On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about.
It's perspective. For the people that hate SC2, they associate with other people who hate the game, read threads bashing the game, and in general are caught up in that drama. Therefore, it starts to appear to them that nearly everyone must really dislike SC2.
In reality, like you said, SC2 is very very popular, has a huge pro-scene and is enjoyed by many thousands of players every day.
The pessimistic, whiny types will always be the most vocal though, so it tends to skew the way things are perceived.
I think the problem with giving the community the creating and balancing of the games are:
a) Only Blizzard has the ability and power to balance the game well enough for a winratio near 50% at high levels. I don't think any person from the community can balance everything without being making mistakes, doing stupid changes and being biased.
b) Most people and professionals simply stick to the normal melee that blizzard offers, and not some custom mode. It would be extremely difficult and even nearly impossible to transition into playing professionally on a mode.
On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about.
It's perspective. For the people that hate SC2, they associate with other people who hate the game, read threads bashing the game, and in general are caught up in that drama. Therefore, it starts to appear to them that nearly everyone must really dislike SC2.
In reality, like you said, SC2 is very very popular, has a huge pro-scene and is enjoyed by many thousands of players every day.
The pessimistic, whiny types will always be the most vocal though, so it tends to skew the way things are perceived.
This pretty much hits the nail on the head. SC2 is doing well, getting more people in would be difficult.
On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about.
This. Many people dont realize that Sc2 is already bigger now then Bw was in gold BW times , numbers or players playing , numbers of tournaments , prizes etc etc , its all bigger then in BW. And im not some Bw hater , I love BW , but Sc 2 is bigger and its a fact.
Sc 2 has only 2 years.. BW has 13 ? realize that..., how someone can write that SC 2 is not that big succes etc . it dont even got one expansion.
I think blizzard is doing a solid job with sc 2 and esports. I think they just don't want community input, they want to have a say in everything that happens. WoL at the end was pretty good, while it still has issues and stuff, the game is going to be changing for a very long time.
When will people realize that there cannot be an comparisation by the fanbase between SC:BW and SC2 ? When BW was at its prime there were only a few tournaments, WCG outside Korea.
SC2 Fan's has been spoiled with Stream's, Tournaments every weekend. OFC there will be more fans of SC2?
IMO i think SC2 sux cuz they made it as noobfriendly that even my grandma can hit diamond
On September 11 2012 17:16 nakedsurfer wrote: I don't understand this thread. You say it's a beautiful game and then proceed in saying we should all just fuckin ditch blizzard and change shit up. If it's so beautiful, why would you feel the need to get rid of the makers? Why would you want to change the game so drastically that it would feel like a completely different game called SC:BW?
I also don't understand why the need for all these "fuck sc2 lets go to BW" threads. It's getting quite annoying seeing all these threads pop up. It just might have something in relation to all Kespa related things are officially SC2 now...
I'm reading the first page of this thread and OP stated he did not play BW and nowhere in his post could I find "Let's go back to BW."
Back on topic: I admire the OP's idealism. I am just too jaded to be enthusiastic about your passion.
Edit: By the page 2 - Oh geez. It has already turned to one of those threads. I feel sorry for the OP.
On September 11 2012 17:16 nakedsurfer wrote: I don't understand this thread. You say it's a beautiful game and then proceed in saying we should all just fuckin ditch blizzard and change shit up. If it's so beautiful, why would you feel the need to get rid of the makers? Why would you want to change the game so drastically that it would feel like a completely different game called SC:BW?
I also don't understand why the need for all these "fuck sc2 lets go to BW" threads. It's getting quite annoying seeing all these threads pop up. It just might have something in relation to all Kespa related things are officially SC2 now...
I'm reading the first page of this thread and OP stated he did not play BW and nowhere in his post could I find "Let's go back to BW." .
"If we work together to make the game something that we all can like, we shan't be stopped. Hell, if Blizzard shuts down the server, try to shift the community right back to BW."
On September 11 2012 17:16 nakedsurfer wrote: I don't understand this thread. You say it's a beautiful game and then proceed in saying we should all just fuckin ditch blizzard and change shit up. If it's so beautiful, why would you feel the need to get rid of the makers? Why would you want to change the game so drastically that it would feel like a completely different game called SC:BW?
I also don't understand why the need for all these "fuck sc2 lets go to BW" threads. It's getting quite annoying seeing all these threads pop up. It just might have something in relation to all Kespa related things are officially SC2 now...
I'm reading the first page of this thread and OP stated he did not play BW and nowhere in his post could I find "Let's go back to BW." .
"If we work together to make the game something that we all can like, we shan't be stopped. Hell, if Blizzard shuts down the server, try to shift the community right back to BW."
Seriously...
OK I missed that part but I did not interpret the OP's post as "SC2 sucks so let's make a SC:BW 3D." Comparison w/ BW isn't the OP's focal point, by his lack of knowlege of BW that he acknowledged.
On September 11 2012 23:49 HeeroFX wrote: I think blizzard is doing a solid job with sc 2 and esports. I think they just don't want community input, they want to have a say in everything that happens. WoL at the end was pretty good, while it still has issues and stuff, the game is going to be changing for a very long time.
I don't think they don't want input. I just think that they don't treat input the way some people with "I have a great"-idea attidudes would want them to treat. I mean, TL is only one place were they will get their information from. Just step over to the b.net forums and have a look what people demand there, it is often times quite different from TL-elitism. And then they surely have people from marketing on their design team that will listen to what "average joe that stopped playing WoL"'s reasons are not to play more. And what "ah yeah starcraft, I heard of that game"'s reasons are not to try it. And out of all this different stuff, they have to make units that fit the game and the (potential) players demands.
On September 11 2012 23:17 Barrin wrote: LET THE FIRE BURN WITHIN THINE HEARTS! lol So glad ppl are keeping this possibility alive :>
No, we don't need Blizzard. Yes, we do need someone to rival Blizzard in the RTS genre. Big companies are not interested in the RTS genre most likely because the casual/hardcore dichotomy is particularly strong. If we want Brood War 2.0, we need to make it ourselves. We're hardcore after all aren't we?
---
This is what I'm looking for
Significantly less 'mineral' income relative to max supply and unit/building costs/supplies.
More difficult mechanics to (more than) compensate for less income (more income = harder to manage).
A focus on making each basic fighting unit interesting with a high potential for multiplying it's unmicro'd strength in an elegant way.
A focus on "area-controlling" units that take time to set up - think Lurkers, BW Tanks, Spider Mines, Burrowed Banelings, Widow Mines, etc.
A focus on making spells extremely powerful - across all races.
A focus on making many unit combinations work well together in non-obvious ways.
In relation to SC2, in general units should have slightly higher hp (or do less damage) and have higher vision, range, and collision radii in relation to movement speed.
A fucking high ground mechanic please.
No mechanics that remove the defender's advantage *eyeballs Warpgate*.
Other than these things I don't really care about any certain unit or it's behavior. I don't want BW anymore, and with just a little bit of imagination you can see that BW is only one of many ways of conforming to the above list. This is just good RTS design philosophy if you want to facilitate deep/rich/complex/dynamic gameplay. If you tell me to just go play BW I will eSlap you.
---
We have two choices really. Do we create a whole new company or do we just go with a Promod? Someone's gotta step up to the plate, and it's up to them how far they wanna take it. I think someone with ambition would make a whole new company.
If we were to make a promod that conforms to the above list it would be such a drastically different game (some units don't even make the cut) that we might as well make our own game. What it comes down to is that SC2 as it is now (and as it will probably be in the foreseeable future) is just too much unlike the kind of deep game we're after to the point that most people who play SC2 as it is now would not (and often already do not) like or even understand the kind of gameplay we're after. Many of the kinds of people who appreciate the gameplay we're after quit SC2 a while ago and never looked back. We need a new player base IMO.
Perhaps a promod is feasible, I just feel like it will only ever be feasible as a shadow of what it should be. Maybe I'll get over that and make it myself someday.
BTW right now we have two things that are kinda like this (but not close enough IMO): a mod called SC2BW and a mod called STARBOW.
What are the chances we can get Valve to make BW2 or some shit?
A major fucking lawsuit of Blizzard the instant they announced it...
SC2 isn't completely figured out yet, especially with the new expansion coming out. The metagame may shift to focus on more skill-oriented things (who knows). That said though, I don't want SC2 to turn out like BW (yes I did play BW); if I wanted that, I would just load up BW. SC2 is a different game. I think Blizzard will eventually head in the right track.
However, I do think some things they are doing to try to make the game easier are unnecessary (such as showing worker count tooltips and auto mining at the beginning <which is good for people who lag at the beginning I guess>). But do we need Blizzard? Probably. I might not agree with all of their decisions, but all in all SC2 is a great game.
Blizzard has given one of the most intricate map editors for any game to date, and here is our way to take the game into our own hands. We can remove Colossus, and replace them with Reavers. We can buff Hydras, and let them morph into Lurkers. We don't need to keep the Warhound, we can add a Goliath and try to modify the Thor. We can make Carriers good. We can make Widow Mines good, yet something deep within me says that Spider Mines should not be introduced. The maps, we can finally make our own map pools, and put our map making teams on the forefront, rather than on the wayside.
This already happend. It's called SC2BW and it's available as a custom map on all servers
Havnt played sc2bw in a while but I doubt its very balanced.. If this is to work we need a balanced game, with loads of support that can lead to tournament play. If we get tourney play (for real money) it can work.
On September 11 2012 17:31 Krystal wrote: As much as I absolutely LOVE this concept, and that it's now being freely discussed. I can't see this worked unless there were some dedicated Pros who were committed to help balance/promote the project. And unfortunately, we have to remember their income comes from major tournaments, and those tournaments won't be able to use a mod of Blizzard originals game.
I didn't realise DoTA wasn't a mod, wow!
Seriously, go back to BW if you dont like SC2 as much or play one of those mods on SC2, quit whining.
On September 11 2012 23:17 Barrin wrote: LET THE FIRE BURN WITHIN THINE HEARTS! lol So glad ppl are keeping this possibility alive :>
No, we don't need Blizzard. Yes, we do need someone to rival Blizzard in the RTS genre. Big companies are not interested in the RTS genre most likely because the casual/hardcore dichotomy is particularly strong. If we want Brood War 2.0, we need to make it ourselves. We're hardcore after all aren't we?
---
This is what I'm looking for
Significantly less 'mineral' income relative to max supply and unit/building costs/supplies.
More difficult mechanics to (more than) compensate for less income (more income = harder to manage).
A focus on making each basic fighting unit interesting with a high potential for multiplying it's unmicro'd strength in an elegant way.
A focus on "area-controlling" units that take time to set up - think Lurkers, BW Tanks, Spider Mines, Burrowed Banelings, Widow Mines, etc.
A focus on making spells extremely powerful - across all races.
A focus on making many unit combinations work well together in non-obvious ways.
In relation to SC2, in general units should have slightly higher hp (or do less damage) and have higher vision, range, and collision radii in relation to movement speed.
A fucking high ground mechanic please.
No mechanics that remove the defender's advantage *eyeballs Warpgate*.
Other than these things I don't really care about any certain unit or it's behavior. I don't want BW anymore, and with just a little bit of imagination you can see that BW is only one of many ways of conforming to the above list. This is just good RTS design philosophy if you want to facilitate deep/rich/complex/dynamic gameplay. If you tell me to just go play BW I will eSlap you.
---
We have two choices really. Do we create a whole new company or do we just go with a Promod? Someone's gotta step up to the plate, and it's up to them how far they wanna take it. I think someone with ambition would make a whole new company.
If we were to make a promod that conforms to the above list it would be such a drastically different game (some units don't even make the cut) that we might as well make our own game. What it comes down to is that SC2 as it is now (and as it will probably be in the foreseeable future) is just too much unlike the kind of deep game we're after to the point that most people who play SC2 as it is now would not (and often already do not) like or even understand the kind of gameplay we're after. Many of the kinds of people who appreciate the gameplay we're after quit SC2 a while ago and never looked back. We need a new player base IMO.
Perhaps a promod is feasible, I just feel like it will only ever be feasible as a shadow of what it should be. Maybe I'll get over that and make it myself someday.
BTW right now we have two things that are kinda like this (but not close enough IMO): a mod called SC2BW and a mod called STARBOW.
What are the chances we can get Valve to make BW2 or some shit?
I still cant see why would valve make a good rts.
valve is more a online publisher then game developer for years. They been feed on the same engine since 2004. only making games of same genre and of same ip. personally I only find tf2 successfull and playable for a long time. I can see the hype of half lifes and portals but... they dont really count for much if we are to credit them as best possible rts devolopment team out there.
I'm mean, if we gonna skip blizzard and put our trust for a remake of bw there is relic, gas powered games way before there is valve.
SC2 is a soulless game. The engine is great, but they made so many poor design decisions. To me, BW and SC2 are on par. Graphics, path-finding, ui and ladder-system are improved.
But the damage model is scaled down (not 3 size categories but damage + bonus damage against certain types). I really liked, how vultures lost hard against goons (until they swarmed them with mines) but obliterated every probe line.
Then there are some stupid design decisions limited to just one unit, e. g. the different speed multipliers on creep for hydralisks and roaches. I think such decisions are distortions.
Then, after release, Blizzard was still tinkering around (after more than 10 years of experience with BW) with the unit roles. Reapers, thors, void rays, ghosts, infestors all changed considerably, because they had basically no idea about their role.
Furthermore I don't agree on the balance policy. It's mainly about weakening successful strategies, rather than promoting alternative strategies. It led to invariability.
Bottom line: chance squandered to create a dominantly better successor. Instead we've got a great engine and online corporate socialism.
On September 11 2012 23:42 Adonminus wrote: I think the problem with giving the community the creating and balancing of the games are:
a) Only Blizzard has the ability and power to balance the game well enough for a winratio near 50% at high levels. I don't think any person from the community can balance everything without being making mistakes, doing stupid changes and being biased.
b) Most people and professionals simply stick to the normal melee that blizzard offers, and not some custom mode. It would be extremely difficult and even nearly impossible to transition into playing professionally on a mode.
a.) I don't think this is true. The game balances itself quite a bit with people learning to play and use their race effectively. Balance finds its way. Blizzard didn't balance BW to perfection. There was like 1 or 2 patches to it that really mattered and then the game was left on its own. And if you were to just look at BW at certain times it would seem extremely imbalanced, but over time people learned how to deal with things and exploit their own OP units. That's what happens when you make a game fun and competitive and have mechanics and micro with a high skill ceiling. Players change the way the game is played and balance shifts. With SC2, Blizzards problem is that they've focused so much on balance that the game is completely uninteresting. Units are lame for fear they would be OP otherwise. As soon as something seems OP it gets balanced. SC2 started out with a bunch of cool ideas that got balanced to hell before beta even started. If BW units made their way to SC2 they would have been nerfed right away. I am hopeful for the game though, especially with expansions. If anyone can do it, it's Blizz.
b.) This is true. Pros will play where the money is at and that will be SC2. We would only get community pros. The community would be isolated from the much larger SC2 community. I'm fine with that as I don't feel I belong in the SC2 community anymore anyways. At least not till HotS.
Blizzard has given one of the most intricate map editors for any game to date, and here is our way to take the game into our own hands. We can remove Colossus, and replace them with Reavers. We can buff Hydras, and let them morph into Lurkers. We don't need to keep the Warhound, we can add a Goliath and try to modify the Thor. We can make Carriers good. We can make Widow Mines good, yet something deep within me says that Spider Mines should not be introduced. The maps, we can finally make our own map pools, and put our map making teams on the forefront, rather than on the wayside.
This already happend. It's called SC2BW and it's available as a custom map on all servers
Yep, it's about the only SC2 I've played in the last year.