| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
metzninja
New Zealand626 Posts
 + Show Spoiler + 10 Soulkey 9 INnoVation 8 Zest 7 Polt 6 MC 5 Bomber 4 Nestea 3 MMA 2 Life 1 Mvp New guess... 10 Rain 9 Soulkey 8 INnoVation 7 Zest 6 Polt 5 Bomber 4 Nestea 3 MMA 2 Life 1 Mvp Sorry TaeJa and MC, the level of competition is too damn high. | ||
|
TheAnarchy
Chile1105 Posts
| ||
nimdil
Poland3768 Posts
On April 13 2015 21:46 TheAnarchy wrote: You forgot Rain Yes I did, I admitted it in the thread immediately because I have him in my top 10 list. I will not redo polls though. Just use Someone else. | ||
|
nimdil
Poland3768 Posts
On April 13 2015 21:36 SetGuitarsToKill wrote: that post is too long, can you please spoiler it? done | ||
|
Skynx
Turkey7150 Posts
using http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Greatest_Players_of_All_Time | ||
|
Doodsmack
United States7224 Posts
On April 13 2015 11:25 Darkhorse wrote: You complain about the thread being locked I say why the thread was locked For some reason you think this is a straw man EDIT: Anyway yeah no Stephano isn't going to be on the list I'd wager You repeated the exact same thing I had just responded to ("people were saying the same thing over and over"), and implied the only reason to keep the thread open would be to get "all the answers about matchfixing". Even though I just explained why I think the thread should be kept open, and it was not to "get all the answers about matchfixing". In other words, you responded to a straw man rather than what I actually said. You did not respond to my point that the importance of the issue in and of itself is the reason the thread should be kept open. | ||
|
Elentos
55586 Posts
On April 14 2015 00:20 Doodsmack wrote: You repeated the exact same thing I had just responded to ("people were saying the same thing over and over"), and implied the only reason to keep the thread open would be to get "all the answers about matchfixing". Even though I just explained why I think the thread should be kept open, and it was not to "get all the answers about matchfixing". In other words, you responded to a straw man rather than what I actually said. You did not respond to my point that the importance of the issue in and of itself is the reason the thread should be kept open. This topic is not supposed to be talked about in this thread anymore. On April 13 2015 05:40 Zealously wrote: Please bring any further thoughts on this subject to Website Feedback. I will be happy to address your thoughts there. | ||
|
KingofdaHipHop
United States25602 Posts
| ||
|
Philozovic
France1677 Posts
 User:Philozovic | ||
The_Templar
your Country52798 Posts
On April 13 2015 23:37 Skynx wrote: Bracket contest time? using http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Greatest_Players_of_All_TimeWell, some of us already know the top ten in order  | ||
|
Meckie
18 Posts
The player who has reached the highest level of skill is undoubtedly Life, but that doesn't make him the greatest of all time. A perfect example is Mvp because relative to his competition, he dominated the most of any player in SC2, but obviously he'd get stomped if he played like he did in his prime now ('cause the skill of players have risen so much). The same goes for Pelé and Maradona. They would get absolutely crushed by players like Messi and Ronaldo if they played at their prime at the same time, but they still dominated their respective era so much that they can be considered greatest of all times. Top 3 will be MC, NesTea and Mvp with the latter being on top. | ||
|
nimdil
Poland3768 Posts
On April 14 2015 01:17 Meckie wrote: Surely, MC will end in top 3 despite him not being on manys top 3 in here. No, he's not as good as KeSPA-players right now, and has been sub-par for quite some time now, but the amount of money earned, tournaments won, and impact on the scene he has had can be matched by close to none. I'd say the only ones capable of challenging him on a list such as this are Mvp and NesTea. The player who has reached the highest level of skill is undoubtedly Life, but that doesn't make him the greatest of all time. A perfect example is Mvp because relative to his competition, he dominated the most of any player in SC2, but obviously he'd get stomped if he played like he did in his prime now ('cause the skill of players have risen so much). The same goes for Pelé and Maradona. They would get absolutely crushed by players like Messi and Ronaldo if they played at their prime at the same time, but they still dominated their respective era so much that they can be considered greatest of all times. Top 3 will be MC, NesTea and Mvp with the latter being on top. What about MMA and Life? O_o | ||
|
JimmyJRaynor
Canada17682 Posts
1. HuK 2. Scarlett 3. Testie | ||
|
Philozovic
France1677 Posts
On April 14 2015 01:36 JimmyJRaynor wrote: Greatest Canadian Players Of All Time 1. HuK 2. Scarlett 3. Testie Combatex duuuuuh | ||
|
SetGuitarsToKill
Canada28396 Posts
On April 14 2015 01:36 JimmyJRaynor wrote: Greatest Canadian Players Of All Time 1. HuK 2. Scarlett 3. Testie Dude, don't forget KiWiKaKi | ||
|
Dodgin
Canada39254 Posts
On April 14 2015 01:17 Meckie wrote: Surely, MC will end in top 3 despite him not being on manys top 3 in here. No, he's not as good as KeSPA-players right now, and has been sub-par for quite some time now, but the amount of money earned, tournaments won, and impact on the scene he has had can be matched by close to none. I'd say the only ones capable of challenging him on a list such as this are Mvp and NesTea. The player who has reached the highest level of skill is undoubtedly Life, but that doesn't make him the greatest of all time. A perfect example is Mvp because relative to his competition, he dominated the most of any player in SC2, but obviously he'd get stomped if he played like he did in his prime now ('cause the skill of players have risen so much). The same goes for Pelé and Maradona. They would get absolutely crushed by players like Messi and Ronaldo if they played at their prime at the same time, but they still dominated their respective era so much that they can be considered greatest of all times. Top 3 will be MC, NesTea and Mvp with the latter being on top. Decent analysis but I think you're vastly overrating Nestea and how long he was on top for, even at the beginning of 2012 he was already descending into mid level player status. Top 5 will be Mvp, Life, MC, MMA and Taeja or Polt. | ||
|
Tauscond
United States181 Posts
 I'm gonna go cry myself to sleep now. | ||
|
Elentos
55586 Posts
On April 14 2015 01:17 Meckie wrote: Surely, MC will end in top 3 despite him not being on manys top 3 in here. No, he's not as good as KeSPA-players right now, and has been sub-par for quite some time now, but the amount of money earned, tournaments won, and impact on the scene he has had can be matched by close to none. I'd say the only ones capable of challenging him on a list such as this are Mvp and NesTea. The player who has reached the highest level of skill is undoubtedly Life, but that doesn't make him the greatest of all time. A perfect example is Mvp because relative to his competition, he dominated the most of any player in SC2, but obviously he'd get stomped if he played like he did in his prime now ('cause the skill of players have risen so much). The same goes for Pelé and Maradona. They would get absolutely crushed by players like Messi and Ronaldo if they played at their prime at the same time, but they still dominated their respective era so much that they can be considered greatest of all times. Top 3 will be MC, NesTea and Mvp with the latter being on top. But what keeps Life from reaching top 3 in your opinion? Life is #2 in total earnings after MC and you yourself said he reached the highest skill of any player ever. Doesn't add up if you ask me <.< | ||
|
Frakkofff
Russian Federation66 Posts
On April 14 2015 01:17 Meckie wrote: Surely, MC will end in top 3 despite him not being on manys top 3 in here. No, he's not as good as KeSPA-players right now, and has been sub-par for quite some time now, but the amount of money earned, tournaments won, and impact on the scene he has had can be matched by close to none. I'd say the only ones capable of challenging him on a list such as this are Mvp and NesTea. The player who has reached the highest level of skill is undoubtedly Life, but that doesn't make him the greatest of all time. A perfect example is Mvp because relative to his competition, he dominated the most of any player in SC2, but obviously he'd get stomped if he played like he did in his prime now ('cause the skill of players have risen so much). The same goes for Pelé and Maradona. They would get absolutely crushed by players like Messi and Ronaldo if they played at their prime at the same time, but they still dominated their respective era so much that they can be considered greatest of all times. Top 3 will be MC, NesTea and Mvp with the latter being on top. I'm totally agree with you, only contrast count. | ||
|
sharkie
Austria18689 Posts
On April 14 2015 00:58 KingofdaHipHop wrote: I'm surprised so many people are putting herO on their list. Don't get me wrong, he's amazing and has achieved some incredible things, but I just don't see how he is GOAT level. Not yet, anyways. Yeah, the funniest thing is it's not even the CJ players who are doing that XD | ||
| ||
|
|
WardiTV Weekly
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
Replay Cast
CrankTV Team League
OSC
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
CrankTV Team League
OSC
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
