|
Starcraft II is the second most beautiful game I have ever experienced. Warcraft III was the game I got to grow up with, most of you grew up with BW I would guess, so for myself I consider my game to be the most beautiful, but I would be too young to actually realize what I had at my fingertips.
What is the reason that we love strategy games. Why do people love Broodwar, why do people love Warcraft 3? Why are DoTA and Counterstrike the most successful mods to grace this earth? Because people love to discover beauty in the complexity.
The amount of dissatisfaction with Starcraft 2 is staggering. Many reasons have been cited as to why this game does not give the same thrill as what has been played in the past. But, look, we have a map editor.
Do you want 6m1g bases? Do you want Lurkers? Do you want Reavers? Do you hate the Warhound? Do you want a Blademaster (probably only me...)?
Blizzard has given one of the most intricate map editors for any game to date, and here is our way to take the game into our own hands. We can remove Colossus, and replace them with Reavers. We can buff Hydras, and let them morph into Lurkers. We don't need to keep the Warhound, we can add a Goliath and try to modify the Thor. We can make Carriers good. We can make Widow Mines good, yet something deep within me says that Spider Mines should not be introduced. The maps, we can finally make our own map pools, and put our map making teams on the forefront, rather than on the wayside.
Most of the community is sick of hard counter type strategy. They don't like how if "I make unit X, the opponent can not make unit A, or B under any circumstance because I counter him too badly." This can be changed. Unit stats are very simple to change in the editor, making new units entirely is a bit more complicated, however it is possible. Just hark back to the STAGGERING amount of custom units in WC3 mods. I have made dozens upon dozens of new units with custom models and abilities in WC3, and since the SC2 editor is much stronger, why can't it be done with it?
Don't get me wrong, I love Starcraft 2 as a Terran player. Marine Tank TvT is much less about composition, but how hard you can outplay your opponent. You are limited only by your skill. I also love Marine Tank in TvZ, every composition is valid from Zerg, and the Terran composition is dynamic in it's own right. The better player wins, and the game is defined by how you use your units and not what units you made.
The community has proved before (without me, I'm a newbie) that they can keep a game alive without Blizzard. Teamliquid, iCCup (and various other servers/tournaments), Afreeca, all contributed to keeping Broodwar alive.
Many problems will arise, the lack of ability to ladder, the need to deal with terrible interfaces, the most terrible problem being that Blizzard will literally grip the entire community by the balls if they threaten to shut down servers. Yet, this website has been up since 2002 because of a passion for RTS.
If we work together to make the game something that we all can like, we shan't be stopped. Hell, if Blizzard shuts down the server, try to shift the community right back to BW.
+ Show Spoiler + It has also been a bit of a fantasy of mine to develop an RTS. But without any coding skills whatsoever, and no funding, it will be a fantasy for at least 5 more years.
|
Blizzard has given one of the most intricate map editors for any game to date, and here is our way to take the game into our own hands. We can remove Colossus, and replace them with Reavers. We can buff Hydras, and let them morph into Lurkers. We don't need to keep the Warhound, we can add a Goliath and try to modify the Thor. We can make Carriers good. We can make Widow Mines good, yet something deep within me says that Spider Mines should not be introduced. The maps, we can finally make our own map pools, and put our map making teams on the forefront, rather than on the wayside.
This already happend. It's called SC2BW and it's available as a custom map on all servers
|
Ladder if we cant play ladder and be playing the same game as the pro's their is going to be a huge problem. Untill something like iccup comes around (which blizzard wont let happen) we will be stuck with blizzard forever.
|
have you noticed the first signs that things were going downhill in blizzard games was when they merged with activision?
there are so many easy to use units in the game and now we get tempests and warhounds on top of it, what type of audience is blizzard targeting with these units?
Think about it...
|
Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about.
|
There was an attempt at a 3rd party ladder system, where you would register and then it would send replays automatically, and it had special maps. Blizzard shut it down after like 2-3 months. Unless there is a way for that one chinese client that allows for lan, and you can make a server off of that then sure. But how many people would play it?
|
So you're basically saying you want us to go back to BW? I'm all for making changes to SC2 but we shouldn't just go back to BW because we can't come up with new and better ideas.
|
Yeah man fight the power man. Why all these OMG LETS GO BACK TO BW threads all of a sudden >_<
|
The most amusing part is "if they shut down the SC2 server, we'll switch back to BW."
How the hell does that accomplish anything? If they shut us down, we don't get to play the game anymore? LOL.
Dude, if you want to play BW, go play it. It's not like you can't jump on iccup and still get a game.
|
On September 11 2012 17:02 Boblhead wrote: There was an attempt at a 3rd party ladder system, where you would register and then it would send replays automatically, and it had special maps. Blizzard shut it down after like 2-3 months. Unless there is a way for that one chinese client that allows for lan, and you can make a server off of that then sure. But how many people would play it?
That's already possible with starfriend.
|
You need money to host a tournament. If there's money, players will practice a certain map or ruleset, become good at it, just to try to win that money.
If you want to run a bizarro SC2BW custom map tournament, go right ahead.
|
On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about.
Much bigger following? That is true. In fact so do League of Legends, Call of Duty and a dozen Korean MMORPGs. The reason for popularity is that they cater to a wider audience and are marketed properly. How do you cater to a wider audience? By simplifying the game to the point where even casual gamers and newcomers to the genre can play it and not feel endlessly frustrated. Which brings me to my next point...
On September 11 2012 17:04 See.Blue wrote: Yeah man fight the power man. Why all these OMG LETS GO BACK TO BW threads all of a sudden >_<
These threads have been around here for quite a while buddy. The only reason there's a sudden increase in them is becase with the current build of Heart of the Swarm, more specifically the way the Warhound and Tempest are designed, Blizzard is telling the more hardcore fans and players to go fuck themselves. At least that's the way I feel, and obviously you are entitled to your own opinion/disagreeing with mine.
If Blizzard spent more time learning how to make interesting units that have a more interesting synergy together beyond just "make this composition and go" (where could they learn that from... I hear there was a good Blizzard RTS that had all the things mentioned before... hmm) and less time rehashing CnC concepts and units, I would be more than content with SC2.
|
I don't understand this thread. You say it's a beautiful game and then proceed in saying we should all just fuckin ditch blizzard and change shit up. If it's so beautiful, why would you feel the need to get rid of the makers? Why would you want to change the game so drastically that it would feel like a completely different game called SC:BW?
I also don't understand why the need for all these "fuck sc2 lets go to BW" threads. It's getting quite annoying seeing all these threads pop up. It just might have something in relation to all Kespa related things are officially SC2 now...
|
On September 11 2012 17:00 MasterCynical wrote: have you noticed the first signs that things were going downhill in blizzard games was when they merged with activision?
there are so many easy to use units in the game and now we get tempests and warhounds on top of it, what type of audience is blizzard targeting with these units?
Think about it...
Yet HoTS requires more multi tasking than WoL. In other words, it's harder, so who are they targeting you ask? The hardcore players.
|
Great thread, but absolutely derailed in the last paragraph. Yes, we can change all the things ourselves (in case you didn't know there are already projects like this, can't remember what they're called though). The problem is the testing, which needs to be really thorough and only Blizzard is in the position to make such testing. Community made changes usually remain theories because of that.
A good example is 6m1g. Big initiative, tournaments (including pros participating) and a somewhat inofficial response from blizzard that they are aware and like the idea IF it proves to be beneficial (we are at the testing part again)
|
Go play BW if you want to fucking play BW. Man. Do we need Blizzard? Yes. They make unbiased calls on units, put lots of developer time into it, and bring both the brand and the marketing to push ESports. Your piddly player made BW hybrid has none of that and would fail horribly.
And what the hell. That last sentence? If Blizzard shuts you down go back to BW? GO BACK NOW and post this crap on BW forums about getting together and playing it since it already exists. You can go and enjoy yourself there while people who enjoy this game enjoy ourselves here.
|
well it has alot to do with the game being made 20 years ago. there wasnt any smooth graphics, u could only move 12 units at a time and u couldnt group several buildings. stuff like that will naturally make the game harder and if we were to move back to that kind of gameplay it would just be annoying.
|
On September 11 2012 16:53 iaguz wrote:Show nested quote +Blizzard has given one of the most intricate map editors for any game to date, and here is our way to take the game into our own hands. We can remove Colossus, and replace them with Reavers. We can buff Hydras, and let them morph into Lurkers. We don't need to keep the Warhound, we can add a Goliath and try to modify the Thor. We can make Carriers good. We can make Widow Mines good, yet something deep within me says that Spider Mines should not be introduced. The maps, we can finally make our own map pools, and put our map making teams on the forefront, rather than on the wayside. This already happend. It's called SC2BW and it's available as a custom map on all servers
Hmm , I know what I will be trying out tonite !! Thanks iaguz!
|
On September 11 2012 17:00 MasterCynical wrote: have you noticed the first signs that things were going downhill in blizzard games was when they merged with activision?
there are so many easy to use units in the game and now we get tempests and warhounds on top of it, what type of audience is blizzard targeting with these units?
Think about it... That's funny because SC2 is happening after that merger and it is a great game in many people's opinions. Want to know what would happen if BW had never existed and Blizzard still had a great history of games and BW was released today? People would HATE on that game. Units that are not balanced. Units that suck. Terrible AI/pathing etc. Another funny thing? Most people would actually really enjoy the game despite the very vocal minority because it was a great game.
|
As much as I absolutely LOVE this concept, and that it's now being freely discussed. I can't see this worked unless there were some dedicated Pros who were committed to help balance/promote the project. And unfortunately, we have to remember their income comes from major tournaments, and those tournaments won't be able to use a mod of Blizzard originals game.
|
|
|
|
|
|