
I do agree on some level and have been disappointed in some of the decisions they have made, but as a whole I like SC2 and there is no other RTS game out there that really compares.
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
p1cKLes
United States342 Posts
![]() I do agree on some level and have been disappointed in some of the decisions they have made, but as a whole I like SC2 and there is no other RTS game out there that really compares. | ||
|
Deleted User 135096
3624 Posts
On September 12 2012 03:47 Antylamon wrote: I say we trust Blizz until they announce the last balance patch of LotV. That is when custom maps should be experimented with. I'm just going to point out that if we stay on relative track timewise with current releases, LotV won't be officially out until close to 2015-16. Food for thought... | ||
|
[UoN]Sentinel
United States11320 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:16 wcr.4fun wrote: Show nested quote + On September 11 2012 23:32 HardlyNever wrote: 1. The "dissatisfaction" with the game is far from wide spread and unanimous across the player base, like you make it sound. This is is the internet, and more specifically TL, where everything that isn't Brood War is complete dog shit and every other poster knows exactly how to make the perfect RTS, just for some reason no one will hire them to do it. I'm by no means saying SC2 is perfect, or that every one likes the game. What I am saying is that the game continues to grow, and that wouldn't happen if a large percentage of people didn't like the game the way it is, overall. Don't read too much into the hate. 2. Blizzard has deliberately made it very hard to eliminate them from the equation that is Starcraft 2. I believe the primary purpose for this was to prevent something like what Kespa did to them in BW (basically completely muscle them out of the pro scene in Korea, meaning little to no profit for Blizzard). You will always have to play on Battle.net and therefore Blizzard has some legal and practical control over what you are doing. Yes, in theory you could set up an alternate ladder on BNET through custom games, but if you think that is going to take off vs. the very easy to hit "find match" button,you have a lot to learn about how people play video games. Even if somehow an alternate version/ladder of the game did become very popular, Blizzard could still exert its will on the scene if it wanted to. 3. Balancing a game like this is actually very hard to do, and Blizzard has the best resources/access to do this. Again, this is TL, where most people will argue that they are doing a "horrible" job at this, but since every race thinks the game is imba, they may actually be doing something right. Trying to seriously balance an RTS with only a few thousand players with no back-end access to data (although you might be able to get to this via really well made custom maps) is a monstrous challenge, even for dedicated players. Most people have jobs and don't have any intentions of becoming a game designer. Most other people are still students. I mean this is just so wrong on so many levels, my blood absolutely boils when I see this type of comment. I've seen it quite a lot these days, especially from sc2 fan boys who think sc2 is heaven. In the meantime zvp and zvt are no rush 14 minutes with broodlord infestor every game. And zvz is roach or ultra fest. And so on... BW PvT is a drawn out battle between tier 1 gateway units with arbiters versus mech every game. TvT is a mech fest. These kinds of things would be nigh impossible to fix once the infrastructure is in place. What is your point? | ||
|
Silencioseu
Cyprus493 Posts
| ||
|
SmileZerg
United States543 Posts
Good job missing the fucking point. | ||
|
Antylamon
United States1981 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:18 wo1fwood wrote: Show nested quote + On September 12 2012 03:47 Antylamon wrote: I say we trust Blizz until they announce the last balance patch of LotV. That is when custom maps should be experimented with. I'm just going to point out that if we stay on relative track timewise with current releases, LotV won't be officially out until close to 2015-16. Food for thought... Well, the BW scene lasted 13 years if I recall correctly, so we have 9 left to go after that. | ||
|
wcr.4fun
Belgium686 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:19 [UoN]Sentinel wrote: Show nested quote + On September 12 2012 05:16 wcr.4fun wrote: On September 11 2012 23:32 HardlyNever wrote: 1. The "dissatisfaction" with the game is far from wide spread and unanimous across the player base, like you make it sound. This is is the internet, and more specifically TL, where everything that isn't Brood War is complete dog shit and every other poster knows exactly how to make the perfect RTS, just for some reason no one will hire them to do it. I'm by no means saying SC2 is perfect, or that every one likes the game. What I am saying is that the game continues to grow, and that wouldn't happen if a large percentage of people didn't like the game the way it is, overall. Don't read too much into the hate. 2. Blizzard has deliberately made it very hard to eliminate them from the equation that is Starcraft 2. I believe the primary purpose for this was to prevent something like what Kespa did to them in BW (basically completely muscle them out of the pro scene in Korea, meaning little to no profit for Blizzard). You will always have to play on Battle.net and therefore Blizzard has some legal and practical control over what you are doing. Yes, in theory you could set up an alternate ladder on BNET through custom games, but if you think that is going to take off vs. the very easy to hit "find match" button,you have a lot to learn about how people play video games. Even if somehow an alternate version/ladder of the game did become very popular, Blizzard could still exert its will on the scene if it wanted to. 3. Balancing a game like this is actually very hard to do, and Blizzard has the best resources/access to do this. Again, this is TL, where most people will argue that they are doing a "horrible" job at this, but since every race thinks the game is imba, they may actually be doing something right. Trying to seriously balance an RTS with only a few thousand players with no back-end access to data (although you might be able to get to this via really well made custom maps) is a monstrous challenge, even for dedicated players. Most people have jobs and don't have any intentions of becoming a game designer. Most other people are still students. I mean this is just so wrong on so many levels, my blood absolutely boils when I see this type of comment. I've seen it quite a lot these days, especially from sc2 fan boys who think sc2 is heaven. In the meantime zvp and zvt are no rush 14 minutes with broodlord infestor every game. And zvz is roach or ultra fest. And so on... BW PvT is a drawn out battle between tier 1 gateway units with arbiters versus mech every game. TvT is a mech fest. These kinds of things would be nigh impossible to fix once the infrastructure is in place. What is your point? Bw pvt has a lot of carrier play. And I find bw PvT a lot of fun to watch. Reavers, spider mines, recall, storms are a lot more fun to watch than fungal and broodlings. TvT is the same, its a lot more fun to watch. Sc2 is boring to watch, brood war is fun to watch. That's my point. As a zerg player, I simply stopped playing because I could only win with broodlord infestor and it's the most boring playstyle ever. When I did watch a few games of zvx again, I just skip the first 12 minutes, check the resource lost and see something along the lines of 200 - 300. lol The other match ups aren't even better, although tvt has some enjoyable games. | ||
|
SoniC_eu
Denmark1008 Posts
| ||
|
NotSorry
United States6722 Posts
On September 11 2012 18:00 BlackPanther wrote: This post is short sighted and desperate. WE NEED BLIZZARD TO GROW ESPORTS! They have the money and the manpower to do it. Trying to come up with workarounds to please BW fans nostalgia and separation anxiety will not help fix our problems. No we don't, blizzard never did anything for BW besides come back 10years later and try to get a pay day for something they put no effort into creating. The community built Esports not blizzard or any other game developer. | ||
|
[UoN]Sentinel
United States11320 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:25 wcr.4fun wrote: Show nested quote + On September 12 2012 05:19 [UoN]Sentinel wrote: On September 12 2012 05:16 wcr.4fun wrote: On September 11 2012 23:32 HardlyNever wrote: 1. The "dissatisfaction" with the game is far from wide spread and unanimous across the player base, like you make it sound. This is is the internet, and more specifically TL, where everything that isn't Brood War is complete dog shit and every other poster knows exactly how to make the perfect RTS, just for some reason no one will hire them to do it. I'm by no means saying SC2 is perfect, or that every one likes the game. What I am saying is that the game continues to grow, and that wouldn't happen if a large percentage of people didn't like the game the way it is, overall. Don't read too much into the hate. 2. Blizzard has deliberately made it very hard to eliminate them from the equation that is Starcraft 2. I believe the primary purpose for this was to prevent something like what Kespa did to them in BW (basically completely muscle them out of the pro scene in Korea, meaning little to no profit for Blizzard). You will always have to play on Battle.net and therefore Blizzard has some legal and practical control over what you are doing. Yes, in theory you could set up an alternate ladder on BNET through custom games, but if you think that is going to take off vs. the very easy to hit "find match" button,you have a lot to learn about how people play video games. Even if somehow an alternate version/ladder of the game did become very popular, Blizzard could still exert its will on the scene if it wanted to. 3. Balancing a game like this is actually very hard to do, and Blizzard has the best resources/access to do this. Again, this is TL, where most people will argue that they are doing a "horrible" job at this, but since every race thinks the game is imba, they may actually be doing something right. Trying to seriously balance an RTS with only a few thousand players with no back-end access to data (although you might be able to get to this via really well made custom maps) is a monstrous challenge, even for dedicated players. Most people have jobs and don't have any intentions of becoming a game designer. Most other people are still students. I mean this is just so wrong on so many levels, my blood absolutely boils when I see this type of comment. I've seen it quite a lot these days, especially from sc2 fan boys who think sc2 is heaven. In the meantime zvp and zvt are no rush 14 minutes with broodlord infestor every game. And zvz is roach or ultra fest. And so on... BW PvT is a drawn out battle between tier 1 gateway units with arbiters versus mech every game. TvT is a mech fest. These kinds of things would be nigh impossible to fix once the infrastructure is in place. What is your point? Bw pvt has a lot of carrier play. And I find bw PvT a lot of fun to watch. Reavers, spider mines, recall, storms are a lot more fun to watch than fungal and broodlings. TvT is the same, its a lot more fun to watch. Sc2 is boring to watch, brood war is fun to watch. That's my point. As a zerg player, I simply stopped playing because I could only win with broodlord infestor and it's the most boring playstyle ever. When I did watch a few games of zvx again, I just skip the first 12 minutes, check the resource lost and see something along the lines of 200 - 300. lol The other match ups aren't even better, although tvt has some enjoyable games. I want to know how you play ZvZ without losing units in the first twelve minutes. Speaking of which, weren't most Brood War ZvZ's extremely short matches involving a total of two units - zergling and mutalisks, and maybe scourge if you were lucky? TvT in Brood War I have to disagree with you though - all the games I watched, or at least 90% of them, were chess matches. I couldn't sit through one without skipping ahead, ever. PvP is actually very enjoyable in SC2. Mix things up and go 1 gate stargate against a 3 gate robo, and you'll have the time of your life that game. | ||
|
wcr.4fun
Belgium686 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:32 [UoN]Sentinel wrote: Show nested quote + On September 12 2012 05:25 wcr.4fun wrote: On September 12 2012 05:19 [UoN]Sentinel wrote: On September 12 2012 05:16 wcr.4fun wrote: On September 11 2012 23:32 HardlyNever wrote: 1. The "dissatisfaction" with the game is far from wide spread and unanimous across the player base, like you make it sound. This is is the internet, and more specifically TL, where everything that isn't Brood War is complete dog shit and every other poster knows exactly how to make the perfect RTS, just for some reason no one will hire them to do it. I'm by no means saying SC2 is perfect, or that every one likes the game. What I am saying is that the game continues to grow, and that wouldn't happen if a large percentage of people didn't like the game the way it is, overall. Don't read too much into the hate. 2. Blizzard has deliberately made it very hard to eliminate them from the equation that is Starcraft 2. I believe the primary purpose for this was to prevent something like what Kespa did to them in BW (basically completely muscle them out of the pro scene in Korea, meaning little to no profit for Blizzard). You will always have to play on Battle.net and therefore Blizzard has some legal and practical control over what you are doing. Yes, in theory you could set up an alternate ladder on BNET through custom games, but if you think that is going to take off vs. the very easy to hit "find match" button,you have a lot to learn about how people play video games. Even if somehow an alternate version/ladder of the game did become very popular, Blizzard could still exert its will on the scene if it wanted to. 3. Balancing a game like this is actually very hard to do, and Blizzard has the best resources/access to do this. Again, this is TL, where most people will argue that they are doing a "horrible" job at this, but since every race thinks the game is imba, they may actually be doing something right. Trying to seriously balance an RTS with only a few thousand players with no back-end access to data (although you might be able to get to this via really well made custom maps) is a monstrous challenge, even for dedicated players. Most people have jobs and don't have any intentions of becoming a game designer. Most other people are still students. I mean this is just so wrong on so many levels, my blood absolutely boils when I see this type of comment. I've seen it quite a lot these days, especially from sc2 fan boys who think sc2 is heaven. In the meantime zvp and zvt are no rush 14 minutes with broodlord infestor every game. And zvz is roach or ultra fest. And so on... BW PvT is a drawn out battle between tier 1 gateway units with arbiters versus mech every game. TvT is a mech fest. These kinds of things would be nigh impossible to fix once the infrastructure is in place. What is your point? Bw pvt has a lot of carrier play. And I find bw PvT a lot of fun to watch. Reavers, spider mines, recall, storms are a lot more fun to watch than fungal and broodlings. TvT is the same, its a lot more fun to watch. Sc2 is boring to watch, brood war is fun to watch. That's my point. As a zerg player, I simply stopped playing because I could only win with broodlord infestor and it's the most boring playstyle ever. When I did watch a few games of zvx again, I just skip the first 12 minutes, check the resource lost and see something along the lines of 200 - 300. lol The other match ups aren't even better, although tvt has some enjoyable games. I want to know how you play ZvZ without losing units in the first twelve minutes. Speaking of which, weren't most Brood War ZvZ's extremely short matches involving a total of two units - zergling and mutalisks, and maybe scourge if you were lucky? TvT in Brood War I have to disagree with you though - all the games I watched, or at least 90% of them, were chess matches. I couldn't sit through one without skipping ahead, ever. PvP is actually very enjoyable in SC2. Mix things up and go 1 gate stargate against a 3 gate robo, and you'll have the time of your life that game. I didn't mean to include zvz. You are right. ZvZ is actually one of the more fun match ups to watch, because stuff still happens. But then again it isn't that interesting, because the roach and infestor are just too good. Although I liked seeing ling into ultra's for awhile, if you've got ultra's going, they're seemingly unstoppable... And I don't bother a lot with PvP games because most of them I saw, were 4 gate or ended up in war of the worlds. Collussus is imo still a unit that has ruined a lot of match ups... I'm not saying I can't enjoy sc2, or that I hate sc2, but I want more units that add to the entertainment aspect. More units with potential for micro. | ||
|
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On September 11 2012 20:23 10734 wrote: Show nested quote + On September 11 2012 19:54 NeonFox wrote: + Show Spoiler + On September 11 2012 19:50 Dalavita wrote: Show nested quote + On September 11 2012 19:17 NeonFox wrote: I'm kind of sick of people keeping making that argument. People bitched about sc2 during the beta, and now the game is amazing. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but sometimes it seems that saying you prefer sc2 over BW is like spitting on your grandma and raping babies. SC2 is far from amazing. It could have been amazing, but Blizzard lacks the competence to make it truly good. The reason BW got so much respect and love was because the game was absolutely hard. For the wrong reasons maybe, but the game allowed for the best of the best to truly shine, and everyone else had to practice hard to even keep up. SC2? Not so much. Instead of fixing the UI issues of BW while keeping the high skill ceiling and diversity of the units Blizzard simplified every unit to the point where the games end up incredibly stale and predictable, and they nerf with an iron fist everything that seems like it will deviate from their plans. SC2 is one dimensional, and it's not nearly as hard as it should be, and that's not from a mechanical standpoint, but rather a tactical and unit one. Also, Blizzards balancing is an insult to everything that requires skill and hard work. They nerf entire races because people are doing well to keep an artificial 50% win rate across the board. That's your opinion. I like SC2 a lot more than BW. edit : spoiler tags I never reallly got into BW too, but aren't you getting tired of similar games? When people play standard in TvP/TvZ I just alt tab and go do something else, the games all feel exactly the same. TvT is the only matchup that I think is fun to watch, there's so much diversity in openings and non-stop action. I've watched maybe 15-20 BW games, so I can't tell if it's the game or just me. Now that I think about it, I tried watching DotA2/LoL for a bit but thought it was boring, I guess I'm just not a fan of eSports. You must not watch much or pay attention because Tvz and PvZ arent remotely similar. I am shocked this garbage wasn't deleted though. | ||
|
renaissanceMAN
United States1840 Posts
On September 11 2012 22:19 Diks wrote: This thread reminded me this : http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=117987 One of the major problem of having such a thing is the community being split in half EDIT : This was on april fool's day in case you weren't there at the time. Having come from a community in which is occurred, I will say that we need Blizzard's support. Call of Duty had an amazing run for the first two games, COD went to the CPL, COD2 went to the WSVG, aside from some in-game issues that were being tackled by the incredibly dedicated mod team, the game was on track to become the next major FPS esport. Then COD4 was announced, and everything was put on hold, not to get bogged down in the fact that this was the point that ports (i.e. the game was built for xbox and ported for PC) took over the design, COD4 was released, and so broken that "competitive" play was almost impossible. So what did the community do? They invented pro-mod, which removed all of the casualness from the game, and the community become split between the casual gamers and the "pros." The result? Sure there were a couple of high-paying tournaments, but the scene quickly fractured more and more as those in charge of the modding became less and less interested in perfecting their mod, and the differences between pro-mod and the regular (straight install) version of the game became greater and greater. It floundered so hard, that what could have been the next CS series, became a joke of the PC-gaming world. (note: it also didn't help that activision/iw/etc. released a new COD every 1.5 years.) We need Blizzard to make the all-encompassing decisions that "leaders" of the community simply cannot make. Obviously Blizzard is doing more to promote the growth of esports than Activision and IW (the company that made COD) did, but the simple fact remains: we need them. This is a different game than BW, than WC3, all of you coming from those games are never going to be satisfied because you're mired in the "success" that those games had. May I remind you that SC2 is one of the biggest games ever, with a long and continuing history of successful tournaments. BW/WC3 didn't have half of the $ going into it that SC2 does. Blizzard is well aware of the legacy of BW/WC3 and are working to make sure that WOL/HoTS live up to that legacy. At least try to put aside your biases in terms of comparing how "good" BW/WC3 were/are to SC2, when discussing a topic like this... | ||
|
YMCApylons
Taiwan359 Posts
At this point, we need someone else to make a serious RTS to keep Blizzard honest. | ||
|
p1cKLes
United States342 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:43 YMCApylons wrote: Agreed.If Valve makes a pro-gaming friendly RTS, I'd be all over that. At this point, we need someone else to make a serious RTS to keep Blizzard honest. | ||
|
SpiZe
Canada3640 Posts
Ok then, if the community isn't to be relied upon, then who ? Only the higher level players ? Ok fine, who's the higher level players ? Masters ? GM ? Pro ? For the sake of that argument let's say the pros have the decisional power over SC2. Your going to end up with a huge bias problem. They play the game for money which means their career will be affected by the decisions they make. If a suggestion is made that is more harmful to X race (not even talking balance, but a change in design) than the other two, then what is the pro that is playing X race for living gonna say. If he accepts it will put him at a disadvantage and might hurt his career. It is much easier for him to say no. The proof of this is asking the pros about balance right now, Terran player : TvZ is horrible, if zerg manages to get to late game, game is over. It's impossible to put pressure on a zerg blablabla. Zerg player : I believe ZvT is fine, terran still has plenty of options to harass the zerg and I believe the better player wins. So this leads me to believe that the community as a whole cannot be trusted. Our only way to change SC2's gameplay is through good and diverse maps and discovery of new playstyle and openings, as it always has. Last point is, you can't get rid of Blizzard if you want to run tournaments, they made sure of that. | ||
|
Yoshi Kirishima
United States10383 Posts
Also most of the changes you talked about... is pretty much just BW o.o you can play SC2 BW already... and not everyone would agree with those changes. But I understand those are just examples, so anyways... there would be too many versions and not enough people to play each one. The community would be split and it wouldn't be any fun. We need blizzard basically. And it's not like they're not reading/listening to our suggestions, they might be slow, but they do listen. I'm always amazed at how well they do listen. And sometimes they seem to listen but refute it; but I agree with those refutations. | ||
|
Terran5
Germany41 Posts
On September 12 2012 05:43 YMCApylons wrote: If Valve makes a pro-gaming friendly RTS, I'd be all over that. At this point, we need someone else to make a serious RTS to keep Blizzard honest. Valve only makes terrible Casualgame with Comic-Graphics. User was temp banned for this post. | ||
|
wcr.4fun
Belgium686 Posts
| ||
|
NiKoJa
26 Posts
| ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games |
|
The PondCast
University League
LiuLi Cup
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
Replay Cast
GSL
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
OSC
Replay Cast
KCM Race Survival
[ Show More ] Ultimate Battle
ZerO vs Bisu
RSL Revival
BSL
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
IPSL
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
WardiTV Weekly
Kung Fu Cup
Solar vs Classic
ByuN vs SHIN
PiGosaur Cup
|
|
|