What If We Don't Need Blizzard? - Page 2
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
bhfberserk
Canada390 Posts
| ||
|
MasterOfPuppets
Romania6942 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:23 mrtomjones wrote: Go play BW if you want to fucking play BW. Man. Do we need Blizzard? Yes. They make unbiased calls on units, put lots of developer time into it, and bring both the brand and the marketing to push ESports. Your piddly player made BW hybrid has none of that and would fail horribly. And what the hell. That last sentence? If Blizzard shuts you down go back to BW? GO BACK NOW and post this crap on BW forums about getting together and playing it since it already exists. You can go and enjoy yourself there while people who enjoy this game enjoy ourselves here. I don't understand kneejerk reactions like yours. Why can't Blizzard look at Brood War, more specifically at some of the interesting units and the way they are used in conjuction with one another, examine and understand why they are interesting and develop something of their own without really having to copy units from Brood War or anything of that nature? As opposed to just adding CnC rip-offs that offer nothing new, units with boring design who are redundant or make other pre-existing units redundant? In fact I personally would respect Blizzard a ton more if they actually took the time to understand the way that unit design affected Brood War and why it's so good; for example the way that some units, despite seeming terrible at first, with proper control can become godlike tools to win a game or give you a lead, because they allow this sick micro to be possible. On September 11 2012 17:33 bhfberserk wrote: It is ok, even we are all dissatisfy with HOTS beta, after all it is only the first patch of beta. Things will be change soon. The problem with the beta isn't imbalance. Another thing that makes this so hard to cope with the way Blizzard is handling this is that they refuse to admit that they're wrong. In other words, they will most likely not make a complete overhaul of the new units, or at least not of the new units we are most concerned about. And if they do change something, it will most likely be minimal and barely touching on the real issue at all. But we'll see... I would love to be wrong, I really would, but it's just not looking like it at the moment. | ||
|
DMaster
Romania61 Posts
![]() | ||
|
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:35 MasterOfPuppets wrote: I don't understand kneejerk reactions like yours. Why can't Blizzard look at Brood War, more specifically at some of the interesting units and the way they are used in conjuction with one another, examine and understand why they are interesting and develop something of their own without really having to copy units from Brood War or anything of that nature? As opposed to just adding CnC rip-offs that offer nothing new, units with boring design who are redundant or make other pre-existing units redundant? In fact I personally would respect Blizzard a ton more if they actually took the time to understand the way that unit design affected Brood War and why it's so good; for example the way that some units, despite seeming terrible at first, with proper control can become godlike tools to win a game or give you a lead, because they allow this sick micro to be possible. The problem with the beta isn't imbalance. Another thing that makes this so hard to cope with the way Blizzard is handling this is that they refuse to admit that they're wrong. In other words, they will most likely not make a complete overhaul of the new units, or at least not of the new units we are most concerned about. And if they do change something, it will most likely be minimal and barely touching on the real issue at all. But we'll see... I would love to be wrong, I really would, but it's just not looking like it at the moment. Beta has some interesting units and some that will be fleshed out. That's my only comment on that. This guys post says to replace pretty much all SC2 units with BW units, play the game through a custom game interface off of Blizzard servers, and if they don't like that to go to BW. I think he is better off in BW. Why in the hell would you call it a knee jerk reaction? | ||
|
Quixotic_tv
Germany130 Posts
When I was like 20, I played a (not so popular) HL Mod called Firearms. There were a lot of changes from version 2.5 to 2.6, and there was a a hell of a drama in the forums. After a few more releases, many people agreed that 2.5 servers would be full, some installed the old version on their servers and guess what? It was a great fail. After a few weeks nobody played the old 2.5 version. And the original developers were amateurs, not Blizzard with a load of manpower, knowledge and money. I do not think that going back, just with better graphics, and gameplay, is a good idea. Blizzard could've done that by themselves. Keep in mind that WC3, that I really loved, just like the OP, was not perfect from the beginning. Remember the patch where u just could build shamans and win the game? Or the imba dryads in the beta? From that point, they are doing a good job. I know nostalgia is a great thing, but do not overrate it, from the retrospect, a lot of things look great, but sometimes one forgets that they were not good from the beginning. Give those new units you dislike, like the warhound, or the swarm host, or tempest, a chance. Those units are in a beta, keep this in mind as well. I am actually enjoying WoL, although I suck, and I am sure I will enjoy HotS as well. My only fear is that they want like 50 bucks for an AddOn, thx to Activision. | ||
|
Jerubaal
United States7684 Posts
| ||
|
Archybaldie
United Kingdom818 Posts
| ||
|
MasterOfPuppets
Romania6942 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:45 mrtomjones wrote: Beta has some interesting units and some that will be fleshed out. That's my only comment on that. This guys post says to replace pretty much all SC2 units with BW units, play the game through a custom game interface off of Blizzard servers, and if they don't like that to go to BW. I think he is better off in BW. Why in the hell would you call it a knee jerk reaction? Oh I completely agree, the OP is pretty silly and unreasonable to say the least, but when someone outlines major flaws with the way Blizzard is handling things and the way the game is designed, it's a pretty silly thing to say "if you want to play Brood War go play Brood War". No, I would like to play a game where units are interesting to play and watch and give you a wide range of possibilities if you are skilled enough to pull it off. Incidentally, Brood War is the game that illustrates that idea very well, which is why we use it as an example. | ||
|
rezoacken
Canada2719 Posts
Blizzard didn't listen for D3. Blizzard isn't listening for HotS. This is getting pretty sad right now ![]() | ||
|
BlackPanther
United States872 Posts
| ||
|
SigmaoctanusIV
United States3313 Posts
| ||
|
Big J
Austria16289 Posts
| ||
|
mrtomjones
Canada4020 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:56 rezoacken wrote: Blizzard didn't listen for WoL. Blizzard didn't listen for D3. Blizzard isn't listening for HotS. This is getting pretty sad right now ![]() Blizzard did MANY balance patches to WoL and got it quite balanced. They have DEFINITELY listened to people on Diablo 3. There have been pretty huge changes there and the game is much more enjoyable at this point than it was at the start. This beta has been out for a few weeks and they have already patched it due to feedback from the community... yah they don't listen at all. I think you should rephrase your post to say this. "Blizzard didn't listen to me for WoL. Blizzard didn't listen to me for D3. Blizzard isn't listening to me for HotS." | ||
|
ragnorr
Denmark6097 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:56 rezoacken wrote: Blizzard didn't listen for WoL. Blizzard didn't listen for D3. Blizzard isn't listening for HotS. This is getting pretty sad right now ![]() Their current way of patching in D3 seems to surgest they actully did listen to concerns about the game and are trying to fix it. | ||
|
ChriseC
Germany440 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:02 FabledIntegral wrote: Greater sense of dissatisfaction? SC2 has a much bigger following than SCBW did in terms of pure numbers, and most of the SC2 community doesn't give a shit about SC:BW. What are you even talking about. the reason why sc2 is so successful is more bcuz of technical aspects than of the gamedesign itself | ||
|
wangstra
922 Posts
Where in that post did he suggest making a BW remake? He specifically addressed creating our own community developed fork of StarCraft 2 using the map editor. As in, the changes we find particularly galling that Blizzard makes, we modify on our own and create a community around that. Some of the more non senile answers here pointed out that Blizz has specifically taken steps to stem this kind of community work such as LAN removal and preventing things like iccup. The changes don't have to be things like bringing back BW units in particular but addressing issues that come up over and over in these forums and making changes as we see fit regardless of what Kim et co are up to. Changes like removing carrier that saw less changes than BCs or even the mothership. | ||
|
wangstra
922 Posts
On September 11 2012 18:12 ragnorr wrote: Their current way of patching in D3 seems to surgest they actully did listen to concerns about the game and are trying to fix it. D3 community is far more vocal than SC2. | ||
|
Zandar
Netherlands1541 Posts
Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them. | ||
|
Orek
1665 Posts
Unlike dictatorship, I have never heard of a democratic government that doesn't get negative feedback all the time. Sure, Blizzard can do things better, but a day will never come when people don't complain about any of their products. Fortunately, you can always quit watching/playing if there comes a point where you really don't like the game any more. That's one way to financially pressure Blizzard, and I recommend those who hate the state of the game not to buy/watch any more so that financial pressure might turn things. | ||
|
Big J
Austria16289 Posts
On September 11 2012 18:30 Zandar wrote: What really needs to happen is someone else making a decent RTS. Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them. Red Alert 3, CnC 3 and CnC:Generals and SupCom were all pretty solid strategy games, that I know off. Also CoH and DoW are said to be pretty good as well. Also Dota games don't have a healthy rivalry. Though I haven't seen/played HoN yet, LoL, Dota and Dota2 are basically the same game. | ||
| ||

