TL Mafia Ban List - Page 123

On January 25 2012 07:14 Liquid`Sheth wrote:
Is it possible to sit out things before I get banned? If so I'd like to sit out BC's Arkham Asylum in case I ever get banned in the future.

On January 25 2012 06:15 prplhz wrote:
We haven't, and I was just about to propose a change to that.

It sucks that you will get a three game ban when it's your second ban, even though your first ban was a year ago and only happened because the new MLP episode had you so excited that you forgot to vote but you've played 30 games without incident since then.

So, it could be cool if there could be some mechanic in place for that, maybe 10 games without incident should erase an earlier ban? All of this should of course be up to the player herself/himself to track, the player could come in here with a list of games and flamewheel would know if there was an offence in those games, 'cause he manages the banlist

-e I also like Mattchew's approach to this more than flamewheel's, one game ban because he broke the rules isn't a lot he can probably play again in a couple of weeks. With a system like the one I propose above in place he wouldn't have to deal with old bans coming back to bite him in the ass later if he just behaves from now on

On January 25 2012 07:30 Cyber_Cheese wrote:


The way I see it, it's not just that it was his first game, and he was lead into it. I think that because the modkill was very early in, he already ended up sitting out most of mafia L, and missing most of your first game for something you overlooked just kind of sucks.

Mattchew, it's honourable of you to want to adhere the rules, but as previously mentioned, the bans stack up (1/3/5 etc games.) and as of yet don't go away. I strongly advise against taking the ban now more for the sake of any future bans.

On January 29 2012 01:23 GMarshal wrote:
Will shelve discussion till post game, but I don't think a permaban is at all warranted for that.

On January 29 2012 01:23 GMarshal wrote:
Will shelve discussion till post game, but I don't think a permaban is at all warranted for that.

On January 29 2012 08:04 Kurumi wrote:

Wrong. We will discuss it when Meapak comes back.

On January 29 2012 09:44 iGrok wrote:

Wrong. A player leaves a game of his own volition during Day 1 without asking for replacement or even informing the host. This isn't "Something happened that I couldn't get on TL". He was on TL and requested his ban. While i'm sure he had a reason for doing so, this is certainly banworthy. Not perma-ban, but certainly multiple games.

If he would like to APPEAL it when he comes back, he can do that then. Until then, he should be on the ban list.

On January 29 2012 09:52 Kurumi wrote:

What's the point of Mafia ban when he can't even play due to TL ban?

On January 29 2012 10:02 iGrok wrote:

Why would you put it off?

Seriously, what is one good reason to not have it put on record now, besides "We could put it off for later when he comes back".

On January 29 2012 10:11 Kurumi wrote:

I seriously don't think any player would ask for 90 day ban to just get out of a Mafia Game if that was his plan. Sounds more like a mistake or something urgent.