cant find a reason to disagree
LB thinks that scum tend to call out bullshit on claims and that we should lynch one of the first people to respond to a Vanilla town or mason claim, so that is Nemesis or Probulous.
+ Show Spoiler +laya was also pissed that BL called johnwubs vt claim suspicious
I am sure BL agrees about this last point
/laya
|
Ok so, jcarl, why Dirkzor?
And everyone, why was Snarfs becoming a big target? Because hes acting different than another game? I don't see that as enough evidence.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
