|
Why I believe Promethelax is a better lynch than Synyster and iamperfection
Synystyr - while he has been suspicious, the suspicion on him so far has been too easy. It's been coming together without any resistance from scum or Synystyr himself. I doubt mafia would sit back and watch one of their own burn with so little resistance. WIFOM, yes, but that's my feeling.
iamperfection - His play has been suspicious, but my confirmation bias may have gotten the best of me when I questioned him. I just can't see mafia deciding to policy-lynch YourHarry from day 1. It seems absurd in my eyes, and I want to see more from iamperfection before I make a decision.
|
|
|
On August 08 2012 02:00 Hapahauli wrote:
Why I believe Promethelax is a better lynch than Synyster and iamperfection
Synystyr - while he has been suspicious, the suspicion on him so far has been too easy. It's been coming together without any resistance from scum or Synystyr himself. I doubt mafia would sit back and watch one of their own burn with so little resistance. WIFOM, yes, but that's my feeling.
iamperfection - His play has been suspicious, but my confirmation bias may have gotten the best of me when I questioned him. I just can't see mafia deciding to policy-lynch YourHarry from day 1. It seems absurd in my eyes, and I want to see more from iamperfection before I make a decision.
The reason why it's felt so easy to lynch Synystyr is because he hasn't been defending himself. I haven't seen a single case or single defense out of him since the train on him started, which is anti-town play. Given how guilty Syn looks and Syn's inactivity, we could just as easily say that scum was bussing him.
|
On August 08 2012 02:09 Shady Sands wrote:Show nested quote +On August 08 2012 02:00 Hapahauli wrote:
Why I believe Promethelax is a better lynch than Synyster and iamperfection
Synystyr - while he has been suspicious, the suspicion on him so far has been too easy. It's been coming together without any resistance from scum or Synystyr himself. I doubt mafia would sit back and watch one of their own burn with so little resistance. WIFOM, yes, but that's my feeling.
iamperfection - His play has been suspicious, but my confirmation bias may have gotten the best of me when I questioned him. I just can't see mafia deciding to policy-lynch YourHarry from day 1. It seems absurd in my eyes, and I want to see more from iamperfection before I make a decision. The reason why it's felt so easy to lynch Synystyr is because he hasn't been defending himself. I haven't seen a single case or single defense out of him since the train on him started, which is anti-town play. Given how guilty Syn looks and Syn's inactivity, we could just as easily say that scum was bussing him.
You could very well be right, however, it's my experience that concensus lynches on D1 rarely end well. Furthermore, his lack of defense is not necessarily mafia-oriented - you'd think mafia would atleast ATTEMPT to defend themselves, or at the very least, his teammates would urge him to post. This reads as bored/ragequitting townie to me.
|
I'm going to reread your case against Prom a few times before responding to it, but I just want to know: What was the tipping point between your previous slight town vibe and "strongest scum read"?
|
On August 08 2012 02:22 mkfuba07 wrote:
I'm going to reread your case against Prom a few times before responding to it, but I just want to know: What was the tipping point between your previous slight town vibe and "strongest scum read"?
I was tunneling iamperfection so hard that I didn't see anything else around me (confirmation bias wooo). Your initial case alerted me to Promethelax's play, and after replying to your case, I was surprised at how little attention he was getting with his relatively low post count (most of his posts are pre-game). One thing led to another, and I decided to write a case this morning.
The last paragraph in his last post really sealed the deal for me - the mafia-motive to me is very clear, and the rest of his play falls into place very well.
|
IMPORTANT
iamperfection accidentally learned the alignment of Hapahauli, both players being town. Talking this over with some people I decided that the best thing I can do is restart the game with a new setup and new role and alignment distribution.
This sucks a lot for everyone but I really think this is the best way to handle this. I can't let iamperfection play on. I could try to fix it with bastard modding or replacement but I think that restarting the game is the best solution for everybody.
+ Show Spoiler [Setup] +Promethelax Vanilla
Dandel Ion Vanilla
Golbat Vanilla
Hapahauli Vanilla
iamperfection Cop
Synystyr Veteran
TolEranceNA Vanilla
Sideni Vanilla
YourHarry Goon
mkfuba07 Goon
Shady Sands Godfather
Lvdr Vanilla
Game restarts as soon as possible.
You will all have to /in again (and I will favor people who played in this game).
|
whoever came up with the idea for a restart is a smart man.
|
akjwehfakwjbfmsndbvamsdnfbewhfjeh2r32heo13halksjdbnck
/in
|
|
|
How did that happen lol?
Anywhooo /in again
|
Also, I am sad now, those mafia were catchable Q.Q
|
Wow a restart. Didn't see that one coming 
|
Blazinghand
United States25552 Posts
|
Btw, is there an obs/mafia QT for D1 we can read through?
|
|
|
Are we going to see a full list of roles from the last game or not?
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On August 08 2012 02:36 Shady Sands wrote:
Are we going to see a full list of roles from the last game or not?
it's in prplhz's post just there
|
On August 08 2012 02:36 Shady Sands wrote:
Are we going to see a full list of roles from the last game or not?
It's in prplz' post?
+ Show Spoiler +
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
