|
On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA.
I went back to XP an was very happy with that decision.
|
On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Actually, a lot of people did went back to xp and even nowdays its still one of the most used OS's so yea.
|
OP makes a terrific point. It is similar to what Apolyton University did for Civilization (and eventually the developers took notice and added in many of the changes to the official game. Hell, community members of Apolyton eventually went to go work for Sid Meier and other game developers as a result). I think Team Liquid is the most likely candidate to achieve something similar for StarCraft.
For those unfamiliar with Apoylton University, it is a fansite for the Civilization series that serves as a hub for Civ strategy discussion and news, similar in many ways to TL.net. One of the major goals of Apolyton was to create a "more perfect" mod of Civilization, where everything was balanced and changes were the result of RIGOROUS community testing and feedback. That is to say that the community worked together to test different strategies and combinations to learn more about the underlying game mechanics and the results were taken into consideration for the crafting the an official Apolyton University mod, whose goal was to be a "more perfect version" of the game.
It would be amazing to see TL.net begin work on a similar project. It might actually give more meaning to the strategy forums and would surely increase our understanding of the Blizzard version of the game, as well as hopefully creating an even more polished version for competitive community play.
EDIT: For such a project to be a success, I think its development would have to be overseen by not just a single person, or even just a few persons, but by a proper development team put together by the community. Starbow is a step in the right direction, but many of the changes implemented are pretty heavy handed, fundamentally change the game in dramatic ways, and are implemented without empirical data supporting their proposed effects on game play.
|
On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA.
Good lord, what a poor choice of analogy. Yes, everyone would tell you to go back to XP, and most people did go back to XP. If you want something shiny and new, use Windows 7, it's actually quite good. Microsoft did learn from XP. They made Windows 7.
Amusingly, they seem to forget what they learned every other release though... Windows 3.1: Hooray, Windows! Windows 95: Was iffy until the service packs. Windows 98: Solid. Windows 2000/ME: KILL IT WITH FIRE Windows XP: Very solid. Windows Vista: It's.. better than 2000? Windows 7: Surprisingly solid. Windows 8: I'm concerned, we'll see.
|
The problem with looking to the pros to determine what should be changed to balance the game, and this has been explicitly pointed out on a number of occasions by the Blizzard guys, is that the pros are heavily invested in their own chosen race being as strong as possible.
That doesn't mean they don't solicit their feedback. (On the most recent Inside The Game, Incontrol points out that he and Idra are on a committee of pro players whose opinions are being solicited actively by the HOTS developers.) However, it would be ludicrous for any game developer to accept such feedback on faith without trying to back it up with analysis of real games.
Posts like the OP just make clear how little understanding the community has of game design. The idea that it can be reduced to some kind of vote among players is pretty far from reality.
|
On September 12 2012 18:30 Big J wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. I went back to XP an was very happy with that decision.
I went back to XP too. Most people i know did.
That's the best way to reinforce your point about how X product needs to get fixed... not using/buying it so the seller will care about it. That's what got us windows 7 much faster than expected.
|
On September 12 2012 20:42 Iranon wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Good lord, what a poor choice of analogy. Yes, everyone would tell you to go back to XP, and most people did go back to XP. If you want something shiny and new, use Windows 7, it's actually quite good. Microsoft did learn from XP. They made Windows 7. Amusingly, they seem to forget what they learned every other release though... Windows 3.1: Hooray, Windows! Windows 95: Was iffy until the service packs. Windows 98: Solid. Windows 2000/ME: KILL IT WITH FIRE Windows XP: Very solid. Windows Vista: It's.. better than 2000? Windows 7: Surprisingly solid. Windows 8: I'm concerned, we'll see.
What? Windows 2000 was the best out of any of those. I wish I could still use it. The most stable for sure. Did you know Windows XP was a derivative of Windows 2000?
Windows ME, on the other hand, was shit.
|
Windows ME should've been burned for evil witchcraft, yeah I do see win 7 now equal to xp as it is really working out for me.
@Topic: Yes, we dont need Blizzard. But Blizzard won't let us go. If you think that the company who got rid of LAN, thumbed down Kespa and announced HOTS for a full-game-prize will let the community do it`s own thing your very wrong. That's about it. BW had a lively community that did a great deal for the game and those people came with high expectations to sc2. But most attempts to do something were shut down by blizz, like the resume from replays tool.
|
Oh vocal minority, you never let me down. This would be almost impossible to implement. You would fall into the situation where "if these were the official rules and the official units with the official numbers, then X player would have won".
|
|
|
On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations.
|
Your point is somewhat valid. But what made Counterstrike a great game ? Because it was different from Half life and that people played it. You have this stuff on SC2 as well (and i'm not talking about SC2BW) but with STARBOW.
People are already doing it and if you want to play those. You can. Maybe some of the mods will attract attention and start having tournaments. Who knows ? Game is still young. Remember how many years it took for CS to be what it is ? Or the birth of Natural Selection.
DOTA is what you are saying. A mod that people started to play more and more and it became a real game today. It's not always working out.
For the question : "Do we need blizzard ?" Yes ! Dota needed Blizzard (Warcraft III). Defrag needed ID Software (Q3A), CS needed valve (HL) And i could continue like this.
So. Yes we need blizzard. If people want to use the editor and make a good game with it. They just will.
|
1. We need Blizzard.
2. Obviously this thread (like so many others) will never lead to a conclusion or have a decent result. So i advise everyone who thinks that we don't need blizzard and that hots sucks to start a certain map editor and get going OR to shut up. At least you could start to organize stuff. This "omg you are so wrong we don't need blizzard because blabla..." is stupid.
3. Proof us wrong, don't talk us down!
|
On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations.
I'm pretty sure there are worse ones but it definitely was not a good one.
|
Another dreamer.
The idea is fine and dandy, but the problem is there is no authority for this kind of thing. There is no unity on what should be done. Developing an alternative takes time. The alternative being accepted takes time, too. Currently there are already alternatives out there, but having the right system in place doesn´t mean automatic success. To prove success there would need to be actual games played with refined builds. Refined builds required(in sc2) ~1 year and dozens of tournaments as incentive to players to beat their fellow enemy.
By this point, you can´t even add island maps to SC2. Island maps were a staple in bw for many years, even if just niche maps that were regularly banned.
Face it, right now we depend on Blizzard for balance. Our attention is better spend at helping them make Hots not quite as shit as it looks right now.
|
On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:Show nested quote +On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations.
they did fix vista, its called Windows 7. they made a better product.
Blizz might eventually do that, as they still have 2 expansions to get everything right, but people are just so impatient nowadays.
i enjoy SC2. of course there's things that could be fixed, but overall its not a bad game. but thats just my opinion.
|
On September 13 2012 03:29 Soulriser wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations. they did fix vista, its called Windows 7. they made a better product. Blizz might eventually do that, as they still have 2 expansions to get everything right, but people are just so impatient nowadays. i enjoy SC2. of course there's things that could be fixed, but overall its not a bad game. but thats just my opinion.
They fixed vista... because most people refused to use vista and just stayed on windows XP.
Hence the "go back to BW".
Is it that hard to understand ?
|
sorry blizzard games dont cut it for me anymore, d3 was the nail in the coffin. ill probably still buy HOTS for the campaign and occasionally watch the sc2 tourneys. funny thing is, i used to follow every sc2 tourney, but now its become so saturated i cant even keep up with the amount of events occuring.
|
On September 13 2012 03:34 BlackGosu wrote: sorry blizzard games dont cut it for me anymore, d3 was the nail in the coffin. ill probably still buy HOTS for the campaign and occasionally watch the sc2 tourneys. funny thing is, i used to follow every sc2 tourney, but now its become so saturated i cant even keep up with the amount of events occuring. lol whining at its best... Diablo 3 has had a ton of patches and is much more enjoyable nowadays. Diablo 2 started off way worse than it finished. Sc1 started off way worse than it finished. Everyone loves the Lurker and it wasn't around in SC1 preBW. World of warcraft started off a bit rough and improved greatly. They may have gone off base lately in an attempt to get more people back who don't have tons of time to play but they turned it into a great game from a good game.
|
On September 13 2012 03:32 Godwrath wrote:Show nested quote +On September 13 2012 03:29 Soulriser wrote:On September 13 2012 01:20 bonifaceviii wrote:On September 12 2012 17:50 architecture wrote: The kind of people that spout, "go back to BW" are repulsively stupid.
If I made Windows Vista, and it was in many ways worse than XP, which has over MANY years showed what works/what doesn't. Would you tell me, go back to XP?
No, the answer is to learn from XP and FIX VISTA. Wow, of all the analogies you could make to prove your point you picked the absolute worst one. Congratulations. they did fix vista, its called Windows 7. they made a better product. Blizz might eventually do that, as they still have 2 expansions to get everything right, but people are just so impatient nowadays. i enjoy SC2. of course there's things that could be fixed, but overall its not a bad game. but thats just my opinion. They fixed vista... because most people refused to use vista and just stayed on windows XP. Hence the "go back to BW". Is it that hard to understand ?
but they still fixed it, it just took time. its not hard to understand. if people want to play BW, then they can play BW, its still there and people are still playing it. im just saying that eventually SC2 will work itself out, its still a relatively new game and there are still 2 expansions for blizzard to work out the kinks, plus however long they decidet to patch after LotV.
|
|
|
|
|
|