Part of me hopes to someday see Blizz and Valve work together in some capacity, but I doubt Acti will ever let go until the milking is complete.
What If We Don't Need Blizzard? - Page 4
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
Torpedo.Vegas
United States1890 Posts
Part of me hopes to someday see Blizz and Valve work together in some capacity, but I doubt Acti will ever let go until the milking is complete. | ||
|
johnny123
521 Posts
anyway, i dislike this thread, there is enough bashing sc2 threads around, This one should be closed. Yes we can make a different version of starcraft 2 in the editor, but guess what, nobody will play it because deep down we all know only in blizzrd we trust! The pro-mod might be made by a biased player , or a community that favors a race over another. For e.g lets say teamliquid made this pro mod. You can bet your bottom dollar it would be a zerg/protoss favored game. Every ladder except for korea is dominated by protoss and zergs. Only in blizzard we TRUST. | ||
|
YyapSsap
New Zealand1511 Posts
On September 11 2012 18:38 Big J wrote: Red Alert 3, CnC 3 and CnC:Generals and SupCom were all pretty solid strategy games, that I know off. Also CoH and DoW are said to be pretty good as well. Is this some kind of a joke?? And Dota 2 is simply a standalone dota custom game from warcraft 3 (with the core game mechanics intact) with a much MUCH better interface built in where Valve actually listens to its community. | ||
|
nemonic
132 Posts
On September 11 2012 18:30 Zandar wrote: What really needs to happen is someone else making a decent RTS. Dota games have so much healthy rivalry, with Lol, Dota2, Hon, but there is only 1 company who makes a decent RTS. So Blizzard can just do what they want, there is no one challenging them. This and nothing else. As long as we don't have any serious competitors for Blizzard (and by that I don't mean MOBA games because they're fundamentally different to SC2), probably nothing 's gonna change here. Blizzard has managed to get into a position in which they can largely ignore community feedback. And we as clients don't have they option to punish them for that other than quit playing RTS games, as there is no contemporary alternative. | ||
|
iky43210
United States2099 Posts
but people would bitch about how easy it is anyway also there is no such entity known as the "community", and most of the time people don't know what the fuck they want. cs:go was completely unchanged but a graphic update from the original, and people bitch about it being unoriginal and boring. Had it been revamp into more modern FPS people would've called valve a sell off and given in the casuals. You just can't win when it comes to sequel to a classic game after years of in-activities. sc2 is an amazing game, not only one of the best in the RTS field but also as a whole in the gaming field regarding difficulties and competitiveness. Just that the nostalgia for broodwar is too strong for people to see its true values | ||
|
Aterons_toss
Romania1275 Posts
On September 11 2012 17:00 MasterCynical wrote: have you noticed the first signs that things were going downhill in blizzard games was when they merged with activision? there are so many easy to use units in the game and now we get tempests and warhounds on top of it, what type of audience is blizzard targeting with these units? Think about it... After the merge with activison: WOW series The best 2 wow raids where released Arguably the best expansion story telling wise was released Starcraft series WOL is released, a game that is strategically more balanced than the original ( including the bw expansion )was in the first 3-5 years of its existence WOL releases the best custom map editor that is ever to grace the sight of any modder WOL is graphically superior to Warcraft 3 TFT ( not even mentioning sc2 ) Blizzard put stupid drm on there games nowadays and refuse to give LAN, they don't put enough effort into balance and from games that were about 5 to 8 years ahead of competition their games are now about 1-2 years ahead. They still shit on any other major publisher and as a matter of fact the company that owned blizzard bought activison, so if you look at it like that basically blizzard bought activision. There is no real argument to be made for there games being worse other than the obvious lack of LAN. ( Which did work in bringing them PC gaming record breaking sales for Diablo 3 ) | ||
|
gawk
Germany310 Posts
They don't offer pleasant possibilities other than basic pull back/attack micro to increase their value. Those units may be attractive to new/casual gamers at first, but as orb stated in his hots thread, also get boring quite quickly. If there were a community-driven overhaul of sc2 with new units, a mod would be a very good solution for that. Reason being sc2 and all the effort Blizzard puts into it still remain valid. New players get to play the campaign and can ladder sc2 as it is. Look at halflife and counterstrike. Buy halflife and when you are interested try counterstrike. A successfull mod would help sell some extra copies of sc2 but could specialise to a specific gamer base. If there is a demand most likely there is someone willing to develop and maintain a mod for that. Like a broodwar remake mod (not only custom maps). Still the question would remain who should make the decisions for a competitive mod. Unfortunately sc2 doesn't offer the possibility to create mods. | ||
|
Dalavita
Sweden1113 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:17 NeonFox wrote: I'm kind of sick of people keeping making that argument. People bitched about sc2 during the beta, and now the game is amazing. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, but sometimes it seems that saying you prefer sc2 over BW is like spitting on your grandma and raping babies. SC2 is far from amazing. It could have been amazing, but Blizzard lacks the competence to make it truly good. The reason BW got so much respect and love was because the game was absolutely hard. For the wrong reasons maybe, but the game allowed for the best of the best to truly shine, and everyone else had to practice hard to even keep up. SC2? Not so much. Instead of fixing the UI issues of BW while keeping the high skill ceiling and diversity of the units Blizzard simplified every unit to the point where the games end up incredibly stale and predictable, and they nerf with an iron fist everything that seems like it will deviate from their plans. SC2 is one dimensional, and it's not nearly as hard as it should be, and that's not from a mechanical standpoint, but rather a tactical and unit one. Also, Blizzards balancing is an insult to everything that requires skill and hard work. They nerf entire races because certain progamers are better than others to keep an artificial 50% win rate across the board. | ||
|
Jetaap
France4814 Posts
WOL releases the best custom map editor that is ever to grace the sight of any modder Not quite sure about that, the map editor has been lacking very important features for a long time (especially to import models correctly), problems with latency etc. And above all the custom map system was abysmal for at least almost 2 years after release, which means that a lot of map makers have been really disapointed by sc2 in that regard (not even talking about the marketplace, or about the current system which is still not very good imo). | ||
|
iky43210
United States2099 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:50 Dalavita wrote: SC2 is far from amazing. It could have been amazing, but Blizzard lacks the competence to make it truly good. The reason BW got so much respect and love was because the game was absolutely hard. For the wrong reasons maybe, but the game allowed for the best of the best to truly shine, and everyone else had to practice hard to even keep up. SC2? Not so much. Instead of fixing the UI issues of BW while keeping the high skill ceiling and diversity of the units Blizzard simplified every unit to the point where the games end up incredibly stale and predictable, and they nerf with an iron fist everything that seems like it will deviate from their plans. SC2 is one dimensional, and it's not nearly as hard as it should be, and that's not from a mechanical standpoint, but rather a tactical and unit one. the meta hasn't even been figured out and you're already calling it stale and predictable. Just look at the terran over the past few months, we're currently undergoing/underwent one of the biggest meta shift in WOL history also the game is still pretty fucking hard. There's a reason why so few foreigners can compete in the international level despite having an overwhelming advantage in the total playerbase. | ||
|
NeonFox
2373 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:50 Dalavita wrote: SC2 is far from amazing. It could have been amazing, but Blizzard lacks the competence to make it truly good. The reason BW got so much respect and love was because the game was absolutely hard. For the wrong reasons maybe, but the game allowed for the best of the best to truly shine, and everyone else had to practice hard to even keep up. SC2? Not so much. Instead of fixing the UI issues of BW while keeping the high skill ceiling and diversity of the units Blizzard simplified every unit to the point where the games end up incredibly stale and predictable, and they nerf with an iron fist everything that seems like it will deviate from their plans. SC2 is one dimensional, and it's not nearly as hard as it should be, and that's not from a mechanical standpoint, but rather a tactical and unit one. Also, Blizzards balancing is an insult to everything that requires skill and hard work. They nerf entire races because people are doing well to keep an artificial 50% win rate across the board. That's your opinion. I like SC2 a lot more than BW. edit : spoiler tags | ||
|
karpo
Sweden1998 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:50 Dalavita wrote: SC2 is far from amazing. It could have been amazing, but Blizzard lacks the competence to make it truly good. The reason BW got so much respect and love was because the game was absolutely hard. For the wrong reasons maybe, but the game allowed for the best of the best to truly shine, and everyone else had to practice hard to even keep up. SC2? Not so much. Instead of fixing the UI issues of BW while keeping the high skill ceiling and diversity of the units Blizzard simplified every unit to the point where the games end up incredibly stale and predictable, and they nerf with an iron fist everything that seems like it will deviate from their plans. SC2 is one dimensional, and it's not nearly as hard as it should be, and that's not from a mechanical standpoint, but rather a tactical and unit one. Also, Blizzards balancing is an insult to everything that requires skill and hard work. They nerf entire races because certain progamers are better than others to keep an artificial 50% win rate across the board. Saw you name, knew instantly what i was about to read and especially that not-so-subtle terran whine in the end. To OP: People like Dota and Counterstrike because they are easy to get into. CS hasn't been a mod for a long time, it's a standalone game. It started as a mod back when there were no similar games out, and got popular by being different. You argue that "most" people prefer this or that yet you provide no sources, it seems based solely on your subjective opinion. I'm pretty sure people bitched and moaned about alot of things in all the "great" old games you listed. It's human nature. Not saying SC2 is perfect, but nostalgia goggles and listening to a vocal group on a forum dedicated to BW, and now SC2, isn't a good base for what "most" people want. | ||
|
Alexj
Ukraine440 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:08 ahappystar wrote: You do realize this isn't the same Blizzard that made those 'classic' games? That Blizzard died a long time ago. You mean Blizzard that was always against iCCup? You mean Blizzard that released StarCraft in a state where some missions couldn't be finished without cheat codes? You mean Blizzard that prosecuted the creators of FreeCraft? You mean Blizzard that mostly ignored BroodWar scene for 10 years? | ||
|
Jerubaal
United States7684 Posts
You would complain about literally anything. | ||
|
lefix
Germany1082 Posts
HOWEVER, the real problem is the Bnet 2.0, which has been a big step backwards from what we had in wc3. Blizzard have shown very little support for the custom games/maps section. Even the new arcade section hasn't brought any improvement. If we were to build the best RTS game ever within SC2, you still wouldn't be able to ladder on it, use matchmaking, or search for games. The only way to find players to play against is via chat channels and inviting them to your game lobby manually. And even the ingame Chat channels are limited to 100 people. Unless Blizzard decides to change something about that, I don't see a mod like that stand much of a chance to ever become popular. | ||
|
Holcan
Canada2593 Posts
On September 11 2012 20:15 Jerubaal wrote: I'm just going to reiterate: You would complain about literally anything. no doubt, I was a part of the american wc3 scene, and its really refreshing to have as many events in north america as there currently is. how about we build the community to being entirely self sustaining before we try to push rts into our own competitive niche. honestly, sc2 is the first large RTS in america, and you are asking for us to rebel and adopt an archaic game? it doesn't make sense, appreciate what you have, and if you want more, put in some time. | ||
|
10734
340 Posts
On September 11 2012 19:54 NeonFox wrote: + Show Spoiler + On September 11 2012 19:50 Dalavita wrote: SC2 is far from amazing. It could have been amazing, but Blizzard lacks the competence to make it truly good. The reason BW got so much respect and love was because the game was absolutely hard. For the wrong reasons maybe, but the game allowed for the best of the best to truly shine, and everyone else had to practice hard to even keep up. SC2? Not so much. Instead of fixing the UI issues of BW while keeping the high skill ceiling and diversity of the units Blizzard simplified every unit to the point where the games end up incredibly stale and predictable, and they nerf with an iron fist everything that seems like it will deviate from their plans. SC2 is one dimensional, and it's not nearly as hard as it should be, and that's not from a mechanical standpoint, but rather a tactical and unit one. Also, Blizzards balancing is an insult to everything that requires skill and hard work. They nerf entire races because people are doing well to keep an artificial 50% win rate across the board. That's your opinion. I like SC2 a lot more than BW. edit : spoiler tags I never reallly got into BW too, but aren't you getting tired of similar games? When people play standard in TvP/TvZ I just alt tab and go do something else, the games all feel exactly the same. TvT is the only matchup that I think is fun to watch, there's so much diversity in openings and non-stop action. I've watched maybe 15-20 BW games, so I can't tell if it's the game or just me. Now that I think about it, I tried watching DotA2/LoL for a bit but thought it was boring, I guess I'm just not a fan of eSports. | ||
|
Zato-1
Chile4253 Posts
Me, I couldn't care less about these things and I'll keep on enjoying SC2 like I have been for the past 2 years. | ||
|
MilesTeg
France1271 Posts
The truth is that Blizzard is doing a better job than you could. They're not always right, they don't always communicate in the best way but they usually end up doing the right thing given enough time. | ||
|
Evangelist
1246 Posts
Let's take this for example: This has been one of the hardest tasks for the coders: Reworking the pathing of the stalker and the immortal to mimic the behavior of their predecessor, the dragoon. It’s not quite the same yet, but it’s damn close, as our players confirm. Why in the name of all that is holy would you EVER want to make a unit play like the fucking dragoon? The only reason it had that style of play is because BW's pathfinding was utterly broken and as anyone who ever played the single player and tried to get up a flight of stairs will attest, it was broken for every single goddamn unit. These massive nostalgia trips have to end. Just go play BW if you want to play BW. We're happy with SC2, cheers. The idea that someone thinks that something that was an april fools (I hope) is a serious future for SC2 is mental. | ||
| ||