What If We Don't Need Blizzard? - Page 5
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
fearus
China2164 Posts
| ||
|
karpo
Sweden1998 Posts
On September 11 2012 20:25 Evangelist wrote: His point is completely ridiculous. Considering some of the "balance" suggestions I've seen on this forum I wouldn't trust the TeamLiquid community to balance a see-saw, nevermind Starcraft 2. Let's take this for example: Why in the name of all that is holy would you EVER want to make a unit play like the fucking dragoon? The only reason it had that style of play is because BW's pathfinding was utterly broken and as anyone who ever played the single player and tried to get up a flight of stairs will attest, it was broken for every single goddamn unit. These massive nostalgia trips have to end. Just go play BW if you want to play BW. We're happy with SC2, cheers. The idea that someone thinks that something that was an april fools (I hope) is a serious future for SC2 is mental. Agreed. I'd love to see the unit area of stalkers/roaches increased so they don't feel as blobby. What i don't want is retarded pathing back, it's the difference between being a fanboy and being realistic. | ||
|
GizmoPT
Portugal3040 Posts
On September 11 2012 20:32 karpo wrote: Agreed. I'd love to see the unit area of stalkers/roaches increased so they don't feel as blobby. What i don't want is retarded pathing back, it's the difference between being a fanboy and being realistic. ye units shouldnt be rubbing on each other thats what i dont like in sc2 they walk pretty tight to each other xp | ||
|
howLiN
Portugal1676 Posts
| ||
|
Spidinko
Slovakia1174 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:15 ahappystar wrote: Yes but EVERY single thing has to be changed if there was a pro-mod. As far as I know a mod of that scale is illegal according to the TOS, Blizzard would never let it see the light of day I don't think they're really afraid of that. People on forums whine and talk shit a lot. But for most of them, that's all they can do. Don't forget that such a project would be pretty difficult to implement. Especially getting many people to play it. | ||
|
Yorbon
Netherlands4272 Posts
Some good rts's other than starcraft would be nice, but the lack of it just shows how incredibly hard it is to make such a game. As other evidence as to why this is so hard, check all the ridiculous balance whine/(bad) design (flaw) topics on tl. To op: you know you sound very immature in your anti-authority rant? If you want to be taken more seriously (by me at least), be a bit more reasonable | ||
|
Grummler
Germany743 Posts
| ||
|
Ragoo
Germany2773 Posts
I think in the end community knows what to do with a game and can filter out the a group of experts who can handle balancing on their own. As examples I would say FPS promods or SC:BW mapmaking. I don't see any new games rising from SC2 because Bnet 2.0 for a long time has been soo unfriendly for custom maps, making many motivated modders who came in from WC3 stop working on new stuff. At the same time it's mostly the people who play ladder that even start SC2 or hang around in Bnet, very much unlike WC3. Also SC2 doesn't have LAN, that's still important for many markets afaik. Blizzard has been quite defensive about letting the community get involved in their design. I'm mainly talking about maps here. Imo working closely together with the community to provide the maps is a no-brainer by now, yet Blizzard still isn't doing nearly enough. Yes there was -one- TLMC, but first of all that's not enough second that's not rly working together with the mapmakers all that much (basically no direct communication). | ||
|
Lignar
United States4 Posts
The WoW player base is gearing up for that game's 4th expansion, and there are daily posts on forums to bring back <insert OP's favorite edition> because the current (or upcoming) version sucks. | ||
|
DjayEl
France252 Posts
If they were in Blizzard's shoes, they will slowly learn how hard it is to balance a game, and after that painful process, they will do exactly the same Blizzard is doing right now. These kind of people are the same that I hear in cafes, talking about economics, telling everyone how the government is shit and how this or this action would be better for the state of the economy. Just because they are so ignorant so they dont understand the real implications of what they say. Being good at a game does not equals to being good at designing it. However, I suspect all these whiners to be aware of their desillusion deep inside, but they would whine anyway just because they are on an Internet forum, and so they can express their frustration. But please, stop now with these anti-blizzard posts. Everyone already told you that: 95% of the people like SC2 and dont give a shit about BW nostalgia. Repeat this sentence 100 times. Go and make a somewhat useful thread. | ||
|
KingAce
United States471 Posts
SC2 is getting less and less interesting to spectate. Because in the back of our minds we all know those amazing high apm moments and tactics are no longer possible. Blizzard is attempting to cater to a fanbase that doesn't exist, and completely shiting on the guys that have helped get the community this far. I don't want a new bw...I just want a more compelling SC2. Put some damn thought in your unit design. After years of balancing there is no excuse for how long it's currently taking for them to grasp the games balance. | ||
|
Wrathsc2
United States2025 Posts
| ||
|
zeo
Serbia6344 Posts
On September 11 2012 21:01 Grummler wrote: @OP: You like BW? Go ahead and play it then. There is no reason in having BW two times. Also, with TL being so elite and everything most people forget that 95% of all SC2 players probably don't care about BW at all. Again, I don't think you understand the point, the mod wouldn't be a neo-BW, it would just fix SC2. The whole point is to fix SC2, make SC2 better. Maybe use experience from BW to make SC2 a better game. The problem in this thread seems to be you people don't have any idea how great SC2 might have been. Fuck's sake, there is a reason most (or a large portion of) people that played BW on this site now play DotA. Always having to go through Blizzard means the pro-gaming community cannot boycott patches, the community has no say. Ahh screw it, it's useless anyway *sigh* | ||
|
rd
United States2586 Posts
| ||
|
xtruder
Afghanistan135 Posts
| ||
|
wcr.4fun
Belgium686 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:26 mrtomjones wrote: That's funny because SC2 is happening after that merger and it is a great game in many people's opinions. Want to know what would happen if BW had never existed and Blizzard still had a great history of games and BW was released today? People would HATE on that game. Units that are not balanced. Units that suck. Terrible AI/pathing etc. Another funny thing? Most people would actually really enjoy the game despite the very vocal minority because it was a great game. what the fuck is this shit? Obviously brood war wouldn't be as openly embraced as it was 15 years ago. 15 years ago people barely even had cellphones. | ||
|
iky43210
United States2099 Posts
On September 11 2012 21:18 KingAce wrote: Some of you need to really stop defending with the blind faith. The success of SC2 was completely built on bw and warcraft. What people generally want isn't BW v.2, but at the very least a game that caters to Esports. Because as we all know the only reason we're all here, that so much money is going into this game....is the result of the success of Esports. SC2 is getting less and less interesting to spectate. Because in the back of our minds we all know those amazing high apm moments and tactics are no longer possible. Blizzard is attempting to cater to a fanbase that doesn't exist, and completely shiting on the guys that have helped get the community this far. I don't want a new bw...I just want a more compelling SC2. Put some damn thought in your unit design. After years of balancing there is no excuse for how long it's currently taking for them to grasp the games balance. oh, we're making hypothetical and thoughtless claims now? let me try. Broodwar success was completely built upon the fact that they have zero competitions in the 1990s as a company with a decent budget. Or how about broodwar success was completely build up by koreans, whereas the game died and declined everywhere else in the 2000s with only release in Korea igniting and bringing back the game alive (though, its still pale relative to everything else in the international sense) | ||
|
karpo
Sweden1998 Posts
On September 11 2012 21:19 ahappystar wrote: Again, I don't think you understand the point, the mod wouldn't be a neo-BW, it would just fix SC2. The whole point is to fix SC2, make SC2 better. Maybe use experience from BW to make SC2 a better game. The problem in this thread seems to be you people don't have any idea how great SC2 might have been. Fuck's sake, there is a reason most (or a large portion of) people that played BW on this site now play DotA. Always having to go through Blizzard means the pro-gaming community cannot boycott patches, the community has no say. Ahh screw it, it's useless anyway *sigh* What you consider a better game might not be close to what others consider better. So most BW people moved over to DotA? Isn't that a much simpler and less mechanically demanding game? Shouldn't it also be harshly criticised for being casual and simplistic? Maybe it's because SC2 is too different to what BW players want so they move on to something fresh? There's alot of assumptions made by people here. "Most" is thrown around alot when, in actuality, people have no idea how many actually believe something or play something. | ||
|
Sawamura
Malaysia7602 Posts
On September 11 2012 21:29 wcr.4fun wrote: what the fuck is this shit? Obviously brood war wouldn't be as openly embraced as it was 20 years ago. 20 years ago people barely even had cellphones you ************. Broodwar would have been unique even though if it is released today if you think isometric games have already been extinct and non existence think again . Indie developer who are developing the supposed true successor to XCOM made a game called xenonauts . No fancy graphics are at play here you control the soldier on the grounds and point it to a destination and they will go without asking any questions . Although each move you can make is really limited . ![]() | ||
|
wcr.4fun
Belgium686 Posts
On September 11 2012 21:31 iky43210 wrote: oh, we're making hypothetical and thoughtless claims now? let me try. Broodwar success was completely built upon the fact that they have zero competitions in the 1990s as a company with a decent budget. Or how about broodwar success was completely build up by koreans, whereas the game died and declined everywhere else in the 2000s with only release in Korea igniting and bringing back the game alive (though, its still pale relative to everything else in the international sense) You are deluded if you think BW had nothing to do with sc2's popularity. BW was pretty immense in america as well with Day9, artosis, etc all passionetely enjoying the game. All these players were freakin' pumped for sc2, the predecessor to the best RTS game ever build. On September 11 2012 21:34 Sawamura wrote: Broodwar would have been unique even though if it is released today if you think isometric games have already been extinct and non existence think again . Indie developer who are developing the supposed true successor to XCOM made a game called xenonauts . No fancy graphics are at play here you control the soldier on the grounds and point it to a destination and they will go without asking any questions . Although each move you can make is really limited . ![]() I didn't say I thought these kinds of games were extinct. But it seems a reasonable assumption to make, that bw wouldn't be as openly embraced, because 15 years ago, bw was graphics etc could be considered pretty technologically advanced (or atleast the norm). | ||
| ||
![[image loading]](http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-sdihraAewj4/T7CpNiAt-eI/AAAAAAAAC6M/2oXvm5BvesM/s1600/Xenonauts+Linux+Game.jpg)