|
On September 13 2012 03:43 Soulriser wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 03:32 Godwrath wrote:On September 13 2012 03:29 Soulriser wrote:On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations. they did fix vista, its called Windows 7. they made a better product. Blizz might eventually do that, as they still have 2 expansions to get everything right, but people are just so impatient nowadays. i enjoy SC2. of course there's things that could be fixed, but overall its not a bad game. but thats just my opinion. They fixed vista... because most people refused to use vista and just stayed on windows XP. Hence the "go back to BW". Is it that hard to understand ? but they still fixed it, it just took time. its not hard to understand. if people want to play BW, then they can play BW, its still there and people are still playing it. im just saying that eventually SC2 will work itself out, its still a relatively new game and there are still 2 expansions for blizzard to work out the kinks, plus however long they decidet to patch after LotV. Its the underlying design of the game I'm worried about. SCBW was extremely lucky in how it turned out.
Blizz during the unit previews seemed to know what to do talking about how units will take away from deathballs and focus more on area control, but that they don't seem to be committed to doing such a thing. Que the endless rants about how the warhound isn't actually mech and fans don't want another boring a move unit.
Another underlying problem is the 200 200 big engagement effect. A lot of times the game simply comes down to who wins that critical 200 army battle, while in BW that wouldn't always end the game. It feels gamey whenever people are dropping their worker count down to around 30 units just to have a bigger army for that make it or break it engagement.
If I have more fun playing a mod instead of SC2, I will. Long as I've got a few opponents to game me, I'm fine. Until Blizz makes regular SC2 more fun for me to play and watch, I simply won't play it or watch GSL anymore.
edit: One additional note. I'm really excited for to see how HOTS will shape up, and I'm really hoping it'll shape up to be a worthy successor, but given WoL's design and the current state of HotS I'm just skeptical for now until we see more.
|
On September 13 2012 03:34 BlackGosu wrote: sorry blizzard games dont cut it for me anymore, d3 was the nail in the coffin. ill probably still buy HOTS for the campaign and occasionally watch the sc2 tourneys. funny thing is, i used to follow every sc2 tourney, but now its become so saturated i cant even keep up with the amount of events occuring.
So d3 was the nail in the coffin because SC2 has too many tournaments for you to watch..... ? O_O Confusing whine at its finest. Imo d3 was still a good game worth it's money. It's not the greatest game of all time. I won't spend thousands of hours on it, but imo it's still top 3 best games since SC2.
|
On September 13 2012 05:04 decemberscalm wrote: Its the underlying design of the game I'm worried about. SCBW was extremely lucky in how it turned out. The reason for that is quite simple: "Overpowered" units didnt matter as much in SCBW because controlling them was hard. The easiest comparison is obviously the Siege Tank with its damage, but Psi Storm and the Reaver work too. All these are attacks which damage an area, BUT there werent as many units in the targeted area as there are in SC2. This made balancing the units very easy and you could have "fun abilities" which were very strong but didnt ruin the whole strategy. That is the thing which Blizzard developers either havent understood OR the are under the delusion that they can handle it. HotS and the last expansion will show us how and so far it doesnt look good, because the goofy abilities they have planned for the next expansion are mostly of the "either totally useless OR totally overpowered with no middle ground for balancing" (due to the difference in usefulness from the maps) category.
If SC2 had a lower "unit density" or at least a way to keep the deathball spread out the devs could make area abilities more powerful and thus have an easier time balancing the game. The problem of too powerful AoE only shows itself when you kill half the enemys units with a few shots from a handful of Siege Tanks or Psi Storms or such. Blizzard hasnt realized that yet OR they are unwilling to acknowledge that mistake in their design concept and change it accordingly.
Another reason why SC2 is worse to balance compared to BW is the "burst production" and the macro mechanics of the three races. They are an integral part of game design and if they removed larva inject, chronoboost, MULE, Reactor and Warp Gate the game would slow down a lot and would be easier to balance. There is a reason why mech is risky and it lies in the inability to burst-produce the units compared to Marines and Medivacs which make up the core or a bio army.
|
United Kingdom12071 Posts
On September 13 2012 05:04 decemberscalm wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 03:43 Soulriser wrote:On September 13 2012 03:32 Godwrath wrote:On September 13 2012 03:29 Soulriser wrote:On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations. they did fix vista, its called Windows 7. they made a better product. Blizz might eventually do that, as they still have 2 expansions to get everything right, but people are just so impatient nowadays. i enjoy SC2. of course there's things that could be fixed, but overall its not a bad game. but thats just my opinion. They fixed vista... because most people refused to use vista and just stayed on windows XP. Hence the "go back to BW". Is it that hard to understand ? but they still fixed it, it just took time. its not hard to understand. if people want to play BW, then they can play BW, its still there and people are still playing it. im just saying that eventually SC2 will work itself out, its still a relatively new game and there are still 2 expansions for blizzard to work out the kinks, plus however long they decidet to patch after LotV. Its the underlying design of the game I'm worried about. SCBW was extremely lucky in how it turned out. Blizz during the unit previews seemed to know what to do talking about how units will take away from deathballs and focus more on area control, but that they don't seem to be committed to doing such a thing. Que the endless rants about how the warhound isn't actually mech and fans don't want another boring a move unit. Another underlying problem is the 200 200 big engagement effect. A lot of times the game simply comes down to who wins that critical 200 army battle, while in BW that wouldn't always end the game. It feels gamey whenever people are dropping their worker count down to around 30 units just to have a bigger army for that make it or break it engagement. If I have more fun playing a mod instead of SC2, I will. Long as I've got a few opponents to game me, I'm fine. Until Blizz makes regular SC2 more fun for me to play and watch, I simply won't play it or watch GSL anymore. edit: One additional note. I'm really excited for to see how HOTS will shape up, and I'm really hoping it'll shape up to be a worthy successor, but given WoL's design and the current state of HotS I'm just skeptical for now until we see more.
That's a problem with the map design in my opinion.
|
On September 13 2012 21:46 Rabiator wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 05:04 decemberscalm wrote: Its the underlying design of the game I'm worried about. SCBW was extremely lucky in how it turned out. The reason for that is quite simple: "Overpowered" units didnt matter as much in SCBW because controlling them was hard. The easiest comparison is obviously the Siege Tank with its damage, but Psi Storm and the Reaver work too. All these are attacks which damage an area, BUT there werent as many units in the targeted area as there are in SC2. This made balancing the units very easy and you could have "fun abilities" which were very strong but didnt ruin the whole strategy. That is the thing which Blizzard developers either havent understood OR the are under the delusion that they can handle it. HotS and the last expansion will show us how and so far it doesnt look good, because the goofy abilities they have planned for the next expansion are mostly of the "either totally useless OR totally overpowered with no middle ground for balancing" (due to the difference in usefulness from the maps) category. If SC2 had a lower "unit density" or at least a way to keep the deathball spread out the devs could make area abilities more powerful and thus have an easier time balancing the game. The problem of too powerful AoE only shows itself when you kill half the enemys units with a few shots from a handful of Siege Tanks or Psi Storms or such. Blizzard hasnt realized that yet OR they are unwilling to acknowledge that mistake in their design concept and change it accordingly. Another reason why SC2 is worse to balance compared to BW is the "burst production" and the macro mechanics of the three races. They are an integral part of game design and if they removed larva inject, chronoboost, MULE, Reactor and Warp Gate the game would slow down a lot and would be easier to balance. There is a reason why mech is risky and it lies in the inability to burst-produce the units compared to Marines and Medivacs which make up the core or a bio army.
I wouldn't necessitate that SC2 has worse balance, just that the game design is worse.
But yeah, Blizzard tries to add in cool abilities like the widow mine, realizes yet again that AOE is op if its made too strong because of the clumping and then hammers it with the nerf stick yet again. I wouldn't even mind if Blizz added a tiny formation button that would automatically give your units some sort of spread, that way aoe could be much stronger. It'd be the same thing as just keeping units clumped, but tiny storms.
Macro mechanics are so arbitrary. Sure, it separates your platinum players from your masters player by who has the apm to keep the production rocking, but by the time you are at a masters player that's not even a question we care about. It's usually a given players at that caliber will have something so simple mastered and trained. Sure we see every now and then someone gets supply blocked or is slipping slightly on energy, but it really doesn't happen that often. And you are right, it does make the economy accelerate way too fast that getting 200/200 is pretty much trivial. There is usually a bit of harassment, and a tiny bit of skirmish, all of a sudden both players are 200/200 on 3 base. Half the map isn't even important to the players until they start running low on minerals.
Warp gate is a beast of its problem, doing things like removing defenders advantage and having absolutely zero use for standard gateways.
A lot of these mechanics also don't really leave in choice. Is there ever a point in time you decide to not go for oribital command first? Do you ever not get queens and inject? Do you ever not research warp gate tech (bar 2 gate proxies)? The only thing you could scarcely call a trade off is saving just enough energy for a scan instead of banking 400 minerals.
@Qikz Maps are not the problem when its just not battle efficient to keep your units spread. Toss wants his max dps so he balls. T wants his max dps during that big fight so he balls. Z finally balls when hes got that sick killing blow brood lord army, but usually he can split to keep the opposing army back by counters.
Even if the maps were massive, you army would still get crushed if you don't attempt to vaporize the opposing army with spell support late game. How effective are spread out tank lines right now outside of WoL TvT? Pretty much reserved for anti baneling and seiging the opponents base.
|
On September 13 2012 05:33 Euronyme wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 03:34 BlackGosu wrote: sorry blizzard games dont cut it for me anymore, d3 was the nail in the coffin. ill probably still buy HOTS for the campaign and occasionally watch the sc2 tourneys. funny thing is, i used to follow every sc2 tourney, but now its become so saturated i cant even keep up with the amount of events occuring. So d3 was the nail in the coffin because SC2 has too many tournaments for you to watch..... ? O_O Confusing whine at its finest. Imo d3 was still a good game worth it's money. It's not the greatest game of all time. I won't spend thousands of hours on it, but imo it's still top 3 best games since SC2.
top 3 games released by blizzard since sc2 right?
3) diablo 2) Sc2 1) Mists of pandaria
(and I don't even play wow, so get the hint :p)
|
all of those games were made when developers didn't support MP at all. developers now support it, if you want to create 'better' game settings then you can, but it has to catch on. if no one plays this game that *you* think is balanced, it doesn't really matter does it.
maybe instead you want is a better interface for bnet so people have a chance to play these competitive alternatives easily so that a community can grow around them.
hots looks quite good actually the only thing i'm concerned about is 1) how powerful the warhound is (this isn't that hard its a numbers game). 2) how shitty protoss seems to be.
but they can easily change things....it looks like blizz is being more invovled in the community and personally the changes that HAVE been made are quite good (except queen change wtf mate)
|
On September 11 2012 21:18 Wrathsc2 wrote: most people love sc2 idk wut u are talking bout. only because they haven't played BW seriously
|
On September 14 2012 04:37 Garmer wrote:Show nested quote +On September 11 2012 21:18 Wrathsc2 wrote: most people love sc2 idk wut u are talking bout. only because they haven't played BW seriously
although bw is a great game and i played it al ong time ago, i can't ever see mysefl playing the game again until they update things like graphics.
unit pathing and AI is also godawful in that game, honestly even though dragoon micro si impressive and never fucking that up is great, i don't really find it to be enjoyable part of playing.
|
On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about.
What are YOU talking about.
SC2 community is sparse and tiny compared the global SC:BW fanbase. Hell in Korea most people still prefer BW, and the same goes for many nations.
Most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW? Again wrong, How come the last BW OSL finals were fucking packed? How come the GSL finals weren't? SC:BW is more loved, more respected, and more widespread than SC2 can hope to achieve in its current iteration.
Just because you and your friends don't give a shit about the best RTS of all time, doesn't mean everyone else is so stupid.
|
On September 14 2012 05:50 Chronald wrote:Show nested quote +On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about. SC2 community is sparse and tiny compared the global SC:BW fanbase. Hell in Korea most people still prefer BW, and the same goes for many nations.
If that was the case then we would be watching broodwar tourneys right now instead of the last broodwar league actually switching over to sc2. Delusional.
The only thing you said that is true is that bw is bigger in korea than sc2. Well i got bad news for you, they are switching aswell.
|
A more interesting OP would be:
What if Blizzard doesn't need us?
I mean, look at all the things Blizzard has committed to in recent memory that fans couldn't get behind: no LAN support, no global play, no clan support, pandas, the list goes on... You do sometimes wonder if Blizzard feels they don't even need us -_-.
But at the end of the day, it's Blizzard that has provided us with the starcraft universe we all know and love today. And without Blizzard we wouldn't have BW or SC2...
The "community rebels" - type philosophy of the OP will get us nowhere. SC2 definitely has its flaws, but without Blizzard there'd be no starcraft. And it's not like they aren't listening... Sure, maybe some of the stuff they're promising in the future should have been provided years earlier, but at least they're planning on implementing them in the future (such as clan support).
Working with Blizzard to make a great game is what we should be doing. You try to undermine Blizzard, and you're undermining the future of Starcraft.
Because fans aren't going to be making Starcraft 3...
|
On September 14 2012 06:07 goodkarma wrote: A more interesting OP would be:
What if Blizzard doesn't need us?
I mean, look at all the things Blizzard has committed to in recent memory that fans couldn't get behind: no LAN support, no global play, no clan support, pandas, the list goes on... You do sometimes wonder if Blizzard feels they don't even need us -_-.
But at the end of the day, it's Blizzard that has provided us with the starcraft universe we all know and love today. And without Blizzard we wouldn't have BW or SC2...
The "community rebels" - type philosophy of the OP will get us nowhere. SC2 definitely has its flaws, but without Blizzard there'd be no starcraft. And it's not like they aren't listening... Sure, maybe some of the stuff they're promising in the future should have been provided years earlier, but at least they're planning on implementing them in the future (such as clan support).
Working with Blizzard to make a great game is what we should be doing. You try to undermine Blizzard, and you're undermining the future of Starcraft. Because fans aren't going to be making Starcraft 3...
the guys who created the starcraft universe, aren't designing sc2 right now... Or atleast not the important ones.
|
On September 14 2012 02:02 decemberscalm wrote: But yeah, Blizzard tries to add in cool abilities like the widow mine, realizes yet again that AOE is op if its made too strong because of the clumping and then hammers it with the nerf stick yet again. I wouldn't even mind if Blizz added a tiny formation button that would automatically give your units some sort of spread, that way aoe could be much stronger. It'd be the same thing as just keeping units clumped, but tiny storms.
I thought about that too. If there was a way to spread units in a reliable way one could actually buff the siege tank (and storm/winfestor/banelings) to allow them for better space control which in turn would allow mapmakers to spread bases more.
Oddly nobody seems to consider another very important factor: the game itself is faster than Broodwar, isn't it? It seems that was made to keep players from being idle while BW players were building stuff at home but it also make it harder to micro during a battle. Things die very fast.
I don't know if "burst" production itself is a problem per se but it might become one combined with warpgates because they are most likely off cooldown once a big fight starts so you have instant ht once units start to die. You can't balance out the strength of HT against their build time. (implying there are 20+ WG)
I'm sorry that the paragraphs are so incoherent. I'm tired.
|
On September 14 2012 06:05 gh0un wrote:Show nested quote +On September 14 2012 05:50 Chronald wrote:On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about. SC2 community is sparse and tiny compared the global SC:BW fanbase. Hell in Korea most people still prefer BW, and the same goes for many nations. If that was the case then we would be watching broodwar tourneys right now instead of the last broodwar league actually switching over to sc2. Delusional. The only thing you said that is true is that bw is bigger in korea than sc2. Well i got bad news for you, they are switching aswell.
Yeah, you know the reason for that right?
Blizzard paid Kespa to not broadcast BW so SC2's barrier of entry gets eliminated.
So if you want to act like an smartass, at least get your facts straight.
And oh by the way, even when StarCraft 2 was paralleled with BW, the latter still managed to beat the former in viewership count. Just some food for thought.
|
On September 14 2012 06:13 wcr.4fun wrote:Show nested quote +On September 14 2012 06:07 goodkarma wrote: A more interesting OP would be:
What if Blizzard doesn't need us?
I mean, look at all the things Blizzard has committed to in recent memory that fans couldn't get behind: no LAN support, no global play, no clan support, pandas, the list goes on... You do sometimes wonder if Blizzard feels they don't even need us -_-.
But at the end of the day, it's Blizzard that has provided us with the starcraft universe we all know and love today. And without Blizzard we wouldn't have BW or SC2...
The "community rebels" - type philosophy of the OP will get us nowhere. SC2 definitely has its flaws, but without Blizzard there'd be no starcraft. And it's not like they aren't listening... Sure, maybe some of the stuff they're promising in the future should have been provided years earlier, but at least they're planning on implementing them in the future (such as clan support).
Working with Blizzard to make a great game is what we should be doing. You try to undermine Blizzard, and you're undermining the future of Starcraft. Because fans aren't going to be making Starcraft 3... the guys who created the starcraft universe, aren't designing sc2 right now... Or atleast not the important ones.
Yeah Blizzard North shut down ages ago. The guys making SC2 right now are the people that worked on WoW/Warcraft 3 and new guys like Dustin Browder whose accomplishments consist of destroying the Command and Conquer franchise and creating "balanced" games like Battle For Middle Earth...
If you take this into consideration, it shouldn't be a surprise that the SC2 team has no fucking clue what its doing.
|
@OP: I myself had the same insight when I was reading about the warhound, we could just ignore that shit. The community has the power to create a mod, potentially better than the original game. One concern though is the fact that Blizzard has control over the created content when the only method of distribution is centralized on Battle.net (I'm not exactly sure if this is correct, but I'm almost certain there's no other way). So if they decide to take down whatever you put there, for whatever reason they like, that's up to no one to contest. All legal documents probably already mention something like that.
On a meta-linguistic off-topic: as proven by many replies here, you shouldn't ever thought of citing "brood war". Your message's content is very interesting, I personally think it carries a lot of potential (at least for a healthy discussion), but format and timing of the writing sometimes mean more than the actual content. People have serious problems grasping the actual meaning of things and they just go for the tiny bit they actually (thought) could understand.
(Kudos to MasterOfPuppets for trying to fight the tide though, and since I never actually said this, thanks for the awesome contribution in the past)
|
Blizzard's balance philosophy reminds me of the cops from the wire. All they care about is the numbers, they don't give a shit how they get them. PvZ is a perfect example, they always talk about how the win-rate is near 50% for both sides, but they don't talk about how each side is winning (Toss 2 base/miricle vortex) or zerg making 17 broodlords. This game just isn't exciting.
Blizzard had like 10 years to study what made bw great, and instead of keeping the formula ( i'm not talking units, I just mean flow of the game) They tried to reinvent the wheel and failed horribly.
|
On September 14 2012 00:56 Qikz wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 05:04 decemberscalm wrote:On September 13 2012 03:43 Soulriser wrote:On September 13 2012 03:32 Godwrath wrote:On September 13 2012 03:29 Soulriser wrote:On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations. they did fix vista, its called Windows 7. they made a better product. Blizz might eventually do that, as they still have 2 expansions to get everything right, but people are just so impatient nowadays. i enjoy SC2. of course there's things that could be fixed, but overall its not a bad game. but thats just my opinion. They fixed vista... because most people refused to use vista and just stayed on windows XP. Hence the "go back to BW". Is it that hard to understand ? but they still fixed it, it just took time. its not hard to understand. if people want to play BW, then they can play BW, its still there and people are still playing it. im just saying that eventually SC2 will work itself out, its still a relatively new game and there are still 2 expansions for blizzard to work out the kinks, plus however long they decidet to patch after LotV. Its the underlying design of the game I'm worried about. SCBW was extremely lucky in how it turned out. Blizz during the unit previews seemed to know what to do talking about how units will take away from deathballs and focus more on area control, but that they don't seem to be committed to doing such a thing. Que the endless rants about how the warhound isn't actually mech and fans don't want another boring a move unit. Another underlying problem is the 200 200 big engagement effect. A lot of times the game simply comes down to who wins that critical 200 army battle, while in BW that wouldn't always end the game. It feels gamey whenever people are dropping their worker count down to around 30 units just to have a bigger army for that make it or break it engagement. If I have more fun playing a mod instead of SC2, I will. Long as I've got a few opponents to game me, I'm fine. Until Blizz makes regular SC2 more fun for me to play and watch, I simply won't play it or watch GSL anymore. edit: One additional note. I'm really excited for to see how HOTS will shape up, and I'm really hoping it'll shape up to be a worthy successor, but given WoL's design and the current state of HotS I'm just skeptical for now until we see more. That's a problem with the map design in my opinion.
I agree with you too. It's the map pool. As much as Zergs want to cry we need more choke points and ramps. Maybe even LOS blockers and small Xel Towers in order to give upper ground advantage.
Choke points force large forces to split and attack at multiple angle, unless they want to be crapped on by splash. And I'm not talking about ramps, we need corridors. Also expansions need to be more spread out. In this way drops and multi-pronged attacks increase in effectiveness.
We can't just put all the blame on Blizzard, as of late the mapmakers have lacked innovation. Every map these days goes as follows.
1)Double Ramp. One for main and one for Natural. 2)Super easy Third. 3) Wide open middle.
|
On September 14 2012 09:19 Zombo Joe wrote:Show nested quote +On September 14 2012 06:13 wcr.4fun wrote:
the guys who created the starcraft universe, aren't designing sc2 right now... Or atleast not the important ones. Yeah Blizzard North shut down ages ago..
Huh? The original Starcraft and Starcraft: Brood War were not developed by Blizzard North.
Also, the Starcraft team has about as many Blizzard veteran developers from back then as you'd expect given that sixteen years have passed since they first showed SC at E3.
|
|
|
|
|
|