On September 11 2012 17:33 bhfberserk wrote: It is ok, even we are all dissatisfy with HOTS beta, after all it is only the first patch of beta. Things will be change soon.
But things have been changing frequently in WoL since beta. Every manipulation is completely overanalyzed and gamers and progamers demand that something be done about! So they do, again and again, only to piss off other people who demand change.
How realistic will it be to expect HOTS to be refined more efficiently than WoL?
so... why not create a custom game where WE decide the balance of the game with our own balance changes? lawl... Maybe this way u can boycot blizzard's balance team. And the GSL with every tournament uses the community's balance changes in the maps rather than blizzards... Mind blowing. What can blizzard do? remove the map? lol
On September 12 2012 13:07 OpTiKDream wrote: so... why not create a custom game where WE decide the balance of the game with our own balance changes? lawl... Maybe this way u can boycot blizzard's balance team. And the GSL with every tournament uses the community's balance changes in the maps rather than blizzards... Mind blowing. What can blizzard do? remove the map? lol
I think the custom map "starbow" is attempting to do that.
Who's going to be in charge of what gets changed? It's impossible to be organized enough to run a league based off of some custom map. People just like to whine too much about balance, but at the end of the day everyone still loves them some SC2.
On September 12 2012 13:07 OpTiKDream wrote: so... why not create a custom game where WE decide the balance of the game with our own balance changes? lawl... Maybe this way u can boycot blizzard's balance team. And the GSL with every tournament uses the community's balance changes in the maps rather than blizzards... Mind blowing. What can blizzard do? remove the map? lol
The community of a small RTS game called LOTR:BFME2 did this. EA dropped support for the game and left it in a shitty position with tons of imbalance, and the community released regular balance patches, which made the game (which six races) amazingly more balanced than it was prior (although you could clearly never necessarily fix it completely).
On September 11 2012 17:33 bhfberserk wrote: It is ok, even we are all dissatisfy with HOTS beta, after all it is only the first patch of beta. Things will be change soon.
But things have been changing frequently in WoL since beta. Every manipulation is completely overanalyzed and gamers and progamers demand that something be done about! So they do, again and again, only to piss off other people who demand change.
How realistic will it be to expect HOTS to be refined more efficiently than WoL?
For every single thing in SC2 there seem to be three major opinions: "nerf" "buff" "keep it the same". This is not a problem with the game, it's a problem with the opinions. You can't go "oh the blizzard balance team only does things wrong, because every time there's a change people are pissed about it". What do you mean by that every change is overanalyzed and people demand that something is done? What does that even mean? People have always and will always try to claim that their race is harder to play and underpowered and it's only through their very significant skill that they managed to win the game / they lost the game because imba world.
Check out Starbow. I casted a few matches of it already simply because there wasn't any.
Community is mainly EU, but us on NA manage to get some games going. Its a hybrid of SCBW, SC2, and some a few carefully added additions. Everything tries to stay familiar to their respective units.
Badly designed units are removed like collosus, roach, sentry. Fun micro units added back in like the vulture and the sci vessel+scourge. You've still got blink stalkers, immortals, queens, planetarys. If something doesn't fit or overlaps, it'll be carefully changed. For instance, the corsair is back but its halfway a pheonix because it has the awesome gravity lift ability now.
Important game mechanic changes are in like 30 percent less high ground damage, and a 10 second delay for warp gate build times. This, combined with chrono boosting effecting cannons tremendously helps match ups like PvP. Here is the direct link: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=304955. Here is a vod:
I have zero motivation to even ladder anymore because of this mod. Its simply more fun to watch and play than SC2.
edit: before you ask, no its not just BW I promise. T, because micro dynamics so relied on that race (what would dragoons do against hellion instead of spider mine? scourge vs sci vessel), its mostly the same as its BW counterpart. Z could have easily gone banelings and flanked the terran bio ball to punish it and force tanks but he tried relying on lurkers instead.
^Wow this starbow mod looks very promising :D I have never thought about what OP said but it actually makes so much sense.....We all have seen enough of ridiculous BS from blizzard done to WoL and i believe we all now lack of confidence on them to balance the game. The thing is, they lost alot players because they couldn't deliver to the right quality of product in the first place, we were all beta testers for WoL, technically. Or may be we are still beta testing WoL, next patch you may see some drastic changes and i am sure you wouldn't be surprised.
People don't really want a sc2bw because people can just play the bw. This Starbow mod however looks very good. Dota is a fun mod to begin with and people grow to love it. WoL sucks in many ways and HotS will probably follow the same (and imagine VotL.....) so why not let the community make a rts mod out of a rts lol
Considering that our E-sport competitors, the MOBAs are all descended from a third party mod I don't get why people dismiss the possibility out of hand.
If anything it's the Bnet 2.0 architecture that will make achieving such a goal really difficult, even if the community as a whole wanted it.
On September 12 2012 13:34 IcedBacon wrote: Who's going to be in charge of what gets changed? It's impossible to be organized enough to run a league based off of some custom map. People just like to whine too much about balance, but at the end of the day everyone still loves them some SC2.
Thats actually the story of dota. 1 man organzing everything on his own and the community never split again since icefrog. Dota1 still has a tournament scene, especially in china.
On September 12 2012 14:28 Wombat_NI wrote: Considering that our E-sport competitors, the MOBAs are all descended from a third party mod I don't get why people dismiss the possibility out of hand.
If anything it's the Bnet 2.0 architecture that will make achieving such a goal really difficult, even if the community as a whole wanted it.
Biggest roadblock is simply that it isn't from Blizzard or a huge company. There are so many games and mods out there that are amazing and not seen simply because mostly people don't go too far off the beaten path to find them. Even if its astonishingly clear HotS will be terrible (I really hope it'll be amazing) people will still swarm to it. Meanwhile, the arcade is still mostly the first tab, instead of everyone defaulting to open games so people would join customs like they did in BW (whatever people happened to be hosting at the moment).
Good to have few lolz when people think they know better how to balance the game :D. Its soo bad, its soo awfull, yet I still keep playing or watching tournaments... Stop goddamn supporting the product alltogether if you think its so bad.
You can't go and compare SC2 balance mod to dota. Dota was a brand new game, not a balance mod of BW. There is no fucking way that people would start using something like promod for all the tournaments. Maybe, just maybe it might happen like in 2020 or something when everyone but the most hardcore fans have dropped the game allready.
The last thing we should do is splinter the community. Fans may make a game popular, but fans alone is not what makes a game succesful; we are in a mutual relationship. We need Blizzard and Blizzard needs us. Any online game won't have popular longevity without healthy support from both the developers and the fans.
On September 12 2012 15:06 stfouri wrote: Good to have few lolz when people think they know better how to balance the game :D. Its soo bad, its soo awfull, yet I still keep playing or watching tournaments... Stop goddamn supporting the product alltogether if you think its so bad.
You can't go and compare SC2 balance mod to dota. Dota was a brand new game, not a balance mod of BW. There is no fucking way that people would start using something like promod for all the tournaments. Maybe, just maybe it might happen like in 2020 or something when everyone but the most hardcore fans have dropped the game allready.
Thinking something can be improved on doesn't equal 'don't buy it we think it's bad, at least at present. HoTS is in beta and people are trying to give constructive feedback on 'the game to see it progress in a manner that we, the fanbase would like to see. Obviously we'll not be homogenous, we'll not all want the same things but that feeback is available for consumption by the devs.
If they don't go through with it, and the product isn't what we want, don't buy it and tell them why. In that sense you're correct for sure, developers will never change unless there's some kind of commercial imperative for them to do so.
Also on an unrelated note to your post, Starcraft isn't a new series. It's building on the legacy of Brood War, and got many of its sales because it was the successor to Brood War. It's not unreasonable to expect them to keep some of the hallmarks of the series and incorporate them, without being told to 'go play BW if you like it so much'.
If Starcraft 2 was an original, new franchise and hadn't been supposedly made to be a great competitive game, I wouldn't give a shit but it's meant to be Starcraft!
I probably won't bring much new, but I think this a good idea. We got some talented people in the community. Starcraft has the best core for strategy in my opinion and they mess it up for the money As many ppl before me said this happened many times so it could happen again with Sc2 if they mess it up completely . I think even Sc2 editor could allow to do that.
On September 12 2012 13:07 OpTiKDream wrote: so... why not create a custom game where WE decide the balance of the game with our own balance changes? lawl... Maybe this way u can boycot blizzard's balance team. And the GSL with every tournament uses the community's balance changes in the maps rather than blizzards... Mind blowing. What can blizzard do? remove the map? lol
1. Good luck making it more balancing, it will be a major trainwreck since people here don't have a freaking clue how balance works. Aka you cannot change one thing that is broken since it completely changes the whole matchup. 2. Good luck getting GSL or any tournament for that sense using those maps. 3. Blizzard owns everything you make in their map creator and on battle.net so yea, they can remove your map without any problem and if they want even IP ban peole that use said maps.
The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA.
The people who tell you to go back to XP actually prefer Vista. I know that doesn't work in your contrived example, but in BW vs SC2 many prefer SC2. I loved playing BW casually when it was released but watching some BW pro games and that Starbow match i feel SC2 is more fun.
On September 12 2012 13:07 OpTiKDream wrote: so... why not create a custom game where WE decide the balance of the game with our own balance changes? lawl... Maybe this way u can boycot blizzard's balance team. And the GSL with every tournament uses the community's balance changes in the maps rather than blizzards... Mind blowing. What can blizzard do? remove the map? lol
Who do you think is paying the bills at Gom? Hint: its not us.