EPTNewbie Mini Mafia IV - Page 22
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
DoYouHas
United States1140 Posts
| ||
|
Alderan
United States463 Posts
On February 28 2012 10:14 DoYouHas wrote: It is possible Qatol is WIFOMing the crap out of us with, "I'll also confirm that he has not hacked the mafia QT." But otherwise he just confirmed FF as town. I see... I don't like to get into that kind of stuff, and urge the rest of you not to either. Task at hand, lynch, 1:45 minutes. 3 options in my mind are: Chocolate igadob Steveling I think a good compromise between my last post and the people on igadob/ We vote Steveling, we're killing a lurker that we don't know, and he's voting with the others that I find suspicious. | ||
|
DoYouHas
United States1140 Posts
Gumshoe, I think we might be in extraordinary enough circumstances to go for a no-lynch today. With at least 2 people being replaced/modkilled and possibly 3(FourFace). We are in a pretty bad place to be deciding our lynch, especially when 2/4 of the people we are considering lynching are among the ones being replaced/killed. I just don't think we should take the chance of a mislynch, a modkill, and a night hit leaving us 3 townies down at the start of day2. My opinion, igabod or no-lynch. | ||
|
Alderan
United States463 Posts
| ||
|
Alderan
United States463 Posts
| ||
|
DoYouHas
United States1140 Posts
| ||
|
Janaan
United States381 Posts
On February 28 2012 10:20 Alderan wrote: I see... I don't like to get into that kind of stuff, and urge the rest of you not to either. Task at hand, lynch, 1:45 minutes. 3 options in my mind are: Chocolate igadob Steveling I think a good compromise between my last post and the people on igadob/ We vote Steveling, we're killing a lurker that we don't know, and he's voting with the others that I find suspicious. I would be ok with Steveling personally. To me, there's not much reason to vote for one over the other, my only concern is that there's not enough time to get enough votes on Steve to actually lynch. As it is, we seem to be at a deadlock between Chocolate and igabod. DYH, I'm sure at least one replacement will be found, so I don't think that we're in any danger of two people dying here. The only difference is that if we lynch Steve, the replacement would be for igabod, where if we lynch igabod the replacement would be for Steve. | ||
|
ghost_403
United States1825 Posts
| ||
|
DoYouHas
United States1140 Posts
| ||
|
Janaan
United States381 Posts
On February 28 2012 10:33 ghost_403 wrote: Remind me again, why are we voting for igabod? Because he's not posting at all, which isn't a pro-town thing to do. | ||
|
ghost_403
United States1825 Posts
| ||
|
DoYouHas
United States1140 Posts
On February 28 2012 10:44 ghost_403 wrote: @doyouhas Understandable, and a good answer. What are your thoughts on the ghost/chocolate thing going on at the moment? (To say this lynch is chocolate/igabod isn't quite accurate IMO.) I think you and Chocolate were both picked on because you were easy targets. I have null reads for both of you atm. I am not willing to vote you day 1 but you had better believe I will be scrutinizing both of you. | ||
|
Alderan
United States463 Posts
On February 28 2012 10:41 DoYouHas wrote: This may have already occurred to you, but I don't trust Alderan atm. That is why I pick igabod for a lurker lynch over Steveling. If you don't want to policy lynch a lurker, I suggest we move towards a no-lynch. This should be good. We need to decide here shortly though regardless, and my vote is going to be crucial. If your plan to no lynch is assuming a modkill then it is inherently flawed and we shouldn't do it. I would still like to lynch Steveling rather than igadob, and potentially Chocolate ahead of igadob. | ||
|
ghost_403
United States1825 Posts
We could vote to lynch Igabod. That's not even really a bad idea. He's been lurking hardcore. Kinda scummy if you ask me. And I don't like scummy. However, his flip doesn't tell us anything. Maybe, we'll get lucky and lynch a scum. Odds are about, what, 28%? You can do worse than that. Other option: You lynch either me or chocolate. I think it's pretty well established, one of the two of us is scum. If whoever gets lynched flips red, awesome! Lynched a scum! If not, guess who the first person on the chopping block is tomorrow. The guy who wasn't lynched. Either way, going into day 3, the town is down one scum. | ||
|
DoYouHas
United States1140 Posts
Alderan, my proposal for a no-lynch isn't assuming a modkill. It is because we have practically no information on 2/3rds of our lynch candidates (I don't think Ghost can be lynched now). Which is not a good place to be making a lynch decision from. | ||
|
Alderan
United States463 Posts
The important thing to remember is we're not lynching this person because of fear that they will continue to lurk, because they will be replaced (if igadob votes last minute we lynch him tomorrow). We are voting because we are going into tomorrow with 0 reads about those players where we have a days worth on others, and all of the current cases could be excused by noob/aggressive town. | ||
|
JekyllAndHyde
42 Posts
First of all, I don't like this swing vote towards Steve. PEOPLE DON'T SWITCH VOTES AT THE LAST MINUTE. Alderan, if you are town please don't. If there's a last minute switch to steve and he flips town, then this whole day would be worthless and it would be your fault, so just no. I don't think lynching igabod is a good answer either. Think about it, if igabod is "modkilled", then he'll be replaced. Hopefully his replacement will be active, and we can figure out if he's scum or not. If there won't be a replacement, then igabod will be modkilled and flip anyways. In 1, it's better to wait and analyse his replacement, in 2 he'll die anyway. I don't really want a choco lynch right now to be honest either. Maybe it's gut feeling like I do in the obs qt all the time, but the tone of his post don't seem at all like the tone from his last game where he was scum. He strikes me as kind of spontaneous at the moment, so right now I'm not liking his lynch either. Considering that, I don't think a NL is that bad. Specially since scum can decide who to switch for at the last minute (either an igabod lynch or a Choco lynch), which would be justified by us townies if we say "We need a lynch at all costs". So no, let's NL, let's wait for replacements/modkills, and analyse this better next day/night. Also, consider if both Choco/igabod are town, we lynch choco and igabod gets modkilled, it means we lose 2 townies right now, and may reach Day 2 MYLO if a vig shoots wrong. Tomorrow/tonight, I say we pressure the replacements (or Steve/igabod if they are not replaced/modkilled), and the other hydra guy who didn't seem to post much at the time. I don't like sloosh's attitude either, I think he would push his reads further if he was town, or at least contribute more. @sloosh, what are your other thoughts on the game? Do you have any other reads other than on Chocolate? Your vote on him was a "preliminary" one, so what will be your final vote? As for ghost. I'm not convinced yet, but he could be scum (considering how my reads have been these past few games >_>). Either way he's not getting lynched right now, barring another last-minute switch, which I'm against. I'd prefer to pressure other people though. Anyways, I'm gonna eat, be here when the deadline hits and then go to sleep. Shit I really don't have much time this game  Why do I have to start a game the day I start uni? Also, dreamflower allowed me to delete/edit that last post I made in the gonzaw account, just a heads up /Hyde | ||
|
Chocolate
United States2350 Posts
On February 28 2012 11:03 ghost_403 wrote: You see, this is how I see it. We could vote to lynch Igabod. That's not even really a bad idea. He's been lurking hardcore. Kinda scummy if you ask me. And I don't like scummy. However, his flip doesn't tell us anything. Maybe, we'll get lucky and lynch a scum. Odds are about, what, 28%? You can do worse than that. Other option: You lynch either me or chocolate. I think it's pretty well established, one of the two of us is scum. If whoever gets lynched flips red, awesome! Lynched a scum! If not, guess who the first person on the chopping block is tomorrow. The guy who wasn't lynched. Either way, going into day 3, the town is down one scum. I don't think we are necessarily on different teams. In fact, I'm reasonably sure we are both town since if I get lynched, I will flip green. If you were mafia you wouldn't say this, knowing I'm town, because you are setting up your own lynch. So if I do get lynched and am green I wouldn't say you are mafia. Have to go to bed in 10min, should I go igabod, steve, or other? | ||
|
gumshoe
Canada3602 Posts
On February 28 2012 10:26 Alderan wrote: Is gum around? It's going to take mine and his votes as it stands now to get the majority. I'm here watcha need boss. | ||
|
ghost_403
United States1825 Posts
On February 28 2012 07:09 Alderan wrote: @Steveling have you been actively pursuing getting a replacement or no? @Chocolate aside from igabod who are you thinking is appearing scummy? Are you really getting a null read on everyone? To anyone who cares, I don't think Ghost_403 is that suspicious anymore. I realized that it is more likely that either Ghost or Chocolate are scum, Chocolate strikes me as someone riding the middle and keeping his head down. That's why. | ||
| ||
