Hey if you like the war hound, oracle, tempest, raped spider mine, pudge-raped defiler, be my guest.
I'm a zerg player in sc2 and I couldn't play more then 10 games a day because I'd get so freakin' bored with infestor/broodlord every game and because there is literally zero micro for me to do.
The viper and 'widow' mine are about the only good things so far for e-sports and entertainment added to HOTS. Abduct is pretty fun to watch and so is the widow mine.
First, I would like to applaud you for stepping out there and posting this. This is what I've been saying for a while but nobody listens. I've made attempts at trying to form a movement to change things about SC2 in the past, but that's not the way to go. We have the tools, and soon we will have the Startools.
Things to consider. Let's say a real SC2mod was made by the community that we were satisfied with. We would be alienating ourselves from a huge community, which I don't have a problem with. I was here when it was just BW ICCup players and I found it just fine. Second, Pros will play where the money is at, which would be SC2. However, community pros would emerge and community tournaments, even if very little cash is involved, would still happen.
There are 2 mods that come to mind that already exist, SC2BW and Starbow. SC2BW is nicely done, but it's not the way to go. It's trying its best to replicate an older game, both the good and the bad. It might however be a good starting point. Then there is Starbow, which is ever changing. Since there seems to be only 1 guy in charge of it and he isn't following any guide like SC2BW is, things can get a bit messy, but overall it's a great experience. I think with some structure and community input, this would be the way to go.(As in, not to replicate something that existed, but to shape our own experience)
If I had a say on how it should be done, I would say that community leaders should be chosen to oversee the game. At least 1 for each race, so 3. There would be votes and threads regarding which units should be there to represent the race and which units should be scrapped. When a leader decides to include a unit or an ability or scrap something, a detailed thread would be made as to why, and people would voice their opinions. No progamers should be chosen, but rather community figures who love the game and their race. I would start with BW units, but with SC2 mechanics and building sizes and all that. Obvious things like highground advantage and microable units. Modified movement so units don't clump on purpose, wide maps to maneuver on, ect ect. That's how it would start. I feel like having 1 or 2 leaders per race would be the way to go. And BALANCE SHOULD NOT BE A FOCUS, not initially at least. Put in what's fun and interesting, take away what's boring. Then we can test it and slowly balance it. Balance the completely broken things, leave in the smaller imbalances to see if we can deal with them over time like BW showed us we can.
Anyways, I'm pretty fed up with SC2 and have been for quite a while. Yeah, this might split the community, but it's definitely worth it. Lets make a game we love and be alienated. It'll be much cozier And also SC2 fans will be happier to be rid of people complaining about their game.
This thread is filled up with non sense. Seems like 3 years of constant debate / arguing / bazillions expert threads never happened. Or maybe its just an endless cycle. What I know tho is that we never had such debates on BW.
On September 11 2012 22:49 Boonbag wrote: This thread is filled up with non sense. Seems like 3 years of constant debate / arguing / bazillions expert threads never happened. Or maybe its just an endless cycle. What I know tho is that we never had such debates on BW.
Not on BW, but when SC1 was released... yeah warcraft 2 vs SC1 comparisons were pretty common.
Ohmagawd they are making the game easier with starcraft 1 !1!1!!11 type.
The problem is that this is not the first time. Heck even I have made a thread about basically the same thing The reason is the same - there are no real leaders here to make that happen. You either need to be very dedicated and convincing, or to convince at least some very infuencial community figures, that it should be done. Just syaing "let's do that" does not make anything happen - and it seems that simply starting a thread on TL on this kind of stuff does not have the desired effect of snowballing into action.
On September 11 2012 17:23 mrtomjones wrote: Go play BW if you want to fucking play BW. Man. Do we need Blizzard? Yes. They make unbiased calls on units, put lots of developer time into it, and bring both the brand and the marketing to push ESports. Your piddly player made BW hybrid has none of that and would fail horribly.
And what the hell. That last sentence? If Blizzard shuts you down go back to BW? GO BACK NOW and post this crap on BW forums about getting together and playing it since it already exists. You can go and enjoy yourself there while people who enjoy this game enjoy ourselves here.
So true, stop complaining about how the older game was better than the new one. Is this not true for any game?? Street fighter, CS 1.6 , BW, Finals fantasy, resident evil's, DIABLO ...anything.... Its a student argument, times have changed and we all need to move on. If your still stuck up on older versions of the game, go play war3/bw with the 200 players....
I don't get why everybody want's to get a harder game. The game is hard enough atm, more and more people are stopping to play it because it takes a fuck load of time to improve. Also last i see its still koreans dominating most tournaments with only a select few pro's capable of keeping up with them (Stephano, Naniwa, Mana,...). I think alot of people that posting here didn't even play broodwar on a decent level D+. They're just trying to act cool by bandwagoning.
Also people saying that dota 2 is harder then SC2 on a mechanical level are bullshitting. I seem one of the few that actively support blizzard cause it's one of the few companies that make games with lasting value (more then 1 year).
On September 11 2012 23:02 massivez wrote: I don't get why everybody want's to get a harder game. The game is hard enough atm, more and more people are stopping to play it because it takes a fuck load of time to improve. Also last i see its still koreans dominating most tournaments with only a select few pro's capable of keeping up with them (Stephano, Naniwa, Mana,...). I think alot of people that posting here didn't even play broodwar on a decent level D+. They're just trying to act cool by bandwagoning.
Also people saying that dota 2 is harder then SC2 on a mechanical level are bullshitting. I seem one of the few that actively support blizzard cause it's one of the few companies that make games with lasting value (more then 1 year).
Haha as though dota hasn't been around for longer than 1 year (even dota2 has been). And if you've never seen a Chen play in dota(2) you have no idea how hard the game can be.
On September 11 2012 23:02 massivez wrote: I don't get why everybody want's to get a harder game. The game is hard enough atm, more and more people are stopping to play it because it takes a fuck load of time to improve. Also last i see its still koreans dominating most tournaments with only a select few pro's capable of keeping up with them (Stephano, Naniwa, Mana,...). I think alot of people that posting here didn't even play broodwar on a decent level D+. They're just trying to act cool by bandwagoning.
Also people saying that dota 2 is harder then SC2 on a mechanical level are bullshitting. I seem one of the few that actively support blizzard cause it's one of the few companies that make games with lasting value (more then 1 year).
Haha as though dota hasn't been around for longer than 1 year (even dota2 has been). And if you've never seen a Chen play in dota(2) you have no idea how hard the game can be.
DotA is an incredibly skill-based game, but on a mechanical level, it's not difficult at all compared to SC2. The difficulty in DotA comes from teamfight coordination, not from the difficulty of controlling a few units. Chen doesn't actually require a lot of micro to be effective with. It's more about using the hero properly than doing crazy demanding things with a few units.
On September 11 2012 23:02 massivez wrote: I don't get why everybody want's to get a harder game. The game is hard enough atm, more and more people are stopping to play it because it takes a fuck load of time to improve. Also last i see its still koreans dominating most tournaments with only a select few pro's capable of keeping up with them (Stephano, Naniwa, Mana,...). I think alot of people that posting here didn't even play broodwar on a decent level D+. They're just trying to act cool by bandwagoning.
Also people saying that dota 2 is harder then SC2 on a mechanical level are bullshitting. I seem one of the few that actively support blizzard cause it's one of the few companies that make games with lasting value (more then 1 year).
Haha as though dota hasn't been around for longer than 1 year (even dota2 has been). And if you've never seen a Chen play in dota(2) you have no idea how hard the game can be.
I had, and i like DOTA2, and you don't have a clue about what you are talking about. DOTA skill mechanichally speaking isn't even close to SC2, and years from BW. But the decission making and teamplay makes up for it. Anyways don't get me wrong, people tend to think overly complicated games make for good e-sports. They are wrong, sports are about the spectator point of view. And yes, SC2 needs some refinament imho, but going full BW isn't the option.
I'm glad blizzard is around. I like sc2 and believe a lot of people do. I think they will fiix the warhound very quickly. As for the tempest, I'm not sure its the most simple unit to utilize. slow/ weak/ low dps/ high supply (opposite of warhound) I'm going to go ahead and stay positive with heart of the swarm.
On September 11 2012 18:30 Zandar wrote: What really needs to happen is someone else making a decent RTS.
Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them.
Red Alert 3, CnC 3 and CnC:Generals and SupCom were all pretty solid strategy games, that I know off. Also CoH and DoW are said to be pretty good as well.
Also Dota games don't have a healthy rivalry. Though I haven't seen/played HoN yet, LoL, Dota and Dota2 are basically the same game.
RA was decent cnc3 was bad, generals was so so (it filled a gap thus played alot), supcom was good but had serious problems in gameplay.
dow 1 was good, dow 2 was god awful (serious responsiveness and balance issues and straight forward gameplay).
COh was great but they just couldnt fix the bugs, and when they did after 4 years they introduced this really mediacore expension tales of valor ana there were as much bugs as the first release. They spent a huge budget and development time on coh online which never got out of beta. also game was too random and the way it worked made that random results cause positive feedbacks and snowball out of control.
Thing is none of these games offered a similar experience to starcraft or warcraft. they had their own gimmicks especially relic ones. other than age of empires online (which had 3 revamps? I think, at last one they managed it quite well) I dont remember any other playable rts games.
Well, but that's the whole point of blizzard games being the best, isn't it? There are other RTS games that are good. but not that good. I mean, people here shit on the warhound, but in a different game this unit could make the top spot in terms of interesting gameplay, just because it is somewhat fast and somewhat strong on its own and could be used for many strategies. (and that doesn't mean I like the warhound. But you know, if I can choose between the warhound and some "medium tank without any abilities or mappresence" that other games offer for the spot of a goto-unit, I'm choosing the warhound)
Anyways, if HotS editor becomes more noobfriendly for this kind of purpose, I might be making my own RTS. Got it all in my head - not because SC2 "sucks", just because I'd love to test some things
1. The "dissatisfaction" with the game is far from wide spread and unanimous across the player base, like you make it sound. This is is the internet, and more specifically TL, where everything that isn't Brood War is complete dog shit and every other poster knows exactly how to make the perfect RTS, just for some reason no one will hire them to do it. I'm by no means saying SC2 is perfect, or that every one likes the game. What I am saying is that the game continues to grow, and that wouldn't happen if a large percentage of people didn't like the game the way it is, overall. Don't read too much into the hate.
2. Blizzard has deliberately made it very hard to eliminate them from the equation that is Starcraft 2. I believe the primary purpose for this was to prevent something like what Kespa did to them in BW (basically completely muscle them out of the pro scene in Korea, meaning little to no profit for Blizzard). You will always have to play on Battle.net and therefore Blizzard has some legal and practical control over what you are doing. Yes, in theory you could set up an alternate ladder on BNET through custom games, but if you think that is going to take off vs. the very easy to hit "find match" button,you have a lot to learn about how people play video games. Even if somehow an alternate version/ladder of the game did become very popular, Blizzard could still exert its will on the scene if it wanted to.
3. Balancing a game like this is actually very hard to do, and Blizzard has the best resources/access to do this. Again, this is TL, where most people will argue that they are doing a "horrible" job at this, but since every race thinks the game is imba, they may actually be doing something right. Trying to seriously balance an RTS with only a few thousand players with no back-end access to data (although you might be able to get to this via really well made custom maps) is a monstrous challenge, even for dedicated players.
On September 11 2012 23:17 Barrin wrote: LET THE FIRE BURN WITHIN THINE HEARTS! lol So glad ppl are keeping this possibility alive :>
No, we don't need Blizzard. Yes, we do need someone to rival Blizzard in the RTS genre. Big companies are not interested in the RTS genre most likely because the casual/hardcore dichotomy is particularly strong. If we want Brood War 2.0, we need to make it ourselves. We're hardcore after all aren't we?
---
This is what I'm looking for
Significantly less 'mineral' income relative to max supply and unit/building costs/supplies.
More difficult mechanics to (more than) compensate for less income (more income = harder to manage).
A focus on making each basic fighting unit interesting with a high potential for multiplying it's unmicro'd strength in an elegant way.
A focus on "area-controlling" units that take time to set up - think Lurkers, BW Tanks, Spider Mines, Burrowed Banelings, Widow Mines, etc.
A focus on making spells extremely powerful - across all races.
A focus on making many unit combinations work well together in non-obvious ways.
In relation to SC2, in general units should have slightly higher hp (or do less damage) and have higher vision, range, and collision radii in relation to movement speed.
A fucking high ground mechanic please.
No mechanics that remove the defender's advantage *eyeballs Warpgate*.
Other than these things I don't really care about any certain unit or it's behavior. I don't want BW anymore, and with just a little bit of imagination you can see that BW is only one of many ways of conforming to the above list. This is just good RTS design philosophy if you want to facilitate deep/rich/complex/dynamic gameplay. If you tell me to just go play BW I will eSlap you.
---
We have two choices really. Do we create a whole new company or do we just go with a Promod? Someone's gotta step up to the plate, and it's up to them how far they wanna take it. I think someone with ambition would make a whole new company.
If we were to make a promod that conforms to the above list it would be such a drastically different game (some units don't even make the cut) that we might as well make our own game. What it comes down to is that SC2 as it is now (and as it will probably be in the foreseeable future) is just too much unlike the kind of deep game we're after to the point that most people who play SC2 as it is now would not (and often already do not) like or even understand the kind of gameplay we're after. Many of the kinds of people who appreciate the gameplay we're after quit SC2 a while ago and never looked back. We need a new player base IMO.
Perhaps a promod is feasible, I just feel like it will only ever be feasible as a shadow of what it should be. Maybe I'll get over that and make it myself someday.
BTW right now we have two things that are kinda like this (but not close enough IMO): a mod called SC2BW and a mod called STARBOW.
What are the chances we can get Valve to make BW2 or some shit?