What If We Don't Need Blizzard? - Page 9
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
sc2CruSha
United States105 Posts
| ||
|
BamBam
745 Posts
On September 11 2012 23:46 pallad wrote: This. Many people dont realize that Sc2 is already bigger now then Bw was in gold BW times , numbers or players playing , numbers of tournaments , prizes etc etc , its all bigger then in BW. And im not some Bw hater , I love BW , but Sc 2 is bigger and its a fact. Sc 2 has only 2 years.. BW has 13 ? realize that..., how someone can write that SC 2 is not that big succes etc . it dont even got one expansion. And its posts like these that make people infuriated at the ignorance many people seem to have. BW - when it was largely supported - was vastly larger than sc2 across the spectrum (even in game sales YTD). To assume sc2 is currently larger than bw in its golden times is just ludicrous. The problem with most fanboys of sc2, is that they have this "move over" attitude about bw and refuse to give any respect to the game or what it represented. Its a shame, at the end of the day we all love starcraft and this is why we all complain about sc2... not because we dont like the game, but because we want it to be better than how it is currently. Sad to say it seems the game's own popularity is crushing sc2 due to it trying to be split amoungst many different areas - casual friendly, competitve game, esports cash cow, etc... | ||
|
Antylamon
United States1981 Posts
That is when custom maps should be experimented with. | ||
|
Orracle
United States314 Posts
On September 11 2012 18:00 BlackPanther wrote: This post is short sighted and desperate. WE NEED BLIZZARD TO GROW ESPORTS! They have the money and the manpower to do it. Trying to come up with workarounds to please BW fans nostalgia and separation anxiety will not help fix our problems. Really? Looked to me like BW grew fine without Blizzard. I would even stretch it to saying BW has done more for SC2 than Blizzard has in terms of a competitive scene. On September 12 2012 03:39 Energizer wrote: [ And its posts like these that make people infuriated at the ignorance many people seem to have. BW - when it was largely supported - was vastly larger than sc2 across the spectrum (even in game sales YTD). To assume sc2 is currently larger than bw in its golden times is just ludicious. The problem with most fanboys of sc2, is that they have this "move over" attitude about bw and refuse to give any respect to the game or what it represented. Its a shame, at the end of the day we all love starcraft and this is why we all complain about sc2... not because we dont like the game, but because we want it to be better than how it is currently. Sad to say it seems the game's own popularity is crushing sc2 due to it trying to be split amoungst many different areas - casual friendly, competitve game, esports cash cow, etc... I don't think people are familiar with how big of a following Brood War actually had.... Not in terms of a player base, but more so an audience. There's a reason, even when SC2 was out, Brood War still played on multiple TV channels in Korea. | ||
|
Sankanyo
United States140 Posts
| ||
|
iamho
United States3347 Posts
The game would have been better developed by the players; balancing should be done through player-made maps and metagame changes, not patches after patches (Blizzard needs to stop listening to the balance whiners). Blizzard also needs to stop focusing on pleasing the "gamers" who play the game 5 hours a day and focus more on making the game exciting to nonplayers, and the way to do that is to let players have more control, not patching unit x to do y more/less damage. | ||
|
FabledIntegral
United States9232 Posts
On September 12 2012 03:39 Energizer wrote: And its posts like these that make people infuriated at the ignorance many people seem to have. BW - when it was largely supported - was vastly larger than sc2 across the spectrum (even in game sales YTD). To assume sc2 is currently larger than bw in its golden times is just ludicrous. The problem with most fanboys of sc2, is that they have this "move over" attitude about bw and refuse to give any respect to the game or what it represented. Its a shame, at the end of the day we all love starcraft and this is why we all complain about sc2... not because we dont like the game, but because we want it to be better than how it is currently. Sad to say it seems the game's own popularity is crushing sc2 due to it trying to be split amoungst many different areas - casual friendly, competitve game, esports cash cow, etc... Sales numbers are irrelevant because the majority of gamers were not multiplayer gamers. The community was not vastly larger than SC2 across the spectrum. It was centrally focused in Korea. In BW, it was a ton of people who picked up and bought the game, beat the campaign, played a few games, and did not really touch it again. And I played BW since it's release, continued to play online, and played SC64 (and even bought the expansion pack for the N64, which I didn't even know existed for the N64, and only found out when I realized SC:BW wasn't enabled on the SC64 cartridge unless you had a N64 expansion) for 3 years straight until I got it back on the PC. I also regularly was up at 2:00 AM to watch MSL/OSL and Proleague, as well as my favorite "GSL" that had Tasteless/Artosis around before it was killed. On September 12 2012 03:34 sc2CruSha wrote: you can't remake broodwar on sc2 lol vultures don't micro the same and mutas just don't stack the same anymore They do stack in SC2:BW, just not in the regular game. They could change it to make them stack like they used to if they wanted. It still has a slightly different feel to it though. | ||
|
ACrow
Germany6583 Posts
If you honestly care about SC2, provide feedback for the HotS beta (with good argumentation and without plain bashing). If you don't care for SC2, just go back to BW. It's still there, you know. | ||
|
koffeinfrei
26 Posts
hell fly the whole kespa dudes to blizzard and let them create a true, epic and beautiful real time strategy game butthats just a dream and will never happen T.T blizzard is using some community maps in the ladderpool tho so maybe there is some hope edit: lol @ butthats xDDDD not gonna edit that cuz its too funny | ||
|
FeyFey
Germany10114 Posts
Seen a ton of balance suggestions and how to increase game depths, most of them are just preferences of one person and far from any improvement for the game. If someone would be really dissatisfied, they would actually bother trying to do it better or just don't care and move on. And if they actually would make it better, we would have something like dota1 if something is really good it will be used. (Custom map or vanilla, blizzard gets the same money) There was this esport rts rush before sc2 was announced, with alot of rts coming out with a focus on esport and investing into it. Well yeah ... warcraft 3 was not impressed. I am really satisfied with how WoL turned out, though they patched to much at the start, so a few nice units got crippled. It is a nice challenge and is fun to play and view. And personally playing bw or sc2 or watching both. I don't think they are far from each other. Warcraft 1 isn't better then 2 or the other way round, same goes for 3. The focus is shifted abit, but overall it is Warcraft. And i wouls say WoL feels like starcraft. (But Blizzard shouldn't have balanced so eager at the start). There were some funny comments in this thread though, like bw didn't need Blizzard. Had to think about BW and what would have happened without the bnet. ("BW ? whats that ooooh starcraft1 yeah the campaign was nice") But the Valve thing made me laugh and i had to think about f2p bw2 with a unit called the keyling you can buy for real money, where you can open random boxes with where superunits come out, but the keyling dies afterwards. Sc2 has to live up to a Legendary game in a world where everyone knows better then the other with no argumentation needed called the internet. I am impressed they actually tried and didn't just make a single player game and make the multiplayer part bw, with better graphics. But i am glad they didn't. But i have to admit that i have a custom game setup without multi group selection and a few other changes haha and a few interceptor changes (because it is way to easy to fungal interceptors when they launch). PS: everyone should dream of butthats | ||
|
RinconH
United States512 Posts
I've played it for almost two years and quite enjoyed it. Is it as good as BW? No... but it's still a cut above 99% of other games. Thing is what makes a sport is competition... not necessarily how good the game is. I'd rather have a very good game with a large player base than a great one that only 100s of people play because then you don't have a community to spur on your sense of competitiveness. That's why I don't believe making a community mod will work. | ||
|
iky43210
United States2099 Posts
On September 12 2012 04:27 iamho wrote: SC2 is not bigger than BW in its prime (or even halo/cs in their prime), nor is it bigger than either of the major moba games. Already SC2 has stagnated in terms of viewership. Frankly, all the foundations of success for the game are there, but Blizzard's need for obsessive control and constant patching are extremely detrimental to the game. The game would have been better developed by the players; balancing should be done through player-made maps and metagame changes, not patches after patches (Blizzard needs to stop listening to the balance whiners). Blizzard also needs to stop focusing on pleasing the "gamers" who play the game 5 hours a day and focus more on making the game exciting to nonplayers, and the way to do that is to let players have more control, not patching unit x to do y more/less damage. when you're talking about bigger are you talking about playerbase or competitive scene? RTS is a niche genre, sc2 had done quite well given active playerbase and its competitive scene. sc competitive scene have far surpass cs or halo even in its prime you need a growing active base in order to have a realistic growing competitive scene, and sc2 or all modern RTS genre just isn't that attractive to modern gamers. Its not a game you can just pick up and be decently good at it, and more importantly its not a social-able game also with broodwar, calling the hype centralized in korea was understatement. The whole broodwar scene is Korea | ||
|
Gentso
United States2218 Posts
Yes, because you need their permission to host a tournament. | ||
|
Hryul
Austria2609 Posts
Given the state that esports is not the country where money grows from trees it's a huge risk to take. But if you don't have at least some big names in it, it doesn't seem to attract a lot of viewers. (TSL anyone?) Also there seems to be a general unwillingness of the community base to move since the bnet does provide a lot of luxury, esp. the match making is really good. So they don't have the need of ICCup. I would really like it, but I don't see it happening in the near future. | ||
|
Zombo Joe
Canada850 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:02 Gentso wrote: Do we need Blizzard? Yes, because you need their permission to host a tournament. Host your own tournament on a custom bnet client. What's stopping you? Lawyers? | ||
|
ACrow
Germany6583 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:05 Zombo Joe wrote: Host your own tournament on a custom bnet client. What's stopping you? Lawyers? It IS illegal. | ||
|
[UoN]Sentinel
United States11320 Posts
On September 12 2012 04:53 RinconH wrote: lolol it's quite a stretch to call this a bad game. I've played it for almost two years and quite enjoyed it. Is it as good as BW? No... but it's still a cut above 99% of other games. Thing is what makes a sport is competition... not necessarily how good the game is. I'd rather have a very good game with a large player base than a great one that only 100s of people play because then you don't have a community to spur on your sense of competitiveness. That's why I don't believe making a community mod will work. This. SC2 has taken esports far. Look at the new foreigner scene, the tournaments on multiple continents instead of just centered around South Korea, streamers and casters and players all making decent amounts of money doing what they love. Without Blizzard, we wouldn't have any of that. They've given us the tools to make great maps, great customs, learning aids and mods all around. Cutting them off and taking matters in our own hands would be a great way to repay them. I'm going to say BW was more revolutionary than SC2, but SC2 was far more enjoyable than BW to watch and to play. Things are faster, more dynamic. The evolution of the game is exceeding the speed BW was evolving at in its prime. In the end, even with HotS Blizzard does know what it's doing. We complained about the same stuff when WoL was in beta. Those problems are gone now. Blizzard will stay. And we will enjoy it. | ||
|
Cereb
Denmark3388 Posts
In truth the game is incredibly successful, loved by millions of people and there is a development team who cares deeply about it and will continue to for many many years after it has been released. I'm all for contructive critism but being a prophet of the end times and why everything is/will be horrible doesn't really add anything. Just say your critism and get out. No need to be depressed drama queen about it. This leads into my argumentation against your idea about a costum game made by "the community". The expression "The community" is used waaay too loosely. I noticed this especially on the SC2 talkshow. They always go like "The community feels/reacted/blahblah.. this". No. This so called community is just a whole bunch of people who all play SC2. However, everyone has vastly different opinions and ideas about everything! Sometimes there are tendencies in what people say but there is no way in hell you could gather up all the many many SC2 fans and have them agree on what the game should look like. This is the case even just looking at teamliquid! If you look at the entire audience of SC2 it becomes even more ridiculous. I can garuentee that even if you gather some of the most noteable figures and RTS-minded people of "the community", there would still be an overhelming amount of critique on what they could produce just because that is what happens when you have a huge group of people in a public forum like this. They are not gonna agree on everything. | ||
|
Scila
Canada1849 Posts
| ||
|
wcr.4fun
Belgium686 Posts
On September 11 2012 23:32 HardlyNever wrote: 1. The "dissatisfaction" with the game is far from wide spread and unanimous across the player base, like you make it sound. This is is the internet, and more specifically TL, where everything that isn't Brood War is complete dog shit and every other poster knows exactly how to make the perfect RTS, just for some reason no one will hire them to do it. I'm by no means saying SC2 is perfect, or that every one likes the game. What I am saying is that the game continues to grow, and that wouldn't happen if a large percentage of people didn't like the game the way it is, overall. Don't read too much into the hate. 2. Blizzard has deliberately made it very hard to eliminate them from the equation that is Starcraft 2. I believe the primary purpose for this was to prevent something like what Kespa did to them in BW (basically completely muscle them out of the pro scene in Korea, meaning little to no profit for Blizzard). You will always have to play on Battle.net and therefore Blizzard has some legal and practical control over what you are doing. Yes, in theory you could set up an alternate ladder on BNET through custom games, but if you think that is going to take off vs. the very easy to hit "find match" button,you have a lot to learn about how people play video games. Even if somehow an alternate version/ladder of the game did become very popular, Blizzard could still exert its will on the scene if it wanted to. 3. Balancing a game like this is actually very hard to do, and Blizzard has the best resources/access to do this. Again, this is TL, where most people will argue that they are doing a "horrible" job at this, but since every race thinks the game is imba, they may actually be doing something right. Trying to seriously balance an RTS with only a few thousand players with no back-end access to data (although you might be able to get to this via really well made custom maps) is a monstrous challenge, even for dedicated players. Most people have jobs and don't have any intentions of becoming a game designer. Most other people are still students. I mean this is just so wrong on so many levels, my blood absolutely boils when I see this type of comment. I've seen it quite a lot these days, especially from sc2 fan boys who think sc2 is heaven. In the meantime zvp and zvt are no rush 14 minutes with broodlord infestor every game. And zvz is roach or ultra fest. And so on... On September 12 2012 03:39 Energizer wrote: And its posts like these that make people infuriated at the ignorance many people seem to have. BW - when it was largely supported - was vastly larger than sc2 across the spectrum (even in game sales YTD). To assume sc2 is currently larger than bw in its golden times is just ludicrous. The problem with most fanboys of sc2, is that they have this "move over" attitude about bw and refuse to give any respect to the game or what it represented. Its a shame, at the end of the day we all love starcraft and this is why we all complain about sc2... not because we dont like the game, but because we want it to be better than how it is currently. Sad to say it seems the game's own popularity is crushing sc2 due to it trying to be split amoungst many different areas - casual friendly, competitve game, esports cash cow, etc... These people also don't realize 15 years ago was a complete different time. People barely had cellphones. Not everyone had pc's. Gaming wasn't considered as normal as it was now and so many other factors to include. Bw didn't even have replays when it first came out. These people are so ignorant it hurts my brain and makes me want to throw stuff around. And not to mention BW is still massively more popular than sc2 in korea and sc2's future was very uncertain although it's starting to look a bit brighter with kespa finally joining in (only for the money). | ||
| ||